Advertisement

Health Care Analysis

, Volume 9, Issue 4, pp 449–462 | Cite as

Power Issues in the Doctor-Patient Relationship

  • Felicity Goodyear-Smith
  • Stephen Buetow
Article

Abstract

Power is an inescapable aspect of all socialrelationships, and inherently is neither goodnor evil. Doctors need power to fulfil theirprofessional obligations to multipleconstituencies including patients, thecommunity and themselves. Patients need powerto formulate their values, articulate andachieve health needs, and fulfil theirresponsibilities. However, both parties canuse or misuse power. The ethical effectivenessof a health system is maximised by empoweringdoctors and patients to develop `adult-adult'rather than `adult-child' relationships thatrespect and enable autonomy, accountability,fidelity and humanity. Even in adult-adultrelationships, conflicts and complexitiesarise. Lack of concordance between doctors andpatients can encourage paternalism but may bebest resolved through negotiated care. Afurther area of conflict involves the `doubleagency' of doctors for both patients and thecommunity. Empowerment of all players is notalways possible but is most likely where eachparty considers and acknowledges power issues.

patient-centred care physician-patient relations power (psychology) 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Toffler, A. (1990) Powershift: Knowledge, Wealth and Violence At the Edge of the 21st Century. Bantam Books.Google Scholar
  2. Pappas, G. (1990) Some Implications for the Study of the Doctor-Patient Interaction: Power, Structure, and Agency in the Works of Howard Waitzkin and Arthur Kleinman. Social Science & Medicine 30(2), 199-204.Google Scholar
  3. Acton, L. (1904) Letter to Bishop Mandell Creighton. Life and letters of Mandell Creighton, p. 372.Google Scholar
  4. Charles, C.,Gafni, A. andWhelan, T. (1997) Shared Decision-Making in the Medical Encounter: What Does It Mean? (Or It Takes at Least Two to Tango). Social Science & Medicine 44(5), 681-692.Google Scholar
  5. Charles, C.,Gafni, A. andWhelan, T. (1999) Decision-making in the Physician-Patient Encounter: Revisiting the Shared Treatment Decision-Making Model. Social Science & Medicine 49(5), 651-661.Google Scholar
  6. Mead, N. andBower, P. (2000) Patient Centredness: A Conceptual Framework and Review of the Empirical Literature. Social Science & Medicine 51, 1087-1110.Google Scholar
  7. Emanuel, E.J. andEmanuel, L.L. (1992) Four Models of the Physician-Patient Relationship. Journal of the American Medical Association 267(16), 2221-2226.Google Scholar
  8. Gwyn, R. andElwyn, G. (1999) When is a Shared Decision Not (Quite) a Shared Decision? Negotiating Preferences in a General Practice Encounter. Social Science & Medicine 49(4), 437-447.Google Scholar
  9. Parsons, T. (1951) The Social System. Glencoe, Il: Free Press.Google Scholar
  10. McKinstry, B. (1992) Paternalism and the Doctor-Patient Relationship in General Practice. British Journal of General Practice 42(361), 340-342.Google Scholar
  11. Freidson, E. (1960) Client Control and Medical Practice. American Journal of Sociology 65, 374-382.Google Scholar
  12. Illich, I. (1974) Medical Nemesis. Lancet 1( 7863), 918-921.Google Scholar
  13. Navarro, V. (1988) Professional Dominance or Proletarianization? Milbank Quarterly 66(Suppl 2), 57-75.Google Scholar
  14. Williams, B. (1994) Patient Satisfaction: A Valid Concept? Social Science & Medicine 38(4), 509-516.Google Scholar
  15. Tuckett, D.,Boulton, M.,Olson, C. andWilliams, A. (1985) Meetings Between Experts: An Approach To Sharing Ideas in Medical Consultations. London: Tavistock.Google Scholar
  16. Hodges, I.D., Wilkie, A., Drennan, C., Toop, L., Thornley, P., O'Hagan, J. et al. (1993) A Community Wide Promotion of Asthma Self Management: Process Evaluation. New Zealand Medical Journal 106(962), 354-347.Google Scholar
  17. Szasz, T. andHollender, M. (1956) A Contribution to the Philosophy of Medicine: The Basic Models of the Doctor-Patient Relationship. Archives of Internal Medicine 97, 585-592.Google Scholar
  18. Stewart, M. andRoter, D. (1989) Communicating with Medical Patients. Newbury Park: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
  19. McMillan, R.C. (1995) Responsibility to or for in the Physician-patient Relationship? Journal of Medical Ethics 21(2), 112-115.Google Scholar
  20. Balint, J. andShelton, W. (1996) Regaining the Initiative. Forging a New Model of the Patient-Physician Relationship. Journal of the American Medical Association 275(11), 887-891.Google Scholar
  21. Brody, H. (1992) The Healer's Power. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  22. Brody, H. (1980) Placebos and the Philosophy of Medicine. Chicago: Chicago Press.Google Scholar
  23. McWhinney, I. (1981) A Textbook of Family Medicine. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  24. Buetow, S. (1998a) The Scope for the Involvement of Patients in Their Consultations with Health Professionals: Rights, Responsibilities and Preferences of Patients. Journal of Medical Ethics 24(4), 243-247.Google Scholar
  25. Anderson, R.M.,Funnell, M.M.,Butler, P.M.,Arnold, M.S.,Fitzgerald, J.T. andFeste, C.C. (1995) Patient Empowerment. Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial. Diabetes Care 18(7), 943-949.Google Scholar
  26. Lerman, C.E.,Brody, D.S.,Caputo, G.C.,Smith, D.G.,Lazaro, C.G.andWolfson, H.G. (1990) Patients' Perceived Involvement in Care Scale: Relationship to Attitudes about Illness and Medical Care. Journal of General Internal Medicine 5(1), 29-33.Google Scholar
  27. Bacon, F. (1971) Essay of Friendship. The Essays. Menston: Scholar Press (1625 ed. reprinted).Google Scholar
  28. Parker, H. (1997) Beyond Ethnic Categories: Why Racism Should be a Variable in Health Services Research. Journal of Health Services & Research Policy 2(4), 256-258.Google Scholar
  29. Saltman, R.B.,Figueras, J. andSakellarides, C. (1998) State of Health Part two: Demand Side Strategies. Critical Challenges for Health Care Reform in Europe.Google Scholar
  30. Chen, G.J. andFeldman, S.R. (2000) Economic Aspect of Health Care Systems. Advantage and Disadvantage Incentives in Different Systems. Dermatologic Clinics 18(2), 211-214.Google Scholar
  31. Pencheon, D. (1998) Matching Demand and Supply Fairly and Efficiently. British Medical Journal 316(7145), 1665-1667.Google Scholar
  32. Dorrell, S. andBogle, I. (1996) Stephen Dorrell Launches £2.75 Million Doctor/patient Partnership Campaign. Press release. London: Department of Health & British Medical Association, 28 February 1996.Google Scholar
  33. Lehrman, N.S. (1991) Chronic Patients' Power Games and the Proper Setting of Limits. Psychiatric Quarterly 62(1), 67-74.Google Scholar
  34. Laidlaw, T. and Goodyear-Smith, F. “Heart-sink” Patients May Benefit from Diagnosis with Personality Disorder. New Zealand Family Physician 24 (4), 13-14.Google Scholar
  35. Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain (1997) From Compliance to Concordance: Achieving Shared Goals in Medicine Taking. London: Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain.Google Scholar
  36. Graber, G. (1998) Basic Theories in Medical Ethics. In: J. Monagle andD. Thomasma (Eds.), Health Care Ethics. Critical Issues for the 21st Century. Gaithersburg (pp. 515-526). Aspen Publishers.Google Scholar
  37. Tobias, J.S. andSouhami, R.L. (1993) Fully Informed Consent Can be Needlessly Cruel. British Medical Journal 307(6913), 1199-1201.Google Scholar
  38. Goodyear-Smith, F. (1999) Ethical Considerations of Informed Consent: A Personal Opinion. New Zealand General Practice 10 September, 32-33.Google Scholar
  39. Kessel, A.S. (1994) On Failing to Understand Informed Consent. British Journal of Hospital Medicine 52(5), 235-238.Google Scholar
  40. Pincus, R.C. (1993) Has Informed Consent Finally Arrived in Australia? A Comment on the Law Following the Decision of the High Court of Australia in Rogers v. Whitaker. Medical Journal of Australia 159(1), 25-27.Google Scholar
  41. Potter, N. ( 1996) Discretionary Power, Lies, and Broken Trust: Justification and Discomfort. Theoretical Medicine 17(4), 329-352.Google Scholar
  42. Bakhurst, D. (1992) On Lying and Deceiving. Journal of Medical Ethics 18(2), 63-66.Google Scholar
  43. Hui, E. (1999) Chinese Health Care Ethics. In: H. Coward andP. Ratanakul (Eds.), A Cross-Cultural Dialogue on Health Care Ethics (pp. 128-137). Waterloo: Wilfred Laurier University Press.Google Scholar
  44. Quill, T.E. andBrody, H. (1996) Physician Recommendations and Patient Autonomy: Finding a Balance Between Physician Power and Patient Choice. Annals of Internal Medicine 125(9), 763-769.Google Scholar
  45. Fox, M. (1979) A Spirituality Named Compassion. San Francisco: Harper and Row.Google Scholar
  46. Buetow, S. (1998b) Four Strategies for Negotiated Care. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 91(4), 199-201.Google Scholar
  47. Angell, M. (1993) The Doctor as Double Agent. Kennedy Institute Ethics Journal 3, 279-286.Google Scholar
  48. Rifkin, D.E. (1999) Community Considerations: The Many Effects of Miscoding. Journal of the American Medical Association 282(17), 1676-1677.Google Scholar
  49. Tännsjö, T. (1999) Coercive Care: The Ethics of Choice in Health and Medicine. London: Rutledge.Google Scholar
  50. Ubel, P. (1999) Physicians' Duties in an Era of Cost Containment: Advocacy or Betrayal? Journal of the American Medical Association 282(17), 1675.Google Scholar
  51. Bauer, M. and Bach, A. Managed Care. Its Impact on Health care in the USA, Especially on Anesthesia and Intensive Care. Anaesthesist 47 (6), 442-459.Google Scholar
  52. Flynn, M. (1995) Power, Professionalism, and Patient Advocacy. American Journal of Surgery 170(5), 407-409.Google Scholar
  53. Friedman, E. (1995) The Power of Physicians: Autonomy and Balance in a Changing System. American Journal of Medicine 99(6), 579-586.Google Scholar
  54. Siegler, M. (1981) Searching for Moral Certainty in Medicine: A Proposal for a New Model of the Doctor-Patient Encounter. Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 57(1), 56-69.Google Scholar
  55. Chell, B. (1998) Competency: What It Is, What It Isn't, and Why It Matters. In: J. Monagle andD. Thomas (Eds.), Heath Care Ethics: Critical Issues for the 21st Century. Gaithersberg: Aspen Publishers Inc.Google Scholar
  56. Brennan, T.A. (1993) An Ethical Perspective on Health Care Insurance Reform. American Journal of Law & Medicine 19(1-2), 37-74.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Felicity Goodyear-Smith
    • 1
  • Stephen Buetow
    • 2
  1. 1.Division of General Practice & Primary Health Care, Faculty of Medical & Health SciencesUniversity of AucklandAucklandNew Zealand
  2. 2.Division of General Practice & Primary Health Care, Faculty of Medical & Health SciencesUniversity of AucklandAucklandNew Zealand

Personalised recommendations