Advertisement

Very Public Scandals: Nongovernmental Organizations in Trouble

  • Margaret Gibelman
  • Sheldon R. Gelman
Article

Abstract

This paper analyzes, from a cross-national perspective, publicized incidents of alleged wrongdoing on the part of nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). Data were derived from daily, weekly, or monthly newspapers and special nonprofit newsletters accessible through websites. Analysis of media reports of “scandals” involving NGOs was conducted to identify issues and trends in governance and management problems associated with this sector. The paper focuses on NGOs involved in the financing or delivery of health and human services. After highlighting some of the precedent-setting cases of NGO improprieties in the United States during the 1990s, prominent global cases of wrongdoing during the period 1998–2000 are reviewed. The underlying problems that allowed these cases to occur and their implications regarding NGO credibility and public trust are identified, and strategic options for enhancing accountability presented.

nongovernmental organizations NGO scandals charities accountability role of the press third-sector credibility 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

REFERENCES

  1. Abelson, R. (2000, April 12). Charity vows sweeping changes after review. New York Times, pp. C1, C22.Google Scholar
  2. Agrawal, A., Jaffe, J. F., and Karpoff, J. M. (1999). Management turnover and governance changes following the revelation of fraud. Journal of Law and Economics, XLII, 209–342.Google Scholar
  3. Arenson, K. W. (1995, April 4). Former United Way chief guilty in theft of more than $600,000. New York Times, pp. A1, A22.Google Scholar
  4. Axelrod, N. R. (1994). Board leadership and board development. In R. D. Herman and Associates(<nt>eds.</nt>), The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership & Management, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA.Google Scholar
  5. Babcock, C. R. (1992, February 20). 3 large locals ask national United Way about president's spending. Washington Post, p.A6.Google Scholar
  6. Berg, B. (1995). Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences, Allyn & Bacon, Needham Heights, MA.Google Scholar
  7. Berry, M. F. (1994, November). A radical departure. Emerge, pp. 83–86.Google Scholar
  8. Billitteri, T. J. (1998, February 12). Goodwill looting: California scam yields lessons for charity man-agers. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.39.Google Scholar
  9. Blum, D. E. (1999, October 18). Baptist charity involved in alleged investment scam files for bankruptcy in Arizona. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.32.Google Scholar
  10. Brophy, K. (1999, February 27). Childline reports 25,000 fall-off in number of calls; fewer children phoning since fraud probe. The Mirror, p.11.Google Scholar
  11. Chaffee, S., and Frank, S. (1996). How Americans get political information: Print versus broadcast news. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 546, 48–58.Google Scholar
  12. Chisholm, C. (2000, February 16). Vic; charity faces fraud charges over raffle prizes. Australian General News [On-line].Google Scholar
  13. Cooper, M. (2000, January 27). Audit finds abuses at a Nassau day care center. New York Times, p.B8.Google Scholar
  14. Daley, S. (1996, December 14). Anti-apartheid fighter charged with defrauding relief funds. New York Times, p.A6.Google Scholar
  15. Davis, D. (1999, September 24). "Kosher sex" rabbi's organization probed by British charity officials. Jewish Standard, p.3.Google Scholar
  16. Dickey, M. (1999, November 18). Major oversight: Trustees are still reluctant to evaluate a CEO's performance, despite a call for measurable results. Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 33, 35.Google Scholar
  17. Drucker, P. F. (1990). Lessons for successful nonprofit governance. Nonprofit Management & Leader-ship, 1(1), 7–14.Google Scholar
  18. Eisenberg, P. (1993, July 13). Press coverage sends a message to non-profits: Clean up your act. Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 41–42.Google Scholar
  19. Eisenberg, P. (2000a). The nonprofit sector in a changing world. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 29(2), 325–330.Google Scholar
  20. Eisenberg, P. (2000b, May 4). Why charities think they can regulate themselves. Chronicle of Philan-thropy, pp. 45, 47.Google Scholar
  21. Fried, J. (1999, August 20). 2 Brooklyn social service agency officials indicted on charges of embezzling funds. New York Times, p.B3.Google Scholar
  22. Gelman, S. R. (1983). The board of directors and agency accountability. Social Casework, 64(2), 83–91.Google Scholar
  23. Gelman, S. R. (1988). Roles, responsibilities, and liabilities of agency boards. In M. Janicki, M. W. Krause, and M. Seltzer (<nt>eds.</nt>), Community Residences for Persons with Developmental Disabili-ties: Here to Stay, Paul H. Brookes, Baltimore.Google Scholar
  24. Gelman, S. R., Gibelman, M., Pollack, D., and Schnall, D. (1996). Philanthropic boards of directors on the line: Roles, realities, and prospects. Journal of Jewish Communal Service, 72(3), 185–194.Google Scholar
  25. Gibelman, M. (1995). Purchasing social services. In R. L. Edwards (<nt>ed.-in-chief</nt>), Encyclopedia of Social Work(19th edn.), NASW Press, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  26. Gibelman, M., Gelman, S. R., and Pollack, D. (1997). The credibility of nonprofit boards: A view from the 1990s. Administration in Social Work, 21(2), 29–40.Google Scholar
  27. Gibelman, M., and Demone, H. W., Jr. (<nt>eds.</nt>) (1998). The Privatization of Human Services: Policy and Practice Issues, Springer, New York.Google Scholar
  28. Greene, S. G. (1998a, August 27). A crossroad for Canadian charities. Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 1, 10–12.Google Scholar
  29. Greene, S. G. (1998b, October 18). In unusual move, Hawaii seeks to remove trustees of embattled Bishop Estate. Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 45, 46.Google Scholar
  30. Greene, S. G. (1999a, May 20). Trustees ousted in Hawaii. Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 30, 31.Google Scholar
  31. Greene, S. G. (1999b, December 16). Bishop estate to pay IRS $9m but retain its tax exempt status. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.32.Google Scholar
  32. Greene, S. G. (2000, June 1). Ousted trustees should repay $5 million to Hawaiian trust, report says. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.32.Google Scholar
  33. Gregoire, C. (2000). Challenges in European governance. Board Member, 9(6), 8, 9.Google Scholar
  34. Hall, M. H., and Reed, P. B. (1998). Shifting the burden: How much can government download to the non-profit sector? Canadian Public Administration, 41(1), 1–20.Google Scholar
  35. Harris, M. (2000). The changing challenges of management and leadership in the UK voluntary sector: An interview with Stuart Etherington. Nonprofit Management & Leadership, 10(3), 319–324.Google Scholar
  36. Hiebert, R. E. (1999). The growing power of mass media. In R. E. Hiebert (<nt>ed.</nt>), Impact of Mass Media: Current Issues (4th edn.), Addison Wesley Longman, New York.Google Scholar
  37. Johnson, N., Jenkinson, S., Kendall, I., Bradshaw, Y., and Blackmore, M. (1998). Regulating for quality in the voluntary sector. Journal of Social Policy, 27(3), 307–328.Google Scholar
  38. Katz, S. N. (1999). Where did the serious study of philanthropy come from? Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 28(1), 74–82.Google Scholar
  39. Kelleher, L. (1999, August 16). Charity boss steps down after fraud squad probe: Sad ISPCC chief resigns. The Mirror, p.7.Google Scholar
  40. Kramer, R. M. (1985). Toward a contingency model of board-executive relations. Administration in Social Work, 9(3), 15–33.Google Scholar
  41. Kramer, R. M. (1998). Nonprofit Organizations in the 21st Century: Will Sector Matter? Aspen Institute, Nonprofit Sector Research Fund, Working Paper Series, Washington DC.Google Scholar
  42. Leat, D. (1994). Challenging Management: An Exploratory Study of Perceptions of Managers Who Have Moved From For-profit to Voluntary Organizations, Centre for Voluntary Sector and Not-for-Profit Management, City University School of Business, London.Google Scholar
  43. Lens, V. (2000). Welfare Reform and the Media. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Yeshiva University, Wurzweiler School of Social Work, New York.Google Scholar
  44. Lenkowsky, L. (2000, February 24). Don't pick a president on "charity issues" alone. Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 43–44.Google Scholar
  45. Lipman, H. (2000, March 9). Pennsylvania sues former top officials of health fund. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.29.Google Scholar
  46. Locy, T. (1995, May 28). Class-action suite filed against NAACP. Washington Post, p.A7.Google Scholar
  47. McDonald, C. (1997). Deinstitutionalised or reinstitutionalised? Developments in the nonprofit human services sector. Australian Journal of Social Issues, 32(4), 341–363.Google Scholar
  48. Miller, B. (1993, January 12). Bracing for big cuts in United Way aid. Chronology of Philanthropy, p. 26–28.Google Scholar
  49. Murawski, J. (1995, July 13). Former United Way chief gets 7 years in jail; sentence praised by charities. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.37.Google Scholar
  50. Neuman, R., Just, M., and Crigler, A. (1992). Common Knowledge: News and The Construction of Political Meaning, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  51. Penman, A., and Greenwood, M. (2000, April 14). Charity shocker. The Mirror, p.8.Google Scholar
  52. Reuters. (1998a, August 25). Apartheid foe faces trial for embezzlement: Former cleric accused of taking funds intended to help cause. Toronto Star, p. A11.Google Scholar
  53. Reuters. (1998b, October 20). South Africa probes donation's disappearance. Toronto Star, p. A14.Google Scholar
  54. Richardson, J., and Gutch, R. (1998). Fears betrayed: Initial impressions of contracting for United Kingdom social services. In M. Gibelman and H. W. Demone, Jr. (<nt>eds.</nt>), The Privatization of Human Services: Policy and Practice Issues, Spring Press, New York.Google Scholar
  55. Richardson, L. (1996, July 31). Former charity head ordered to prison. New York Times, p. B3.Google Scholar
  56. Rubin, A., and Babbie, E. (1997). Research methods for social work (3rd edn.), Brooks/Cole, Pacific Grove, CA.Google Scholar
  57. Salamon, L. (1995). The Global Associational Revolution: The Rise of the Third Sector On the World Scene, The Future of Charities and the Voluntary Sector Working Paper No. 7, Demos, London.Google Scholar
  58. Schoenberger, C. R. (1998, July 10). Report details nonprofit woes. Boston Globe, p. E1.Google Scholar
  59. Schroeder, M. (1999, June 9). SEC says Washington lawyer bilked charity, others in $6.2 million scheme. Wall Street Journal, p.B8.Google Scholar
  60. Shepard C. E., and Miller, B. (1994, September 14). Former United Way chief is indicted in fund misuse. Washington Post, pp. A1, A8.Google Scholar
  61. Sherman, J., and Ashworth, J. (1999, October 24). Lottery charities accused of wasting £145m. The Times [On-line].Google Scholar
  62. Simross, L. (1992, April 28). Charities in a bind. Washington Post, p. C5.Google Scholar
  63. Sins of the secular missionaries. (2000, January 20). The Economist, pp. 25–27.Google Scholar
  64. Staff. (1994, September 17). United Way and Mr. Aramony (editorial). Washington Post, p. A14.Google Scholar
  65. Staff. (1995, April 6). United Way after Mr. Aramony (editorial). Washington Post, p. A20.Google Scholar
  66. Staff. (1998, December). Ecuadorian charity falls for investment scam. Board Member, 7(10), 2.Google Scholar
  67. Staff. (1999a, May 25). Cancer charity chief goes on trial for fraud. The Times [On-line].Google Scholar
  68. Staff (1999b, March 25). Boesak gets 6 years in fraud case. The Atlanta Constitution [On-line].Google Scholar
  69. Staff. (1999c, November/December). Taking the helm of a sinking ship: An interview with Mike Fox. Board Member, 8(10), 7.Google Scholar
  70. Staff. (1999d, December 2). Bankrupt PA. Health system sued by creditors. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p. 32.Google Scholar
  71. Staff. (2000a, January 7). Case against charity "could mean fraud". Sydney Morning Herald, p.2.Google Scholar
  72. Staff. (2000b, February 4). Charity organiser on theft chargers. Australasian Business Intelligence, p.5.Google Scholar
  73. Staff. (2000c, April 6). Charges filed in PA health case. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.29.Google Scholar
  74. Staff. (2000d, April 6). Charity ex-chief admits to stealing. Chronicle of Philanthropy, p.29.Google Scholar
  75. Staff. (2000e, April 19). Corrupt German Red Cross officials sent to prison. Deutsche Presse-Agentur [On-line].Google Scholar
  76. Staff. (2000f, June 8). Official accused of stealing millions. New York Times, p. A21.Google Scholar
  77. Staff. (2000g, June 11). Cancer society executive surrenders to the FBI. New York Times, p.41.Google Scholar
  78. Stephens, C. R. (1995, June 29). New Era philanthropy: Recipe for disaster (letter to the editor). Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 36–37.Google Scholar
  79. Wagner, D. (2000, February 24). The "virtue" of charity: Debunking an American myth. Chronicle of Philanthropy, pp. 42–43.Google Scholar
  80. Ward, A., Bishop, K., and Sonnenfeld, J. A. (1999). Pyrrhic victories: The cost to the board of ousting the CEO. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 20, 767–781.Google Scholar
  81. Webster, P. (1999, May 26). Charity boss on trial for £30m fraud. Manchester Guardian, p.14.Google Scholar
  82. Weiner, T. (1994, September 14). United Way's ex-chief indicted in theft. New York Times, p. A12.Google Scholar
  83. Weiser, B. (1999, April 20). Ex-director accused of theft from Head Start. New York Times, p.B1.Google Scholar
  84. Wellford, W. H., and Gallagher, J. G. (1988). Unfair Competition: The Challenge to Charitable Ex-emption, The National Assembly of National Voluntary Health and Social Welfare Organizations, Washington DC.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© International Society for Third-Sector Research and The Johns Hopkins University 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Margaret Gibelman
    • 1
  • Sheldon R. Gelman
    • 1
  1. 1.Wurzweiler School of Social WorkYeshiva UniversityNew York City

Personalised recommendations