Journal of Management and Governance

, Volume 3, Issue 3, pp 287–305 | Cite as

Mixed Consequences of Government Aid for New Venture Creation: Evidence from Italy

  • Vincenzo Maggioni
  • Mario Sorrentino
  • Mary Williams
Article

Abstract

Most countries have designed programsto stimulate the birth and development of new firms.One of the most important issues in evaluating theimpact of public entrepreneurial policies is toanalyze their influence on the post-entry performanceof the new ventures. This paper examines how the mostimportant government program to encourageentrepreneurship in Italy (the Law 44 program) affectsseveral aspects of the early performance of new firms.A sample of new firms receiving government aid iscompared to a matched sample of new firms notreceiving public assistance, i.e., ``control'' firms. The control firms were born in the same year, launchedtheir business in the same geographical area andoperate in the same industry classification. Resultsshow that the public program produces mixed effects.Government aid allows firms to have a higher level oftechnology. However, government funding gives rise toentrepreneurial start-ups, which are not fullyefficient. A discussion of these findings andsuggestions for future research are presented.

aided and non-aided new firms new venture creation post-entry performance public programs for entrepreneurship start-up 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Aldrich, H. and E. Auster: 1986, "Even Dwarfs Started Small: Liabilities of Age and Size and Their Strategic Implications", in L. Cummings and B. Staw (eds.), Research in Organizational Behaviour (Greenwich, CT: JAI Press).Google Scholar
  2. Aldrich, H.: 1995, "Entrepreneurial Strategies in New Organization Populations", in I. Bull, H. Thomas and G. Willard (eds.), Entrepreneurship. Perspectives on Theory Building (Pergamon).Google Scholar
  3. Arrighetti, A.: 1991, "La mortalità delle imprese e l'ipotesi di selezione naturale", Economia e Politica Industriale 72: 57–83.Google Scholar
  4. Baird, I.S. and Thomas, H.: 1985, "Toward a Contingency Model of Strategic Risk Taking", Academy of Management Review 30(1): 51–66.Google Scholar
  5. Birch, D.: 1979, Job Creation in America (New York, NY: The Free Press).Google Scholar
  6. Birley, S.: 1986, "The Role of New Firms: Births, Deaths, and Job Generation", Strategic Management Journal 7(4): 361–376.Google Scholar
  7. Block, Z. and I.C. MacMillan: 1985, "Milestones for Successful Venture Planning", Harvard Business Review 636(5): 184–196.Google Scholar
  8. Block, Z. and I.C.MacMillan: 1993, Corporate Venturing: Creating New Businesses within the Firm(Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press).Google Scholar
  9. Brito, P. and A. Mello: 1995, "Financial Constraints and FirmPost-entry Performance", International Journal of Industrial Organization 13(4): 543–565.Google Scholar
  10. Bruderl, J. and Schussler, R.: 1990, “Organizational Mortality: The Liability of Newness and Adoloscence”, Administrative Science Quarterly 35(3): 530–547.Google Scholar
  11. Buttà, C.: 1995, Condizioni e fattori per la diffusione dell'imprenditorialità nel Mezzogiorno, Atti del Convegno Dall'azienda protetta all'azienda competitiva: i modelli imprenditoriali emergenti nell'economia italiana. Accademia Italiana di Economia Aziendale. Bologna: Clueb.Google Scholar
  12. Cafferata, R.: 1990, "Gli incentivi alla formazione di piccole imprese nelle politiche pubbliche per il Mezzogiorno: Problemi e prospettive", Piccola Impresa/Small Business 1: 65–85.Google Scholar
  13. Carrol, G.R. and M.T. Hannan: 1989, "Density Delay in the Evolution of Organizational Populations: A Model and Five Empirical Tests", Administrative Science Quarterly 34(3): 411–430.Google Scholar
  14. Carter, R.B. and H. Van Auken: 1990, “Personal Equity Investment and Small Business Financial Difficulties”, Entrepreneuriship Theory and Practice 15(2): 51–60.Google Scholar
  15. Castrogiovanni, G.J.: 1996, "Pre-start-up Planning and the Survival of New Small Firms", Journal of Management 22(6): 801–823.Google Scholar
  16. Chrisman, J.J., and J. Leslie: 1989, "Strategic, Administrative, and Operating Problems: The Impact of Outsiders on Small Firm Performance", Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 13(2): 37–51.Google Scholar
  17. Contini, B., and Revelli, R.: 1986, "Natalità e mortalità delle imprese italiane: risultati preliminari e nuove prospettive di ricerca", L=Industria 7(2): 195–232.Google Scholar
  18. Cooper, A.C., F.J. Gimeno-Gascon and C.Y. Woo: 1994, "Initial Human and Financial Capital as Predictors of New Venture Performance", Journal of Business Venturing 9(5): 371–395.Google Scholar
  19. Corò, G. and E. Rullani: 1998, "Neo-imprenditorialità e politiche regionali per l'innovazione: l'applicazione della legge 44/86 in contesti a sviluppo diffuso", Piccola Impresa/Small Business 1: 15–45.Google Scholar
  20. de Marco, A.: 1998, Uncertainty and Start up Investment Strategies. Working Paper discussed at the 1998th Entrepreneurship Doctoral Consortium, Academy of Management Meeting, San Diego, USA.Google Scholar
  21. Dickenson, R.: 1981, "The Business Failure Rate", American Journal of Small Business 5: 17–25.Google Scholar
  22. ENSR: 1994, The European Observatory for SMEs: First Annual Report. Foetermeer, The Netherlands: European Observatory for SME Research and EIM Small Business Research and Consultancy.Google Scholar
  23. Evans, D.S. and B. Jovanovic: 1989, "An Estimated Model of Entrepreneurial Choice under Liquidity Constraints", Journal of Political Economy 97(4): 808–827.Google Scholar
  24. Fichman, M. and D.A. Levinthal: 1991, "Honeymoons and the Liabilities of Adoloscence: A New Perspective on Duration Dependence in Social and Organizational Relationships", Academy of Management Review 16(2): 442–468.Google Scholar
  25. Gibbs, A. and M. Scott: 1985, "Strategic Awareness, Personal Commitment and the Process of Planning in the Small Business", Journal of Management Studies 22(6): 597–631.Google Scholar
  26. GPO: 1996, The State of Small Business: A Report of the President (Washington, DC: United States Government Printing Office).Google Scholar
  27. Hambrick, D.C. and I.C. MacMillan: 1984, "Asset Parsimony: Managing Assets to Manage Profits", Sloan Management Review 25(2): 67–74.Google Scholar
  28. Hisrich, R.D.: 1988, "New Business Formation Through the Enterprise Development Center: A Model for New Venture Creation", IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management 35(4): 221–231.Google Scholar
  29. Huallachain, B.O. and M.A. Satterthwaite: 1992, "Sectoral Growth Patterns at the Metropolitan Level: An Evaluation of Economic Development Incentives", Journal of Urban Economics 31(1): 25–58.Google Scholar
  30. Kirzner, I.: 1985, "Entrepreneurship and American Competition", in S.M. Butler and W. Dennis (eds.), Entrepreneurship: The Key to Economic Growth (Heritage Foundation and National Federation of Independent Business).Google Scholar
  31. Lamberson, M. and C. Johnson: 1992, "Financing Experiences of Small Manufacturers in Arkansas: Survey and Analysis", Economic Development Review 10(2): 62–66.Google Scholar
  32. Lipparini, A. and M. Sobrero: 1994, "The Glue and the Pieces: Entrepreneurship and Innovation in Small-firm Network", Journal of Business Venturing 9(1): 125–140.Google Scholar
  33. Lipparini, A. and M. Sobrero: 1997, "Coordinating Multi-firms Innovative Processes. Entrepreneurs as Catalysts in Small-firm Networks, in M. Eber (ed.), The Formation of Inter-organizational Networks (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Google Scholar
  34. MacMillan, I.C., and M.B. Low: 1986, "Techniques of the Habitual Entrepreneur: Flow Building and Progress Optimization", Working Paper Series, Snider Center for Entrepreneurial Studies (Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania).Google Scholar
  35. Maggioni, V.: 1995, La criticità degli aspetti finanziari nella nascita delle nuove imprese. Atti del Convegno Dall'azienda protetta all'azienda competitiva: i modelli imprenditoriali emergenti nell'economia italiana, Accademia Italiana di Economia Aziendale. Bologna: Clueb.Google Scholar
  36. Maggioni, V.: 1997, Oltre lo start up. Il percorso di consolidamento delle imprese 44, Collana Fare Impresa IG, Edizioni Gruppo Abele, Torino.Google Scholar
  37. McGrath, R.G.: 1996, Options and the Entrepreneur: Toward a Strategic Theory of Entrepreneurial Behavior. Working Paper Series, Snider Center for Entrepreneurial Studies, Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania.Google Scholar
  38. McGrath, R.G.: 1997, "A Real Options Logic for Initiating Technology Positioning Investments", Academy of Management Review 22(4): 974–996.Google Scholar
  39. McGrath, R.G. and I.C. MacMillan: 1995, "Discovery Driven Planning", Harvard Business Review 73(4): 44–54.Google Scholar
  40. Moint, A.H.: 1998, "Small Firms Exporting: How Effective are Government Assistance Programs", Journal of Small Business Management, January: 1–15.Google Scholar
  41. Monks, S.: 1991, "Job Creation and Job Displacement: The Impact of Enterprise Board Investment of Firms in UK", Regional Studies 25(4): 355–362.Google Scholar
  42. OECD: 1995, 1997, Best Practice Policies for Small and Medium Sized Enterprises (Paris).Google Scholar
  43. Peterson, R., G. Kozmetsky and N. Ridgway: 1983, "Perceived Causes of Small Business Failures: A Research Note", American Journal of Small Business 8: 15–19.Google Scholar
  44. Plant, T.R. and J.E. Pluta: 1983, "Business Climate, Taxes and Expenditures, and State Industrial Growth in the United States", Southern Economic Journal 50: 99–119.Google Scholar
  45. Porter, M.E.: 1982, La strategia competitiva. Analisi per le decisioni, Tipografia Compositori, Bologna.Google Scholar
  46. Porter, M.E.: 1985, Competitive Advantage (New York, NY: The Free Press).Google Scholar
  47. Raposo M. and M.J. Silva: 1999, "Initial Financing and the New Firm Performance", 44th ICSB World Conference Proceedings (Naples: ESI).Google Scholar
  48. Reynolds, P.D.: 1987, "New Firms: Societal Contribution versus Survival Potential", Journal of Business Venturing 2(3): 231–246.Google Scholar
  49. Reynolds, P.D. and B. Miller: 1992, "New Firm Gestation: Conception, Birth and Implications for Research", Journal of Business Venturing 7(5): 405–417.Google Scholar
  50. Ring, P.S. and H. Van de Ven: 1992, "Structuring Cooperative Relationship between Organizations", Strategic Management Journal 13(7): 483–492.Google Scholar
  51. Rogoff, E.G. and M.S. Lee: 1996, "Putting Government's Role in Perspective: The Impact of Government Programmes on Entrepreneurs and Small Business Owners", Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship 1(1): 57–73.Google Scholar
  52. Sardar, J.H., D. Ghosh and P. Rosa: 1997, "The Importance of Support Services to Small Enterprise in Bangladesh", Journal of Small Business Management 35(2): 26–36.Google Scholar
  53. Schillaci, C.E.: 1992, "I collegamenti interpersonali e la loro rilevanza nella nascita di una nuova impresa", Sinergie 28: 97–107.Google Scholar
  54. Schoeffler, S., R. Buzzel and D. Heany: 1974, "Impact of Strategic Planning on Profit Performance", Harvard Business Review 52(2): 137–145.Google Scholar
  55. Segura, E.: 1988, "Industrial Trade and Financial Sector Policies to Foster Private Enterprise in Developing Countries", Columbia Journal of World Business 23(1): 19–26.Google Scholar
  56. Shane, S. and L. Kolvereid: 1995, "National Environment, Strategy, and New Venture Performance: A Three Country Study", Journal of Small Business Management 33(2): 37–50.Google Scholar
  57. Shapero, A.: 1985, "Why Entrepreneurship? A Worldwide Perspective", Journal of Small Business Management 23(4): 1–5.Google Scholar
  58. Shapero, A. and J. Giglierano: 1982, "Exit and Entries: A Study in Yellow Pages Journalism", in K.H. Vesper (ed.), Frontiers of Entrepreneurship Research (Wellesley, MA: Babson College).Google Scholar
  59. Small Business Administration: 1995, The State of Small Business: A Report of the President(Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office).Google Scholar
  60. Sorrentino, M.: 1995, "Condizioni e limiti di sviluppo delle nuove imprese", Economia e Politica Industriale 87: 147–183.Google Scholar
  61. Sorrentino, M.: 1997, "I fattori esplicativi delle performance post-entry: modelli interpretativi a confronto", in Maggioni V., Lo sviluppo delle nuove imprese, Prismi, Napoli.Google Scholar
  62. Starr J.A. and I.C. MacMillan: 1990, "Resource Cooptation via Social Contracting: Resource Acquisition Strategies for New ventures", Strategic Management Journal 11(2): 79–92.Google Scholar
  63. Staw, B.M. and J. Ross: 1987, "Knowing When to Pull the Plug", Harvard Business Review 65(2): 68–74.Google Scholar
  64. Stinchcombe, A.L.: 1965, "Organizations and Social Structure", in J. March (ed.), Handbook of Organizations (Chicago: Rand McNally).Google Scholar
  65. Storey, D.J.: 1994, Understanding the Small Business Sector (London: Routledge).Google Scholar
  66. Storey, D.J.: 1998, Six Steps to Heaven: Evaluating the Impact of Public Policies to Support Small Businesses in Developed Economies. CSME Working Papers, nE59. University of Warwick.Google Scholar
  67. Stuart, R. and P.A. Abetti: 1987, "Start-up Ventures: Toward the Prediction of Initial success", Journal of Business Venturing 2(3): 215–230.Google Scholar
  68. Timberg, T.: 1992, "Missing Research on Small and Microenterprise Promotion Programmes", Small Enterprise Development 3(2): 42–46.Google Scholar
  69. Tornikoski, E.: 1999, "Entrepreneurship and Theory Development: The Use of the Constructivist Approach", 44th ICSB World Conference Proceedings (Naples: ESI).Google Scholar
  70. Venkataraman, S., A. Van de Ven, J. Buckeye and R. Hudson: 1990, "Starting up in a Turbulent Environment: A Process Model of Failure among Firms with High Customer Dependence", Journal of Business Venturing 5(5): 277–295.Google Scholar
  71. Vivarelli, M.: 1994, La nascita delle imprese in Italia. Teorie e verifiche empiriche (Milano: Egea).Google Scholar
  72. Vivarelli, M. and D. Audretsch: 1994, The Link between the Entry Decision and Post-entry Performance. Working Paper, CNR Project Internationalization.Google Scholar
  73. Walter, N.: 1995, Local Economic Development Incentives and Internal Trends (Boulder, CO: Westview Press).Google Scholar
  74. Woo C.Y., U. Dallenbach and C. Nicholls-Nixon: 1994, "Theory Building in the Presence of "Randomness": The Case of Venture Creation and Performance', Journal of Management Studies 31(4): 507–524.Google Scholar
  75. Zinman, J.: 1994, "Enhancing Small/Medium Size Businesses as Job Creators", Economic Development Abroad 8: 2–4.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1999

Authors and Affiliations

  • Vincenzo Maggioni
    • 1
  • Mario Sorrentino
    • 2
  • Mary Williams
    • 3
  1. 1.Second University of NaplesCapua (CE)Italy
  2. 2.Dipartimento di Studi e Ricerche AziendaliUniversity of SalernoFisciano (SA)Italy
  3. 3.Widener University, One University PlaceChesterUSA

Personalised recommendations