Journal of Risk and Uncertainty

, Volume 17, Issue 1, pp 5–26 | Cite as

On the Contingent Valuation of Safety and the Safety of Contingent Valuation: Part 1-Caveat Investigator

  • JANE BEATTIE*
  • JUDITH COVEY
  • PAUL DOLAN
  • LORRAINE HOPKINS
  • MICHAEL JONES-LEE
  • GRAHAM LOOMES
  • NICK PIDGEON
  • ANGELA ROBINSON
  • ANNE SPENCER

Abstract

This article reports the results of two studies aimed at testing and refining a procedure for estimating willingness-to-pay based monetary values of safety using the contingent valuation method. In spite of the fact that respondents were given the opportunity to discuss various safety issues and key concepts in focus group meetings held in advance of individual interviews, and were also given ample opportunity to revise their responses in the light of the overall pattern of these responses, the results show clear evidence of extensive and persistent insensitivity to the scale and scope of the safety improvements that were specified in the contingent valuation questions, as well as vulnerability to framing effects. This clearly casts serious doubt on the reliability and validity of willingness-to-pay based monetary values of safety estimated using conventional contingent valuation procedures.

safety contingent valuation embedding scope sequencing 

References

  1. Arrow, K., Solow, R., Portney, P., Leamer, E., Radner, R., and Schuman, H. (1993) Report of the NOAA Panel on Contingent Valuation. Federal Register, 58, 4602–14.Google Scholar
  2. Beattie, J., Chilton, S., Cookson, R., Covey, J., Hopkins, L., Jones–Lee, M., Loomes, G., Pidgeon, N., Robinson, A. and Spencer, A. (1998) Valuing Health & Safety Controls: A Literature Review, London, Health and Safety Executive.Google Scholar
  3. Bjornstad, D.J. and Kahn, J.R. (eds) (1996) The Contingent Valuation of Environmental Resources, Cheltenham, UK and Brookfield, US, Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
  4. Dalvi, M.Q. (1988) The Value of Life and Safety: A Search for a Consensus Estimate, London Department of Transport.Google Scholar
  5. Department of Transport (1988) Valuation of Road Accident Fatalities, London, Department of Transport.Google Scholar
  6. Desaigues, B., and Rabl, A. (1995) “Reference Values for Human Life: An Econometric Analysis of a Contingent Valuation in France” in Schwab Christe, N.G., and Soguel, N.C. (eds) Contingent Valuation, Transport Safety and the Value of Life, Boston, Kluwer.Google Scholar
  7. Desvousges, W.H. Hudson, S.P., and Ruby, M.C. (1996) “Evaluating CV Performance: Separating the Light from the Heat” In Bjornstad, D.J. and Kahn, J.R. (eds) The Contingent Valuation of Environmental Resources, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
  8. Dubourg, W.R. Jones–Lee, M.W., and Loomes, G. (1997) “Imprecise Preferences and Survey Design in Contingent Valuation”, Economica, 64, 681–702.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Fischhoff, B., Jacobs Quadrel, M., Kamlet, M., Loewenstein, G., Dawes, R., Fischbeck, P., Klepper, S., Leland, J. and Stroh, P. (1993) “Embedding Effects: Stimulus Representation and Response Mode”, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 6, 211–234.Google Scholar
  10. H.M. Treasury (1997) Appraisal and Evaluation in Central Government (“The Green Book”), London, the Stationery Office.Google Scholar
  11. Jones–Lee, M.W. (1989) The Economics of Safety and Physical Risk, Oxford, Basil Blackwell.Google Scholar
  12. Jones–Lee, M.W., Hammerton, M. and Philips, P.R. (1985) “The Value of Safety: Results of a National Sample Survey”, Economic Journal, 95, 49–72.Google Scholar
  13. Jones–Lee, M.W., Loomes, G., and Philips, P.R. (1995) “Valuing the Prevention of Non–Fatal Road Injuries: Contingent Valuation vs Standard Gambles”, Oxford Economic Papers, 47, 676–695.Google Scholar
  14. Jones–Lee, M.W., and Loomes, G. (1995) “Scale and Context Effects in the Valuation of Transport Safety”, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 11, 183–203.Google Scholar
  15. Kahneman, D., Knetsch, J.L. (1992) “Valuing Public Goods: The Purchase of Moral Satisfaction”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 22, 57–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Kahneman, D., Slovic, P., and Tversky, A. (eds) (1982) Judgement Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
  17. McDaniels, T.L., Kamlet, M.S. and Fischer, G.W. (1992) “Riska Perception and the Value of Safety”, Risk Analysis, 12, 495–503.Google Scholar
  18. Mendeloff, J. and Kaplan, R.M. (1990) “Are Twenty–fold Differences in 'Lifesaving' Costs Justified?: A Psychometric Study of the Relative Value Placed on Preventing Deaths from Programs Addressing Different Hazards,” in Cox, L.A. Jr. and Ricci, D.F. (eds) New Risks, New York, Plenum Press.Google Scholar
  19. Savage, I. (1993) “An Empirical Investigation into the Effect of Psychological Perceptions on the Willingness–to–Pay to Reduce Risk” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 6, 75–90.Google Scholar
  20. Schulze, W., McClelland, G., Waldman, D., and Lazo, J. (1996) “Sources of Bias in Contingent Valuation” In Bjornstad, D.J. and Kahn, J.R. (eds) The Contingent Valuation of Environmental Resources, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar.Google Scholar
  21. U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Aviation Administration (1995) Treatment of the Values of Life and Injury in Economic Analysis, APO Bulletin APO–95–1, Washington, Federal Aviation Adminsitration.Google Scholar
  22. Viscusi, W.K., Magat, W.A., and Huber, J. (1987) “An Investigation of the Rationality of Consumer Valuations of Multiple Health Risks” RAND Journal of Economics, 18, 465–479.Google Scholar
  23. Viscusi, W.K., Magat, W.A., and Huber, J. (1991) “Pricing Environmental Health Risks: Survey Assessments of Risk–Risk and Risk–Dollar Trade–Offs for Chronic Bronchitis”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 21, 32–51.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  24. Viscusi, W.K. (1993) “The Value of Risks to Life and Health” Journal of Economic Literature, 31, 1912–1946.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© 1998 Kluwer Academic Publishers 1998

Authors and Affiliations

  • JANE BEATTIE*
    • 1
  • JUDITH COVEY
    • 2
  • PAUL DOLAN
    • 3
  • LORRAINE HOPKINS
    • 4
  • MICHAEL JONES-LEE
    • 5
  • GRAHAM LOOMES
    • 5
  • NICK PIDGEON
    • 4
  • ANGELA ROBINSON
    • 5
  • ANNE SPENCER
    • 2
  1. 1.University of SussexUK
  2. 2.University of YorkUK
  3. 3.University of SheffieldUK
  4. 4.University of WalesBangor
  5. 5.University of Newcastle upon TyneUK

Personalised recommendations