Advertisement

Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 47, Issue 3, pp 237–252 | Cite as

The Use of Criminal Record in Employment Decisions: The Rights of Ex-offenders, Employers and the Public

  • Helen Lam
  • Mark Harcourt
Article

Abstract

The evidence suggests that employers discriminate against ex-offenders in the labour market. The problem is potentially serious as it involves a substantial proportion of the population, especially the male population. Since research has shown that most people with prior convictions stop offending by their late 20s or early 30s, the validity of selection based on criminal record remains questionable. This paper examines the need for legal protection of ex-offenders by limiting employers' access to, and use of, information on criminal background. The rights and interests of the various parties involved, employers, ex-offenders, and the general public, are discussed. Approaches to the legal protection of ex-offenders in Australia are reviewed and legislative changes proposed.

discrimination employees employers ex-offenders rights 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Albright, S. and F. Denq: 1996, 'Employer Attitudes Toward Hiring Ex-Offenders', Prison Journal 76, 118-137.Google Scholar
  2. Anonymous: 1996, 'Employing Ex-Offenders', Industrial Relations Law Bulletin, 2-10.Google Scholar
  3. Arthur, A.: 1997, 'How Much Should Employers Know?' Black Enterprise 28(3), 56.Google Scholar
  4. Auletta, K.: 1982, The Underclass (Random House, New York).Google Scholar
  5. Borland, J. and B. Hunter: 2000, 'Does Crime Affect Employment Status? The Case of Indigenous Australians', Economica 67(265), 123-144.Google Scholar
  6. Britt, C. L.: 1997, 'Reconsidering the Unemployment and Crime Relationship-Variation by Age Group and Historical Period', Journal of Quantitative Criminology 13, 405-428.Google Scholar
  7. Burr, G. N., S. Wong, S. V. Veen and D. Gu: 2000, 'Three Strikes and You're Out: An Investigation of False Positive Rates Using a Canadian Sample', Federal Probation 64, 3-6.Google Scholar
  8. Bushway, S. D.: 2000, 'The Stigma of a Criminal History Record in the Labor Market', in J. P. May and K. R. Pitts (eds.), Building Violence: How America's Rush to Incarcerate Creates More Violence (Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, California), pp. 142-148.Google Scholar
  9. Carmichael, F. and R. Ward: 2000, 'Youth Unemployment and Crime in the English Regions and Wales', Applied Economics 32, 559-571.Google Scholar
  10. Carrington, P.: 2001, 'Population Aging and Crime in Canada, 2000-2041', Canadian Journal of Criminology 43, 331-356.Google Scholar
  11. Clay, J. M. and E.C. Stephens: 1995, 'Liability for Negligent Hiring: The Importance of Background Checks', Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly 36(5), 74-81.Google Scholar
  12. Colman, A.: 1997, 'Crime & Justice', Youth Studies Australia 3(4), 4.Google Scholar
  13. Colman, A.: 1998, 'Crime & Justice', Youth Studies Australia 17(4), 5-6.Google Scholar
  14. Correctional Services of Canada: 1993, 'Recidivists Tend to be..', Forum on Corrections Research 5(3), 14-16.Google Scholar
  15. 'Crime & justice': 1990, Youth Studies Australia 9(4), 5-6.Google Scholar
  16. Crutchfield, R. D. and S. R. Pitchford: 1997, 'Work and Crime: The Effects of Labor Stratification', Social Forces 76, 93-118.Google Scholar
  17. Duplessis, D., S. Enman, S. Gunz and S. O'Byrne: 2001, Canadian Business and the Law (Nelson Thomson Learning, Scarborough, Ontario, Canada).Google Scholar
  18. Fletcher, D. R.: 2001, 'Ex-Offenders, the Labour Market and the New Public Administration', Public Administration 79, 871-891.Google Scholar
  19. Freeman, R.: 1991, 'Crime and the Employment of Disadvantaged Youth', National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 3875.Google Scholar
  20. Gottfredson, M. and T. Hirschi: 1990, A General Theory of Crime (Stanford University, Stanford, California).Google Scholar
  21. Greve, M.: 1993, 'The Importance of Property Rights', Vital Speeches of the Day 59, 569-573.Google Scholar
  22. Grogger, J.: 1992, 'Arrests, Persistent Youth Joblessness, and Black/White Employment Differentials', Review of Economics and Statistics 74, 100-106.Google Scholar
  23. Grogger, J.: 1995, 'The Effect of Arrests on the Employment and Earnings of Young Men', Quarterly Journal of Economics 110, 51-71.Google Scholar
  24. Grier, A. and T. Thomas: 2000, 'Unsuitable to Work with Young People: The Pre-employment Screening of Youth Workers', Youth & Policy 70, 1-10.Google Scholar
  25. Harcourt, M. and S. Harcourt: 2003, 'The Importance of Full Legal Protection from Discrimination on the Basis of a Criminal Record', Human Rights Law and Practice, forthcoming.Google Scholar
  26. Hirschl, R.: 2000, '“Negative” Rights vs. “Positive” Entitlements: A Comparative Study of Judicial Interpretations of Rights in an Emerging Neoliberal Economic Order', Human Rights Quarterly 22, 1060-1098.Google Scholar
  27. Hubbell, W.: 2001, 'Without Pardon: Collateral Consequences of a Felony Conviction', Federal Sentencing Reporter 13, 223-224.Google Scholar
  28. Hulsey, L.: 1990, Attitudes of Employers with Respect to Hiring Released Prisoners, Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas.Google Scholar
  29. Hyde, J.: 1998, 'The Case of the Disappearing Property (Rights), IPA Review 50(3), 9-10.Google Scholar
  30. Irwin, J.: 1970, The Felon (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey).Google Scholar
  31. Israel, P.: 2002, 'Employee Misconduct... Employer Responsibility?' Canadian HR Reporter 15(10), 5.Google Scholar
  32. Johnstone, R.: 1994, The Court and the Factory: The Legal Construction of Occupational Health and Safety Offences in Victoria, Unpublished Doctor of Philosophy thesis, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.Google Scholar
  33. Jolly, J. and J. Frierson: 1989, 'Playing it Safe', Personnel Administrator 34(6), 44-50.Google Scholar
  34. Juszkiewics, J. and M. Schindler: 2001, 'Youth Crime/Adult Time: Is Justice Served?' Corrections Today 63, 102-107.Google Scholar
  35. Kanazawa, S. and M. C. Still: 2000, 'Why Men Commit Crimes (and Why They Desist)', Sociological Theory 18, 434-447.Google Scholar
  36. Knowler, J.: 1994, 'Living Down the Past-Spent Convictions Schemes in Australia', Privacy Law and Policy Reporter 1, 103-106.Google Scholar
  37. Kondrasuk, J. N., H. L. Moore and H. Wang: 2001, 'Negligent Hiring: The Emerging Contributor to Workplace Violence in the Public Sector', Public Personnel Management 30, 185-195.Google Scholar
  38. Lauritsen, J. L.: 1998, 'The Age-Crime Debate-Assessing the Limits of Longitudinal Self-report Data', Social Forces 77, 127-154.Google Scholar
  39. Liegl, P.: 2001, 'Background Checks are a Must When Hiring', Air Conditioning, Heating & Refrigeration News 212(5), 76-77.Google Scholar
  40. Liker, J. K.: 2002, 'Wage and Status Effects for Employment on Affective Well-being among Exfelons', American Sociological Review 47, 264-283.Google Scholar
  41. Locke, J.: 1967, Two Treatises of Government (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom).Google Scholar
  42. Long, J.: 2001, 'Background Checks Step by Step', Security Management 45(2), 72-78.Google Scholar
  43. Lovell, R. and M. Norris: 1990, 'One in Four: Offending from Age Ten to Twenty-Four in a Cohort of New Zealand Males', Study of Social Adjustment: Research Report No. 8, Research Section, Department of Social Welfare, Wellington, New Zealand.Google Scholar
  44. Meisenhelder, T.: 1977, 'An Exploratory Study of Exiting from Criminal Careers', Criminology 15, 319-334.Google Scholar
  45. Minehan, M.: 1997, 'War on Crime Presents Challenges for Employers', HRMagazine, 184.Google Scholar
  46. Motiuk, L. and R. Belcourt: 1997, 'Profiling Federal Offenders with Violent Crimes', Forum on Corrections Research 9(2), 8-13.Google Scholar
  47. Needels, K. E.: 1996, 'Go Directly to Jail and Do Not Collect-A Long-Term Study of Recidivism, Employment, and Earnings Patterns among Prison Releasees', Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 33, 471-496.Google Scholar
  48. Nozick, R.: 1974, Anarchy, State, and Utopia (Basic Books, New York).Google Scholar
  49. Perrone, S.: 1999, 'Violence in the Workplace', Australian Institute of Criminology Research and Public Policy Series No. 22, Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra, Australia.Google Scholar
  50. Piquero, A. R., A. Blumstein, R. Brame, R. Haapanen, E. P. Mulvey and D. S. Nagin: 2001, 'Assessing the Impact of Exposure Time and Incapacitation on Longitudinal Trajectories of Criminal Offending', Journal of Adolescent Research 16, 54-74.Google Scholar
  51. Raphael, S. and R. Winter-Ebmer: 1998, 'Identifying the Effect of Unemployment on Crime', Department of Economics Working Paper 98/19 (University of California at San Diego, San Diego, California).Google Scholar
  52. Raudenbush, S. and W. Chan: 1992, 'Growth Curve Analysis in Accelerated Longitudinal Designs', Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 29, 387-411.Google Scholar
  53. Ramirez, J. R. and W. D. Crano: 2003, 'Deterrence and Incapacitation: An Interrupted Time-Series Analysis of California's Three-Strikes Law', Journal of Applied Social Psychology 33, 110-144.Google Scholar
  54. Roberts, A.: 2002, 'EU Drug Monitoring Office in Lisbon', Europe 415, S3.Google Scholar
  55. Rossi, P. H., R. A. Berk and K. J. Lenihan: 1980, Money, Work and Crime (Academic Publishers, New York).Google Scholar
  56. Rosen, L. S.: 2002, 'Background Screening and Safe Hiring: An Introduction', Occupational Health and Safety 71(4), 16-20.Google Scholar
  57. Saunders, D., J. Leck and L. Marcil: 1992, 'What Predicts Employer Propensity to Gather Protected Group Information from Job Applicants?' New Approaches to Employee Management: Fairness in Employee Selection 1, 105-130.Google Scholar
  58. Savage, D. G.: 2002, 'Were '90's Laws Too Tough?' ABA Journal 88(11), 22-23.Google Scholar
  59. Stone, D. and E. Stone: 1987, 'Effects of Missing Application-Blank Information on Personnel Selection Decisions: Do Privacy Protection Strategies Bias the Outcome?' Journal of Applied Psychology 72, 452-456.Google Scholar
  60. Sullivan, D.: 1998, 'Employee Violence, Negligent Hiring, and Criminal Records Checks: New York's Need to Reevaluate its Priorities to Promote Public Safety', St. John's Law Review 72, 591-605.Google Scholar
  61. Tillman, R.: 1987, 'The Size of the 'Criminal Population': The Prevalence and Incidence of Adult Arrest', Criminology 25, 561-580.Google Scholar
  62. Uggen, C.: 2000, 'Work as a Turning Point in the Life Course of criminals: A Duration Model of Age, Employment, and Recidivism', American Sociological Review 65, 529-546.Google Scholar
  63. U.S. Department of Justice: 2002, 'Federal Bureau of Investigation-Crime in the United States 2001'. Retrieved on May 15, 2003 from http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/01cius.htm.Google Scholar
  64. Van Vliet, H. J.: 1990, 'Separation of Drug Markets and the Normalization of Drug Problems in the Netherlands: An Example', Journal of Drug Issues 20, 463-471.Google Scholar
  65. Waldfogel, J.: 1994, 'The Effect of Criminal Conviction on Income and the Trust Reposed in the Workmen', Journal of Human Resources 29, 62-81.Google Scholar
  66. Williamson, B.: 1993, April, 'Discrimination on the Ground of Criminal Record', Law Society Journal, 44-45.Google Scholar
  67. Witte, A. and H. Tauchen: 1994, 'Work and Crime: An Exploration Using Panel Data', National Bureau of Economic Researching Working Paper 4794.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2003

Authors and Affiliations

  • Helen Lam
    • 1
  • Mark Harcourt
    • 2
  1. 1.Department of Human Resource Management, Centre for Innovative ManagementAthabasca UniversitySt. AlbertCanada
  2. 2.Department of Strategic Management and Leadership, Waikato Management SchoolWaikato UniversityHamiltonNew Zealand

Personalised recommendations