Journal of Business Ethics

, Volume 29, Issue 4, pp 289–307 | Cite as

When Organizations Break Their Promises: Employee Reactions to Unfair Processes and Treatment

  • Jill Kickul
Article

Abstract

Research has shown that the strongest reactions to organizational injustice occur when an employee perceives both unfair outcomes (distributive injustice) and unfair and unethical procedures and treatment. Utilizing the Referent Cognitions Theory (RCT) framework, this study investigates how a form of distributive injustice, psychological contract breach, along with procedural and interactional injustice influences employees' negative attitudes and behaviors. More specifically, the interactional effects of these forms of injustices should be notably greater than those exhibited when an employee of the organization, following a contract breach, perceives both fair and ethical processes and treatment. Three hundred and twenty-two employees from a variety of organizational settings completed measures of contract breach, procedural injustice, interactional injustice, and negative affect toward the organization. Their respective supervisors completed a measure of deviant work behaviors. Results revealed a three-way interaction between contract breach, procedural injustice, and interactional injustice on negative affect and deviant work behavior. The nature of the interaction was further investigated through simple slope analyses. Consistent with the study's propositions, deviant work behavior was higher following a contract breach when both procedural and interactional injustice were high. However, the association between negative affect and breach was high when both forms of injustices were high and when only interactional injustice was high. Study contributions and limitations as well as theoretical and ethical implications are discussed.

deviant work behavior interactional injustice negative affect procedural injustice psychological contract breach 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Aiken, L. S. and S. G. West: 1991, Multiple Regression: Testing and Interpreting Interactions (Sage, Newbury Park, New Jersey).Google Scholar
  2. Argyris, C.: 1960, Understanding Organizational Behavior (The Dorsey Press, Homewood, Illinoisn).Google Scholar
  3. Ball, G. A., L. K Trevino and H. P. Sims: 1994, 'Just and Unjust Punishment: Influences on Subordinate Performance and Citizenship', Academy of Management Journal 37(2), 299–322.Google Scholar
  4. Bentler, P. M. and D. G. Bonett: 1980, 'Significance Tests and Goodness of Fit in the Analysis of Covariance Structures', Psychological Bulletin 88, 588–606.Google Scholar
  5. Bies, R. J., D. L. Shapiro and L. L. Cummings: 1988, 'Causal Accounts and Managing Organizational Conflict: Is It Enough to Say It's Not My Fault?', Communication Research 15, 381–399.Google Scholar
  6. Brief, A. P., M. J. Burke, J. M. George, B. S Robinson and J. Webster: 1988, 'Should Negativity Remain an Unmeasured Variable in the Study of Job Stress?', Journal of Applied Psychology 73, 193–198.Google Scholar
  7. Brockner, J., M. Konovsky, R. Cooper-Schneider, R. Folger, C. Martin and R. J. Bies: 1994, 'Interactive Effects of Procedural Justice and Outcome Negativity on Victims and Survivors of Job Loss', Academy of Management Journal 37(2), 397–409.Google Scholar
  8. Brockner, J. and B. M. Wiesenfeld: 1996, 'An Interactive Framework for Explaining Reactions to Decisions: Interactive Effects of Outcomes and Procedures', Psychological Bulletin 120(2), 189–208.Google Scholar
  9. Cappelli, P.: 1999, The New Deal at Work (Harvard Business School Press, Boston, Massachusetts).Google Scholar
  10. Coffey, R. E., C. Cook and P. L. Hunsaker: 1994, Management and Organizational Behavior (Irwin, Burr Ridge, Illinois).Google Scholar
  11. Cohen, J. and P. Cohen: 1983, Applied Multiple Regression/Correlation Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences (Erlbaum, Hillsdale, Illinois).Google Scholar
  12. Cropanzano, R. and R. Folger: 1989, 'Referent Cognitions and Task Decision Autonomy: Beyond Equity Theory', Journal of Applied Psychology 74, 293–299.Google Scholar
  13. Cropanzano, R. and M. A. Konovsky: 1995, 'Resolving the Justice Dilemma by Improving the Outcomes: The Case of Employee Drug Screening', Journal of Business and Psychology 10, 221–243.Google Scholar
  14. Donaldson, T. and T. W. Dunfee: 1994, 'Toward a Unified Conception of Business Ethics: Integrative Social Contracts Theory,' Academy of Management Journal 19(2), 252–284.Google Scholar
  15. Eby, L. T. and K. Buch: 1998, 'The Impact of Adopting an Ethical Approach to Employee Dismissal During Corporate Restructuring,' Journal of Business Ethics 17, 1253–1264.Google Scholar
  16. Ehrlich, C. J.: 1994, 'Creating An Employer-Employee Relationship for the Future', Human Resource Management 33(3), 491–501.Google Scholar
  17. Folger, R.: 1993, 'Reactions to Mistreatment at Work', in J. K. Murnigham (ed.), Social Psychology in Organizations: Advances in Theory and Practice (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey), pp. 161–183.Google Scholar
  18. Folger, R.: 1986, 'Rethinking Equity Theory: A Referent Cognitions Model', in H. W. Bierhoff, R. L. Cohen, and J. Greenberg (eds.), Justice in Social Relations (Plenum Press, New York 5), pp. 145–162.Google Scholar
  19. Folger, R. and R. J. Bies: 1989, 'Managerial Responsibilities and Procedural Justice', Employee Rights and Responsibilities Journal 2, 79–90.Google Scholar
  20. Greenberg, J.: 1990, 'Organizational Justice: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow', Journal of Management 16, 399–432.Google Scholar
  21. Greenberg, J.: 1994, 'Using Socially Fair Treatment to Promote Acceptance of a Work Site Smoking Ban', Journal of Applied Psychology 79(2), 288–297.Google Scholar
  22. Guzzo, R., K. Noonan and E. Elron: 1994, 'Expatriate Managers and the Psychological Contract', Journal of Applied Psychology 79(4), 617–626.Google Scholar
  23. Hitt, M. A.: 1998, 'Twenty-First Century Organizations: Business Firms, Business Schools, and the Academy', Academy of Management Review 23(2), 218–224.Google Scholar
  24. Kickul, J. R., C. P. Parker and S. Young: 1998, The Role of Individual Antecedents in the Psychological Contract, Technical Report (DePaul University, Chicago, Illinois).Google Scholar
  25. Kolb, D. A., J. S. Osland and I. M. Rubin: 1995, Organizational Behavior: An Experiential Approach (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey).Google Scholar
  26. Kotter, J. P.: 1973, 'The Psychological Contract: Managing the Joining-Up Process', California Management Review 15, 91–99.Google Scholar
  27. Kreitner, R. and R. Kinicki: 1995, Management (Houghton Mifflin, New York).Google Scholar
  28. Leventhal, G. S.: 1980, 'What Should Be Done with Equity Theory? New Approaches to the Study of Fairness in Social Relationships', in K. Gergen, M. Greenberg, and R. Willis (eds.), Social exchange: Advances in Theory and Research (Plenum Press, New York), pp. 27–55.Google Scholar
  29. Levinson, H., C. R. Price, K. J. Munden, and C. M. Solley: 1962, Men, Management, and Mental Health (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts).Google Scholar
  30. Lind, E. A. and T. R. Tyler: 1988, The Social Psychology of Procedural Justice (Plenum Press, New York).Google Scholar
  31. Makin, P., C. Cooper and C. Cox: 1996, Organizations and the Psychological Contract (Praeger, Westport, Conn).Google Scholar
  32. Marsh, H. W., J. R. Balla and R. P. McDonald: 1988, 'Goodness-of-Fit Indexes in Confirmatory Factor Analysis: The Effect of Sample Size', Psychological Bulletin 103, 391–410.Google Scholar
  33. McLean Parks, J. and D. L. Kidder: 1994, 'Till Death Do Us Part...: Changing Work Relationships in the 1990s', in C. L. Cooper and D. M. Rousseau (eds.), Trends in Organizational Behavior (Wiley, New York), pp. 112–133.Google Scholar
  34. McLean Parks, J., D. L. Kidder and D. G. Gallagher: 1998, 'Fitting Square Pegs into Round Holes: Mapping the Domain of Contingent Work Arrangements onto the Psychological Contract', Journal of Organizational Behavior 19, 697–730.Google Scholar
  35. McLean Parks, J., and D. Schmedemann: 1994, 'When Promises Become Contracts: Implied Contracts and Handbook Provisions on Job Security', Human Resource Management 33, 403–424.Google Scholar
  36. Moorman, R. H.: 1991, 'Relationship Between Organizational Justice and Organizational Citizenship Behaviors: Do Fairness Perceptions Influence Employee Citizenship?', Journal of Applied Psychology 76, 845–855.Google Scholar
  37. Morrison, E. W. and S. L. Robinson: 1997, 'When Employee Feel Betrayed: A Model of How Psychological Contract Violation Develops', Academy of Management Review 22(1), 226–256.Google Scholar
  38. Niehoff, B. P. and R. H. Moorman: 1993, 'Justice as a Mediator of the Relationship Between Methods of Monitoring and Organizational Citizenship Behavior', Academy of Management Journal 36(3), 527–556.Google Scholar
  39. Nunnally, J.: 1978, Psychometric Theory (McGraw-Hill, New York).Google Scholar
  40. Pedhazer, E. J.: 1982, Multiple Regression in Behavioral Research (Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, New York).Google Scholar
  41. Robbins, S.: 1994, Organizational Behavior (Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey).Google Scholar
  42. Robinson, S. L. and R. J. Bennett: 1995, 'A Typology of Deviant Workplace Behaviors: A Multidimensional Scaling Study', Academy of Management Journal 38(2), 555–572.Google Scholar
  43. Robinson, S. L., M. S. Kraatz and D. M. Rousseau: 1994, 'Changing the Obligations and the Psychological Contract', Academy of Management Journal 37, 437–452.Google Scholar
  44. Robinson, S. L. and E. W. Morrison: 1995, 'Psychological Contracts and Organizational Citizenship Behavior: The Effects of Unfulfilled Obligations', Journal of Organizational Behavior 15, 245–259.Google Scholar
  45. Robinson, S. L. and D. M. Rousseau: 1994, 'Violating the Psychological Contract: Not the Exception But the Norm', Journal of Organizational Behavior 15, 245–259.Google Scholar
  46. Roehling, M. V.: 1996, August, 'Critical Issues in the Conceptualization of the Psychological Contract Construct', Paper presented at the meeting of Academy of Management, Cincinnati, OH.Google Scholar
  47. Rousseau, D. M.: 1990, 'New Hire Perceptions of their Own and their Employer's Obligations: A Study of Psychological Contracts', Journal of Organizational Behavior 11, 389–400.Google Scholar
  48. Rousseau, D. M.: 1998, 'The “Problem” of the Psychological Contract Considered', Journal of Organizational Behavior 19, 665–671.Google Scholar
  49. Rousseau, D. M.: 1995, Psychological Contracts in Organizations: Understanding Written and Unwritten Agreements (Sage, Thousand Oaks, California).Google Scholar
  50. Rousseau, D. M.: 1989, 'Psychological and Implied Contracts in Organizations', Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 2, 121–139.Google Scholar
  51. Rousseau, D. M. and M. M. Greller: 1994, 'Human Resource Practices: Administrative Contract Makers', Human Resource Management 33, 385–401.Google Scholar
  52. Rousseau, D. M. and J. McLean Parks: 1993, 'The Contracts of Individuals in Organizations', in L. L. Cummings and B. M. Staw (eds.), Research in Organizational Behavior, vol. 15 (JAI Press, Greenwich, Connecticut), pp. 1–43.Google Scholar
  53. Rousseau, D. M. and S. A. Tijoriwala: 1998, 'Assessing Psychological Contract: Issues, Alternatives and Measures', Journal of Organizational Behavior 19, 679–695.Google Scholar
  54. Rutte, C. G. and D. M. Messick: 1995, 'An Integrated Model of Perceived Unfairness in Organizations', Social Justice Research 8(3), 239–261.Google Scholar
  55. Schaubroeck, J., D. R. May and F. W. Brown: 1994,' Procedural Justice Explanations and Employee Reactions to Economic Hardship: A Field Study', Journal of Applied Psychology 79, 455–460.Google Scholar
  56. Schein, E. H.: 1965, Organizational Psychology (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey).Google Scholar
  57. Schein, E. H.: 1980, Organizational Psychology (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey).Google Scholar
  58. Schminke, M., M. L. Ambrose and T. W. Noel: 1997, 'The Effects of Ethical Frameworks on Perceptions of Organizational Justice', Academy of Management Journal 40(5), 1190–1207.Google Scholar
  59. Shore, L. M. and K. Barksdale: 1998, 'Examining Degree of Balance and Level of Obligation in the Employment Relationship: A Social Exchange Approach', Journal of Organizational Behavior 19, 731–744.Google Scholar
  60. Sims, R. R.: 1994, 'Human Resource Management's Role in Clarifying the New Psychological Contract', Human Resource Management 33, 373–382.Google Scholar
  61. Sims, R. R.: 1991, 'The Institutionalization of Organizational Ethics', Journal of Business Ethics 10, 493–506.Google Scholar
  62. Skarlicki, D. P. and R. Folger: 1997, 'Retaliation in the Workplace: The Roles of Distributive, Procedural, and Interactional Justice', Journal of Applied Psychology 82(3), 434–443.Google Scholar
  63. Spector, P. E.: 1981, Research Designs (Sage Publications, Newbury Park, California).Google Scholar
  64. Stone, E. F. and J. R. Hollenbeck: 1984, 'Some Issues Associated with the Use of Moderated Regression', Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 34, 195–213.Google Scholar
  65. Tabachnick, B. G. and L. S. Fidell: 1989, Using Multivariate Statistics (Harper Collins, Northridge, California).Google Scholar
  66. Thomas, H. D. and N. Anderson: 1998, 'Changes in Newcomers' Psychological Contracts During Organizational Socialization: A Study of Recruits Entering the British Army', Journal of Organizational Behavior 19, 745–767.Google Scholar
  67. Tyler, T.: 1994, 'Psychological Models of the Justice Motive: Antecedents of Distributive and Procedural Justice', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 67(5), 850–863.Google Scholar
  68. Tyler, T., P. Degoey and H. Smith: 1996, 'Understanding Why the Justice of Group Procedures Matters: A Test of the Psychological Dynamics of the Group-Value Model', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 70(5), 913–930.Google Scholar
  69. Wilhelm, W. R.: 1994, 'Guest Editor's Note: The Employment Contract', Human Resource Management 33(3), 323–324.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Jill Kickul

There are no affiliations available

Personalised recommendations