Social Indicators Research

, Volume 45, Issue 1–3, pp 475–504 | Cite as

The Structure of Mental Health: Higher-Order Confirmatory Factor Analyses of Psychological Distress and Well-Being Measures

  • Raymond Massé
  • Carole Poulin
  • Clément Dassa
  • Jean Lambert
  • Sylvie Bélair
  • Alex Battaglini


This paper addresses the question of whether psychological distress and subjective well-being are the opposite poles of the same axis of mental health or independent constructs that should be measured on two independent axes. The measures used in this study originate from a preliminary ethnosemantic study and the content analysis of narratives of psychological distress and well-being episodes experienced by a random sample of francophone Quebecers (Canada). Two scales were produced: a Psychological Distress Manifestation Scale (PDMS) based on 23 items and four factors (Anxiety/Depression, Irritability, Self-Depreciation, and Social Disengagement), and a Psychological Well-Being Manifestation Scale with 25 items and six factors (Self-Esteem, Social Involvement, Mental Balance, Control of Self and Events, Sociability, and Happiness). Structural equation modeling analyses confirm that these 10 factors can be viewed as components of two correlated dimensions (psychological distress and well-being) (r = −0.65) of a two-dimensional latent construct which reflects a higher-order concept of mental health. We conclude that assessment of mental health in general populations should use concomitant measures of psychological distress and well-being.


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. American Psychiatric Association: 1994, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (APA Press, Washington).Google Scholar
  2. Argyle, M.: 1987, The Psychology of Happiness (Methuen, New York).Google Scholar
  3. Bentler, P. M.: 1995, EQS: Structural Equation Program Manual (Multivariate Software, Inc., Encino, CA).Google Scholar
  4. Berkanovic, E., M-L. Hurwicz and J. Landsverk: 1988, ‘Psychological distress and the decision to seek medical care’, Social Science and Medicine 27, pp. 1215–1221.Google Scholar
  5. Blazer, D., M. Swartz, M. Woodbury, K. G. Manton, D. Hughes and L. K. George: 1988, ‘Depressive symptoms and depressive diagnoses in a community population’, Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 45, pp. 1077–1084.Google Scholar
  6. Bollen, K. A. and J. S. Long: 1993, Testing Structural Equation Models (Sage Publications, London).Google Scholar
  7. Byrne, B. M.: 1994, Structural Equation Modelling with EQS and EQS/Windows (Sage Publications, London).Google Scholar
  8. Campbell, A., P. E. Converse and W. L. Rodgers: 1976, The Quality of American Life (Russell Sage Foundation, New York).Google Scholar
  9. Carmines, E. G. and J. P. McIver: 1981, ‘Analysing models with unobserved variables. Analysis of covariance structure’, in G. W. Bohrnstedt and Borgatta (eds.), Social Measurement: Current Issues (CA: Sage, Beverly Hills), pp. 65–115.Google Scholar
  10. Chamberlain, K. and S. Zika: 1992, ‘Stability and change in subjective well-being over short time periods’, Social Indicators Research 26, pp. 101–117.Google Scholar
  11. Chang, C. C.: 1985, ‘A cross-cultural study of depressive symptomatology’, Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 9, pp. 295–317.Google Scholar
  12. Cherlin, A. and L. G. Reeder: 1975 ‘The dimensions of psychological well-being, a critical review’, Social Methods Research 4, pp. 189–214.Google Scholar
  13. Clark V. A., C. S. Aneshensel, R. R. Frerichs and T. M. Morgan: 1981 ‘Analysis of effects of sex and age in response to items on the CES-D scale’, Psychiatry Research 5.Google Scholar
  14. Costa, P. T., R. R. McCrae and A. B. Zonderman: 1987, ‘Environmental and disponistional influences on well-being longitudinal follow-up of an American national sample’, Bristish Journal of Psychology 78, pp. 299–306.Google Scholar
  15. Derogatis, L. R., R. S. Lipman, K. Rickels, E. H. Chlenhuth, and L. Covi: 1974, ‘The Hopkins symptom checklist (HSCL): A self-report inventory’, Behavioral Science 19, pp. 1–15.Google Scholar
  16. Diener, E: 1984, ‘Subjective well-being’, Psychological Bulletin 95, pp. 542–575.Google Scholar
  17. Diener, E: 1994, ‘Assessing subjective well-being: Progress and opportunities’, Social Indicators Research 33, pp. 103–157.Google Scholar
  18. Diener, E., F. Fujita and F. Smith: 1993, The Death of Social Desirability: An Empirical Demonstration, Manuscript in preparation.Google Scholar
  19. Dobson, K. S.: 1985. ‘An analysis of anxiety and depression scales’, Journal of Personality Assessment 49, pp. 522–527.Google Scholar
  20. Dohrenwend, B. P., P. E. Shrout, G. Egri and F. S. Mendelsohn: 1980, ‘Nonspecific psychological distress and other dimensions of psychopathology’, Archives of General Psychiatry 37, pp. 1229–1236.Google Scholar
  21. Frank, J. D.: 1973, Persuasion and Healing (John Hopkins Press, Baltimore).Google Scholar
  22. Gaines, A. D.: 1992, ‘From DSM-I to III-R, voices of self, mastery and the other: A cultural constructivist reading of U.S. psychiatry classification’, Social, Science and Medicine 35, pp. 3–24.Google Scholar
  23. Goldbert, D. P., K. Bridges, P. Duncan-Jones and P. Grayson: 1987, ‘Dimensions of neuroses seen in primary-care setting’, Psychological Medicine 17, pp. 461–470.Google Scholar
  24. Goldbert, D. P., J. J. Steele, A. Johnson and C. Smith: 1982 ‘Ability of primary care physicians to make accurate ratings of psychiatric symptoms’. Archives of General Psychiatry 39, pp. 829–833.Google Scholar
  25. Good, B. J.: 1994, Medicine, Rationality and Experience (Cambridge University Press).Google Scholar
  26. Gotlib, I. H. and D. B. Cane: 1989, ‘Self-report assessment of depression and anxiety’, in P. C. Kendall and David Watson (eds.), Anxiety and Depression, Distinctive and Overlapping Features (Academic Press, San Diego, New-York).Google Scholar
  27. Gotlib, I. H. and J. P. Meyer: 1986, ‘Factor analysis of the multiple affect adjective check List: A separation of positive and negative affect’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 50, pp. 1161–1165.Google Scholar
  28. Green, D. P., S. Boldman and P. Salovey: 1993, ‘Measurement error masks bipolarity in affect ratings’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 64, pp. 1029–1041.Google Scholar
  29. Headey, B. and A. Wearing: 1989, ‘Personality, life events, and subjective well-being: Toward a dynamic equilibrium model’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 57, pp. 731–739.Google Scholar
  30. Inkeles, A.: 1990/91, ‘National character revisited’, The Tocqueville Review 12, pp. 83–117.Google Scholar
  31. Ilfeld, F. W.: 1976, ‘Further validation of a psychiatric symptom index in a normal population’, Psychological Reports 39, pp. 1215–1228.Google Scholar
  32. Iwata, Noboru and Robert E. Roberts: 1996, ‘Age differences among Japanese on the center for epidemiologic studies depression scale: an ethnocultural perspective on somatization’, Social Science and Medicine 43, pp. 967–974.Google Scholar
  33. Jöreskog, K. G. and D. Sörbom: 1993, LISREL8: Structural Equation Modeling with the SIMPLIS Command Language (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers Hillsdale, NJ).Google Scholar
  34. Katon, W., E. Lin, M. Von Korff, J. Russo, P. Lipscomb and T. Bush: 1991, ‘Somatization: A spectrum of severity’, American Journal of Psychiatry 148, pp. 34–40.Google Scholar
  35. Kendall and D. Watson (eds.): 1989, Anxiety and Depression: Distinctive and Overlapping Features (Academic Press, N. Y.), pp. 131–163.Google Scholar
  36. Kirmayer, L. J.: 1984, ‘Culture, affect and somatization’, Transcultural, Psychiatric Research Review 21, pp. 237–262.Google Scholar
  37. Lee, S.-Y., W.-Y. Poon and P. M. Bentler: 1994, ‘Covariance and correlation structure analyses with continuous and polytomous variables’, in T. W. Anderson, K.-T. Fang and I. Olkin (eds.), Multivariate Analysis and Its Applications 24, (Institute of Mathematical Statistics, Hayward, CA), pp. 347–358.Google Scholar
  38. Martin, F., S. Sabourin and P. Gendreau: 1989, ‘Les dimensions de la détresse psychologique: Analyse factorielle confirmatoire de type hiérarchique’, International Journal of Psychology 24, pp. 571–584.Google Scholar
  39. Massé, R., C. Poulin and A. Battaglini: 1997a, Élaboration d'un Outil de Mesure de la Santé Mentale des Montréalais Francophones. Rapport de recherche, Direction de la Santé Publique de Montréal, Écologie Humaine et Sociale.Google Scholar
  40. Massé, R., C. Poulin and A. Battaglini: 1997b, ‘Les idiomes d'expression de la détresse psychologique au Québec’, Manuscript, Department of Anthropology, Laval University, Québec, Canada.Google Scholar
  41. Massé, R., C. Poulin, C. Dassa, J. Lambert, S. Bélair and A. Battaglini: 1998a, ‘Élaboration et validation d'un outil de mesure de la détresse psychologique dans une population non clinique de Québécois francophones’, Canadian Review of Public Health 89, pp. 183–189.Google Scholar
  42. Massé, R., C. Poulin, C. Dassa, J. Lambert, S. Bélair and A. Battaglini: 1998b, ‘Élaboration et validation d'un outil de mesure du bien-être psychologique: L'ÉMMBEP’, Canadian Review of Public Health, 89, to be published, autumn 1998.Google Scholar
  43. Mazmanian, D., J. D. Mendonca, R. R. Holden and B. Dufton: 1986, ‘Psychopathologuy and response styles in the SCL-90 responses of acutely distressed persons’, Research Bulletin 4 (St-Thomas Psychiatric Hospital, St. Thomas, Canada).Google Scholar
  44. McNeil, J. K., M. J. Stones and A. Kozma: 1986, ‘Subjective well-being in later life: Issues concerning measurement and prediction’, Social Indicators Research 18, pp. 35–70.Google Scholar
  45. Mirowski, J. and C. E. Ross: 1989, Social Causes of Psychological Distress, (Aldyne de Gruyter, New York).Google Scholar
  46. Okun, M. A. and W. A. Stock: 1987, ‘Correlates and components of subjective well-being among the elderly’, Journal of Applied Gerontology 6, pp. 95–112.Google Scholar
  47. Parmentier, T. R.: 1994, ‘Quality of life as a concept and measurable entity’, Social Indicators Research 33, pp. 3–46.Google Scholar
  48. Pedhazur, E. J. and L. Pedhazur Schmelkin: 1991, Measurement, Design, and Analysis (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ).Google Scholar
  49. Préville, M., R. Boyer, L. Potvin, C. Perreault and G. Légaré: 1991, La Démoralisation: Détermination de la Fiabilité et de la Validité de la Mesure Utilisée dans l'Enquête Santé Québec (Rapport de recherche, DSC Maisonneuve-Rosemont, Montréal).Google Scholar
  50. Préville, M., L. Potvin and R. Boyer: 1995, ‘The structure of psychological distress’, Psychological Reports 77, pp. 275–293.Google Scholar
  51. Prusoff B. and G. L. Klerman: 1974, ‘Differentiating depressed from anxiours neurotic outpatients: Use of discriminant function analysis for separation of neurotic affective states’, Archives General Psychiatry 30, pp. 302–309.Google Scholar
  52. Santé Nationale et Bien-être social Canada: 1988, La Santé Mentale des Canadiens: Vers un juste équilibre, Cat. H39–128/1988F (Ministère des Approvisionnements et Services, Canada).Google Scholar
  53. Schwarz N. and G. Clore: 1983, ‘Mood, misattribution, and judgements of well-being: Informative and directive functions of affective states’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45, pp. 513–523.Google Scholar
  54. Sherman, S. J. and E. Corty: 1984, Cognitive Heuristics in Handbook of Social Cognition (R.S Wyers and T.K. Srull, Erlbaum, Hillsdale, NJ), pp. 189–286.Google Scholar
  55. Sörbom, D. and K. G. Jöreskog: 1982, ‘The use of structure equation models in evaluation research’, in C. Fornell (ed.), A Second Generation of Multivariate Analysis 2, Measurement and Evaluation (Praeger, New York), pp. 381–418.Google Scholar
  56. Strack, F., N. Schwarz and E. Gschneidinger: 1985, ‘Happiness and reminiscing: The role of time perspective, affect and mode of thinking’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 49, pp. 1460–1469.Google Scholar
  57. Tanaka, J. S. and G. T. Huba: 1984, ‘Structures of psychological distress: Testing confirmatory hierarchical models’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 46, pp. 621–635.Google Scholar
  58. Tellengen, A. et al.: 1988, ‘Personality similarity in twins reared apart and together’, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54, pp. 1031–1037.Google Scholar
  59. Van Schuur, W. H. and M. Kruijtbosch: 1995, ‘Measuring subjective well-being: Unfolding the Bradburn affect balance scale’, Social Indicators Research 34, pp. 49–73.Google Scholar
  60. Veenhoven, R.: 1994, ‘Is happiness a trait? Tests of the theory that a better society does not make people any happier’, Social Indicators Research 32, pp. 101–160.Google Scholar
  61. Veenhoven, R.: 1998, ‘Two state-trait discussions on hapiness. A reply to Stones et al.’, Social Indicators Research, 43, pp. 211–225.Google Scholar
  62. Veit, C. T. and J. E. Ware: 1983, ‘The structure of psychological distress and well-being in general populations’, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 51, pp. 730–742.Google Scholar
  63. Vella-Brodrick, D. A. and F. C. L. Allen: 1995, ‘Development and psychometric Validation of the mental, physical and spiritual well-being scale’, Psychological Reports 77, pp. 659–674.Google Scholar
  64. Watson, D. and P. C. Kendall: 1989, ‘Understanding anxiety and depression: their relation to negative and positive affective state’, in P. C. Kendall and D. Watson (eds.), Anxiety and Depression: Distinctive and Overlapping Features (Academic Press, NT), pp. 3–25.Google Scholar
  65. Weissman, M. M., J. K. Myers and C. E. Ross: 1988, Community Surveys of Psychiatric Disorders (Rutgers University Press, NJ).Google Scholar
  66. Wells, K. B., J. M. Golding and M. A. Burnam: 1988, ‘Psychiatric disorder in a sample of the general population with and without chronic medical conditions’, American Journal of Psychiatry 145, pp. 976–981.Google Scholar
  67. Yardley, J. K. and R. W. Rice: 1991, ‘The relationship between Mood and Subjective Well-being’, Social Indicators Research 24, pp. 101–111.Google Scholar
  68. Zautra, A. J., C. A. Guarnaccia and J. W. Reich: 1988, ‘Factor structure of mental health measures for older adults’, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 56, pp. 514–519.Google Scholar
  69. Zinbarg, R. E., D. H. Barlow, M. Liebowitz, L. Street, E. Broadhead, and W. Katon: 1994, ‘The DSM-IV Field trial for mixed anxiety-depression’, American Journal of Psychiatry 151, pp. 1153–1162.Google Scholar
  70. Zurawski, R. M. and T. W. Smith: 1987, ‘Assessing irrational beliefs and emotional distress: Evidence and implications of limited discriminant validity’, Journal of Counseling Psychology 34, pp. 224–227.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1998

Authors and Affiliations

  • Raymond Massé
    • 1
  • Carole Poulin
    • 1
  • Clément Dassa
    • 1
  • Jean Lambert
    • 1
  • Sylvie Bélair
    • 1
  • Alex Battaglini
    • 1
  1. 1.Département d'anthropologieUniversité LavalQuebecCanada

Personalised recommendations