, Volume 8, Issue 1, pp 33–48 | Cite as

A Comparison of a Sentinel Species Evaluation Using Creek Chub (Semotilus Atromaculatus Mitchill) to a Fish Community Evaluation for the Initial Identification of Environmental Stressors in Small Streams

  • Dean G. Fitzgerald
  • Roman P. Lanno
  • D. George Dixon


Application of a sentinel species-based population evaluation using creek chub (Semotilus atromaculatus), a common minnow in eastern North America, could provide a framework for environmental assessments and focus future research in small streams. Analysis of creek chub endpoints (growth, condition, fecundity) was based on an assessment framework for white sucker (Catostomus commersoni) populations (Gibbons & Munkittrick, 1994). We evaluated creek chub and fish community endpoints simultaneously in two streams with differing degrees of urbanization, agriculture, and thermal regimes during spring, summer, and fall. Fish from the more altered stream appear to be suffering from a feeding-based niche shift, and demonstrate reproductive anomalies suggestive of exposure to some unknown sublethal stressor(s). Fish community assessments identified modified habitat and water quality but did not detect the presence of any additional stressor(s). Similarity in fish community and population responses, widespread distribution of creek chub, limited within-stream movements, and the ability of this species to populate even the smallest streams where the resident fish community may be depauperate and fish community-type assessments limited, makes the potential use of creek chub as a monitor for small streams promising over a wide geographic zone.

stream assessment sentinel species fish community Index of Biotic Integrity 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Barber, W.E. and Minkley, W.L. (1971) Summer foods of the cyprinid fish Semotilus atromaculatus. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc. 101, 283-9.Google Scholar
  2. Barton, D.R., Taylor, W.D. and Biette, R.M. (1985) Dimensions of riparian buffer strips required to maintain trout habitat in Southern Ontario streams. N. Am. J. Fish. Manage. 5, 364-78.Google Scholar
  3. Baxter, R.M. and Glaude, P. (1980) Environmental effects of dams and impoundments in Canada: experience and prospects. Can. Bull. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 34p. 205.Google Scholar
  4. Becker, G.C. (1983) Fishes of Wisconsin. Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press.Google Scholar
  5. Casselman, J.M. (1990) Growth and relative size of calcified structures of fish. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc. 119, 673-688.Google Scholar
  6. Cox, J., Hendrickson, C., Skelton, I. and Suffling, R. (1996) Watershed planning for urbanization to avoid undesirable stream outcomes. Can. Water Res. J. 21, 237-51.Google Scholar
  7. DeAngelis, D.L., Barnthouse, L.W. and Van Winkle, W. (1990) A critical appraisal of population approaches in assessing fish community health. J. Great Lakes Res. 16, 576-90.Google Scholar
  8. DeVries, D.R. and Frie, R.V. (1996) Determination of age and growth. In Fisheries Techniques 2nd edition. (B.R. Murphy and D.W. Willis, eds.) pp. 483-512. Bethesda: American Fisheries Society.Google Scholar
  9. Diamond, J.M., Barbour, M.T. and Stribling, J.B. (1996) Characterizing and comparing bio-assessment methods and their results: a perspective. J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc. 15, 713-727.Google Scholar
  10. Fernando, C.H. and Holcík J. (1991) Fish in reservoirs. Int. Revue ges. Hydrobiol. 76, 149-167.Google Scholar
  11. Fitzgerald, D.G., Kott, E., Lanno, R.P. and Dixon, D.G. (1998) A quarter century of change in the fish communities of three small streams modified by anthropogenic activities. J. Aquat. Ecosystem Stress Recovery 6, 111-127.Google Scholar
  12. Foucher, R.P. and Beamish, R.J. (1980) Production of nonviable oocytes by Pacific hake (Merluccius productus). Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 37, 41-8.Google Scholar
  13. Garie, H.L. and McIntosh, A. (1986) Distribution of benthic macroinvertebrates in a stream exposed to urban runoff. Wat. Res. Bull. 22, 447-55.Google Scholar
  14. Gauch, H.G. (1982) Multivariate Analysis in Community Ecology. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  15. Gibbons, W.N. and Munkittrick, K.R. (1994) A sentinel monitoring framework for identifying fish population responses to industrial discharges. J. Aquat. Ecosys. Health 3, 227-37.Google Scholar
  16. Gibbons, W.N., Munkittrick, K.R. and Taylor, W.D. (1998) Monitoring aquatic environments recieving industrial effluents using small fish species. I: Response of spoonhead sculpin (cottus ricei) downstream of a bieacheal. Kraft pulp Mill. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 17, 2227-2237.Google Scholar
  17. Goldstein, R.M. (1981) Longitudinal succession in impact assessment of river system fish communities. Wat. Res. Bull. 17, 75-81.Google Scholar
  18. GRCA (Grand River Conservation Authority) (1979) Environmental assessment of water control structures in the Grand River basin: Technical Volume 4: Evaluation of ecological and social environmental effects of proposed alternatives (appendices). Grand River Conservation Authority Project Team, Cambridge, ON.Google Scholar
  19. Haedrich, R.L. (1983) Reference collections and faunal surveys. In Fisheries Techniques (L.A. Nielsen and D.L. Johnson, eds.) pp 275-82. Bethesda: American Fisheries Society.Google Scholar
  20. Hansen, M.J. and Ramm, C.W. (1994) Persistence and stability of fish community structure in a southwest New York stream. Am. Nat. 132, 52-67.Google Scholar
  21. Hanski, I. and Simberloff, D. (1997) The metapopulation approach, its history, conceptual domain, and application to conservation. In: Metapopulation Biology Ecology, Genetics, and Evolution (I.A. Hanski and M.E. Gilpin, eds) pp. 5-26. London: Academic Press.Google Scholar
  22. Heins, D.C. (1991) Variation in reproductive investment among populations of the longnose shiner, Notropis longirostris, from contrasting environments. Copeia 1991, 736-44.Google Scholar
  23. Heins, D.C. and Baker, J.A. (1987) Analysis of factors associated with intraspecific variation in propagule size of a stream-dwelling fish. In The ecology and evolution of North American stream fish communities. (W.J. Mathews and D.C. Heins, eds) pp. 223-31. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.Google Scholar
  24. Heins, D.C. and Rabito, F.G. (1988) Reproductive traits in populations of the weed shiner, Notropis texanus, from the gulf coastal plain. Southwest. Nat. 33, 147-56.Google Scholar
  25. Herricks, E.E. and Schaeffer D.J. (1985) Can we optimize biomonitoring? Environ. Manag. 9, 487-492.Google Scholar
  26. Hodson, P.V., Munkittrick, K.R., Stevens, R. and Colodey, A. (1996) A tier-testing strategy for managing programs of environmental effects monitoring. Can Wat. Res. J. 31, 215-24.Google Scholar
  27. Hubbs, C.L. and Lagler, K.F. (1964) Fishes of the Great Lakes region. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press.Google Scholar
  28. Hynes, H.B.N. (1970) The Ecology of Running Waters. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Google Scholar
  29. Kakonge, S. (1970) Ecology of Small Stream Fishes. Unpublished M.Sc. thesis, Department of Biology, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON.Google Scholar
  30. Karr, J.R. (1981) Assessment of biotic integrity using fish communities. Fisheries 6, 21-7.Google Scholar
  31. Karr, J.R., Fausa, K.D., Angemeier, P.L., Yant, P.R. and Schlosser, I.J. (1986) Assessing Biological integrity in running waters: A method and its rationale. Ill. Nat. Hist. Sur. Spec. Publ. 5, 28p.Google Scholar
  32. Karr, J.R. (1987) Biological monitoring and environmental assessment: a conceptual framework. Environ. Manag. 11, 249-256.Google Scholar
  33. Kling, D. (1981) Total atresia of the ovaries of Tilapia leucosticta (Cichlidae) after intoxication with the insecticide Lebaycid®. Experimentia 37, 73-4.Google Scholar
  34. Kwak, A. and Waters, T. (1997) Trout production dynamics and water quality in Minnesota streams. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc. 126, 35-48.Google Scholar
  35. LeBlanc, R.T., Brown, R.D. and FitzGibbon, J.E. (1997) Modelling the effects of land use change on the water temperature in unregulated urban streams. J. Environ. Manag. 49, 445-69.Google Scholar
  36. Mahon. R. (1984) Divergent structure in fish taxocenes of north temperate streams. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 41, 330-350.Google Scholar
  37. McCormick, J.H., Stokes, G.N. and Hermanutz, R.O. (1989) Oocyte atresia and reproductive success in fathead minnows Pimephales promelas exposed toacidified hardwater environments. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 18, 207-14.Google Scholar
  38. McMaster, M.E., Vanderkraak, G.J. and Munkittrick, K.R. (1996) Exposure to bleached kraft pulp-mill effluent reduces the steroid biosynthetic capacity of white sucker ovarian follicles. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 112C, 169-78.Google Scholar
  39. Moccia, R.D. and Bevan, D.J. (1996) Aquastats, Ontario Aquaculture Production in 1995 and Situation Outlook. University of Guelph, FS96-001.Google Scholar
  40. Molnar, K., Hanek, G. and Fernando, C.H. (1974) Parasites of fishes from Laurel Creek, Ontario. J. Fish Biol. 6, 717-28.Google Scholar
  41. Montgomery, D.C. (1984) Design and Analysis of Experiments. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
  42. Moshenko, R.W. and Gee, J.H. (1973) Diet, time and place of spawning, and environments occupied by creek chub (Semotilus atromaculatus) in the Mink River, Manitoba. J. Fish. Res. Board Can. 30, 357-62.Google Scholar
  43. Munkittrick, K.R. (1992) A review and evaluation of study design considerations for site-specifically assessing the health of fish populations. J. Aquat. Ecosys. Health 1, 283-93.Google Scholar
  44. Munkittrick, K.R. and Dixon, D.G. (1988) Growth, fecundity and energy stores of white sucker (Catostomus commersoni) from lakes containing elevated levels of copper and zinc. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 45, 1355-65.Google Scholar
  45. Munkittrick, K.R. and Dixon, D.G. (1989) Use of white sucker (Catostomus commersoni) populations to assess the health of aquatic ecosystems exposed to low-level contaminant stress. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 46, 1455-62.Google Scholar
  46. Munkittrick, K.R., Miller, P.A. Barton, D.R. and Dixon, D.G. (1991) Altered performance of white sucker populations in the Manitouwadge chain of lakes is associated with changes in benthic macroinvertebrate communities as a result of copper and zinc contamination. Ecotoxicol. Environ. Safety 21, 318-26.Google Scholar
  47. Nagler, J.J., Aysola, P. and Ruby, S.M. (1986) Effect of sublethal pentachlorophenol on early oogenesis in maturing female rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri). Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 15, 549-55.Google Scholar
  48. Neves, R.J. and Angermeier, P.L. (1990) Habitat alteration and its effects on native fishes in the upper Tennessee River system, east-central USA. J. Fish Biol. 37, 45-52.Google Scholar
  49. Newsome, G.E. and Gee, J.H. (1978) Preference and selection of prey by creek chub (Semotilus atromaculatus) inhabiting the Mink River, Manitoba. Can. J. Zoo. 56, 2486-97.Google Scholar
  50. Odum, E.P. (1985) Trends expected in stressed ecosystems. Bioscience 35, 419-22.Google Scholar
  51. Pearse, V., Pearse, J., Buchsbaum, M. and Buchsbaum, R. (1987) Living invertebrates. Palo Alto and Pacific Grove: Blackwell Scientific Publications and the Boxwood Press.Google Scholar
  52. Peters, R.H. (1991) A Critique for Ecology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  53. Pielou, E.C. (1975) Ecological Diversity. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
  54. Poole, R.W. (1974) An Introduction to Quantitative Ecology. New York: McGraw Hill Inc., Scientific Publications.Google Scholar
  55. Power, M. and McCarty, L.S. (1997) Fallacies in ecological risk assessment. Environ. Sci. Technol. 31, 370-5.Google Scholar
  56. Powles, P.M. (1966) Validity of ageing young American plaice from otoliths. Int. Comm. Northwest Atl. Fish. Res. Bull. No. 3.Google Scholar
  57. Powles, P.M., Parker, D. and Reid, R. (1977) Growth, maturation, and apparent and absolute fecundity of creek chub, Semotilus atromaculatus (Mitchill), in the Kawartha Lakes region, Ontario. Can. J. Zoo. 55, 843-6.Google Scholar
  58. Pulliam, H.R. and Danielson, B.J. (1991) Sources, sinks, and habitat selection: a landscape perspective. Am. Nat. 137, 50-66.Google Scholar
  59. Rand, G.M., Wells, P.G. and McCarty, L.S. (1995) Introduction to aquatic toxicology. In Fundamentals of Aquatic Toxicology (G. M. Rand, ed) pp. 3-67. Washington DC: Taylor and Francis.Google Scholar
  60. Robins, C.R. (and six co-authors) (1991) Common and Scientific Names of Fishes. Bethesda: American Fisheries Society, Spec. Publ. 20.Google Scholar
  61. Rooke, J.B. and Mackie, G.L. (1982) An ecological analysis of lotic environments: I. Design and testing. J. Fresh. Ecology 1, 422-31.Google Scholar
  62. Scott, W.B. and Crossman, E.J. (1973) Freshwater fishes of Canada. Bull. Fish. Res. Board Can. 966p. 184.Google Scholar
  63. Sheldon, V.E. (1968) Species diversity and longitudinal succession in stream fishes. Ecology 49, 193-8.Google Scholar
  64. Smith, P.W. (1971) Illinois streams: A classification based on their fish and an analysis of factors responsible for the disappearance of native species. Ill. Nat. Hist. Sur. Biol. Note. 14p. 76.Google Scholar
  65. Steedman, R.J. (1988) Modification and assessment of an index of biotic integrity to quantify stream quality in southern Ontario. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 45, 492-501.Google Scholar
  66. Sokal, R.R. and Rohlf, F.J. (1995) Biometry. New York: W.H. Freeman and Company.Google Scholar
  67. Thornton, K.W., Kimmel, B.L. and Payne, F.E. (1990) Reservoir limnology: ecological perspectives. New York: John Wiley and Sons.Google Scholar
  68. Underwood, A.J. (1994) On beyond BACI: sampling designs that might reliably detect environmental disturbances. Ecol. Appl. 4, 3-15.Google Scholar
  69. Vladykov, V. (1956) Fecundity of wild speckled trout (Salvelinus fontinalis) in Quebec lakes. J. Fish. Res. Board Can. 13, 799-841.Google Scholar
  70. Wilkinson, L. (1990) SYSTAT: the system for statistics. Evanston: SYSTAT Inc.Google Scholar
  71. Wood, P.J. and Armitage, P.D. (1997) Biological effects of fine sediment in the lotic environment. Environ. Manag. 21, 203-217.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1999

Authors and Affiliations

  • Dean G. Fitzgerald
    • 1
  • Roman P. Lanno
    • 2
  • D. George Dixon
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of BiologyUniversity of WaterlooWaterloo
  2. 2.Department of ZoologyOklahoma State UniversityStillwater

Personalised recommendations