Advertisement

Health Care Management Science

, Volume 2, Issue 3, pp 161–172 | Cite as

Efficiency measurement of health care: a review of non‐parametric methods and applications

  • Bruce Hollingsworth
  • P.J. Dawson
  • N. Maniadakis
Article

Abstract

There has been increasing interest in measuring the productive performance of health care services, since the mid-1980s. This paper reviews this literature and, in particular, the concept and measurement of efficiency and productivity. Concerning measurement, we focus on the use of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), a technique particularly appropriate when multiple outputs are produced from multiple inputs. Applications to hospitals and to the wider context of general health care are reviewed and the empirical evidence from both the USA and Europe (EU) is that public rather than private provision is more efficient.

Keywords

Data Envelopment Analysis Data Envelopment Analysis Model Production Frontier Total Factor Productivity Growth Malmquist Index 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. [1]
    R.D. Banker, Maximum likelihood, consistency and DEA: a statistical foundation, Management Science 39(10) (1993) 1265–1273.Google Scholar
  2. [2]
    R.D. Banker, Hypothesis tests using data envelopment analysis, J. Productivity Analysis 7 (1996) 139–159.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. [3]
    R.D. Banker, R.F. Conrad and R.P. Strauss, A comparative application of data envelopment analysis and translog methods — an illustrative study of hospital production, Management Science 32(1) (1986) 30–44.Google Scholar
  4. [4]
    R.R. Bannick and Y.A. Ozcan, Efficiency analysis of federally funded hospitals: comparison of DoD and VA hospitals using data envelopment analysis, Health Services Management Research 8(2) (1995) 73–85.Google Scholar
  5. [5]
    G.R. Bitran and J. Valor-Sabatier, Some mathematical programming based measures of efficiency in health care institutions, Advances in Math. Programming and Financial Planning 1 (1987) 61–84.Google Scholar
  6. [6]
    J.L.T. Blank, E. Eggink and A.I. de Graaff, Een empirisch onderzoek naar de productiestructuur van verpleeghuizen in Nederland, Zuinig op Zorg (September, 1996) 3–5.Google Scholar
  7. [7]
    J.P. Borden, An assessment of the impact of diagnosis-related group (Drg)-based reimbursement on the technical efficiency of New Jersey hospitals using data envelopment analysis, J. Accounting and Public Policy 7 (1988) 77–96.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. [8]
    J.J. Burgess and P.W. Wilson, Technical efficiency in veterans administration hospitals, in: The Measurement of Productive Efficiency, eds. H.O. Fried, C.A.K. Lovell and S.S. Schmidt (Oxford Univ. Press, New York, 1993).Google Scholar
  9. [9]
    J.E. Burgess and P.W. Wilson, Decomposing hospital productivity changes, 1985–1988: a nonparametric Malmquist approach, J. Productivity Analysis 6 (1995) 343–363.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. [10]
    J.E. Burgess and P.W. Wilson, Hospital ownership and technical inefficiency, Management Science 42(1) (1996) 110–123.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. [11]
    P. Byrnes and V. Valdmanis, Analyzing technical and allocative effi-ciency of hospitals, in: DEA Theory, Methodology and Applications, eds. A. Charnes, W. Cooper, A. Lewin and L. Seiford (Kluwer, Boston, 1994).Google Scholar
  12. [12]
    R.A.D. Capettini and R.C. Morey, Reimbursement rate setting for medicaid prescription drugs based on relative efficiencies, J. Accounting and Public Policy 4 (1985) 83–110.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. [13]
    D.W. Caves, L.R. Christensen and W.E. Diewert, The economic theory of index numbers and the measurement of input, output and productivity, Econometrica 50 (1982) 1393–1414.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. [14]
    A. Charnes, W.W. Cooper and E. Rhodes, Measuring efficiency of decision making units, European J. Oper. Res. 2(6) (1978) 429–444. (Corrections: European J. Oper. Res. 3(4) (1979) 339.)CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. [15]
    A. Charnes, W.W. Cooper, A.Y Lewin and L.M. Seiford, Data Envelopment Analysis, Theory, Methodology and Applications (Kluwer, the Netherlands, 1994).Google Scholar
  16. [16]
    S. Chattopadhyay and C.S. Ray, Technical, scale, and size efficiency in nursing home care: a non-parametric analysis of Connecticut homes, Health Economics 5 (1996) 363–373.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. [17]
    S. Chattopadhyay and D. Heffley, Are for-profit nursing homes more efficient? Data envelopment analysis with a case-mix constraint, Eastern Economic J. 20(2) (1994) 171–187.Google Scholar
  18. [18]
    J.A. Chilingerian, Investigating non-medical factors associated with the technical efficiency of physicians in the provision of hospital services. A pilot study, Health Care Administration (1989) 85–89.Google Scholar
  19. [19]
    J.A. Chilingerian and H.D. Sherman, Managing physician efficiency and effectiveness in providing hospital services, Health Services Management Research 3(1) (1990) 3–15.Google Scholar
  20. [20]
    J.A. Chilingerian, Evaluating why some physicians hospital practices are more efficient: taking DEA inside the hospital, in: DEA Theory, Methodology and Applications, eds. A. Charnes, W. Cooper, A. Lewin and L. Seiford (Kluwer, Boston, 1994).Google Scholar
  21. [21]
    J.A. Chilingerian, Evaluating physician efficiency in hospitals — a multivariate-analysis of best practices, European J. Oper. Res. 80(3) (1995) 548–574.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. [22]
    J.A. Chilingerian and H.D. Sherman, Benchmarking physician practice patterns with DEA: a multi-stage approach for cost containment, Ann. Oper. Res. 67 (1997) 83–116.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. [23]
    J.A. Chilingerian and H.D. Sherman, DEA and primary care physician report cards: deriving preferred practice cones from managed care service concepts and operating strategies, Ann. Oper. Res. 73 (1996) 35–66.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. [24]
    T.N. Chirikos and A.M. Sear, Technical efficiency and the competitive behaviour of hospitals, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 28(4) (1994) 219–227.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. [25]
    D.A. Dittman, R. Capettini and R.C. Morey, Measuring efficiency in acute care hospitals: an application of data envelopment analysis, J. Health and Human Resources Administration 14(1) (1991) 89–108.Google Scholar
  26. [26]
    B. Efron and R. Tibshirani, An Introduction to the Bootstrap (Chapman and Hall, New York, 1993).Google Scholar
  27. [27]
    R.G. Evans, Behavioural cost functions for hospitals, Canadian J. Economics 4 (1971) 198–215.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  28. [28]
    R. Färe, S. Grosskopf and C.A.K. Lovell, The Measurement of Efficiency of Production (Kluwer-Nijhoff, Boston, 1985).Google Scholar
  29. [29]
    R. Färe, S. Grosskopf, B. Lindgren and P. Roos, Productivity developments in Swedish hospitals: A Malmquist output index approach, Discussion Paper No 89-3, Southern Illinois University, Illinois (1989).Google Scholar
  30. [30]
    R. Färe, S. Grosskopf, B. Lindgren and P. Roos, Productivity changes in Swedish pharmacies 1980–1989: a non-parametric Malmquist approach, J. Productivity Analysis 3 (1992) 85–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. [31]
    R. Färe, S. Grosskopf, B. Lindgren and P. Roos, Productivity developments in Swedish hospitals: a Malmquist output index approach, in: Data Envelopment Analysis: Theory, Methodology and Applications, eds. A. Charnes, W. Cooper, A. Lewin and L. Seiford (Kluwer, Boston, 1994).Google Scholar
  32. [32]
    R. Färe, S. Grosskopf, B. Lindgren and P. Roos, Productivity and quality changes in Swedish pharmacies, Internat. J. Production Economics 39 (1995) 137–147.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  33. [33]
    R. Färe, S. Grosskopf, B. Lindgren and J.P. Poullier, Productivity growth in health care delivery, Medical Care 35(4) (1997) 354–366.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. [34]
    M.J. Farrell, The measurement of productive efficiency, J. Royal Statistical Society Series A 120(3) (1957) 253–281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. [35]
    G.D. Ferrier and V. Valdmanis, Rural hospital performance and its correlates, J. Productivity Analysis 7 (1996) 63–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. [36]
    J.L. Fizel and T.S. Nunnikhoven, The efficiency of nursing-home chains, Applied Economics 25 (1993) 49–55.Google Scholar
  37. [37]
    S. Folland, A.C. Goodman and M. Stano, The Economics of Health and Health Care (Prentice-Hall, NJ, 1997).Google Scholar
  38. [38]
    A. Ganley and J.S. Cubbin, Public Sector Efficiency Measurement: Applications of Data Envelopment Analysis (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1992).Google Scholar
  39. [39]
    T.E. Getzen, Health Economics: Fundamentals and Flow of Funds (Wiley, New York, 1997).Google Scholar
  40. [40]
    S. Grosskopf, Efficiency and productivity, in: The Measurement of Productive Efficiency: Techniques and Applications, eds. H.O. Fried, C.A.K. Lovell and S.S. Schmidt (Oxford Univ. Press, New York, 1993).Google Scholar
  41. [41]
    S. Grosskopf and V. Valdmanis, Measuring hospital performance: a non-parametric approach, J. Health Economics 6 (1987) 89–107.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. [42]
    S. Grosskopf and V. Valdmanis, Evaluating hospital performance with case-mix-adjusted outputs, Medical Care 31(6) (1993) 525–532.Google Scholar
  43. [43]
    S.H.S. Hao and C.C. Pegels, Evaluating relative efficiencies of veterans affairs medical-centers using data envelopment, ratio, and multiple-regression analysis, J. Medical Systems 18(2) (1994) 55–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  44. [44]
    B. Hollingsworth and D. Parkin, The efficiency of Scottish acute hospitals — an application of data envelopment analysis, IMA J. Mathematics Applied in Medicine and Biology 12(3–4) (1995) 161–173.Google Scholar
  45. [45]
    I.K. Kleinsorge and D.F. Karney, Management of nursing-homes using data envelopment analysis, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 26(1) (1992) 57–71.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. [46]
    P. Kooreman, Data envelopment analysis and parametric frontier estimation — complementary tools, J. Health Economics 13(3) (1994) 345–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. [47]
    G.B. Lopez-Valcarcel and P.B. Perez, Changes in the efficiency of Spanish public hospitals after the introduction of program-contracts, Investigaciones Economica 20(3) (1996) 377–402.Google Scholar
  48. [48]
    C.A.K. Lovell, Production frontiers and productive efficiency, in: The Measurement of Productive Efficiency: Techniques and Applications, eds. H.O. Fried, C.A.K. Lovell and S.S. Schmidt (Oxford Univ. Press, New York, 1993).Google Scholar
  49. [49]
    K. Luoma, M. Jarvio, I. Suuoniemi and R. Hjerppe, Financial incentives and productive efficiency in Finnish health centres, Health Economics 5 (1996) 435–445.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  50. [50]
    A. Maindiratta, Largest size-efficient scale and size efficiencies of decision-making units in data envelopment analysis, J. Econometrics 46(1–2) (1990) 57–72.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. [51]
    J. Magnussen, Efficiency measurement and the operationalization of hospital production, Health Services Research 31(1) (1996) 21–37.Google Scholar
  52. [52]
    S. Malmquist, Index numbers and indifference surfaces, Trabajos de Estatistics 4 (1953) 209–242.Google Scholar
  53. [53]
    R.C. Morey and D.A. Dittman, Cost pass-through reimbursement to hospitals and their impacts on operating efficiencies, Ann. Oper. Res. 67 (1996) 117–139.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. [54]
    R.C. Morey, D.J. Fine and S.W. Loree, Comparing the allocative ef-ficiencies of hospitals, Internat. J. Management Science 18(1) (1990) 71–83.Google Scholar
  55. [55]
    J.P. Newhouse, Frontier estimation: how useful a tool for health economics?, J. Health Economics 13(3) (1994) 317–322.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. [56]
    M. Nishimuzu and J.M. Page, Total factor productivity growth, technological progress and technical efficiency change: dimensions of productivity change in Yugoslavia 1965–1978, Economic J. 92 (1982) 920–936.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. [57]
    T.R. Nunamaker, Measuring routine nursing service efficiency — a comparison of cost per patient day and data envelopment analysis models, Health Services Research 18(2) (1983) 183–205.Google Scholar
  58. [58]
    J.A. Nyman and D.L. Bricker, Profit incentives and technical effi-ciency in the production of nursing home care, Review of Economics and Statistics (1989) 586–594.Google Scholar
  59. [59]
    J.A. Nyman, D.L. Bricker and D. Link, Technical efficiency in nursing homes, Medical Care 28(6) (1990) 541–551.Google Scholar
  60. [60]
    OECD, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development CREDES Databases (Paris, 1997).Google Scholar
  61. [61]
    Y.A. Ozcan and J.R. Lynch, Rural hospital closures: an inquiry into efficiency, Advances in Health Economics and Health Services Research 13 (1992) 205–244.Google Scholar
  62. [62]
    Y.A. Ozcan, Sensitivity analysis of hospital efficiency under alternative output/input and Peer groups: a review, Internat. J. Knowledge Transfer and Utilisation 5(4) (1992) 1–29.Google Scholar
  63. [63]
    Y.A. Ozcan and R.R. Bannick, Trends in department of defense hospital efficiency, J. Medical Systems 18(2) (1994) 69–83.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  64. [64]
    Y.A. Ozcan, Efficiency of hospital-service production in local markets — the balance-sheet of US medical armament, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 29(2) (1995) 139–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  65. [65]
    Y.A. Ozcan, M.J. McCue and A.A. Okasha, Measuring the technical efficiency of psychiatric hospitals, J. Medical Systems 20(3) (1996a) 141–150.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  66. [66]
    Y.A. Ozcan, S.C. Yeh, D. McCollum and J.W. Begun, Trends in labor efficiency among American hospital markets, Ann. Oper. Res. 67 (1996b) 61–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  67. [67]
    D. Parkin and B. Hollingsworth, Measuring production efficiency of acute hospitals in Scotland 1991–1994: validity issues in data envelopment analysis, Applied Economics 29 (1997) 1425–1433.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. [68]
    V. Pina and L. Torres, Evaluating the efficiency of nonprofit organizations: an application of data envelopment analysis to the public health service, Financial Accountability and Management 8(3) (1992) 213–224.Google Scholar
  69. [69]
    R. Rosenman, K. Siddharthan and M. Ahern, Output efficiency of health maintenance organisations in Florida, Health Economics 6 (1997) 295–302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. [70]
    M.D. Rosko, J.A. Chilingerian, J.S. Zinn and W.E. Aaronson, The effects of ownership, operating environment, and strategic choices on nursing-home efficiency, Medical Care 33(10) (1995) 1001–1021.Google Scholar
  71. [71]
    J. Salinas-Jimenez and P. Smith, Data envelopment analysis applied to quality in primary health care, Ann. Oper. Res. 67 (1996) 141–161.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. [72]
    A.P. Schinnar, E. Kamis-Gould, N. Delucia and A.B. Rothbard, Organizational determinants of efficiency and effectiveness in mental health partial care programs, Health Services Research (1990) 387–421.Google Scholar
  73. [73]
    L.M. Seiford, Data envelopment analysis: the evolution of the state of the art, J. Productivity Analysis 7 (1996) 99–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. [74]
    T.R. Sexton, A.M. Leiken, A.H. Nolan, S. Liss, A. Hogan and R.H. Silkman, Evaluating managerial efficiency of veterans administration medical-centers using data envelopment analysis, Medical Care 27(12) (1989a) 1175–1188.Google Scholar
  75. [75]
    T.R. Sexton, A.M. Leiken, S. Sleeper and A.F. Coburn, The impact of prospective reimbursement on nursing home efficiency, Medical Care 27(2) (1989) 154–163.Google Scholar
  76. [76]
    R. Shepherd, Cost and Production Functions (Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, 1953).Google Scholar
  77. [77]
    H.D. Sherman, Hospital efficiency measurement and evaluation, Medical Care 22(10) (1984) 922–939.Google Scholar
  78. [78]
    R. Shone, Applications in Intermediate Microeconomics (Martin Robertson, Oxford, 1981).Google Scholar
  79. [79]
    R.H. Silkman, Measuring Efficiency: An Assessment of Data Envelopment Analysis (Jossey Bass, San Francisco, 1986).Google Scholar
  80. [80]
    L. Simar, Aspects of statistical analysis in DEA-type frontier models, J. Productivity Analysis 7 (1996) 177–185.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  81. [81]
    SPSS, SPSS for Windows: Base System User's Guide Release 6.0, SPSS, Illinois.Google Scholar
  82. [82]
    A. Szczepura, A. Davies, C.J. Fletcher and A. Boussofiane, Efficiency and effectiveness in general practice, J. Management in Medicine 7(5) (1993) 36–47.Google Scholar
  83. [83]
    M. Tambour, The impact of health care policy initiatives on productivity, Health Economics 6 (1997) 57–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  84. [84]
    E. Thanassoulis, A. Boussofiane and R.G. Dyson, A comparison of data envelopment analysis and ratio analysis as tools for performance assessment, Omega Internat. J. Management Science 24(3) (1996) 229–244.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  85. [85]
    L.H. Tyler, Y.A. Ozcan and S.E. Wogen, Mental health case management and technical efficiency, J. Medical Systems 19(5) (1995) 413–423.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  86. [86]
    V. Valdmanis, Ownership and technical efficiency of hospitals, Medical Care 28(6) (1990) 552–561.Google Scholar
  87. [87]
    V. Valdmanis, Sensitivity analysis for DEA models — an empirical example using public Vs NFP hospitals, J. Public Economics 48(2) (1992) 185–205.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  88. [88]
    A. Wagstaff, Quantitative techniques for investigating health service efficiency, paper presented at seminar on Economia y Salud del Sistema Sanitario Espanol, Santander, Spain (1992).Google Scholar
  89. [89]
    K.R. White and Y.A. Ozcan, Church ownership and hospital efficiency, Hospital and Health Services Administration 41(3) (1996) 297–310.Google Scholar
  90. [90]
    J. Yeh, K.R. White and Y.A. Ozcan, Efficiency evaluation of community based youth services in Virginia, Community Mental Health J. 33(6) (1997) 487–499.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  91. [91]
    S.T. Young, Multiple productivity measurement approaches for management, Health Care Management Review 17(2) (1992) 51–58.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1999

Authors and Affiliations

  • Bruce Hollingsworth
    • 1
  • P.J. Dawson
    • 1
  • N. Maniadakis
    • 1
  1. 1.Health Economics Group, Department of Epidemiology and Public HealthUniversity of Newcastle upon TyneNewcastle upon TyneUK E-mail:

Personalised recommendations