Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy

, Volume 4, Issue 2, pp 139–151 | Cite as

Criteria for patient decision making (in)competence: A review of and commentary on some empirical approaches

  • Sander P. K. Welie


The principle of autonomy presupposes Patient Decision Making Competence (PDMC). For a few decades a considerable amount of empirical research has been done into PDMC. In this contribution that research is explored. After a short exposition on four qualities involved in PDMC, different approaches to assess PDMC are distinguished, namely a negative and a positive one. In the negative approach the focus is on identifying psychopathologic conditions that impair sound decision making; the positive one attempts to assess whether a patient actually has the required abilities and qualities. Characteristic of the latter approach is the use of (or development of) test-like instruments for PDMC assessment. Some of these tests are discussed and commented on. Although they may be useful in investigating aspects of PDMC, none of the described approaches and tests offers a reliable and valid method for PDMC assessment. In response to a potential misuse of tests, the concept of a “supportive situation” is briefly introduced in order to draw attention to the risk of prematurely deeming patients incompetent on the basis of low test scores, whereas their insufficient performance may be (partly) attributable to alack of situational support. Also, the need for and possibility of an emotionalist concept of PDMC are suggested, as an alternative to the more common rationalist one. In this regard,the legitimacy of competence being conceived as a presumption or fiction of law, deserves further investigation.

emotional competence empirical criteria incompetence legal fiction of competence psychology supportive situation tests 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Alexander, M.P.: 1988, 'Clinical Determination of Mental Competence: A Theory and a Retrospective Study', Archives of Neurology 45 (1), 23–26.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  2. American Psychiatric Assocation: 1994, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders IVTM. Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Assocation.Google Scholar
  3. Appelbaum, P.S. and L.H. Roth: 1982, 'Competency to Consent to Research: A Psychiatric Overview', Archives of General Psychiatry 39 (8), 951–958.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  4. Appelbaum, P.S. and T. Grisso: 1995, 'The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. I: Mental Illness and Competence to Consent to Treatment', Law and Human Behavior 19 (2), 105–126.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  5. Appelbaum, P.S. and T. Grisso: 1997, 'Capacities of Hospitalized, Medically Ill Patients to Consent to Treatment', Psychosomatics 38 (2), 119–125.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  6. Appelbaum, P.S.: 1998, 'Ought We to Require Emotional Capacity as Part of Decisional Competence?', Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 8 (4), 377–387.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  7. Bean, G., S. Nishisato, N.A. Rector and G. Glancy: 1996, 'The Assessment of Competence to Make a Treatment Decision: An Empirical Approach', Can. J. Psychiatry 41 (2), 85–92.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  8. Beauchamp, T.L. and J.F. Childress: 1994, Principles of Biomedical Ethics. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  9. Berghmans, R.L.P.: 2000, Bekwaam genoeg? Wils(on)bekwaamheid in geneeskunde, gezondheidsrecht en gezondheidsethiek (Preadvies uitgebracht ten behoeve van de jaarvergadering van de Nederlandse Vereniging voor Bioethiek, op 23 juni 2000). Utrecht: Nederlandse Vereniging voor Bio–ethiek.Google Scholar
  10. Biesaart, M.C.I.H., J.H. Hubben and G.H.v. Gemert: 2000, Methodiek voor de vaststelling van wilsonbekwaamheid bij mensen met een verstandelijke handicap: verslag van een onderzoek verricht met steun van Stichting Philadelphia Zorg en Vereniging Gehandicaptenzorg Nederland.Nunspeet/Utrecht: Stichting Philadelphia Zorg/Vereniging Gehandicaptenzorg Nederland.Google Scholar
  11. Black, H.C., J.R. Nolan and J.M. Nolan–Haley: 1990, Black's Law Dictionary: Definitions of the Terms and Phrases of American and English Jurisprudence, Ancient and Modern. St. Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.Google Scholar
  12. Callahan, S.: 1988, 'The Role of Emotion in Ethical Decision Making', Hastings Center Report (June/July) 18, 9–14.Google Scholar
  13. Charland, L.C.: 1998, 'Appreciation and Emotion: Theoretical Reflections on theMacArthur Treatment Competence Study', Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 8 (4), 359–376.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  14. Cohen, L.M., J.D. McCue and G.M. Green: 1993, 'Do Clinical and Formal Assessments of the Capacity of Patients in the Intensive Care Unit to Make Decisions Agree?', Arch. Intern. Med. 153 (21), 2481–2485.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cournos, F.: 1993, 'Do Psychiatric Patients Need Greater Protection than Medical Patients when They Consent to Treatment?', Psychiatric Quarterly 64 (4), 319–329.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Culver, C.M. and B. Gert: 1990, 'The Inadequacy of Incompetence', The Milbank Quarterly 68 (4), 619–643.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  17. Diamond, E.L., J.A. Jernigan, R.A. Moseley, V. Messina and R.A. McKeown: 1989, 'Decision–Making Ability and Advance Directive Preferences in Nursing Home Patients and Proxies. 21st Annual Spring Conference of the Society of Teachers of Family Medicine (1988, Baltimore, Maryland)', Gerontologist 29 (5), 622–626.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  18. Drane, J.F.: 1984, 'Competency to Give an Informed Vonsent.A Model for Making Clinical Assessments', Journal of the American Medical Association 252 (7), 925–927.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  19. Drane, J.F.: 1985, 'The Many Faces of Competency', Hastings Center Report 15 (2), 17–21.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  20. Fitten, L.J. and M.S. Waite: 1990a, 'Impact of Medical Hospitalization on Treatment Decision–Making Capacity in the Elderly', Arch. Intern. Med. 150(8), 1717–1721.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Fitten, L.J., R. Lusky and C. Hamann: 1990b, 'Assessing Treatment Decision–Making Capacity in Elderly Nursing Home Residents', Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 38 (10), 1097–1104.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  22. Folstein, M.F., S.E. Folstein and P.R. McHugh: 1975, 'Minimental State: A Practical Method for Grading the Cognitive State of Patients for the Clinician', Journal of Psychiatric Research 12 (3), 189–198.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Freedman, B.: 1981, 'Competence, Marginal and Otherwise: Concepts and Ethics', International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 4 (1–2), 53–72.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Freedman, M., D.T. Stuss and M. Gordon: 1991, 'Assessment of Competency: The Role of Neurobehavioral Deficits', Annals of Internal Medicine 115 (3), 203–208.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  25. Frijda, N.: 1993, De psychologie heeft zin. Amsterdam: Prometheus.Google Scholar
  26. Glass, K.C.: 1997, 'Refining Definitions and Devising Instruments: Two Decades of Assessing Mental Competence', International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 20 (1), 5–33.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  27. Golinger, R.C. and J.P. Fedoroff: 1989, 'Characteristics of Patients Referred to Psychiatrists for Competency Evaluations', Psychosomatics 30 (3), 296–299.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  28. Gouwenberg, B.M., C. Jonker, J.H. Smit and B. Schmand: 1997, Beoordeling van wilsbekwaamheid bij ouderen met dementie: ontwikkeling van een methode. Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit.Google Scholar
  29. Grisso, T., P.S. Appelbaum, E.P. Mulvey and K. Fletcher: 1995a, 'The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. II: Measures of Abilities Related to Competence to Consent to Treatment', Law and Human Behavior 19 (2), 127–148.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Grisso, T. and P.S. Appelbaum: 1995b, 'The MacArthur Treatment Competence Study. III: Abilities of patients to consent to psychiatric and medical treatments', Law and Human Behavior 19(2), 149–174.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Grisso, T., P.S. Appelbaum and C. Hill–Fotouhi: 1997, 'The MacCAT–T: A Clinical Tool to Assess Patients' Capacities to Make Treatment Decisions', Psychiatric Services 48 (11), 1415–1419.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  32. Groth–Marnat, G.: 1990, Handbook of Psychological Assessment.New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  33. Hanson, L.C., M. Danis, E. Mutran and N.L. Keenan: 1994, 'Impact of Patient Incompetence on Decisions to Use or Withhold Life–Sustaining Treatment', Am. J. Med. 97 (3), 235–241.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  34. Have, H.A.M.J.ten, R.H.J.ter Meulen and E.v. Leeuwen: 1998, Medische ethiek. Houten/Diegem: Bohn Stafleu Van Loghum.Google Scholar
  35. Janofsky, J.S., R.J. McCarthy and M.F. Folstein: 1992, 'The Hopkins Competency Assessment Test: A Brief Method for Evaluating Patients' Capacity to Give Informed Consent', Hospital and Community Psychiatry 43 (2), 132–136.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  36. Kapp, M.B. and D. Mossman: 1996, 'Measuring Decisional Capacity: Cautions on the Construction of a “Capacimeter”', Psychology, Public Policy and Law 2 (1), 73–95.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  37. Katz, S., A. Ford, R.W. Moskowitz, B.A. Jackson and M.W. Jaffe: 1963, 'Studies of Illness in the Aged: The Index of ADL; a Standardized Measure of Biological and Psychosocial Function', Journal of the American Medical Association 185 (12), 94–99.Google Scholar
  38. Kitamura, F., A. Tomoda, K. Tsukada, M. Tanaka, I. Kawakami, S. Mishima and T. Kitamura: 1998, 'Method for Assessment of Competency to Consent in the Mentally Ill: Rationale, Development, and Comparison with the Medically Ill', International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 21 (3), 223–244.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  39. Lawton, M.P. and E.M. Brody: 1969, 'Assessment of Older People: Self–Maintaining and Instrumental Activities of Daily Living', The Gerontologist 9 (3), 179–186.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  40. Lezak, M.D.: 1995, Neuropsychological Assessment. New York/Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  41. Madigan, K.V., D. Checkland and M. Silberfeld: 1994, 'Presumptions Respecting Mental Competence', Can. J.Psychiatry 39 (3), 147–52.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  42. Mangone, C.A., R.M. Sanguinetti, P.D. Baumann, R.C. Gonzalez, S. Pereyra, F.G. Bozzola, P.B. Gorelick and R.E. Sica: 1993, 'Influence of Feelings of Burden on the Caregiver's Perception of the Patient's Functional Status', Dementia 4 (5), 287–293.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  43. Marson, D.C., A. Chatterjee, K.K. Ingram and L.E. Harrell: 1996, 'Toward a Neurologic Model of Competency: Cognitive Predictors of Capacity to Consent in Alzheimer's Disease Using Three Different Legal Standards', Neurology 46 (3), 666–672.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  44. Marson, D.C., B. McInturff, L. Hawkins, A. Bartolucci and L.E. Harrell: 1997a, 'Consistency of Physician Judgments of Capacity to Consent in Mild Alzheimer's Disease', Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 45 (4), 453–457.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  45. Marson, D.C., L. Hawkins, B. McInturff and L.E. Harrell: 1997b, 'Cognitive Models that Predict Physician Judgments of Capacity to Consent inMild Alzheimer's Disease', Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 45 (4), 458–464.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  46. McKegney, F.P., B.J. Schwartz and M.A. O'Dowd: 1992, 'Reducing Unnecessary Psychiatric Consultations for Informed Consent by Liaison with Administration', Gen. Hosp. Psychiatry 14 (1), 15–19.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Melamed, Y., R. Kimchi, D. Shnit, D. Moldavski and A. Elizur: 1999, 'Clinical Assessment of Competency to Consent to Psychiatric Hospitalization', International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 22 (1), 55–64.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Murphy, G.H. and I.C.H. Clare: 1995, 'Adults' Capacity to Make Decisions Affecting the Person: Psychologists' Contribution (Chapter 2.5)', In: R. Bull and D. Carson (eds.), Handbook of Psychology in Legal Contexts (John Wiley & Sons, Chichester [etc.], pp. 97–128.Google Scholar
  49. Pfeiffer, E.: 1975, 'A Short Portable Mental Status Questionnaire for the Assessment of Organic Brain Deficit in Elderly Patients', Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 23 (10), 433–441.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  50. Pincoffs, E.L.: 1991, 'Judgments of Incompetence and Their Moral Presuppositions', in: M.A.G. Cutter and E.E. Shelp (eds.), Competency: A Study of Informal Competency Determinations in Primary Care (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht/Boston/London), pp. 79–89.Google Scholar
  51. Rosenfeld, B.D. and E.N. Turkheimer: 1995, 'Modeling Psychiatric Patients' Treatment Decision Making', Law and Human Behavior 19 (4), 389–405.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. Ruskin, P.E.: 1985, 'Geropsychiatric Consultation in a University Hospital: A Report on 67 Referrals', Am. J. Psychiatry 142 (3), 333–336.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  53. Rutman, D. and M. Silberfeld: 1992, 'A Preliminary Report on the Discrepancy Between Clinical and Test Evaluations of Competence', Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 37 (9), 634–639.Google Scholar
  54. Stanley, B., J. Guido, M. Stanley and D. Shortell: 1984, 'The Elderly Patient and Informed Consent. Empirical Findings', Jama 252 (10), 1302–1306.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  55. Tomoda, A., R. Yasumiya, T. Sumiyama, K. Tsukada, T. Hayakawa, K. Matsubara, F. Kitamura and T. Kitamura: 1997, 'Validity and Reliability of Structured Interview for Competency Incompetency Assessment Testing and Ranking Inventory', Journal of Clinical Psychology 53 (5), 443–450.PubMedCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  56. Tymchuk, A.J., J.G. Ouslander, B. Rahbar and J. Fitten: 1988, 'Medical Decision–Making Among Elderly People in Long Term Care', The Gerontologist 28 (Suppl.; Special Issue: Autonomy and long–term care), 59–63.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  57. Welie, J.V.M. and S.P.K. Welie: 2001, 'Patient Decision Making Competence: Outlines of a Conceptual Analysis', Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 4 (2), 127–138.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  58. Wenger, N.S., R.K. Oye, P.E. Bellamy, J. Lynn, R.S. Phillips, N.A. Desbiens, P. Kussin and S.J. Youngner: 1994a, 'Prior Capacity of Patients Lacking Decision Making Ability Early in Hospitalization: Implications for Advance Directive Administration. The SUPPORT Investigators. Study to Understand Prognoses and Preferences for Outcomes and Risks of Treatments', J. Gen. Intern. Med. 9 (10), 539–543.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  59. Wenger, N.S. and J. Halpern: 1994b, 'Can a Patient Refuse a Psychiatric Consultation to Evaluate Decision–Making Capacity? Case and Discussion', The Journal of Clinical Ethics 5 (3), 230–234.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  60. White, B.C.: 1994, Competence to Consent. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press.Google Scholar
  61. Winograd, C.H.: 1984, 'Mental Status Tests and the Capacity for Self–Care', Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 32 (1), 49–55.PubMedGoogle Scholar
  62. World Health Organisation: 1994, 'A Declaration on the Promotion of Patients' Rights in Europe', European Journal of Health Law 1, 279–291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Sander P. K. Welie
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Health Care Ethics and Philosophy (Uns 40)University of MaastrichtMaastrichtThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations