Human Ecology

, Volume 28, Issue 2, pp 145–169 | Cite as

Clearcutting Maine: Implications for the Theory of Common Property Resources

  • James Acheson


One of the basic tenets of the theory of common property resources is that private property rights work to conserve natural resources. There is growing evidence, however, that some large forest owners in Maine are cutting their forests heavily, using poor-quality silviculture techniques. This overexploitation is being done by paper companies, forest contractors, and some private land owners, who are being motivated by very different sets of factors. This article explores the reasons that private owners of forest resources are overexploiting their own lands and the implications of this for the theory of common property resources. Secure private property rights alone will not be enough to conserve resources and do away with externalities when the owners are operating in a system demanding constant short-term profits, where they are producing undifferentiated commodities in a highly competitive market, where the future value of slow-growing resources is very low, and where harvesting has so many ramifying biological and social effects.

deforestation Maine common property industrial forestry clearcutting 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Acheson, J. M. (1989). Management of Common Property Resources. In Plattner, S. (ed.), Economic Anthropology, Stanford University Press, Palo Alto, CA, pp. 351–378.Google Scholar
  2. Associated Press (1998). Auction of Idle Mill recessed for two weeks. Bangor Daily News May 16–17: A9.Google Scholar
  3. Associated Press (1999a). Mead Corp. to reduce Rumford work force. Bangor Daily News June 30: A4.Google Scholar
  4. Associated Press (1999b). Sappi's Westbrook mill shuts down pulp-making. Bangor Daily News June 6: A1.Google Scholar
  5. Baskerville, G. L. (1995). The forestry problem: Adaptive lurches of renewal. In Gunderson, L. H., Hollings, C. S., and Light, S. S. (eds.), Barriers and Bridges to the Renewal of Ecosystems and Institutions, Columbia University Press, New York, pp. 37–102.Google Scholar
  6. Boyd, S. (1998). Company invests, trims, focuses. Bangor Daily News Jan. 1: A1.Google Scholar
  7. Cheung, S. N. S. (1970). The structure of a contract and the theory of a non-exclusive resource. Journal of Law and Economics 13(1): 45–70.Google Scholar
  8. Clark, C. (1973). The economics of over-exploitation. Science 181: 630–634.Google Scholar
  9. Feeney, D., Hanna, S., and McEvoy, A. F. (1996). Questioning the assumptions of the ''tragedy of the commons'' model of fisheries. Land Economics 72(2): 187–205.Google Scholar
  10. Gadzik, C., Blanck, J., and Caldwell, L. (1998). Timber supply outlook for Maine: 1995–2045. Maine Forest Service, Augusta.Google Scholar
  11. Gagnon, D. (1997). Merger creating uncertainty. Bangor Daily News Dec. 31: A1.Google Scholar
  12. Graettinger, D. (1997). Efficiency critical to mill's stability. Bangor Daily News Dec. 29: A1.Google Scholar
  13. Griffith, D. M., and Allerich, C. (1996). Forest Statistics for Maine, 1995. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Radner, PA.Google Scholar
  14. Hagen, J. M. (1996). Clearcutting in Maine: Would somebody please ask the right question? Maine Policy Review 5(2): 7–19.Google Scholar
  15. Hanna, S. (2000). Transforming the ocean frontier: U.S. fishery governance in an age of limits. Ecological Economics (in press).Google Scholar
  16. Hardin, Garrett (1968). The tragedy of the commons. Science 162: 1243–1248.Google Scholar
  17. Hunter, M. (1990). Wildlife, Forests and Forestry: Principles of Managing Forests for Biological Diversity, Prentice Hall Career and Technology, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.Google Scholar
  18. Irland, L. C. (1996). Land, Timber and Recreation in Maine's Northwoods: Essays by Lloyd C. Irland, Miscellaneous Publication 730, Maine Agricultural and Forest Experiment Station, University of Maine, Orono.Google Scholar
  19. Irland, L. C. (1998). Condition and Outlook for Maine's Spruce-Fir Forest, Irland Group, Winthrop, ME.Google Scholar
  20. Irland, L. and McWilliams, W. H. (1997). Maine's 1995 forest inventory: A first look. Northern Logger and Timber Processor, p. 24 ff.Google Scholar
  21. Irland Group (1988). Clearcutting as a Management Practice in Maine Forest, Report to the Maine Department of Conservation, Forests for the Future Program, Irland Group, Augusta, ME.Google Scholar
  22. Izakson, O. (1998a). Low-impact forestry acts considered. Bangor Daily News May 18: B6.Google Scholar
  23. Izakson, O. (1998b). IP sells 185,000 acres. Bangor Daily News, Dec. 16: A1.Google Scholar
  24. Izakson, O. (1998c). Lumber firms offers plan for Nicatous Lake. Bangor Daily News Sept. 19–20: A1.Google Scholar
  25. Izakson, O. (1999). Land in the balance. Bangor Daily News Feb. 27–28: A1.Google Scholar
  26. Johnson, O. E. G. (1972). Economic analysis, the legal framework and land tenure systems. Law and Economics 15: 259–276.Google Scholar
  27. Kinzie, S. (1998). Clear-cut foes vow new fight. Bangor Daily News July 15: A1.Google Scholar
  28. Lansky M. (1992). Beyond the Beauty Strip, Tilbury House, Gardiner, ME.Google Scholar
  29. Lansky, M. (1996). After cutting is done, what's left: An evaluation of forest practices in Maine 1991–1993 (unpublished ms.).Google Scholar
  30. Lansky, M. (1998). The 1995 U.S. Forest Service inventory of the Maine woods: What does it show? (unpublished ms.).Google Scholar
  31. Legasse, M. A. (1997). Wall Street gem no community hero. Bangor Daily News Dec. 30: A1.Google Scholar
  32. Legasse, M. A. (1998). Bowater buyout proposal draws mixed reactions. Bangor Daily News May 11: A6.Google Scholar
  33. Legasse, M. A. (1999). Quebec firm to buy Great Northern. Bangor Daily News May 20: A1.Google Scholar
  34. Legasse, M. A., and Izakson, O. (1998). Bowater selling more land. Bangor Daily News, Nov. 3: A1.Google Scholar
  35. Lucier, A. A. (1994). Criteria for success in managing forested landscapes. Journal of Forestry 92(7): 20–24.Google Scholar
  36. Maine Council on Sustainable Forest Management (1996). Sustaining Maine's Forests: Criteria, Goals, and Benchmarks for Sustainable Forest Management, Maine Department of Conservation, Augusta.Google Scholar
  37. Maine Forest Service (1995). An Evaluation of the Effects of the Forest Practices Act, Submitted to the Joint Standing Committee of the 117 Legislature, Apr. 11, 1995, Maine Forest Service, State House Station 22, Augusta.Google Scholar
  38. Maine Public Law (1989). Chapter 555. An Act to Implement Sound Forest Practices. Laws of Maine, Augusta.Google Scholar
  39. Maine Pulp and Paper Association (n.d.). Highlights, Augusta, ME.Google Scholar
  40. Mass, D., and Vicary, B. (1991). The value of increased survival and stocking with herbicide treatments. In Proceedings of Northeastern Weed Science Society Meeting, Vol. 45, pp. 15–32.Google Scholar
  41. McDonald, M. (1997). Paper industry struggles in ever-toughter market. Bangor Daily News Dec. 27–28: A1.Google Scholar
  42. McDonald, M. (1998). Sappi selling Moosehead land. Bangor Daily News June 3: A1.Google Scholar
  43. McWilliams, W. H. (1997). Results from the 1995 Maine Forest Inventory, Special Report No. 97–07, USDA Forest Service, Northeastern Forest Experiment Station, Radnor, PA.Google Scholar
  44. McWilliams, W. H. (1998). Maine's recent forest Inventory: What does it tell us? Presentation to the Committee on Agriculture, Conservation and Forestry, Augusta, Maine, Jan. 29, 1998, USDA Forest Service, Radnor, PA.Google Scholar
  45. Omohundro, J., and Roy, M. (1997). No clearcutting in my backyard: Competing visions of the forest in northern Newfoundland. Paper presented at the Meetings of the Canadian Anthropological Society, St. John, Newfoundland, June 12–14.Google Scholar
  46. Osborne, W. (1974). The Paper Plantation, Viking Press, New York.Google Scholar
  47. Ostrom, E. (1990). Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  48. Pierce, R., Hornbeck, J. W., Martin, C. W., Tritton, L. M., Tattersall Smith, C., Federer, C. A., and Yawney, H. W. (1993). Whole Tree clearcutting in New England: Manager's Guide to Impacts on Soils, Streams and Regeneration, USDA Forest Service, Northeastern Forest Experiment Station, General Technical Report NE-172, USDA Forest Service, Radnor, PA.Google Scholar
  49. Scott, A. (1955). The fishery: Objectives of sole ownership. Journal of Political Economy 63: 116–34.Google Scholar
  50. Seymour, R. S., and Lemin, R. (1989). Timber Supply Projections for Maine, 1980–2080, Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Miscellaneous Report 337, Orono.Google Scholar
  51. Smith, W. H. (1984). Ecosystem pathology: A new perspective for phytopathology. Forest Ecology and Management 9: 193–219.Google Scholar
  52. Solomon, D., Hosmer, R., and Haslett, H. (1987). FIBRE Handbook: A Growth Model for Spruce-Fir and Northern Hardwood Forest Types, NE-RP-602, Northeastern Forest Experiment Station, Broomall, PA.Google Scholar
  53. United States Forest Service (1991). Fact sheet for first 40 years of results, C No. 90, MID-Intensive Selection, Penobscot Experimental Forest, Bradley, ME, Mar.Google Scholar
  54. Young, S. (1999). 750,000 acres to be left undeveloped. Bangor Daily News Mar. 4: A1.Google Scholar
  55. Voight, R. O. (1999). Jobs throughout Maine are still going, going, gone. Bangor Daily News May 6: A9.Google Scholar
  56. Vollmers, G. (1998) Personal communication, College of Business, University of Maine, Orono.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Plenum Publishing Corporation 2000

Authors and Affiliations

  • James Acheson
    • 1
  1. 1.Department of Anthropology and School of Marine SciencesUniversity of MaineOrono

Personalised recommendations