Biology and Philosophy

, Volume 16, Issue 1, pp 53–68 | Cite as

How Molecular is Molecular Developmental Biology? A Reply to Alex Rosenberg's Reductionism Redux: Computing the Embryo

  • Manfred D. Laubichler
  • Günter P. Wagner


This paper argues in defense of theanti-reductionist consensus in the philosophy ofbiology. More specifically, it takes issues with AlexRosenberg's recent challenge of this position. Weargue that the results of modern developmentalgenetics rather than eliminating the need forfunctional kinds in explanations of developmentactually reinforce their importance.

molecular developmental biology physicalist antireductionism functional kinds 


Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.


  1. Alberch, P. and Gale, E.A.: 1983, 'Size Dependence During the Development of the Amphibian Foot. Colchicine-Induced Digital Loss and Reduction', J. Embryol. Exp. Morph. 76, 177–197.Google Scholar
  2. Alberch, P. and Gale, E.A.: 1985, 'A Developmental Analysis of Evolutionary Trend: Digital Reduction in Amphibians', Evolution 39, 8–23.Google Scholar
  3. Boveri, T.: 1910, ' Die Potenzen der Ascaris-Blastomeren bei abgeänderter Furchung, zugleich ein Beitrag zur Frage qualitativ-ungleicher Chromosomen Teilung', Festschrift Richard Hertwig III, 133–214.Google Scholar
  4. Brandon, R.: 1996, Concepts and Methods in Evolutionary Biology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  5. Carroll, S.B., Gallant, R., Keys, D., Lewis, D. et al.: 2000, 'Co-option and Developmental Pathways', American Zoologist 40, forthcomingGoogle Scholar
  6. Davis, E.P., Witte, D.P., Hsieh-Li, H.M., Potter, S.S. and Capecchi, M.R.: 1995, 'Absence of Radius and Ulna in Mice lacking Hoxa-ll and Hoxd-ll', Nature 375, 791–795.Google Scholar
  7. Gerhart, J. and Kirschner, M.: 1997, Cells, Embryos, and Evolution, Blackwell, Oxford.Google Scholar
  8. Gilbert S.F., Opitz, J.M. and Raff, R.A.: 1996, 'Resynthesizing Evolutionary and Developmental Biology', Developmental Biology 173, 357–372.Google Scholar
  9. Gottlieb, G.: 1992, Individual Development and Evolution, Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar
  10. Gurwitch, V.A.: 1922, ' Ñber den Begriff des embryonalen Feldes', Roux's Archiv für Entwicklungsmechanik der Organismen 51, 383–415.Google Scholar
  11. Haack, H. and Gruss, P.: 1993, 'The Establishment of Murine Hox-1 Expression Domains During Patterning of the Limb', Developmental Biology 157, 410–422.Google Scholar
  12. Haraway, D.: 1976, Crystals, Fabrics and Fields, Yale University Press, New Haven and London.Google Scholar
  13. Huxley, J. and de Beer, G.R.: 1934, The Elements of Experimental Embryology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar
  14. Ingham, P.W.: 1994, 'Hedgehog Points the Way', Current Biology 4, 1–4Google Scholar
  15. Keys, D.N., Lewis, D.L., Selegue, J.E., Pearson, B.J. et al.: 1999, 'Recruitment of a Hedgehog Regulatory Circuit in Butterfly Eyespot Evolution', Science 283, 532–534.Google Scholar
  16. Laubichler, M.D. and Wagner, G.P.: 2000, 'Organism and Character Decomposition: Steps Towards an Integrative Theory of Biology', Philosophy of Science, Supplement 67, S289–300.Google Scholar
  17. Laufer, E. et al.: 1994, 'Sonic Hedgehog and Fgf-4 Act Through a Signaling Cascade and Feedback Loop to Integrate Growth and Patterning of the Developing Limb Bud', Cell 79, 993–1003.Google Scholar
  18. Nelson, C.E., Morgan, B.A., Burke, A.C., Laufer, E., DiMambro, E., Murtaugh, L.C., Gonzales, E., Tessasollo, L., Parada, L. and Tabin, C.: 1996, 'Analysis of Hox Gene Expression in the Chick Limb Bud', Development 122, 1449–1466.Google Scholar
  19. Newman, S.A.: 1996, 'Sticky Fingers: Hox Genes and Cell Adhesion in Vertebrate Limb Development', BioEssays 18, 171–174.Google Scholar
  20. Newman, S.A. and Comper, W.D.: 1990, '“Generic” Physical Mechanisms of Morphogenesis and Pattern Formation', Development 110, 1–18.Google Scholar
  21. Niswander, L., Jeffrey, S., Martin, G.R. and Tickle, C.: 1994, 'Positive Feedback Loop Coordinates Growth and Patterning of the Vertebrate Limb', Nature 371, 609–612.Google Scholar
  22. Oster, G.F., Shubin, N., Murray, J.D. and Alberch, P. 1988: 'Evolution and Morphogenetic Rules: The Shape of the Vertebrate Limb in Ontogeny and Phylogeny', Evolution 42, 862–884.Google Scholar
  23. Raff, R.: 1996: The Shape of Life, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar
  24. Rosenberg, A.: 1997, 'Reductionism Redux: Computing the Embryo', Biology and Philosophy 12, 445–470.Google Scholar
  25. Spemann, H.: 1921, ' Die Erzeugung tierischer Chimären durch heteroplastische embryonale Transplantation zwischen Triton cristatus und taeniatus', Roux's Archiv für Entwicklungsmechanik der Organismen 48, 533–570.Google Scholar
  26. Tautz, D.: 1992, 'Redundancies, Development and the Flow of Information', BioEssays 14, 263–266.Google Scholar
  27. Wagner, G.P. and Laubichler, M.D.: 2000, 'Character Identification in Evolutionary Biology: The Role of the Organism', Theory in Bioscience 119, 20–40.Google Scholar
  28. Weiss, P.: 1939, Principles of Development, Holt, New York.Google Scholar
  29. Wilder, E.L. and Perrimon, N.: 1995, 'Dual Functions of Wingless in the Drosophila Leg Imaginal Disc', Development 121, 477–488.Google Scholar
  30. Wolpert, L.: 1969, 'Positional Information and the Spatial Pattern of Cellular Formation', Journal of Theoretical Biology 25, 1–47.Google Scholar
  31. Wolpert, L.: 1994, 'Do We Understand Development?', Science 266, 571–572.Google Scholar
  32. Yokouchi, Y., Nakazato, S., Yamamoto, M., Goto, Y., Kameda, T., Iba, H. and Kuroiwa, A.: 1995, 'Misexpression of Hoxa-13 Induces Cartilage Homeotic Transformation and Changes Cell Adhesiveness in Chick Limb Buds', Genes and Development 9, 2509–2522.Google Scholar
  33. Yokouchi, Y., Sasaki, H. and Kuroiwa, A.: 1991, 'Homeobox Gene Expression Correlated with the Bifurcation Process of Limb Cartilage Development', Nature 353, 443–445.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • Manfred D. Laubichler
    • 1
  • Günter P. Wagner
    • 2
  1. 1.Program in History of SciencePrinceton UniversityPrincetonUSA
  2. 2.Department of Ecology and Evolutionary BiologyYale UniversityNew HavenUSA

Personalised recommendations