Mental Health Services Research

, Volume 1, Issue 3, pp 159–170 | Cite as

A Comparison of Public and Privatized Approaches to Managed Behavioral Health Care for Persons with Serious Mental Illness

  • Dow A. Wieman
  • Robert A. Dorwart


This article compares public and privatized approaches to managed behavioral health care for persons with serious mental illness in Massachusetts. Data from the Department of Mental Health (DMH) for 247 patients receiving care managed by DMH and 312 in a Medicaid carve-out were compared. Repeated measures multivariate analysis of variance models were used to examine adjusted changes in number of admissions, bed days, and facilities used from a baseline year before program implementation in 1992 through two follow-up years. Results were comparable for the two programs with similar reductions in the number of people receiving inpatient care but increases in admissions and bed days. Possible problems with continuity of care, indicated by individuals using multiple facilities, were identified for both. Given the evidence of comparable results, the choice between the two approaches is likely to be dictated by various pragmatic and subjective factors other than their demonstrated effectiveness.

Medicaid managed care managed behavioral health care privatization 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Beinecke, R., Cavanaugh, D., Dickey, B., Fisher, W., Larson, M. J., Leff, H. S., Michel, J. O., Mulkern, V. M., McCarty, D., Norton, E., Shepard, D., Wieman, D., & Woocher, L. S. (1996). An overview of evaluations of the Massachusetts Medicaid managed behavioral health care program. Cambridge, MA: The Evaluation Center.Google Scholar
  2. Bergman, G. (1998). Then and now—Evolution of behavioral health managed care. SAMHSA Managed Care Tracking Report, 1.Google Scholar
  3. Berk, R. (1983, June). An introduction to sample selection bias in sociological data. American Sociological Review, 48, 386–398.Google Scholar
  4. Callahan, J., Shepard, D., Beinecke, R., Larson, M., & Cavanaugh, D. (1994). Evaluation of the Massachusetts Medicaid Mental Health/Substance Abuse Program. Waltham, MA: Brandeis University, Heller School for Advanced Studies in Social Welfare.Google Scholar
  5. Callahan, J., Shepard, D., Beinecke, R., Larson, M., & Cavanaugh, D. (1995). Mental health/substance abuse treatment in managed care: The Massachusetts Medicaid experience. Health Affairs, 14(3), 173–184.Google Scholar
  6. Campbell, D., & Stanley, J. (1965). Experimental and quasi-experimental designs for research. Chicago: Rand McNally.Google Scholar
  7. Center for Health Care Strategies, Inc. (1998). Medicaid managed care program update. Health Strategies Quarterly, 2, 4.Google Scholar
  8. Dickey, B., Normand, S., Norton, E., Azeni, H., Fisher, W., & Althaffer, F. (1996, October). Managing the care of schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry, 53, 945–952.Google Scholar
  9. Eddy, D. (1998). Performance measurement: Problems and solutions. Health Affairs, 17(4), 7–25.Google Scholar
  10. Fisher, W., & Phillips, B. (1990). Modeling the growth of long stay patients in public mental hospitals. Social Science and Medicine, 30, 1341–1347.Google Scholar
  11. Frank, R. G., & McGuire, T. G. (1997). Savings from a Medicaid carve-out for mental health and substance abuse services in Massachusetts. Psychiatric Services, 48(9), 1147–1152.Google Scholar
  12. Geller, J., Fisher, W., McDermeit, M., & Brown, J. (1998). The effects of public managed care on patterns of intensive use of inpatient psychiatric services. Psychiatric Services, 49(3), 327–332.Google Scholar
  13. Gold, M., Sparer, M., & Chu, K. (1996). Medicaid managed care: Lessons from five states. Health Affairs, 15(3), 153–166.Google Scholar
  14. Hurley, R., & McCue, M. (1998). Medicaid and commercial HMOs: An at-risk relationship. Princeton, NJ: Center for Health Care Strategies, Inc.Google Scholar
  15. Iglehart, J. K. (1996). Health policy report: Managed care and mental health. New England Journal of Medicine, 334(2), 131–135.Google Scholar
  16. Iverson, G., & Norpoth, H. (1976). Analysis of variance. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.Google Scholar
  17. Kleinbaum, D., Kupper, L., & Muller, K. (1988). Applied regression analysis and other multivariable methods (2nd ed.). Boston: PWS/Kent.Google Scholar
  18. Koran, L., Sox, H., Marton, K., et al. (1989). Medical evaluation of psychiatric patients. Archives of General Psychiatry, 46, 733–739.Google Scholar
  19. Leadholm, B., & Kerzner, J. (1995). Public managed care: Comprehensive community support in Massachusetts. Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 22(5), 543–552.Google Scholar
  20. Leff, H., & Woocher, L. (1998, March/April). Trends in the evaluation of managed mental health care. Harvard Review of Psychiatry, V, 344–347.Google Scholar
  21. McPheeters, H. (1984). Statewide mental health outcome evaluation: A perspective of two sourthern states. Community Mental Health Journal, 20, 44–55.Google Scholar
  22. Mechanic, D., Schlesinger, M., & McAlpine, D. (1995). Management of mental health and substance abuse services: State of the art and early results. Milbank Quarterly, 73, 19–55.Google Scholar
  23. Mental Health Report. (1998). Public sector managed care increases for mental health, substance abuse. Mental Health Report, 22(7), 56.Google Scholar
  24. Patterson, D. (1990). Managed care: An approach to rational psychiatric treatment. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 41, 1092–1095.Google Scholar
  25. Reid, W., Pham, V., & Rago, W. (1993). Clozapine use by state programs: Public mental health systems respond to a new medication. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 44(8), 739–743.Google Scholar
  26. Stroup, T., & Dorwart, R. (1995). State health care reform: Impact of a managed mental health program on Medicaid recipients with severe mental illness. Psychiatric Services, 46(9), 885–889.Google Scholar
  27. Stroup, T. S., & Dorwart, R. A. (1997). Overview of public sector managed mental health care. In K. Minkoff & D. Pollack (Eds.), Managed mental health care in the public sector: A survival guide. Amsterdam: Harwood Academic.Google Scholar
  28. Tanenbaum, S., & Hurley, R. (1995). Disability and the managed care frenzy: A cautionary note. Health Affairs, 14(4), 213–319.Google Scholar
  29. Wieman, D., & Dorwart, R. (1998). Evaluating state mental health care reform: The case of privatization of state mental health services in Massachusetts. In M. Gibelman & H. Demone (Eds.), The privatization of human services: Policy and practice issues, Volume 1. New York: Springer.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Plenum Publishing Corporation 1999

Authors and Affiliations

  • Dow A. Wieman
    • 1
  • Robert A. Dorwart
    • 2
  1. 1.John F. Kennedy School of GovernmentHarvard UniversityCambridge
  2. 2.John F. Kennedy School of Government and theHarvard Medical School Department of PsychiatryCambridge

Personalised recommendations