Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy

, Volume 4, Issue 1, pp 19–30

A disease by any other name: Musings on the concept of a genetic disease

  • Kelly C. Smith


What exactly is a genetic disease? For a phrase one hears on a daily basis, there has been surprisingly little analysis of the underlying concept. Medical doctors seem perfectly willing to admit that the etiology of disease is typically complex, with a great many factors interacting to bring about a given condition. On such a view, descriptions of diseases like cancer as geneticseem at best highly simplistic, and at worst philosophically indefensible. On the other hand, there is clearly some practical value to be had by classifying diseases according to theirpredominant cause when this can be accomplished in a theoretically satisfactory manner. The question therefore becomes exactly how one should go about selecting a single causal factor among many to explain the presence of disease. When an attempt to defend such causal selection is made at all, the standard accounts offered (Koch's postulates, Hill's epidemiological criteria, manipulability) are all clearly inadequate. I propose, however, an epidemiological account of disease causation which walks the fine line between practical applicability and theoretical considerations of causal complexity and attempts to compromise between patient-centered and population-centered concepts of disease. The epidemiological account is the most basic framework consistent with our strongly held intuitions about the causal classification of disease, yet it avoids the difficulties encountered by its competitors.

causality epidemiology genetic disease 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Brandon, R.N. et al.: 1994, 'Sober on Brandon on screeningoff and the levels of selection', Philosophy of Science 61(3), 475–486.Google Scholar
  2. Burian, R.: 1981–1982, 'Human sociobiology and genetic determinism', The Philosophy Forum XIII(2–3), 43–66.Google Scholar
  3. Collingwood, R.G.: 1938, 'On the so–called idea of causation', in Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, pp. 85–112.Google Scholar
  4. Ducasse, C.J.: 1924, 'Causation and the types of necessity', University of Washington Publications in the Social Sciences 1(2), 69–200.Google Scholar
  5. Gardenfors, P.: 1980, 'A pragmatic theory of explanation', Philosophy of Science 47, 404–423.Google Scholar
  6. Gifford, F.: 1990, 'Genetic traits', Biology and Philosophy 5(3), 327–347.Google Scholar
  7. Hart, H.L.A. and A.M. Honore: 1959, Causation in the Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  8. Hesslow, G.: 1983, 'Explaining differences and weighting causes', Theoria 49, 87–111.Google Scholar
  9. Hesslow, G.: 1984, 'What is a genetic disease? On the relative importance of causes', in: L. Nordenfelt and B.I.B. Lindahl (eds.), Health, Disease, and Causal Explanations in Medicine. Dordrecht: Reidel.Google Scholar
  10. Hesslow, G.: 1988, 'The problem of causal selection', in: D.J. Hilton (ed.), Contemporary Science and Natural Explanation: Commonsense Conceptions of Causality, New York: NYU Press.Google Scholar
  11. Hilton, D.J.: 1988, 'The problem of causal selection', in: D.J. Hilton (ed.), Contemporary Science and Natural Explanation: Commonsense Conceptions of Causality. New York: NYU Press.Google Scholar
  12. Mackie, J.L.: 1965, 'Causes and conditions', American Philosophical Quarterly 2(4), 245–264.Google Scholar
  13. Mackie, J.L.: 1974, Cement of the Universe. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Google Scholar
  14. Martin, R.: 1978, 'Judgments of contributory causes and objectivity', Philosophy of Social Science 8, 173–186.Google Scholar
  15. Mill, J.S.: 1859, A System of Logic. London: Longmanns (reprinted 1961).Google Scholar
  16. Nagel, E.: 1961, The Structure of Science: Problems in the Logic of Scientific Explanation. New York: HBJ.Google Scholar
  17. Rothman, K.J.: 1976, 'Causes', American Journal of Epidemiology 104, 587–592.Google Scholar
  18. Ryle, G.: 1949, The Concept of Mind. London: Hutchison.Google Scholar
  19. Salmon, W.: 1984, Scientific Explanation and the Causal Structure of the World. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Google Scholar
  20. Smith, K.C.: 1999 (in press), 'What is a genetic trait?', in: D. Magnus (ed.), Contemporary Genetic Technology: Scientific, Ethical, and Social Challenges. Melbourne: Krieger Publishing.Google Scholar
  21. Smith, K.C.: 1998, 'Equivocal notions of accuracy and genetic screening of the general population', The Mount Sinai Journal of Medicine 65(3), 178–183.Google Scholar
  22. Smith, K.C.: 1992, 'The new problem of genetics: A response to Gifford', Biology and Philosophy 7, 331–348.Google Scholar
  23. Sterelny, K., K.C. Smith and M. Dickison: 1996, 'The extended replicator', Biology and Philosophy 11, 377–403.Google Scholar
  24. Stern, C.: 1973, Principles of Human Genetics. San Francisco: Freeman.Google Scholar
  25. Van Fraassen, B.C.: 1980, The Scientific Image. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
  26. Wulff, H.R.: 1984, 'The causal basis of the current disease classification', in: L. Nordenfelt and B.I.B. Lindahl (eds.), Health, Disease, and Causal Explanations in Medicine. Dordrecht: Reidel.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Kelly C. Smith
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Philosophy and ReligionClemson UniversityClemsonUSA

Personalised recommendations