Journal of Aquatic Ecosystem Stress and Recovery

, Volume 7, Issue 3, pp 229–246 | Cite as

Impact of bleached kraft pulp mill effluent on benthic community structure in relation to environmental factors

  • Paul K. Sibley
  • D.G. Dixon
  • D.R. Barton


In this study, we assessed the impact of bleachedkraft pulp mill effluent (BKME) on the distributionand composition of benthic communities at JackfishBay, Lake Superior. Sediment samples were collectedfrom 44 stations from which several environmentalvariables (extractable organic chlorine [EOCl],metals, organic carbon, particle size, secchi depth,and water depth) and benthic community compositionwere determined. Relationships between environmentalvariables and benthic community structure wereassessed using canonical correspondence analysis(CCA). CCA revealed two distinct biological gradientsat Jackfish Bay, the first associated with degradedbottom sediments and nutrient enrichment and thesecond associated with water depth. Both gradientsrevealed three distinct regions at Jackfish Bay: 1) anarea of highly degraded sediments, located 300–1200 mbelow the outfall, 2) a small, mesotrophic (nutrientenriched) area adjacent to this zone, and 3) remainingareas of Jackfish Bay, including the internalreference sites in Tunnel Bay. Sediments in theimpaired region contained high concentrations oforganic matter (7–21% as loss on ignition [LOI]) andEOCl (up to 5200 mg/kg dw); together these variablesaccounted for 73% of the variation associated withthe first canonical axis of the CCA. This region wasdominated by the oligochaetes Tubifex tubifexand Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri (64–100% of thebenthic community). Sediments in the second regionwere characterized by an abundant and diverse benthiccommunity comprised of benthic harpacticoids,Chironomidae, and oligochaetes. Stations outside ofthese two regions were characterized by a benthiccommunity similar in composition to that expected foroligotrophic Lake Superior waters, including Diporiea sp., Stylodrilus heringianus, Mysis relicta, Sphaerium, Pisidium and benthicharpacticoids. Based on a Monte Carlo significancetest, benthic community structure was significantly(p = 0.01) related to the environmental variablescomprising the first axis of the CCA. Water depth wasthe most important explanatory variable associatedwith the second axis of the CCA; both taxa richnessand abundance declined significantly with increasingdepth. The comprehensive approach employed in thisstudy clearly delineated the occurrence and degree ofimpact on the benthic environment and may be useful infuture risk assessments of sites affected byanthropogenic activity.

sediments pulp mill effluent benthic community structure canonical correspondence analysis 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Adams, S. M., W. D. Crumby, M. S. Greeley Jr., L. R. Shugart & C. F. Saylor, 1992. Responses of fish populations and communities to pulpmill effluents: A holistic approach. Ecotox Environ Safety 24: 347–360.Google Scholar
  2. Ankley, G. T., 1996. Evaluation of metal/acid volatile sulfide relationships in the prediction of metal bioaccumulation by benthic macroinvertebrates. Environ Toxicol Chem 15: 2138–2146.Google Scholar
  3. Aschan, M., 1990. Changes in soft-bottom macrofauna communities along environmental gradients. Ann Zool Fenn 27: 329–336.Google Scholar
  4. American Society for Testing and Materials, 1990. Standard Practice for the Extraction of Trace Metals from Sediments. ASTM, Philadelphia. pp. 557–559.Google Scholar
  5. Aston, R. J., 1973. Tubificids and water quality: A review. Environ Pollut 5: 1–10.Google Scholar
  6. Baker, A. S. & A. J. McLachlan, 1979. Food preferences of Tanypodinae larvae (Diptera: Chironomidae). Hydrobiologia 62: 283–288.Google Scholar
  7. Barton, D. R., 1988. Distribution of some common benthic invertebrates in nearshore Lake Erie, with emphasis on depth and substratum. J Great Lakes Res 14: 34–43.Google Scholar
  8. Bonsor, N., N. McCubbin & J. B. Sprague, 1988. Kraft Mill Effluents in Ontario. Report prepared for the Ontario Ministry of the Environment. 260 pp.Google Scholar
  9. Brinkhurst, R. O., 1974. The Benthos of Lakes. MacMillan Press, London.Google Scholar
  10. Chapman, P. M. & R. O. Brinkhurst, 1984. Lethal and sublethal tolerances of aquatic oligochaetes with reference to their use as a biotic index of pollution. Hydrobiologia 115: 139–144.Google Scholar
  11. Comba, M. E., V. S. Palabrica & K. L. E. Kaiser, 1994. Volatile halocarbons as tracers of pulp mill effluent plumes. Environ Toxicol Chem 13: 1065–1074.Google Scholar
  12. Dermott, R., 1978. Benthic diversity and substrate-fauna associations in Lake Superior. J Great Lakes Res 4: 505–512.Google Scholar
  13. Dermott, R., 1984. Benthic fauna assemblages in Batchewana Bay, Lake Superior. Can Tech Rep Fish Aquat Sci No. 1265.Google Scholar
  14. Dines, R. A. & J. R. Wharfe, 1985. The environmental impacts of paper mill waste discharges to the Swale. Environ Pollut Ser A 38: 245–260.Google Scholar
  15. Dube, M. G. & J. M. Culp, 1996. Growth responses of periphyton and chironomids exposed to biologically treated bleached-kraft pulp mill effluent. Environ Toxicol Chem 15: 2019–2027.Google Scholar
  16. Ferara, S. P., D. R. Hart, P. M. McKee & D. M. Pugh, 1988. Benthic Community Evaluation of Jackfish Bay, Lake Superior 1969, 1975, 1987. North Shore of Lake Superior Remedial Action Plans Tech. Rep #7.Google Scholar
  17. Flanagan, J. F., 1970. Efficiencies of various grabs and corers in sampling freshwater benthos. J Fish Res Bd Can 27: 1691–1700.Google Scholar
  18. German, M. J. & D. M. Pugh, 1969. Biological Evaluation of the Pollution Status of Jackfish Bay, Lake Superior. Ontario Water Resources Commission. 7 pp.Google Scholar
  19. Hill, M. O., 1979. DECORANA: A Fortran Program for Detrended Correspondence Analysis and Reciprocal Averaging. Section of Ecology and Systematics, Cornell University, Ithaca, New York.Google Scholar
  20. Hilton, D. F. J., 1980. The effect of kraft paper mill effluents on insects inhabiting the St. Francis River near Angus, Quebec. Ann Entomol Soc Quebec 25: 179–189.Google Scholar
  21. Hiltunen, J. K., 1969. Invertebrate macrobenthos of western Lake Superior. The Michigan Academecian 54: 123–133.Google Scholar
  22. Hocking J., 1991. Regulation of discharge of organochlorines from pulp mills in Canada. Environ Managem 15: 195–204.Google Scholar
  23. Johnson, R. K., T. Weiderholm & D. M. Rosenberg, 1993. Freshwater biomonitoring using individual organisms, populations, and species assemblages of benthic macroinvertebrates. In: D.M. Rosenberg & V. H. Resh (eds), Freshwater Biomonitoring and Benthic Macroinvertebrates, pp. 40–158. John Wiley & Sons.Google Scholar
  24. Karl, W., 1992. The new Terrace Bay. Pulp & Paper J 91: 43–46.Google Scholar
  25. Leonardsson, K., 1993. Long-term ecological effects of bleached pulp-mill effluents on benthic macrofauna in the Gulf of Bothnia. Ambio 22: 359–362.Google Scholar
  26. Lowell, R. B., J. M. Culp & F. J. Wrona, 1995. Stimulation of increased short-term growth and development of mayflies by pulp mill effluent. Environ Toxicol Chem 14: 1529–1541.Google Scholar
  27. Martinsen K., A. Kringstad & G. E. Carlberg, 1988. Methods for determination of sum parameters and characterization of organochlorine compounds in spent liquors from pulp mills, water, sediment, and biological samples from receiving waters. Wat Sci Technol 20: 13–24Google Scholar
  28. McCall, P. L. & F.M. Soster, 1990. Benthos response to disturbance in western Lake Erie: regional faunal surveys. Can J Fish Aquat Sci. 47: 1996–2009.Google Scholar
  29. McMaster, M. E., G. J. Van der Kraak, C. B. Portt, K. R. Munkittrick, P. K. Sibley I. R. Smith & D. G. Dixon, 1991. Changes in hepatic mixed-function oxygenase (MFO) activity, plasma steroid levels and age at maturity of a white sucker (Catostomus commersoni) population exposed to a bleached kraft pulp mill effluent. Aquat Toxicol 21: 199–218.Google Scholar
  30. McMaster, M. E., G. J. Van der Kraak & K. R. Munkittrick, 1996. Exposure to bleached kraft mill effluent reduces the steroid biosynthetic capacity of white sucker ovarian follicles. Comp Biochem Physiol 112C: 169–178.Google Scholar
  31. Ministry of the Environment, 1991. Jackfish Bay Area of Concern. Environmental Conditions and Problem Statement – Stage 1. Un-numbered report by the Ontario Ministry of the Environment. 158 pp.Google Scholar
  32. Mozley, S. C. & L. C. Garcia, 1972. Benthic macroinvertebrate fauna in the coastal zone of southeastern Lake Michigan. In: Proc. 15th Conf. Great Lakes Res. pp. 102–116.Google Scholar
  33. Munkittrick, K. R., G. J. Van der Kraak, M. E. McMaster, C. B. Portt, M. R. Van den Heuval & M. R. Servos, 1994. Survey of receiving-water environmental impacts associated with discharges from pulp mills. 2. gonad size, liver size, hepatic EROD activity and plasma sex steroid levels in white sucker. Environ Toxicol Chem 13: 1089–1011.Google Scholar
  34. Newell, A. D., D. J. Blick & R. C. Hjort, 1993. Testing for trends when there are changes in methods. Water, Air, Soil Pollut 67: 457–468.Google Scholar
  35. Owens, J. W., 1991. The hazard assessment of pulp and paper effluents in the aquatic environment: A review. Environ Toxicol Chem 10: 1511–1540.Google Scholar
  36. Owens, J. W., S. M. Swanson & D. A. Birkholz, 1994. Environmental monitoring of bleached kraft pulp mill chlorophenolic compounds in a northern Canadian system. Chemosphere 29: 89–109.Google Scholar
  37. Palmer, M. W., 1993. Putting things in even better order: The advantages of canonical correspondence analysis. Ecology 74: 2215–2230.Google Scholar
  38. Pearson, T. H. & R. Rosenberg, 1978. Macrozoobenthic succession in relation to organic enrichment and pollution of the marine environment. Oceanogr Mar Biol Annu Rev 16: 229–311.Google Scholar
  39. Personen, M. & T. Anderson, 1992. Toxic effects of bleached and unbleached paper mill effluents in primary cultures of rainbow trout hepatocytes. Ecotoxicol Environ Safety 24: 63–71.Google Scholar
  40. Rosenberg, R., 1976. Benthic faunal dynamics during succession following pollution abatement in a Swedish estuary. Oikos 27: 414–427.Google Scholar
  41. Rosemarin, A., K.-J. Lehtinen & M. Notini, 1990. Effects of treated and untreated softwood pulp mill effluents on Baltic Sea algae and invertebrates in model ecosystems. Nordic Pulp & Paper Res J 2: 83–87.Google Scholar
  42. Ryder, R. A. & C. J. Edwards, 1985. A Conceptual Approach for the Application of Biological Indicators of Ecosystem Quality in the Great Lakes Basin. Rep. Great Lakes Sci. Adv. Bd., Windsor, Ontario. 169 pp.Google Scholar
  43. Saether, O. A., 1975. Nearctic chironomids as indicators of lake typology. Verh Internat Verien Limnol 19: 3127–3133.Google Scholar
  44. Sallenave, R. M. & D. R. Barton, 1990. The distribution of benthic invertebrates along a natural turbidity gradient in Lake Temiskaming, Ontario-Quebec. Hydrobiologia 206: 225–234.Google Scholar
  45. Sandilands, R. G., 1977. Effect of pulp mill effluent on the surficial sediments of western Nipigon Bay, Lake Superior. J Fish Res Bd Can 34: 817–823.Google Scholar
  46. Sarkka, J., 1992. Effects of eutrophication and organic loading on the occurrence of profundal harpacticoids in a lake in southern Finland. Environ Monit Assess 21: 211–223.Google Scholar
  47. Scrimgeour, G. J., 1989. Effects of bleached kraft mill effluent on macroinvertebrate and fish populations in weedbeds in a New Zealand hydro-electric lake. New Zealand J Mar Fresh Res 23: 373–379.Google Scholar
  48. Sibley, P. K., J. Legler, D. G. Dixon & D. R. Barton, 1997. Environmental health assessment of the benthic habitat adjacent to a pulp mill discharge. I. Acute and chronic toxicity of sediments to benthic macroinvertebrates. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 32: 274–284.Google Scholar
  49. Sibley, P. K., D. G. Dixon & D. R. Barton, 1998. Environmental health assessment of the benthic habitat adjacent to a pulp mill discharge. II. Distribution of Sediment EOCl in relation to environmental factors. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 34: 158–166.Google Scholar
  50. Sibley, P. K., G. T. Ankley, A. M. Cotter & E. N. Leonard, 1996. Predicting chronic toxicity of sediments spiked with zinc: An evaluation of the acid-volatile sulfide model using a life-cycle test with the midge Chironomus tentans. Environ Toxicol Chem 12: 2102–2112.Google Scholar
  51. Sly, P. G. & W. J. Christie, 1992. Factors influencing densities and distributions of Pontoporiea hoyi in Lake Ontario. Hydrobiologia 235/236 (Developments in Hydrobiology 75): 321–352.Google Scholar
  52. Sokal, R. R. & F. J. Rohlf, 1969. Biometry. W.H. Freeman and Company, New York.Google Scholar
  53. Suominen, K. P. & C. Wittmann, 1999. Ecotoxicological assessment of a recipient lake sediment of bleached-kraft pulping discharges. Environ Toxicol Chem 18: 2262–2267.Google Scholar
  54. Svanberg, O. & B.-E. Bengtsson, 1996. Impact of bleached pulp mill effluents on the aquatic environment (The Swedish Environment/ Cellulose Project) – a case study. Res Conserv Recyc 16: 189–199.Google Scholar
  55. Tana, J., A. Rosemarin, K.-J. Lehtinen, J. Hardig, O. Grahn & L. Landner, 1994. Assessing impacts on Baltic coastal ecosystems with mesocosm and fish biomarker tests: A comparison of new and old wood pulp bleaching technologies. The Sci Total Environ 145: 213–234.Google Scholar
  56. Ter Braak, C. J. F & P. Smilauer, 1998. CANOCO Reference Manual and User's Guide to Canoco for Windows: Software for Canonical Community Ordination (version 4). Microcomputer Power, Ithaca, New York, 352 pp.Google Scholar
  57. Ter Braak, C. J. & P. F. M. Verdonschot, 1995. Canonical correspondence analysis and related multivariate methods in aquatic ecology. Aquat Sci 57: 255–289.Google Scholar
  58. Thomas, G. P. & N. Munteanu, 1997. Benthic community populations near two adjacent northern pulp mill discharges. Wat Sci Technol 35: 381–388.Google Scholar
  59. Van der Wal, J., 1977. Relation between Nipigon Bay benthic macroinvertebrates and selected aspects of their habitat. J Fish Res Bd Can 34: 824–829.Google Scholar
  60. Van Duyl, F. C., A. J. Kop, A. Kok & A. J. J. Sandee, 1992. The impact of organic matter and macrozoobenthos on bacterial and oxygen variables in marine sediment boxcosms. Netherlands J Sea Res 29: 343–355.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000

Authors and Affiliations

  • Paul K. Sibley
    • 1
  • D.G. Dixon
    • 1
  • D.R. Barton
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of BiologyUniversity of WaterlooWaterlooCanada

Personalised recommendations