Values of Farmers, Sustainability and Agricultural Policy

  • Ben Schoon
  • Rita te Grotenhuis
Article

Abstract

This article describes the feasibility of researchinto the relation between values of farmers andsustainability for the Dutch Ministry of Agricultureand the Dutch Federation of Agricultural andHorticultural Organisations.

Firstly, a theoretical framework describes differentlevels of motivation behind conduct and choices. Itenables exploration and analysis of individualinterviews with small groups of conventional andecological farmers. The aim is to find out what theirbasic convictions regarding nature and sustainabilityare, and to analyze the relation between theseconvictions and the actual choices they make in theirfarming practice. The research shows that for somefarmers, differences in farming practice go back to themotivation level of moral convictions about what is`good farming'. For others, the motivations for aspecific farming practice are more pragmatic or`superficial'. This knowledge can be of significancefor the process of policy making.

Secondly, this research demonstrates thatinvestigation into the relation between values andbehavioral choices is possible. The analysis ofinterviews among a small group of farmers gives anidea of the importance of personal values in additionto (and sometimes of more importance than) economicconsiderations. Due to the restricted size of theresearch population, however, these conclusions are oflimited generalizability. Finally, in order to make alarger research agenda possible, the research methodology isevaluated on the basis of scientific criteria.

Agriculture cultural ethics empirical research sustainability values 

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

REFERENCES

  1. Barbour, I.G., Technology, Environment and Human Values (Praeger, New York, 1980).Google Scholar
  2. Bruin, R. de., Dynamiek en duurzaamheid (CERES - Landbouwuniversiteit Wageningen, Wageningen, 1997).Google Scholar
  3. Curry-Roper, J.M., “Community-Level Worldviews and the Sustainability of Agriculture,” in B. Ilbery et al. (eds), Agricultural Restructuring and Sustainability. A Geographical Perspective (CAB International, Wallingford [etc.], 1997).Google Scholar
  4. Fairweather, J.R., “Understanding How Farmers Choose Between Organic and Conventional Production: Results from New Zealand and Policy Implications,” Agriculture and Human Values 16 (1999), 51-63.Google Scholar
  5. Festinger, L., Conflict, Decision, and Dissonance (Stanford U.P., Stanford, 1967).Google Scholar
  6. Filson, G.C., “Demographic and Farm Characteristic Differences in Ontario Farmers” Views about Sustainability Policies,” Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics9(2) (1996), 165-180.Google Scholar
  7. Flora, C.B., “Values and the Agricultural Crisis: Differential Problems, Solutions, and Value Constraints,” Agriculture and Human Values 3(3) (1986), 16-23.Google Scholar
  8. Graaf, H. van de and J. Grin (eds), Milieubeleid van onderaf bezien, deel a. (Ministry of VROM/Amsterdam, University of Amsterdam, Den Haag, 1996).Google Scholar
  9. MacIntyre, A., After Virtue (Duckworth, London, 1985).Google Scholar
  10. Morris, C. and Ch. Andrews. 1997. “The Construction of Environmental Meanings Within 'Farming Culture” in the UK: The Implications for Agri-Environmental Research,” in B. Ilbery et al. (eds), Agricultural Restructuring and Sustainability. A Geographical Perspective (CAB International, Wallingford [etc.], 1997).Google Scholar
  11. RMNO, Duurzame ontwikkeling: onze tweede natuur (RMNO, Rijswijk, 1995).Google Scholar
  12. Schoon, B., R. te Grotenhuis and H. Jochemsen, Haalbaarheidsonderzoek duurzame landbouw: cultuurethische aspecten (Instituut voor CultuurEthiek, Amersfoort, 1998.Google Scholar
  13. Schuyt, C.J.M., “Drie manieren om gedrag te veranderen,” Milieu 7(2) (1992), 43-47.Google Scholar
  14. Sullivan, S., E. McCann, R. De Young, and D. Erickson, “Farmers” Attitudes about Farming and the Environment: A Survey of Conventional and Organic Farmers,” Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 9(2) (1996), 123-143.Google Scholar
  15. Taylor, Ch., Sources of the Self (Cambridge U.P., Cambridge, 1989).Google Scholar
  16. Vandenabeele, J. and D. Wildemeersch, “Learning for Sustainable Development: Examining Lifeworld Transformation among Farmers,” in D. Wildemeersch et al. (eds), Adult Education and Social Responsibility (Lang., Frankfurt am Main [etc.], 1998).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000

Authors and Affiliations

  • Ben Schoon
    • 1
  • Rita te Grotenhuis
    • 2
  1. 1.Institute for Cultural EthicsAmersfoortThe Netherlands E-mail
  2. 2.Centre for EntrepreneurshipNyenrode UniversityBreukelenThe Netherlands

Personalised recommendations