Human Ecology

, Volume 31, Issue 3, pp 417–437 | Cite as

Participatory Development and Community-Based Conservation: Opportunities Missed for Lessons Learned?

Abstract

This paper traces the evolution as well as key elements, and provides examples of implementation of participatory development and community-based conservation, two concepts that resemble distant cousins in the intersecting worlds of development assistance and environmental conservation. The paper examines the connections between the concepts, the implications of participatory development for community-based conservation, and the reasons for the differences in their conceptualization and implementation. The paper is based on a review of the literature in both fields and on the authors' research and experience with participatory development and community-based conservation. Several keys to understanding the disconnection between the concepts emerge; intellectual and pragmatic origins of and impetus for the concepts, the expertise and interests of their promoters, and the differing emphasis on participation as means versus end. Results may inform our understandings of why many participatory approaches to conservation have failed to achieve meaningful participation in practice.

conservation participatory development theory praxis 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Adams, W. M., and Thomas, D. H. L. (1993). Mainstream sustainable development: The challenge of putting theory into practice. Journal of International Development 5: 591–604.Google Scholar
  2. Agrawal, A., and Gibson, C. C. (1999). Enchantment and disenchantment: The role of community in natural resource conservation. World Development 27(4): 629–649.Google Scholar
  3. Agrawal, A., and Gibson, C. C. (eds.). (2001). Communities and the Environment: Ethnicity, Gender, and the State in Community-Based Conservation, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ.Google Scholar
  4. Anderson, D., and Grove, R. (eds.). (1987). Conservation in Africa: People, Policies and Practice, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.Google Scholar
  5. Arnstein, S. (1969). A ladder of community participation. American Institute of Planners Journal 35(4): 216–224.Google Scholar
  6. Banuri, T., and Apffel-Marglin, F. (1993). Who Will Save the Forests? Knowledge, Power and Environmental Destruction, Zed Books, London.Google Scholar
  7. Berkes, F., Colding, J., and Folke, C. (2000). Rediscovery of traditional ecological knowledge as adaptive management. Ecological Applications 10(5): 1251–1262.Google Scholar
  8. Berkes, F., and Pocock, D. (1981). Self-regulation of commercial fisheries of the outer Long Point Bay, Lake Erie. Journal of Great Lakes Research 7(2): 111–117.Google Scholar
  9. Bhatt, Y., and Tandon, R. (2001). Citizen participation in natural resource management. In Reason, P., and Bradbury, H. (eds.), Handbook of Action Research Beverly, Hills, CA, Sage, pp. 301–306.Google Scholar
  10. Boza, M. (1993). Conservation in action: Past, present, and future of the national parks system in Costa Rica. Conservation Biology 7(2): 239–247.Google Scholar
  11. Brosius, J. P., Lowenhaupt Tsing, A., and Zerner, C. (1998). Representing communities: Histories and politics of community-based natural resource management. Society and Natural Resourcs 11: 157–168.Google Scholar
  12. Campbell, L. M. (1997). International conservation and local development: The sustainable use of marine turtles in Costa Rica, Unpublished doctoral thesis, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.Google Scholar
  13. Campbell, L. M. (1998). Use them or lose them? The consumptive use of marine turtle eggs at Ostional, Costa Rica. Environmental Conservation 24: 305–319.Google Scholar
  14. Campbell, L. M. (2000). Human need in rural developing areas: Perceptions of wildlife conservation experts. The Canadian Geographer 44(2): 167–181.Google Scholar
  15. Campbell, L. M. (2002a). Conservation narratives and the “received wisdom” of ecotourism: Case studies from Costa Rica. International Journal of Sustainable Development 5(3): 300–325.Google Scholar
  16. Campbell, L. M. (2002b). Sustainable use of marine turtles: Views of conservation experts. Ecological Applications 12(4): 1229–1246.Google Scholar
  17. Campbell, L. M. (2002c). Conservation narratives in Costa Rica: Conflict and coexistence. Development and Change 33(1): 29–56.Google Scholar
  18. Carroll, T. F. (1992). Intermediary NGO's: The supporting link in grassroots development, Kumarian Press, Hartford, CT.Google Scholar
  19. Chambers, R. (1997). Whose Reality Counts? Putting the Last First, Intermediate Technology Publications, London.Google Scholar
  20. Dale, A. (1995). Multistakeholder processes: Panacea or window dressing? SDRI Discussion Paper Series, Sustainable Development Research Institute, University of British Columbia.Google Scholar
  21. Derman, B. (1995). Enviromental NGOs, dispossession, and the state: The ideology and praxis of African nature and development. Human Ecology 23(2): 199–215.Google Scholar
  22. Dove, M. R. (2002). Hybrid histories and indigenous knowledge among Asian rubber smallholders. International Social Science Journal 173: 349–359.Google Scholar
  23. Ecological Applications (1993). Special Issue: Science and Sustainability 3(4).Google Scholar
  24. Ekins, P. (1992). A New World Order: Grassroots Movements for Global Change, Routledge, London.Google Scholar
  25. Evans, S. (1999). The Green Republic: A Conservation History of Costa Rica, University of Texas Press, Austin.Google Scholar
  26. Fals Borda, O. (1977) For praxis: The problem of how to investigate reality in order to transform it. African Regional Workshop on Participatory Research, Mzumbe, Tanzania, 37 pp.Google Scholar
  27. Fals Borda, O. (1987). The application of participatory action research in Latin America. International Sociology 2(4): 329–347.Google Scholar
  28. Fisher, J. (1993). The Road from Rio: Sustainable Development and the Nongovernment Movement in the Third World, Praeger, Westport, CT.Google Scholar
  29. Ghimire, K. B., and Pimbert, M. P. (eds.). (1997). Social Change and Conservation, Earthscan, London.Google Scholar
  30. Gow, D. and Vansart, J. (1983). Beyond the rhetoric of rural development participation: How can it be done? World Development 11(5): 427–446.Google Scholar
  31. Habermas, J. (1973) Theory and Practice, Beacon Press, Boston, MA.Google Scholar
  32. Hackel, J. D. (1999). Community conservation and the future of Africa's wildlife. Conservation Biology 13(4): 726–734.Google Scholar
  33. Heinen, J. T. (1993). Park-people relations in Kosi Tappu Wildlife Reserve, Nepal: A socio-economic analysis. Environmental Conservation 20(1): 25–33.Google Scholar
  34. Homewood, K. M., and Rogers, W. A. (1991). Maasailand Ecology: Pastoralist Development and Wildlife Conservation in Ngorongoro, Tanzania, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.Google Scholar
  35. INBio (2000). El Instituto Nacional de Biodiversidad (INBio) Home Page. El Instituto Nacional de Biodiversidad (INBio). Available at http://www.inbio.ac.cr [2000, 25/03/00]Google Scholar
  36. Janzen, D. H., Hallwachs, W., Jimenez, J., and Gamez, R. (1993). The role of parataxonomists, inventory managers, and Costa Rica's national biodiversity inventory. In Reid, W. V., Laird, S. A., and Meyer, C. A. (eds.), Biodiversity Prospecting: Using Genetic Resources for Sustainable Development, World Resources Institute, Washington, DC, Annex 1.Google Scholar
  37. Kellert, S. R., Mehta, J. N., Ebbin, S. A., and Litchtenfeld, L. L. (2000). Community natural resource management: Promise, rhetoric, and reality. Society and Natural Resouces 13: 705–715.Google Scholar
  38. Leach, M., Fairhead, J., and Millimouno, D. (1997a). Second Nature: Building Forests in West Africa's Savannas, Video. 40', ODA, UK.Google Scholar
  39. Leach, M., Mearns, R., and Scoones, I. (1997b). Challenges to community-based sustainable development: Dynamics, entitlements, institutions. IDS Bulletin 4: 4–14.Google Scholar
  40. Little, P. (1994). The link between local participation and improved conservation: A review of issues and experiences. In Western, D., and Wright, M. A. (eds.), Natural Connections: Perspectives in Community-Based Conservation, Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 347–372.Google Scholar
  41. Lundy, P. (1999). Community participation in Jamaican conservation projects. Community Development Journal 34(2): 122–132.Google Scholar
  42. Macdonald, L. (1995). NGOs and the problematic discourse of participation: Cases from Costa Rica. In Moore, D. B., and Schmitz, G. J. (eds.), Debating Development Discourse: Institutional and Popular Perspectives, St. Martin's Press, New York, pp. 201–229.Google Scholar
  43. Mangel, M., Talbot, L. M., Meffe, G. K., Agardy, M. T., Alverson, D. L., Barlow, J., Botkin, D. B., Budowski, G., Clark, T., Cooke, J., Crozier, R. H., Dayton, P. K., Elder, D. L., Fowler, C. W., Funtowicz, S., Giske, J., Hofman, R. J., Hold, S. J., Kellert, S. R., Kimball, L. A., Ludwig, D., Magnusson, K., Malayang, B. S., Mann, C., Norse, E. A., Northridge, S. P., Perrin, W. F., Perrings, C., Peterman, R. M., Rabb, G. B., Regier, H. A., Reynolds, J. E., Sherman, K., Sissenwine, M. P., Smith, T. D., Starfield, A., Taylor, R. J., Tillman, M. F., Toft, C., Jr., J. R. T., Wilen, J., and Young, T. P. (1996). Principles for the conservation of wild living resources. Ecological Applications 6(2): 338–362.Google Scholar
  44. Marks, S. (1984). The Imperial Lion: Human Dimensions of Wildlife Management in Central Africa, Bowker Epping, UK.Google Scholar
  45. Matose, F. (1997). Conflicts around forest reserves in Zimbabwe: What prospects for community management? IDS Bulletin 28(4): 69–78.Google Scholar
  46. McCormick, J. (1989). The Global Environmental Movement: Reclaiming Paradise, Belhaven, London.Google Scholar
  47. Meehan, J. (1995). Feminists Read Habermas: Gendering the Subject of Discourse. Routledge, New York.Google Scholar
  48. Mehta, J. N., and Kellert, R. (1998). Local attitudes toward community-based conservation policy and programmes in Nepal: A case study in the Makalu-Barun Conservation Area. Environmental Conservation 25(4): 320–333.Google Scholar
  49. Meyer, C. A. (1993). Environmental NGOs in Ecuador. Journal of Developing Areas 27: 191–210.Google Scholar
  50. Meyer, C. A. (1997). Public-nonprofit partnerships and North-South green finance. Journal of Environment and Development 6(2): 123–146.Google Scholar
  51. Meyer, J. L., and Helfman, G. S. (1993). The ecological basis of sustainability. Ecological Applications 3(4): 569–571.Google Scholar
  52. Moore, M., Gould. J., Joshi, A., and Oksanen, R. (1996). Ownership in the Finnish Aid programme. Evaluation Report, 3. Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Finland. 106 pp.Google Scholar
  53. Nygren, A. (1998). Environment as discourse: Searching for sustainable development in Costa Rica. Environmental Values 7: 201–222.Google Scholar
  54. Parry, D., and Campbell, B. (1992). Attitudes of rural communities to animal wildlife and its utilization in Chobe Enclave and Mababe Depression, Botswana. Environmental Conservation 19(3): 245–251.Google Scholar
  55. Peskin, J. (2002). Attitudes of local guides toward ecotourism, sea turtle conservation, and guiding in Tortuguero, Costs Rica.. Unpublished MA thesis, University of Florida.Google Scholar
  56. Pilcher, N. J. (2002). Editorial: Contemporary science or interference? The inclusion of modern thought and science into traditional management practices. Kachhapa 7: 1–3.Google Scholar
  57. Price, M. (1994). Ecopolitics and environmental nongovernmental organizations in Latin America. The Geographical Review 84(1): 42–58.Google Scholar
  58. Princen, T., and Finger, M. (1996). Environmental NGOs: Carving out a new niche. Ecodecision, 22: 26–29.Google Scholar
  59. Sachs, W. (ed.). (1992). The Development Dictionary: A Guide to Knowledge as Power, Zed Books, London.Google Scholar
  60. Schöitz, A. (1989). Conserving biological diversity: Who is responsible. Ambio 18(8): 454–457.Google Scholar
  61. Smith, A. H., and Berkes, F., (1991). Solutions to the “tragedy of the commons”: Sea-urchin management in St. Lucia, West Indies. Environmental Conservation 18(2): 131–136.Google Scholar
  62. Songorwa, A. N. (1999). Community-based wildlife management (CWM) in Tanzania: Are the communities interested? World Development 27(12): 2061–2079.Google Scholar
  63. Swantz, M. (1986). Development: From bottom to top or top to bottom? Grassroot dynamics and directed development: The case of Tanzania. Working paper, WIDER Helsinki, 27 pp.Google Scholar
  64. Troëng, S., Ranstam, J., Rankin, E. (2002). Beyond trends: Reconciling the concepts of absolute protectionism and sustainable extractive use to achieve “best use” of seas turtles. Paper presented at the 22nd Annual Symposium on Sea Turtle Biology and Conservation, Miami, FL, April 4–7.Google Scholar
  65. Turton, D. (1987). The Mursi and national park development in the Lower Omo Valley. In Anderson, D., and Grove, R. (eds.), Conservation in Africa: People, Policies and Practice, University of Cambridge Press, Cambridge, UK.Google Scholar
  66. Vainio-Mattila, A. (1996). The impact of development interventions on community-based natural resource management: Cases from Kenya and Namibia. Fennia 174(2): pp. 125–222.Google Scholar
  67. Vainio-Mattila, A. (1997). Participation: Concept, practice and implications for Finnish development cooperation. Blue Series 1997:1. Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Finland.Google Scholar
  68. Vainio-Mattila, A. (2000). The seduction and significance of participation for development interventions. Canadian Journal of Development Studies (Special Issue): 431–446.Google Scholar
  69. Verhaagen, K. (1987). The methodology of self-help promotion: A systems approach. EADI General Conference, Amsterdam, September 1987.Google Scholar
  70. Wainwright, C., and Wehrmeyer, W. (1998). Success in integrating conservation and development? A study from Zambia. World Development 26(6): 933–944.Google Scholar
  71. Wapner, P. (1995). Politics beyond the state: Environmental activism and world civic politics. World Politics 47: 311–340.Google Scholar
  72. WCED (1987). Our Common Future, Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
  73. Wells, M., and Brandon, B. (1992). People and Parks: Linking Protected Area Management with Local Communities, IBRD, Washington.Google Scholar
  74. Wells, M. P., and Brandon, K. E. (1993). The principles and practice of buffer zones and local participation in biodiversity conservation. Ambio 22(2–3): 57–162.Google Scholar
  75. Western, D., and Wright, M. A. (1994). The background to community-based conservation. In Western, D., and Wright, M. A. (eds.), Natural Connections: Perspectives in Community-Based Conservation, Island Press, Washington, DC, pp. 1–12.Google Scholar
  76. Wilde, V., and Vainio-Mattila, A. (1995). International Training Package on Gender Analysis and Forestry in Asia, Food and Agriculture Organization of the UN, Rome.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Plenum Publishing Corporation 2003

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Marine Laboratory, Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth SciencesDuke UniversityBeaufort
  2. 2.Centre for International StudiesHuron University CollegeLondonCanada

Personalised recommendations