Social Indicators Research

, Volume 40, Issue 1–2, pp 5–98

TOWARD A CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR ASSESSING PROGRESS TOWARD SUSTAINABILITY

  • Tony Hodge
Article

Abstract

Through the past half-century, much effort in a variety of disciplines, has been put to developing an approach to assessing change that pushes beyond an emphasis on economic signals to include a more complete treatment of human and ecosystem wellbeing. This challenge lies at the very heart of reporting on progress toward sustainability. Key to addressing this challenge is developing an effective conceptualization of the human-ecosystem relationship. The results of a review of 29 conceptual models that address the human-ecosystem relationship are presented. These results are used to develop a conceptual approach to assessing progress toward sustainability that: (1) builds on a number of common features drawn from these models; (2) is founded on a value set that insists on parallel care and respect for people and the ecosystem together; and (3) is consistent with systems ideas.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

REFERENCES

  1. Atkinson, C. J. and P. B. Checkland: 1988, 'Extending the metaphor “System”', Human Relations 41(10), pp. 709–725.Google Scholar
  2. BCRTEE: 1992, Towards a Strategy for Sustainability (British Columbia Round Table on the Environment and the Economy, Victoria).Google Scholar
  3. BCRTEE: 1993, Sustainability: From Ideas to Action (British Columbia Round Table on the Environment and the Economy, Victoria).Google Scholar
  4. Beanlands, G. E., and P. N. Duinker: 1983, An Ecological Framework for Environmental Impact Assessment in Canada (Institute for Resource and Environmental Studies, Dalhousie University, Halifax; Hull: The Federal Environmental Assessment Review Office, Halifax).Google Scholar
  5. Bird, P. M. and D. J. Rapport: 1986, State of the Environment Report for Canada (Environment Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  6. Checkland, P. and J. Scholes: 1990, Soft Systems Methodology in Action (John Wiley & Sons, Chichester).Google Scholar
  7. Chiras, D. D.: 1991, Environmental Science – Action for a Sustainable Future (Benjamin/Cummings, Redwood City, California).Google Scholar
  8. CIDA: 1991, Sustainable Development (Policy Branch, Canadian International Development Agency, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  9. CMA: 1991, Health, the Environment, and Sustainable Development – Policy Paper (Canadian Medical Association, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  10. Comolet, A.: 1992, 'How OECD countries respond to state-of-the-environment reports', International Environmental Affairs: Journal for Research and Policy 4(1), pp. 3–17 (University Press of England for Dartmouth College, Hanover, New Hampshire).Google Scholar
  11. CORE: 1996, Report on British Columbia's Progress Toward Sustainability (interim draft) (British Columbia Commission on Resources and Environment, Victoria).Google Scholar
  12. CPHA, CIP, and FCM: 1991, The Multiplier – Challenge/Change. Newsletter of the Strengthening Community Health Program and the Canadian Healthy Communities Project (The Canadian Public Health Association, Canadian Institute of Planners and the Federation of Canadian Municipalities, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  13. Crombie, D.: 1992, Regeneration – Toronto's Waterfront and the Sustainable City – Final Report (Royal Commission on the Future of the Toronto Waterfront, Toronto and Ottawa).Google Scholar
  14. Daly, H. E.: 1989, 'Sustainable development: From concept and theory towards operational principles', Paper Presented at Hoover Institution Conference, Population and Development Review. Also published in H. Daly, 1991. Steady State Economics (2nd edition) (Island Press, Washington D.C.), pp. 241–260.Google Scholar
  15. Daly, H. E.: 1991, Steady State Economics (2nd edition) (Island Press, Washington D.C.).Google Scholar
  16. Daly, H. E. and J. B. Cobb, Jr.: 1989, For the Common Good: Redirecting the Economy Toward Community, the Environment, and a Sustainable Future (Beacon Press, Boston).Google Scholar
  17. Dansereau, P.: 1975, Harmony and Disorder in the Canadian Environment – Occasional Paper No. 1 (Canadian Environmental Advisory Council, Environment Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  18. Dansereau, P.: 1976, EZAIM: Ecologic de la Zone de l'Aeroport International de Montreal – Le Cadre d'une recherche ecologique interdisciplinaire (Presses de L'Univ. de Montreal, Montreal).Google Scholar
  19. Dansereau, P.: 1990, 'Interdisciplinary perspective on production-investment-control processes in the environment', UNESCO, 1990. Vancouver Declaration: Final Report of the UNESCO Symposium on Science and Culture for the 21st Century: Agenda for Survival (Canadian Commission for UNESCO, Ottawa), pp. 55–100.Google Scholar
  20. DIPSC: 1991,Using Development Indicators for Aboriginal Development (Development Indicator Project Steering Committee. Economic Development Staff Program, Indian and Northern Affairs Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  21. Dorcey, A. H. J. (ed.): 1991. Perspectives on Sustainable Development in Water Management: Towards Agreement in the Fraser River Basin. Research Program on Water in Sustainable Development, Volume 1 (Westwater Research Centre, University of British Columbia, Vancouver).Google Scholar
  22. Dorcey, A. H. J.: 1991a, 'Water in sustainable development: From ideal to reality', in A. H. J. Dorcey (ed.), Perspectives on Sustainable Development in Water Management: Towards Agreement in the Fraser River Basin. Research Program on Water in Sustainable Development, Volume 1 (Westwater Research Centre, University of British Columbia, Vancouver), pp. 1–16.Google Scholar
  23. Dorcey, A. H. J.: 1991b, 'Towards agreement on sustainable development in water management: Learning from the differences', in A. H. J. Dorcey (ed.), Perspectives on Sustainable Development in Water Management: Towards Agreement in the Fraser River Basin. Research Program on Water in Sustainable Development, Volume 1 (Westwater Research Centre, University of British Columbia, Vancouver), pp. 533–554.Google Scholar
  24. Dorcey, A. H. J.: 1991c. 'Towards agreement in water management: An evolving sustainable development model', in A. H. J. Dorcey (ed.), Perspectives on Sustainable Development in Water Management: Towards Agreement in the Fraser River Basin. Research Program on Water in Sustainable Development, Volume 1 (Westwater Research Centre, University of British Columbia, Vancouver), pp. 555–586.Google Scholar
  25. Easter, K. W., J. A. Dixon, and M. M. Hufschmidt (eds.): 1986, Watershed Resources Management: An Integrated Framework with Studies from Asia and the Pacific (Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado).Google Scholar
  26. Elkin, T. J.: 1987, State of the Environment Report – Regional Municipality of Waterloo.Working Paper Series No. 23 (School of Urban and Regional Planning, Faculty of Environmental Studies, University of Waterloo, Waterloo).Google Scholar
  27. Evans, R. G. and G. L. Stoddart: 1990, Producing Health, Consuming Health Care. Population Health Program Working Paper No. 6 (Canadian Institute for Advanced Research, Toronto).Google Scholar
  28. Firey, W.: 1960, Man, Mind and Land – A Theory of Resource Use (The Free Press, Glencoe, Illinois).Google Scholar
  29. Freeman III, A. M., R. H. Haveman, and A. V. Kneese: 1973, The Economics of Environmental Policy (John Wiley & Sons, New York).Google Scholar
  30. Friend, A. M.: 1991, 'Pluarism in national accounting', Paper presented at the Special IARIW Conference of Environmental Accounting, 27–29 May 1991, Baden, Austria (Institute for Research on Environment and Economy, University of Ottawa, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  31. Friend, A. M. and D. J. Rapport: 1989, 'Environmental information systems for sustainable development', Paper presented at the Seventh Annual Meeting of the International Association for Impact Assessment, Montreal. 24–28 June, 1989 (Institute for Research on Environment and Economy, University of Ottawa, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  32. Friend, A. M. and D. J. Rapport: 1990, The Evolution of Information Systems for Sustainable Development. Occasional paper Series, No. 1 (Institute for Research on Environment and Economy, University of Ottawa, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  33. Friend, A. M. and D. J. Rapport: 1991, 'The evolution of macro-information systems for sustainable development', Ecological Economics 3, pp. 59–76.Google Scholar
  34. Georgescu-Roegen, N.: 1971, 'The entropy law and the economic problem', in H. E. Daly and K. N. Townsend (eds.), 1993. Valuing the Earth – Economics, Ecology, Ethics (MIT Press, Cambridge).Google Scholar
  35. Georgescu-Roegen, N.: 1975, 'Selections from “Energy and Economic Myths”', in H. E. Daly and K. N. Townsend (eds.), 1993. Valuing the Earth – Economics, Ecology, Ethics (MIT Press, Cambridge), pp. 89–112.Google Scholar
  36. GLWQA: 1978, Revised Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement of 1978 as amended by Protocol, November 18, 1987. Consolidated by the International Joint Commission (International Joint Commission, Washington D.C. and Ottawa).Google Scholar
  37. Goldberg, M.: 1989, On Systemic Balance – Flexibilty and Stability in Social, Economic, and Environmental Systems (Praeger, New York).Google Scholar
  38. Goodland, R. and G. Ledec: 1987, 'Neoclassical economics and principles of sustainable development', Ecological Modelling 38, pp. 19–46.Google Scholar
  39. Gosselin, P, D. Bélanger, Jean-Francois Bibeault, A. Webster, with collaboration From G. Laroche, Jean-Pierre Reveret, L. Coughlin, M. O'Neill, P. Marc Johnson and the Steering Committee on Indicators for a Sustainable Society: 1991, Feasibility Study on the Development of Indicators for a Sustainable Society (Health Promotion Directorate, Health and Welfare Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  40. Gosselin, P, D. Bélanger, Jean-Francois Bibeault, A. Webster, with collaboration From G. Laroche, Jean-Pierre Reveret, L. Coughlin, M. O'Neill, P. Marc Johnson and the Steering Committee on Indicators for a Sustainable Society: 1993, 'Indicators for a sustainable society', Canadian Journal of Public Health May– June, pp. 197–200.Google Scholar
  41. Hamilton, K.: 1991, 'The population environment process framework', Statistics Canada, 1991. Human Activity and the Environment 1991. Catalogue 11-509E Occassional (Minister of Industry, Science and Technology, Ottawa), Appendix 5.1.Google Scholar
  42. Hancock, T.: 1985, 'The mandala of health: A model of the human ecosytem', Family and Community Health, November, pp. 1–10.Google Scholar
  43. Hancock, T.: 1989, 'Sustaining health: Achieving health for all in a secure environment', Health * Environment * Economy – Strategies for a Sustainable Future, conference sponsored by Health and Welfare Canada and Environment Canada. York University.Google Scholar
  44. Hancock, T.: 1990b, 'Towards healthy and sustainable communities: Health, environment, and economy at the local level', 3rd Colloquium on Environmental Health, Quebec, 22 Nov. 1990.Google Scholar
  45. Hancock, T. and F. Perkins: 1985. 'The mandala of health: A conceptual model and teaching tool', Health Education 24(1), pp. 8–10.Google Scholar
  46. Health and Welfare Canada: 1974, A New Perspective on the Health of Canadians (Lalonde Report) (Health and Welfare Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  47. Health and Welfare Canada: 1986, Achieving Health for All: A Framework for Health Promotion. (Health and Welfare Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  48. Hill, S. B.: 1989, Notes on the Theory and Practice of Sustainable Development (Department of Entomology, MacDonald College, McGill University, Montreal).Google Scholar
  49. Hodge, R. A.: 1993, Reporting on Sustainable and Equitable Development – Project Paper No. 1, Conceptual Approach (Evaluation Unit, Corporate Affairs and Initiatives Division, The International Development Research Centre, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  50. Hodge, R.A.: 1995a. Assessing Progress Toward Sustainability: Development of a Systemic Framework and Reporting Structure. Ph.D. (interdisciplinary) Dissertation (School of Urban Planning, Faculty of Engineering, McGill University, Montreal).Google Scholar
  51. Hodge, T, S. Holtz, C. Smith, and K. Hawke Baxter: 1995, Pathways to Sustainability: Assessing our Progress (National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  52. Hueting, R.: 1991, 'Correcting national income for environmental losses: A practical solution for a theoretical dilemma', in R. Costanza (ed.), Ecological Economics – The Science and Management of Sustainability (Columbia UP, New York), pp. 194–213.Google Scholar
  53. Isard, W.: 1960, Methods of Regional Analysis: An Introduction to Regional Science (The M.I.T. Press, Cambridge).Google Scholar
  54. IUCN, UNEP, and WWF: 1980, World Conservation Strategy – Living Resource Conservation for Sustainable Development (International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources; Nairobi: United Nations Environment Programme; and Geneva: the World Wildlife Fund, Gland).Google Scholar
  55. IUCN, UNEP, and WWF: 1991, Caring for the Earth – A Strategy for Sustainable Living (International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources; Nairobi: United Nations Environment Programme; and Geneva: the World Wildlife Fund, Gland).Google Scholar
  56. IUCN International Assessment Team: 1995, 'Assessing progress toward sustainability: A new approach', in Trzyna, T. (ed.), A Sustainabile World (International Center for the Environment and Public Policy, California Institute of Public Affairs, Sacramento), pp. 152–172.Google Scholar
  57. Jacobs, M.: 1991 and 1993, The Green Economy: Environment, Sustainable Development, and the Politics of the Future (Pluto Press, London/UBC Press, Vancouver).Google Scholar
  58. Janis, I. L.: 1954, 'Problems of theory in the analysis of stress behavior', Journal of Social Issues X, pp. 12–25.Google Scholar
  59. Kasperson, R. E.: 1969, 'Environmental stress and the municipal political system', in R. E. Kasperson and J. V. Minghi (eds.), The Structure of Political Geography (Aldine Publishers, Chicago), pp. 481–500.Google Scholar
  60. Kneese, A. V., R. U. Ayres, and R. C. d'Arge: 1970. Economics and the Environment: A Materials Balance Approach (Resources for the Future Inc., Washington).Google Scholar
  61. Kneese, A. V., and B. T. Bower: 1979, Environmental Quality and Residuals Management (Johns Hopkins UP/Resources for the Future Inc., Baltimore).Google Scholar
  62. Leeman, E., and J. Cox: 1990, Sustainable Urban Devevopment: Strategic Considerations For Urbanizing Nations (Chreod Development Planning Consultants, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  63. Macelli, T.: 1977, 'An introduction to multiple process analysis – conceptual tools and research strategy for interdisciplinary development studies of man-nature systems', Msida (Faculty of Arts, University of Malta, Malta).Google Scholar
  64. Manning, E. W.: 1990, 'Presidential address: Sustainable development, the challenge', The Canadian Geographer 34(4), pp. 290–302.Google Scholar
  65. Michalos, A. C.: 1981, 'A reconsideration of the idea of a science court', in P. T. Durbin (ed.), Research in Philosophy and Technology, Vol. 3 (JAI Press) pp. 10–21.Google Scholar
  66. Miller, J. G.: 1978, Living Systems (McGraw-Hill, New York).Google Scholar
  67. Mitchell, B.: 1980, 'Models of resource management', Progress in Human Geography 4(1), pp. 32–56.Google Scholar
  68. Mitchell, B.: 1991, '“Beating” conflict and uncertainty in resource management and development', in B. Mitchel (ed.), Resource Management and Development (Oxford UP, Toronto), pp. 268–285.Google Scholar
  69. Murdie, R. A., D. Rhyne, and J. Bates: 1992, Modelling Quality of Life Indicators in Canada: A Feasibility Analysis (Institute for Social Research, York University, Toronto; The Centre for Future Studies in Housing and Living Environments, Canada Mortage and Housing Corporation, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  70. Nault, J.: 1991, Participatory Extension Strategies for the Implementation of Sustainable Agriculture, M.SC. Thesis (Department of Renewable Resources, McGill University, Montreal).Google Scholar
  71. NRTEE: 1993, Toward Reporting Progress on Sustainable Development in Canada – Report to the Prime Minister (National Round Table on the Environment and the Economy, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  72. NTFHI: 1991, Health Information for Canada, Final Draft Report (National Task Force on Health Information, National Health Information Council, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  73. OECD: 1979, The State of the Environment in OECD Member Countries (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris).Google Scholar
  74. OECD: 1985, The State of the Environment (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris).Google Scholar
  75. OECD: 1991, Environmental Indicators – A Preliminary Set (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris).Google Scholar
  76. OECD: 1993, Environmental Indicators: Basic Concepts and Terminology. Draft Background Paper No. 1 (Group on the State of the Environment, Environment Directorate. Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development, Paris).Google Scholar
  77. Oxford: 1989, The Oxford English Dictionary (Clarendon Press, Oxford).Google Scholar
  78. Parkin, M., and R. Bade: 1991, Economics – Canada in the Global Environment (Addison-Wesley, Don Mills).Google Scholar
  79. Pearce, D. W., and S. Freeman: 1991, 'Information requirements of policy decision-makers', Proceedings of the Environmental Information Forum, Montreal, Canada, 21–24 May, 1991 (State of Environment Reporting, Environment Canada. Minister of Supply and Services Canada, Ottawa), pp. 56–101.Google Scholar
  80. PFRA: 1992, Rural Prairie Sustainability: A Background Paper, Draft for Discussion (Prairie Farm Rehabilitation Administration, Regina).Google Scholar
  81. Pigou, A. C.: 1920, Economics of Welfare, 4th Edition (Macmillan, 1962, London).Google Scholar
  82. Rapport, D.: 1983, 'The stress-response environmental statistical system and its applicability to the Laurentian Lower Great Lakes', Statistical Journal of the United Nations ECE 1, pp. 377–405.Google Scholar
  83. Rapport, D. and A. Friend: 1979, 'Towards a comprehensive framework for environmental statistics: a stress-response approach', Statistics Canada Catalogue 11-510 (Minister of Supply and Services Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  84. Rawls, J.: 1987, 'The idea of an overlapping consensus', Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 7(1), pp. 1–25.Google Scholar
  85. Rees, W. E., forthcoming: 1993, 'Understanding sustainable development: natural capital and the new world order', Journal of the American Planning Association.Google Scholar
  86. Robinson, J. B.: 1989, 'Exploring a sustainable future for Canada: The next step in the conserver society discussion', Meeting of the Leaders of National 21st Century Studies (Institute for 21st Century Studies and World Futures Society, Washington).Google Scholar
  87. Robinson, J. B.: 1991, Notes on Sustainable Society Project Indicator Diagrams (Department of Environment and Resource Studies, University of Waterloo, Waterloo).Google Scholar
  88. Robinson, J. G., G. Francis, R. Legge, and S. Lerner: 1990, 'Defining a sustainable society: values, principles, and definitions', Alternatives 17(2), pp. 36–46.Google Scholar
  89. Sadler, B.: 1988, Impact Assessment, Development Planning and International Assistance in Post Brundtland Perspective. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Impact Assessment for International Development (International Association for Impact Assessment, Vancouver), pp. 775–787.Google Scholar
  90. Sadler, B.: 1990a, 'Sustainable development and water resource management', Alternatives 17(3), pp. 14–24.Google Scholar
  91. Sadler, B.: 1990b, 'Sustainable development, northern realities and the design and implementation of regional conservation strategies', Achieving Sustainable Development Through Northern Conservation Strategies (University of Calgary Press, Calgary).Google Scholar
  92. Sadder, B. and P. Jacobs: 1990, Conclusions and Recommendations on Further Directions for Research and Development. P. Jacobs and B. Saddler, 1991. Sustainable Development and EnvironmentalAssessment: Perspectives on Planning for a Common Future (Canadian Environmental Assessment Research Council, Ottawa), pp. 169–173.Google Scholar
  93. SCC: 1977, Canada as a Conserver Society: Resource Uncertainties and the Need for New Technologies. Report No. 27 (Science Council of Canada, Ottawa).Google Scholar
  94. Siebert, H.: 1981, Economics of the Environment. Lexington (Lexington Books, Massachusetts).Google Scholar
  95. Stankey, G. H.: 1972, 'A strategy for the definition and management of wilderness quality', in J. V. Krutilla (ed.), Natural Environments: Studies in Theoretical and Applied Analysis (Johns Hopkins UP, Baltimore), pp. 88–114.Google Scholar
  96. Tietenberg: 1992, Environmental and Natural Resource Economics, 3rd. edition (Harper Collins, New York).Google Scholar
  97. UNCED: 1992, AGENDA 21. United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (United Nations, New York).Google Scholar
  98. Underwood, D. A. and P. G. King: 1989, 'On the ideological foundations of environmental policy', Ecological Economics 1(4), pp. 315–334.Google Scholar
  99. Valaskakis, K., P. Sindell, J. G. Smith, and I. Fitzpatrick-Martin: 1975, Tentative Blueprints for a Conserver Society in Canada (GAMMA, Montreal).Google Scholar
  100. Van Dusen, K., and A. C. Johnson Hayden: 1989, The Gulf ofMaine – Sustaining our Common Heritage (State Planning Office, Portland, Maine).Google Scholar
  101. Ward, B., and R. Dubos: 1972, Only One Earth – The Care and Maintenance of a Small Planet (Norton, New York).Google Scholar
  102. WCED: 1987, Our Common Future – Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development (Oxford University Press, London).Google Scholar
  103. WHO: 1947, Charter (World Health Organization, Geneva).Google Scholar
  104. WHO: 1987, Proceedings: Healthy Cities Project – Workshop on Indicators held in Barcelona Spain, March 8–12, 1987 (WHO Europe, Geneva). WHO: 1993, WHO Consultation on the Development and Use of Environmental Health Indicators in the Management of Environmental Risks to Human Health – Summary Report (World Health Organization, Geneva). WHO, Health and Welfare Canada, and the Canadian Public Health Association: 1986, Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion (World Health Organization/Health and Welfare Canada, Ottawa). ai]Wolfson, M.C.: 1990, A System of Health Statistics Toward a New Conceptual Framework for Integrating Health Data. Population Health Working Paper No. 1 (revised) (Canadian Institute for Advanced Research, Toronto). ai]Wolpert, J.: 1966, 'Migration as an adjustment to environmental stress', Journal of Social Issues XXII (October), pp. 93. ai]Young, M. D.: 1992, Sustainable Investment and Resource Use – Equity, Environmental Integrity and Economic Effiency. Man and the Biosphere Series Volume 9 (CSIRO Division of Wildlife and Ecology, Melbourne, Australia; UNESCO, Paris, France; Parthenon, Park Ridge, New Jersey).Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 1997

Authors and Affiliations

  • Tony Hodge
    • 1
  1. 1.VictoriaCanada

Personalised recommendations