Were Small Producers the Engines of Growth in the Canadian Manufacturing Sector in the 1980s?
Small firms are often seen to be the engines of growth. There are two main sources of empirical evidence that are adduced to support this conclusion. The first is that job creation has been coming mainly from small firms. The second is that the share of employment accounted for by small firms has increased in the past two decades. Both of these sources rely on a simple metric-employment. This paper asks whether changes in this metric affect the view of the role that small firms play in the growth process.
The first section of the paper maintains employment as the measure that is used to evaluate the importance of small firms but modifies the raw measure of employment to correct for the fact that small firms pay lower wages than large firms. When this is done, small producers are no longer found to outperform large producers in terms of job creation over the 1970s and 1980s in the Canadian manufacturing sector.
The second section of the paper changes the metric used to evaluate relative performance by moving from employment to output and labour productivity. The paper demonstrates that while small producers have increased their employment share dramatically, they have barely changed their output share. Small firms have been falling behind large firms both with respect to wages paid and labour productivity.
Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.
- Armington, C. and M. Odle, 1982, ‘Small Business — How Many Jobs?’, The Brookings Review 1, 14-17.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R., 1995, The Dynamics of Industrial Competition: A North American Perspective, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R., 1996, ‘Productivity Growth, Plant Turnover and Restructuring in the Canadian Manufacturing Sector’, in D. Mayes (ed.), Sources of Productivity Growth, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R. and B. Diverty, 1995, Advanced Technology Use in Canadian Manufacturing Establishments, Research Paper No. 85. Analytical Studies Branch. Statistics Canada.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R. and P. K. Gorecki, 1990a, Structural Change and the Adjustment Process: Perspectives on Firm Growth and Worker Turnover, Ottawa: Economic Council of Canada.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R. and P. K. Gorecki, 1990b, ‘Measuring Firm Entry and Exit with Panel Data’, in A.C. Singh and P. Whitridge (eds), Analysis of Data in Time, Ottawa: Statistics Canada.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R. and G. Picot, 1995, ‘Employment Generation by Small Producers in the Canadian Manufacturing Sector’, Small Business Economics 7, 1-14.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R. and M. Rafiquzzaman, 1994, Structural Change in the Canadian Manufacturing Sector: 1970–90, Research Paper No. 61. Analytical Studies Branch: Statistics Canada.Google Scholar
- Baldwin, J. R. and D. Sabourin, 1995, Technology Adoption in Canadian Manufacturing, Catalogue 88-512, Ottawa: Statistics Canada.Google Scholar
- Birch, D. and S. MacCracken, 1983, The Small Business Share of Job Creation: Lessons Learned from the use of a Longitudinal File. Unpublished report, MIT Programme on Neighbourhood and Regional Change.Google Scholar
- Brown, C., J. Hamilton and J. Medoff, 1990, Employers Large and Small, Cambridge. Mass: Harvard University Press.Google Scholar
- Davis, S. J., J. Haltiwanger and S. Schuh, 1993, Small Business and Job Creation: Dissecting the Myth and Reassessing the Facts, Working Paper No. 4492. National Bureau of Economic Research.Google Scholar
- Johnson, S. and D. Storey, 1985, Job Generation: An International Survey, U.S. and Canadian Job Generation Studies Using Dun and Bradstreet Data: Some Methodological Issues, Research Working Paper 1. Newcastle, U.K.: University of Newcastle-upon-Tyne.Google Scholar
- Morissette, R., 1993, ‘Canadian Jobs and Firm Size: Do Small Firms Pay Less?’, Canadian Journal of Economics 26, 159-174.Google Scholar
- Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, 1987, Structural Adjustment and Economic Performance, Paris: OECD.Google Scholar
- Picot, G., J. R. Baldwin and R. Dupuy, 1995, ‘Small Firms and Job Creation: A Reassessment’, Canadian Economic Observer (January), 3.1-3.18.Google Scholar
- Wannel, E., 1991, Trends in the Distribution of Employment by Employer Size: Recent Canadian Evidence, Research Paper No. 39. Analytical Studies Branch: Statistics Canada.Google Scholar