Climatic Change

, Volume 52, Issue 1–2, pp 65–91 | Cite as

Risk Estimation of Collapse of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet

  • David G. Vaughan
  • John R. Spouge


Complete collapse of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) would raise global sea level by around 5 m, but whether collapse is likely, or even possible, has been `glaciology's grand unsolved problem' for more than two decades. Collapse of WAIS may result from readjustments continuing since the last glacial maximum, or more recent climate change, but it is also possible that collapse will result from internal flow instabilities, or not occur at all in the present inter-glacial. Such complexity led the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change to conclude in its Second Assessment Report that `estimating the likelihood of a collapse during the next century is not yet possible'. However, a refusal by scientists to estimate the risk leaves policy-makers with no sound scientific basis on which to respond to legitimate public concerns. Here we present a discussion of the likelihood of WAIS-collapse, drawing input from an interdisciplinary panel of experts. The results help to summarise the state of scientific knowledge and uncertainty. While the overall opinion of the panel was that WAIS most likely will not collapse in the next few centuries, their uncertainty retains a 5% probability of WAIS causing sea level rise at least 10 mm/year within 200 years. Since this uncertainty reflects both the unpredictability of the physical system and the scientific uncertainty, it will undoubtedly change as a better understanding is established.


Climate Change Risk Estimation Assessment Report Intergovernmental Panel Unsolved Problem 
These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Bentley, C. R.: 1982, ‘West Antarctic Ice Sheet: Diagnosis and Prognosis’, Carbon Dioxide Research Conference: Carbon Dioxide, Science and Consensus, Conference 820970, Dept. of Energy, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
  2. Bentley, C. R.: 1998a, ‘Ice on the Fast Track’, Nature 394, 21–22.Google Scholar
  3. Bentley, C. R.: 1998b, ‘Rapid Sea-Level Rise from a West Antarctic Ice-Sheet Collapse: A Short-Term Perspective’, J. Glaciol. 44, 157–163.Google Scholar
  4. Bindschadler, R. A.: 1997, ‘West Antarctic Ice Sheet Collapse?’, Science 276, 662–663.Google Scholar
  5. Bindschadler, R. A.: 1998, ‘Future of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet’, Science 282, 428–429.Google Scholar
  6. Bindschadler, R. A., Alley, R. B., Anderson, J., Shipp, S., Borns, H., Fastook, J., Jacobs, S., Raymond, C. F., and Shuman, C. A.: 1999, ‘What is Happening to the West Antarctic Ice Sheet?’, EOS. 79, 257, 264–265.Google Scholar
  7. Bindschadler, R. A. and Vornberger, P.: 1998, ‘Changes in the West Antarctic Ice Sheet since 1963 from Declassified Satellite Photography’, Science 279, 689–692.Google Scholar
  8. Blankenship, D. D., Bell, R. E., Hodge, S.M., Brozena, J. M., Behrendt, J. C., and Finn, C. A.: 1993, ‘Active Volcanism beneath the West Antarctic Ice Sheet and Implications for Ice-Sheet Stability’, Nature 361, 526–529.Google Scholar
  9. Budd, W. F., McInnes, B. J., Jenssen, D., and Smith, I. N.: 1987, ‘Modelling the Response of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet to a Climatic Warming’, in van der Veen, C. J., and Oerlemans, J. (eds.), Dynamics of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, pp. 321–358.Google Scholar
  10. Center for Chemical Process Safety: 1992, ‘Guidelines for Hazard Evaluation Procedure’, 2nd edition, American Institute of Chemical, Engineers, New York.Google Scholar
  11. Clemen, R. T. and Winkler, R. L.: 1999, ‘Combining Probability Distributions from Experts in Risk Analysis’, Risk Analysis 19, 187–203.Google Scholar
  12. Dalkey, N. C.: 1969, ‘The Delphi Method: An Experimental Study of Group Opinion’, RM-5888-PR. The Rand Corporation.Google Scholar
  13. Department of the Environment: 1995, A Guide to Risk Assessment and Risk Management for Environmental Protection, The Stationery Office, London, pp. 1–92.Google Scholar
  14. Det Norske Veritas: 1997, Risks from BSA via Environmental Pathways, Report to the Environment Agency 1997, Det Norske Veritas, London.Google Scholar
  15. Doake, C. S. M., Corr, H. F. J., Rott, H., Skvarca, P., and Young, N. W.: 1998, ‘Breakup and Conditions for Stability of the Northern Larsen Ice Shelf, Antarctica’, Nature 391, 778–780.Google Scholar
  16. European Environment Agency: 1998, ‘Environmental Risk Assessment – Approaches, Experiences and Information Sources’, European Environment Agency, Copenhagen.Google Scholar
  17. Environmental Protection Agency: 1998, ‘Guidelines for Ecological Risk Assessment’, Risk Assessment Forum, U.S. Environment Protection Agency, Washington D.C.Google Scholar
  18. Fairbanks, R. G.: 1989, ‘A 17,000-year Glacio-Eustatic Sea Level Record: Influence of Glacial Melting Rates in the Younger Dryas Event and Deep-Ocean Circulation’, Nature 342, 637–642.Google Scholar
  19. Fowler, T., Gabroski, M., and Harrald: 1997, ‘Overview of Prince William Sound Risk Assessment Project’, Institute of Marine Engineers, Marine Risk Assessment Conference 1997, London.Google Scholar
  20. Fox, A. J. and Cooper, A. P. R.: 1994, ‘Measured Properties of the Antarctic Ice Sheet Derived from the SCAR Antarctic Digital Database’, Pol. Rec. 30, 201–206.Google Scholar
  21. Gudmundsson, M. T., Sigmundsson, F., and Bjornsson, H.: 1997, ‘Ice-Volcano Interaction of the 1996 Gjalp Subglacial Eruption, Vatnajokull, Iceland’, Nature 389, 954–957.Google Scholar
  22. Her Majesty's Inspectors of Pollution: 1996, Risk Assessment of Dioxin Releases from Municipal Waste Incineration Processes. Her Majesty's Inspectors of Pollution, London.Google Scholar
  23. Hindmarsh, R. C. A.: 1990, ‘Time-Scales and Degrees of Freedom Operating the Evolution of Continental Ice-Sheets’, Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Sciences 81, 371–384.Google Scholar
  24. Hindmarsh, R. C. A.: 1996, ‘Stability of Ice Rises and Uncoupled Marine Ice Sheets’, Ann. Glaciol. 23, 105–115.Google Scholar
  25. Houghton, J. T., Jenkins, G. J., and Ephraums, J. J.: 1990, Climate Change: The IPCC Scientific Assessment, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 1–364.Google Scholar
  26. Hughes, T. J.: 1973, ‘Is the West Antarctic Ice Sheet Disintegrating?’, J. Geophys. Res. 78, 7884–7910.Google Scholar
  27. Hughes, T. J.: 1982, ‘The Stability of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet: What Has Happened and What Will Happen?’, Carbon Dioxide Research Conference: Carbon Dioxide, Science and Consensus, Conference 820970, Dept. of Energy, Washington, D.C.Google Scholar
  28. Huybrechts, P. and De Wolde, J.: 1999, ‘The Dynamic Response of the Greenland and Antarctic Ice Sheets to Multiple-Century Climatic Warming’, J. Climate 12, 2169–2188.Google Scholar
  29. Jacobs, S. S., Helmer, H. H., Doake, C. S. M., Jenkins, A., and Frolich, R. M.: 1992, ‘Melting of Ice Shelves and the Mass Balance of Antarctica’, J. Glaciol. 38, 375–387.Google Scholar
  30. Keith, D. W.: 1996, ‘When Is It Appropriate to Combine Expert Judgements?’, Clim. Change 33, 139–143.Google Scholar
  31. Lingle, C. S.: 1985, ‘A Model of a Polar Ice Stream and Future Sea Level Rise Due to Possible Drastic Retreat of theWest Antarctic Ice Sheet’, in Glaciers, Ice Sheets, and Sea Level: Effect of a CO 2 —Induced Climatic Change, Dept. of Energy, Washington D.C. DOE/ER/60235/1, 317–330.Google Scholar
  32. Lythe, M., Vaughan, D. G., and The BEDMAP Consortium: 2001, ‘BEDMAP: A New Ice Thickness and Subglacial Topographic Model of Antarctica’, J. Geophys. Res. 106 (B6), 11335–11352.Google Scholar
  33. MacAyeal, D. R.: 1992, ‘Irregular Oscillations on the West Antarctic Ice Sheet’, Nature 359, 29–32.Google Scholar
  34. Mercer, J. H.: 1968, ‘Antarctic Ice and Sangamon Sea Level’, International Association of Scientific Hydrology Symposia 79, 217–225.Google Scholar
  35. Mercer, J. H.: 1978, ‘West Antarctic Ice Sheet and CO2 Greenhouse Effect: A Threat of Disaster’, Nature 271, 321–325.Google Scholar
  36. Nicholls, K.W.: 1997, ‘Predicted Reduction in Basal Meltrates for an Antarctic Ice Shelf in aWarmer Climate’, Nature 388, 460–462.Google Scholar
  37. Ohmura, A., Wild, M., and Bengtsson, L.: 1996, ‘A Possible Change in Mass Balance of Greenland and Antarctic Ice Sheets in the Coming Century’, J. Climate 9, 2124–2135.Google Scholar
  38. Oppenheimer, M.: 1998, ‘Global warming and the stability of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet’, Nature 393, 325–332.Google Scholar
  39. Paterson, W. S. B.: 1993, ‘World Sea Level and the PresentMass Balance of the Antarctic Ice Sheet’, NATO ASI Series 12, 131–140.Google Scholar
  40. Perissontto, R. and Pakhomov, E. A.: 1998, ‘Contribution of Salps to Carbon Flux of Marginal Ice Zone of the Lazarev Sea, Southern Ocean’, Marine Biology 131, 25–32.Google Scholar
  41. Pidgeon, N., Hood, C., Jones, D., Turner, B., and Gibson, R.: 1992, ‘Risk Perception’, in Risk: Analysis, Perception and Management, The Royal Society, London, pp. 89–134.Google Scholar
  42. Rose, K. E.: 1979, ‘Characteristics of Ice Flow in Marie Byrd Land, Antarctica’, J. Glaciol. 24, 63–75.Google Scholar
  43. Sammonds, P. R.: 1999, ‘Understanding the Fundamental Physics Governing the Evolution and Dynamics of the Earth's Crust and Ice Sheets’, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London A. 357, 3377–3401.Google Scholar
  44. Scherer, R. 1993: ‘There is Direct Evidence for Pleistocene Collapse of theWest Antarctic Ice Sheet’, J. Glaciol. 39, 716–722.Google Scholar
  45. Scherer, R. P., Aldahan, A., Tulaczyk, S., Possnert, G., Engelhardt, H., and Kamb, B.: 1998, ‘Pleistocene Collapse of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet’, Science 281, 82–85.Google Scholar
  46. Shabtaie, S. and Bentley, C. R.: 1987, ‘West Antarctic Ice Streams Draining into the Ross Ice Shelf: Configuration and Mass Balance’, J. Geophys. Res. 92, 1311–1336.Google Scholar
  47. Spouge, J. and Vaughan, D. G.: 1999, ‘Risk Estimation of the Collapse of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet’, Final Report the Dept. of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, Det Norske Veritas, London, p. 40.Google Scholar
  48. Thomas, R. H.: 1979, ‘Effect of Climatic Warming on the West Antarctic Ice Sheet’, Nature 277, 355–358.Google Scholar
  49. Titus, J. G. and Narayanan, V.: 1995, The Probability of Sea Level Rise, Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C., pp. 1–197.Google Scholar
  50. Titus, J. G. and Narayanan, V.: 1996, ‘The Risk of Sea Level Rise: A Delphic Monte Carlo Analysis in which Twenty Researcher Specify Subjective Probability Distributions for Model Coefficients within their Respective Areas of Expertise’, Clim. Change 33, 151–212.Google Scholar
  51. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency: 1998, ‘Guidelines for Ecological Risk Assessment’, Washington, D.C., U.S. Environment Protection Agency, Risk Assessment Forum.Google Scholar
  52. Vaughan, D. G.: 1999, ‘A Review of the Causes and Mechanisms that May Lead to Globally Significant Change in the Antarctic Ice Sheet 1999’, British Antarctic Survey Report for DNV Ltd and DETR.Google Scholar
  53. Vaughan, D. G., Bamber, J. L., Giovinetto, M., Russell, J., and Cooper, A. P. R.: 1999, ‘Reassessment of Net Surface Mass Balance in Antarctica’, J. Climate 12, 933–946.Google Scholar
  54. Vaughan, D. G. and Doake, C. S.M.: 1996, ‘Recent AtmosphericWarming and Retreat of Ice Shelves on the Antarctic Peninsula’, Nature 379, 328–331.Google Scholar
  55. Warrick, R. A., Le Provost, C., Meier, M., Oerlemans, J., and Woodworth, P. L.: 1996, ‘Changes in Sea Level’, in Houghton J. T., Meira Filho, L. G., Callander, B. A., Harris, N., Kattenberg, A., and Maskell, K. (eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 358–405.Google Scholar
  56. Weertman, J.: 1974, ‘Stability of the Junction of an Ice Sheet and an Ice Shelf’, J. Glaciol. 13, 3–11.Google Scholar
  57. Weertman, J.: 1976, ‘Glaciology's Grand Unsolved Problem’, Nature 260, 284–286.Google Scholar
  58. Wingham, D. J., Ridout, A. J., Scharroo, R., Arthern, R. J., and Schum, C. K.: 1998, ‘Antarctic Elevation Change from 1992 to 1996’, Science 282, 456–458. (Received 10 July 2000; in revised form 6 April 2001)Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2002

Authors and Affiliations

  • David G. Vaughan
    • 1
  • John R. Spouge
    • 2
  1. 1.British Antarctic SurveyCambridgeU.K
  2. 2.Det Norske VeritasLondonU.K

Personalised recommendations