GeoJournal

, Volume 56, Issue 3, pp 191–199

Deforestation in the Madagascar Highlands – Established `truth' and scientific uncertainty

  • Jorgen Klein
Article

Abstract

The Madagascar central highlands with their red soils and erosion gullies are often held up as a frightening example of the consequences of deforestation. They are also used as a model of how the entire island will look if so-called `forest unfriendly activities' of local people continue. This insight is based on a narrative that describes the highlands as totally forested by the time of human arrival and gradually deforested as a response to human activities. This paper questions the deforestation narrative of Madagascar and points at alternative explanations for present day land cover. By the use of alternative sources of information the paper presents a counter-narrative that sees the treeless rolling planes of Madagascar as a result of several abiotic and biotic changes and not as the work of one single agent. The paper points at the political nature of the deforestation narrative as an explanation for its hegemonic position. On a theoretical level the paper makes an attempt to investigate the epistemological implication of a social constructivist approach to environmental discourses in Third World settings.

deforestation environmental narratives Madagascar natural resource management 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Bakke J.E., 1991: Madagaskar-et levende museum: om natur og miljø på et lite kontinent. HIS. Stavanger.Google Scholar
  2. Baron R., 1890: The Flora of Madagascar. J. Linnean Soc. 25: 246–282.Google Scholar
  3. Basset T.J. and Koli Z., 2000: Environmental Discourses and the Ivorian Savanna. Ann. Asso. Am. Geogr. 90(1): 67–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. Bates D.G. and Skogseid H., 1997: Menneskelig tilpasning. En humanøkologisk innføring i globalt miljø Universitetsforlaget. Oslo.Google Scholar
  5. Blaikie P. and Brookfield H., 1987: Land Degradation and Society. Routledge, London and New York.Google Scholar
  6. Botkin D.B., 1990: Discordant harmonies: a new ecology for the twenty-first century. Oxford university Press, New York.Google Scholar
  7. Bourgeat F., 1972: Sol sur socle ancient à Madagascar. Mémoires. 57. ORSTOM, Paris.Google Scholar
  8. Burney D.A., 1987: Late holocene vegetational change in central Madagascar. Quater. Res. 28: 130–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Burney D.A., 1997: Theories and Facts Regarding Holocene Environmental Change before and after Human Colonization. In: Goodman S.M. and Patterson B.D. (eds), Natural Change and Human Impact in Madagascar. Smithsonian Institution Press. Washington.Google Scholar
  10. Clements F.C., 1916: Plant succession: an analysis of the development of vegetation. Carnegie institution of Washington, Washington.Google Scholar
  11. Dahle L., 1876: Madagaskar og dets beboere. Jac. Dybwad forlag.Google Scholar
  12. Demeritt, D., 1998: Science, Social Constructivism, and Nature. In: Braun B. and Castree N. (eds), Remaking Reality. Nature at the Millennium. Routledge, London.Google Scholar
  13. Dewar R.E. and Wright H.T., 1994: The culture history of Madagascar. J. World Prehistory 7: 417–466.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Dewar R.E.: 1997: Were People Responsible for the Extinction of Madagascar Subfossils, And How Will We Ever Know? In: Goodman S.M. and Patterson B.D. (eds), Natural Change and Human Impact in Madagascar. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington.Google Scholar
  15. Fairhead J. and Leach M., 1995: False Forest History, Complicit Social Analysis: Rethinking Some West African Environmental Narratives. World Develop. 23(6): 1023–1035.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Fairhead J. and Leach M.: 1996: Misreading the African Landscape. Society and ecology in a forest-savanna mosaic. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  17. Foucault M., 1972: The Archaeology of knowledge. Tavistock, London.Google Scholar
  18. Gade D.W., 1996: Deforestation and its effects in Highland Madagascar. Mount. Res. Develop. 16(2): 101–116.Google Scholar
  19. Gautier E., 1902: Madagascar: essai de géographie physique. Challamel, Paris.Google Scholar
  20. Ghimire K.B., 1991: Parks and People: Livelihood Issues in National Park Management in Thailand and Madagascar. UNRISD Discussion paper, Geneva.Google Scholar
  21. Glenn-Lewin D.C., Peet R.K. and Veblen T.T., 1992: Plant Succession. Theory and prediction. Chapman & Hall, London.Google Scholar
  22. Goodman S.M. and Patterson B.D. (eds), 1997: Natural Change and Human Impact in Madagascar. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington.Google Scholar
  23. Grandidier G., 1905: Les animaux disparus de Madagascar. Revue de Madagascar. N o 2.Google Scholar
  24. Hoben A., 1995: Paradigms and politics: the cultural construction of environmental policy in Ethiopia. World Develop. 23(6): 1007–1022.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Humbert H., 1927: Destruction d'une flore insulaire par les feux: Principaux aspects de la végétation à Madagascar. Mémoires de l'académie Malgache 5: 1–80.Google Scholar
  26. Humbert, H. 1949: La dégradation des sols à Madagascar. Mémoires de l'Institut de Recherche Scientifique de Madagascar 1: 33–53.Google Scholar
  27. Jarozs, L., 1996: Defining deforestation in Madagascar. In: Peet R. and Watts M. (eds), Liberation Ecologies. Environment, development and social movements. Routledge, London.Google Scholar
  28. Jary D. and Jary J., 1995: Collins Dictionary of Sociology. Harper Collins Publishers, Glasgow.Google Scholar
  29. Jenkins M.D., 1987: Madagascar: an environmental profile. IUCN Conservation Monitoring Centre, Gland, Switzerland.Google Scholar
  30. Kent R.K., 1970: Early kingdoms in Madagascar. 1500–1700. Holt, Rinehart and Winston Inc.Google Scholar
  31. Klein, J., 2002: Social Constructivism and Environmental Problems—Epistemologicial Challenges. Nordisk Samhällsgeografisk Tidskrift 33: 3–24.Google Scholar
  32. Krause D.W., Hartman J.H. and Wells N.A., 1997: Late Cretaceous Vertebrates from Madagscar. In: Goodman, S.M. and Patterson B.D. (eds), Natural Change and Human Impact in Madagscar. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington.Google Scholar
  33. Kull, C., 1999: Observations on repressive environmental policies and landscape burning strategies in Madagascar. Afr. Studies Quart. 3(2).Google Scholar
  34. Kull C., 2000: Deforestation, Erosion, and Fire: Degradation Myths in the Environmental History of Madagascar. Environ. History 6: 423–450.Google Scholar
  35. Leach M. and Mearns R., 1996: The Lie of the Land. Challenging Recieved Wisdom of the African Environment. Heineman, London.Google Scholar
  36. Leach M. and Fairhead J., 2000: Fashioned Forest Pasts, Occluded Histories? International Environmental Analysis in West African Locales. Develop. Change 31: 35–59.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Macphee R.D.E., Burney D.A. and Wells N.A., 1985: Early Holocene chronology and environment of Ampasambazimba, a Malagasy subfossil lemur site. Internl. J. Primatol. 6: 463–489.Google Scholar
  38. Madagascar Environmental Action Plan. Vol. 1., 1988: World Bank, Washington.Google Scholar
  39. Martin P.S., 1966: Africa and pleistocene overkill. Nature 212: 339–342.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Meadows, M.E. and Linder H.P., 1993: A palaeoecological perspective on the origin of Afromontane grasslands. Journal of Biogeography, 20: 345–355.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Müntz A. and Rousseaux F., 1901: Etude sur la valeur agricole des terres de Madagascar. Revue de Madagascar 3(1): 29–41.Google Scholar
  42. Myers N., Mittermeier R.A., Mittermeier C.T. and daFonseca G.A., 2000: Biodiversity hotspots for conservation priorities. Nature 403: 853–858.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  43. Peet R. and Watts M., 1996: Liberation Ecologies. Environment, development and social movements. Routledge, London.Google Scholar
  44. Perrier de la Bâthie H., 1921: La végétation malgache. Annales du Museum Colonial. Marseille 9: 1–266.Google Scholar
  45. Perrier de la Bâthie H., 1936: Biogéographie des plantes de Madagascar. Société d'Editions Géographiques, Maritimes, et Coloniales, Paris. Pp. 116–128.Google Scholar
  46. Proctor J.D., 1998: The Social Construction of Nature: Relativist Accusations, Pragamtist and Critical Realist Responses. Ann. Asso. Am. Geogr. 88(3): 352–376.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Rakotoariso J. 1997: A Cultural History of Madagascar. Evolution and Interpretation of the Archaeological Evidence. In: Goodman S.M. and Patterson B.D. (eds), Natural Change and Human Impact in Madagascar. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington.Google Scholar
  48. Roe E., 1991: Development Narratives, or Making the Best of Blueprint Development. World Develop 19(4): 287–300.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Roe E., 1994: Narrative Policy Analysis. Duke University Press, London.Google Scholar
  50. Roe E., 1995: Except Africa: postscript to a special section on development narratives. World Develop. 23(6): 1065–1070.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Schatz G.E., 1996: Malagasy/Indo-australo-malesian phytogeographic connections. In: Lourenço W.R. (ed.), Biogéographie de Madagascar, pp. 73–84. Editions ORSTOM, Paris.Google Scholar
  52. Sibree J., 1896: Madagascar before the conquest. T. Fisher Unwin, London.Google Scholar
  53. USAID, 1998: The USAID FY 1998 Congressional Presentation. Online: http://www.info.usaid.gov./pubs/cp98/afr/countries/mg.htm.Google Scholar
  54. Wells N. and Andriamihaja B.R., 1997: Extreme Gully Erosion in Madagascar and its Natural and Anthropogenic Causes. In: Goodman S.M. and Patterson B.D. (eds), Natural Change and Human Impact in Madagascar. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington.Google Scholar
  55. World Conservation Monitoring Centre, 1994: Biodiversity Source Book. Cambridge.Google Scholar
  56. Zimmerer K.S., 2000: The Reworking of Conservation Geographies: Nonequilibrium Landscapes and Nature-Society Hybrids. Ann. Asso. Am. Geogr. 90(2): 356–369.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2002

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jorgen Klein
    • 1
  1. 1.Hogskoleni Hedmark LUHHamarNorway

Personalised recommendations