Argon and the Periodic System: the Piece that Would not Fit

  • Carmen J. Giunta


The discovery of the noble gases and their incorporation into the periodic system are examined in this paper. A chronology of experimental reports on argon and helium and the properties relevant to their nature and position in the periodic system is presented. Proposals on the nature of argon and helium that appeared in the aftermath of their discovery are examined in light of the various empirical and theoretical considerations that supported and contradicted them. ``The piece that would not fit'' refers not only to argon, the element that at first seemed not to fit into the periodic system, but also to the piece or pieces of evidence that various researchers and observers were prepared to discard or discount in coming to terms with the newly discovered gases.


  1. W.W. Andrews. The Position of Argon in the Periodic System. Chemical News 71: 235, 1895.Google Scholar
  2. BAAS (British Association for the Advancement of Science). Report of the 64th Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, p. 614, 1894.Google Scholar
  3. C.E. Basevi. Argon and the Kinetic Theory. Nature 52: 221-222, 1895.Google Scholar
  4. Marcellin Berthelot. Essais pour faire entrer l'argon en combinaison chimique. Comptes Rendus 120: 581-585, 1895a.Google Scholar
  5. Marcellin Berthelot. Nouvelles recherches de M. Ramsay sur l'argon et sur l'hélium. Comptes Rendus 120: 660-662, 1895b (translated as New Researches by Prof. Ramsay on Argon and Helium. Chemical News 71: 176, 1895).Google Scholar
  6. Marcellin Berthelot. Sur l'argon et l'hélium. Comptes Rendus 120: 1049, 1895c (excerpt translated as On Argon and Helium. Chemical News 71: 259, 1895).Google Scholar
  7. Bohuslav Brauner. Ueber das Atomgewicht des Tellurs. Berichte 16: 3055-3056, 1883.Google Scholar
  8. Bohuslav Brauner. Some Remarks on 'Argon'. Chemical News 71: 79, 1895a.Google Scholar
  9. Bohuslav Brauner. Note on Gases of the Hclium and Argon Type. Chemical News 71: 271, 1895b.Google Scholar
  10. Bohuslav Brauner. Argon, Helium, and Prout's Hypothesis. Chemical News 74: 223-224. 1896.Google Scholar
  11. Chemical News. A Supposed New Gaseous Element in the Atmosphere. Chemical News 70: 87, 1894a.Google Scholar
  12. Chemical News. The Royal Society Anniversary Meeting, November 30th, 1894. Chemical News 70: 288-292, 303-306, 1894b.Google Scholar
  13. Chemical News. Chemical Society, Ordinary Meeting, December 6th, 1894. Chemical News 70: 300-303, 1894c.Google Scholar
  14. Chemical News. The Royal Society, Thursday, January 31st 1895. Chemical News 71: 51-63, 1895.Google Scholar
  15. Chemical Society. Annual General Meeting. Journal of the Chemical Society (Transactions) 67: 1105-1172, 1895.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Per Cleve. Sur la densité de l'hélium. Comptes Rendus 120: 1212, 1895 (translated as On the Density of Helium. Chemical News 71: 283, 1895).Google Scholar
  17. William Crookes. On the Spectra of Argon. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 186A: 243-251, 1895.Google Scholar
  18. William Crookes. On the Position of Helium, Argon, and Krypton in the Scheme of Elements. Proceedings of the Royal Society 63: 408-411, 1898.Google Scholar
  19. R.M. Deeley. Helium and Argon: their Places Among the Elements. Chemical News 72: 297-298, 1895.Google Scholar
  20. James Dewar. The New Element. Chemical News 70: 87, 1894a.Google Scholar
  21. James Dewar. The New Element. Chemical News 70: 87-88, 1894b (the second of two letters with the same title).Google Scholar
  22. James Dewar. A Supposed New Gaseous Element in the Atmosphere. Chemical News 70: 109, 1894c.Google Scholar
  23. James Dewar. The Relative Behaviour of Chemically Prepared and of Atmospheric Nitrogen in the Liquid State. Proceedings of the Chemical Society 10: 222-225, 1894d.Google Scholar
  24. Carmen J. Giunta. Using Case Histories to Teach Scientific Method: the Case of Argon. Journal of Chemical Education 75: 1322-1325, 1998.Google Scholar
  25. John Hall Gladstone. Argon. Nature 51: 389-390, 1895.Google Scholar
  26. Erwin N. Hiebert. Historical Remarks on the Discovery of Argon, the First Noble Gas, in Herbert H. Hyman (Ed.), Noble-Gas Compounds. University of Chicago, Chicago, pp. 3-20, 1963.Google Scholar
  27. Richard F. Hirsh. A Conflict of Principles: The Discovery of Argon and the Debate Over its Existence. Ambix 28: 121-130, 1981.Google Scholar
  28. Keith J. Laidler. The World of Physical Chemistry. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1993.Google Scholar
  29. Paul-Émile Lecoq de Boisbaudran. Remarques sur les poids atomiques. Comptes Rendus 120: 361-362, 1895a.Google Scholar
  30. Paul-Émile Lecoq de Boisbaudran. Classification des éléments chimiques. Comptes Rendus 120: 1097-1103, 1895b (translated as Classification of the Chemical Elements. Chemical News 71: 271-273, 1895).Google Scholar
  31. J. Norman Lockyer. On the New Gas Obtained from Uraninite, Second Note. Proceedings of the Royal Society 58: 113-116, 1895.Google Scholar
  32. James Clerk Maxwell. Illustrations of the Dynamical Theory of Gases. Philosophical Magazine 19: 19-32; 21-37, 1860.Google Scholar
  33. Raphael Meldola. The State of Chemical Science in 1851. Report of the 65th Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science: 639-655, 1895. (Also in Nature 52: 477-484, 1895 and Chemical News 72: 141-148, 151-152, 1895.)Google Scholar
  34. Dmitrii Mendeleev. Zeitschrift für Chemie 12: 405-406, 1869 (abstracted from Zhurnal Russkoe Fiziko-Khimicheskoe Obshchestvo 1: 60-77, 1869).Google Scholar
  35. Dmitrii Mendeleev. Die periodische Gesetzmassigkeit der chemischen Elemente. Annalen der Chemie und Pharmacie (Suppl. 8): 133-229, 1872.Google Scholar
  36. Dmitrii Mendeleev. Professor Mendeléeff on argon. Nature 51: 543, 1895a.Google Scholar
  37. Dmitrii Mendeleev. On Argon. Chemical News 72: 14, 1895b.Google Scholar
  38. Dmitrii Mendeleev. The Principles of Chemistry (translated from 6th Russian edition by George Kamensky). Longmans, Green, London, 1897.Google Scholar
  39. Dmitrii Mendeleev. The Principles of Chemistry (translated from 7th Russian edition by George Kamensky). Longmans, Green, London, 1905.Google Scholar
  40. Nature. Chemistry at the British Association. Nature 50: 409-411, 1894a.Google Scholar
  41. J.A.R. Newlands. Relations between Equivalents. Chemical News 10: 59, 1864.Google Scholar
  42. J.A.R. Newlands. On the 'Law of Octaves'. Chemical News 13: 130, 1866.Google Scholar
  43. Nobel Foundation. Chemistry, 1901-1921. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1966.Google Scholar
  44. Karol Olszewski. The Liquefaction and Solidification of Argon. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 186A: 253-257, 1895.Google Scholar
  45. W. Preyer. Argon and Helium in the System of the Elements. Chemical News 73: 235-236, 1895.Google Scholar
  46. William Ramsay. On a Gas Showing the Spectrum of Helium, the Reputed Cause of D3, One of the Lines in the Coronal Spectrum, Preliminary Note. Proceedings of the Royal Society 58: 65-67, 1895a.Google Scholar
  47. William Ramsay. Helium, a Gaseous Constituent of Certain Minerals, Part I. Proceedings of the Royal Society 58: 81-89, 1895b.Google Scholar
  48. William Ramsay. Attempt to Liquefy Helium. Nature 52: 544, 1895c.Google Scholar
  49. William Ramsay. The Gases of the Atmosphere, Macmillan and Co., London, 1896.Google Scholar
  50. William Ramsay. An Undiscovered Gas. Report of the 67th Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science: 593-601, 1897. (Also printed in Nature 56: 378-382, 1897 and Chemical News 76: 91-93, 97-99, 1897.)Google Scholar
  51. William Ramsay. J. Norman Collie and Morris Travers, Helium, a Constituent of Certain Minerals. Journal of the Chemical Society (Transactions) 67: 684-701, 1895.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  52. William Ramsay and Robert Whytlaw Gray. La densité de l'èmanation du radium. Comptes Rendus 151: 126-128, 1910.Google Scholar
  53. William Ramsay and Morris W. Travers. On a New Constituent of Atmospheric Air. Proceedings of the Royal Society 63: 405-408, 1898a.Google Scholar
  54. William Ramsay and Morris W. Travers. On the Companions of Argon. Proceedings of the Royal Society 63: 437-440, 1898b.Google Scholar
  55. William Ramsay and Morris W. Travers. On the Extraction from Air of the Companions of Argon. Report of the 68th Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science: 828-830, 1898c.Google Scholar
  56. F. Rang. The Period-Table. Chemical News 72: 200-201, 1895.Google Scholar
  57. Lord Rayleigh. Argon. Royal Institution Proceedings 14: 524-538, 1895a.Google Scholar
  58. Lord Rayleigh. The Refraction and Viscosity of Argon and Helium. Chemical News 72: 152, 1895b.Google Scholar
  59. Lord Rayleigh and William Ramsay. Argon, a New Constituent of the Atmosphere. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society 186A: 187-241, 1895.Google Scholar
  60. C.J. Reed. A Prediction of the Discovery of Argon. Chemical News 71: 213-215, 1895.Google Scholar
  61. J. Emerson Reynolds. Argon and the Periodic System. Nature 51: 486-487, 1895.Google Scholar
  62. Eric R. Scerri and John Worrall. Prediction and the Periodic Table. To appear in Studies in History and Philosophy of Science.Google Scholar
  63. William Sedgwick. The Existence of an Element without Valency of the Atomic Weight of 'Argon' Anticipated before the Discovery of 'Argon' by Lord Rayleigh and Prof. Ramsay. Chemical News 71: 139-140, 1895.Google Scholar
  64. J.W. van Spronsen. The Periodic System of Chemical Elements: A History of the First Hundred Years. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 246-259, 1969.Google Scholar
  65. G. Johnstone Stoney. Argon — a Suggestion. Chemical News 71: 67-68, 1895.Google Scholar
  66. F. Sherwood Taylor. The Work of Sir William Ramsay; He Discovered Five New Elements in Six Years. American Scientist 41: 449-452, 1953.Google Scholar
  67. Julius Thomsen. Über die mutmassliche Gruppe inaktiver Elemente. Zeitschrift für anorganische Chemie 9: 283-288, 1895 (translated as On the Conjectural Group of Inactive Elements. Chemical News 77: 120-121, 1898).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Morris W. Travers. The Discovery of the Rare Gases. Edward Arnold, London, 1928.Google Scholar
  69. Morris W. Travers. A Life of Sir William Ramsay, K.C.B., F.R.S. Edward Arnold, London, 1956.Google Scholar
  70. Mary Elvira Weeks and Henry M. Leicester. Discovery of the Elements, 7th edition. Journal of Chemical Education, Easton, PA, 1968.Google Scholar
  71. John H. Wolfenden. The Noble Gases and the Periodic Table: Telling it like it Was. Journal of Chemical Education 46: 569-567, 1969.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Carmen J. Giunta
    • 1
  1. 1.Le Moyne CollegeSyracuseUSA

Personalised recommendations