Space Science Reviews

, Volume 95, Issue 1–2, pp 325–345 | Cite as

A Multiscale Model for Substorms

  • A.T.Y. Lui
Article

Abstract

Most substorm researchers assume substorms to be caused by a unique large-scale process. However, a critical evaluation of substorm observations indicates that a new paradigm is needed to understand the substorm phenomenon and the magnetospheric dynamics in general. It is proposed here that substorms involve a number of physical processes covering over a wide range of spatial and temporal scales. Potential candidates include the kinetic or shear ballooning instability, the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability, the cross-field current instability, the tearing instability, and magnetic reconnection. An observational constraint on the qualified process for substorm onset is that it must be associated with magnetic field lines of auroral arcs since substorm onsets start with brightening of a pre-existing auroral arc. Which particular process dominates in a given substorm depends on the present and past states of the magnetosphere as well as the external solar wind. The magnetosphere is almost perpetually driven by the solar wind to be near a critical point and in a metastable state. Magnetospheric disturbances occur sporadically in multiple localized sites. A substorm is realized when the combined effect of these localized disturbances become global in extent, much like the system-wide activity in a sandpile or avalanche model.

Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

References

  1. Aikio, A. T., Sergeev, V. A., Shukhtina, M. A., Vagina, L. I., Angelopoulos, V., and Reeves, G. D.: 1999, ‘Characteristics of Pseudobreakups and Substorms Observed in the Ionosphere, at the Geosynchronous Orbit, and in the Midtail’ J. Geophys. Res. 104, 12263.Google Scholar
  2. Akasofu, S.-I.: 1964, ‘The Development of the Auroral Substorm’ Planet. Space Sci. 12, 273.Google Scholar
  3. Akasofu, S.-I.: 1998, in S. Kokubun and Y. Kamide (eds), ‘The Rise and Fall of Paradigms and Some Long Standing Unsolved Problems in Solar-Terrestrial Physics’ Substorms-4, Terra Scientific Publishing Co., Tokyo, Japan, Pp. 21.Google Scholar
  4. Akasofu, S.-I., Lui, A. T. Y., Meng, C.-I., and Haurwitz, M.: 1978, ‘Need for a Three-Dimensional Analysis of Magnetic Fields in the Magnetotail During Substorms’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 5, 283.Google Scholar
  5. Angelopoulos, V., Baumjohann, W., Kennel, C. F., Coroniti, F. V., Kivelson, M. G., Pellat, R., Lühr, H. and Paschmann, G.: 1992, ‘Bursty Bulk Flow in the Inner Central Plasma Sheet’ J. Geophys. Res. 97, 4027.Google Scholar
  6. Angelopoulos, V., Kennel, C. F., Coroniti, F. V., Pellat, R., Kivelson, M. G., Walker, R. J., Russell, C. T., Baumjohann, W., Feldman, W. C. and Gosling, J. T.: 1994, ‘Statistical Characteristics of Bursty Bulk Flow Events’ J. Geophys. Res. 99, 21257.Google Scholar
  7. Angelopoulos, V., Phan, T. D., Larson, D. E., Mozer, F. S., Lin, R. P., Tsuruda, K., Hayakawa, H., Mukai, T., Kokubun, S., Yamamoto, T., Williams, D. J., McEntire, R. W., Lepping, R. P., Parks, G. K., Brittnacher, M., Germany, G., Spann, J., Singer, H. J. and Yumoto, K.: 1997, ‘Magnetotail Flow Bursts: Association to Global Magnetospheric Circulation, Relationship to Ionospheric Activity and Direct Evidence for Localization’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 24, 2271.Google Scholar
  8. Axford, W. I.: 1994, ‘The Good Old Days’ J. Geophys. Res. 99, 19199.Google Scholar
  9. Bak, P., Tang, C. and Wiesenfeld, K.: 1987, ‘Self-Organized Criticality:An Explanation of 1/f Noise’ Phys. Rev. Lett. 59, 381.Google Scholar
  10. Baker, D. N., Pulkkinen, T. I., Büchner, J. and Klimas, A. J.: 1999, ‘Substorms: A Global Instability of the Magnetosphere-Ionosphere System’ J. Geophys. Res. 104, 14601.Google Scholar
  11. Baumjohann, W., Paschmann, G. and Luhr, H.: 1990, ‘Characteristics of High-Speed Ion Flows in the Plasma Sheet’ J. Geophys. Res. 95, 3801.Google Scholar
  12. de la Beaujardiere, O., Lyons, L. R., Ruohoniemi, J. M., Friis-Christensen, E., Danielson, C., Rich, F. R. and Newell, P. T.: 1994, ‘Quiet-Time Intensifications Along the Poleward Auroral Boundary Near Midnight’ J. Geophys. Res. 99, 287.Google Scholar
  13. Bhattacharjee, A., Ma, Z. W. and Wang, X.: 1998, ‘Ballooning Instability of a Thin Current Sheet in the High-Lundquist Number Magnetotail’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 25, 861.Google Scholar
  14. Brittnacher, M., Quest, K. B. and Karimabadi, H.: 1998, ‘A Study of the Effect of Pitch Angle and Spatial Diffusion on Tearing Instability Using a New Finite Element Based Linear Code’ J. Geophys. Res. 103, 4587.Google Scholar
  15. Chapman, S. C., Watkins, N. W., Dendy, R. O., Helander, P. and Rowlands, G.: 1998, ‘A Simple Avalanche Model as an Analogue for Magnetospheric Activity’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 25, 2397.Google Scholar
  16. Chang, T. S. C.: 1992, ‘Low Dimensional Behavior and Symmetry Breaking of Stochastic Systems Near Criticality — Can These Effects be Observed in Space and in the Laboratory?’ IEEE Trans. Plasma Sci. 20, 691.Google Scholar
  17. Chang, T. S. C.: 1998, in J. L. Horwitz, D. L. Gallagher, and W. K. Peterson (eds), ‘Sporadic Localized Reconnection and Multiscale Intermittent Turbulence in the Magnetotail, in Encounter Between Global Observations and Models in the ISTP era’ AGU, Washington, D. C., P. 193.Google Scholar
  18. Chang, T.: 1999, ‘Self-Organized Criticality, Multi-Fractal Spectra, Sporadic Localized Reconnections and Intermittent Turbulence in the Magnetotail’ Phys. Plasmas 6, 4137.Google Scholar
  19. Cheng, C. Z. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1998, ‘Kinetic Ballooning Instability for Substorm Onset and Current Disruption Observed by AMPTE/CCE’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 25, 4091.Google Scholar
  20. Consolini, G.: in Aiello, et al. (eds), 1997, ‘Sandpile Cellular Automata and Magnetospheric Dynamics’ Proceedings of Cosmic Physics in the Year 2000, Vol. 58, SIF, Bologna, Italy, P. 123.Google Scholar
  21. Consolini, G. and Michelis, P. D.: 1998, ‘Non-Gaussian Distribution Function of AE-Index Fluctuations: Evidence for Time Intermittency’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 25, 4087.Google Scholar
  22. Consolini, G. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1999, ‘Sign-Singularity Analysis of Current Disruption’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 26, 1673.Google Scholar
  23. Dendy, R. O. and Helander, P.: 1998, ‘On the Appearance and Non-Appearance of Self-Organized Criticality in Sandpiles’ Phys. Rev. E57, 3641.Google Scholar
  24. Dungey, J. W.: 1961, ‘Interplanetary Magnetic Field and the Auroral Zones’ Phys. Rev. Lett. 6 (2), 47.Google Scholar
  25. Erickson, G. M.: 1995, ‘Substorm Theories: United They Stand, Divided They Fall’ Rev. Geophys. 33, 685.Google Scholar
  26. Frank, L. A., Sigwarth, J. B. and Paterson, W. R.: 1998, in S. Kokubun and Y. Kamide (eds.), ‘High-Resolution Global Images of Earth's Auroras During Substorms’ Substorms-4, Terra Scientific Publishing Co., Tokyo, Japan, P. 3.Google Scholar
  27. Gold, T.: 1959, ‘Motions in the Magnetosphere of the Earth’ J. Geophys. Res. 64, 1219.Google Scholar
  28. Hones, E.W., Jr.: 1973, ‘Plasma Flow in the Plasma Sheet and its Relation to Substorms’ Radio Sci. 8, 979.Google Scholar
  29. Hoyle, F.: 1958, Recent Researches in Solar Physics, Cambridge University Press, New York, Sec. 27.Google Scholar
  30. Huba, J. D., Gladd, N. T. and Papadopoulos, K.: 1977, ‘The Lower-Hybrid-Drift Instability as a Source of Anomalous Resistivity for Magnetic Field Line Reconnection’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 4, 125.Google Scholar
  31. Jacquey, C., Sauvaud, J. A., Dandouras, J. and Korth, A.: 1993, ‘Tailward Propagating Cross-Tail Current Disruption and Dynamics of Near-Earth Tail: A Multi-Point Measurement Analysis’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 20, 983.Google Scholar
  32. Ji, H., Yamada, M., Hsu, S. and Kulsrud, R.: 1998, ‘Experimental Test of the Sweet-Parker Model of Magnetic Reconnection’ Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 3256.Google Scholar
  33. Krimigis, S.M. and Sarris, E. T.: 1979, in S.-I. Akasofu (ed.), ‘Energetic Particle Bursts in the Earth's Magnetotail’ Dynamics of the Magnetosphere, P. 599. AUTHOR, PUBLISHER AND TOWN PLEASEGoogle Scholar
  34. Kropotkin, A. P., Trubachev, O. O. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1999, ‘Nonlinear Instability of the Geomagnetotail Current Sheet Combining the Features of Tearing and Cross-Field Current Instabilities’ J. Geophys. Res. 104, 371.Google Scholar
  35. Liou, K., Meng, C.-I., Lui, A. T. Y., Newell, P. T., Brittnacher, M., Parks, G., Reeves, G. D., Anderson, R. R. and Yumoto, K.: 1999, ‘On Relative Timing in Substorm Onset Signatures’ J. Geophys. Res. 104, 22807.Google Scholar
  36. Lui, A. T. Y.: 1979, in S.-I. Akasofu (ed.), ‘Observations on Plasma Sheet Dynamics During Magnetospheric Substorms’ Dynamics of the Magnetosphere, P. 563.Google Scholar
  37. Lui, A. T. Y.: 1991a, ‘A Synthesis of Magnetospheric Substorm Models’ J. Geophys. Res. 96, 1849.Google Scholar
  38. Lui, A. T. Y.: 1991b, in G. R. Wilson (ed.), ‘Plasma Transport in the Earth's Magnetotail’ Modeling Magnetospheric Plasma Processes, p. 41.Google Scholar
  39. Lui, A. T. Y.: 1996, ‘Current Disruption in the Earth's Magnetosphere: Observations and Models’ J. Geophys. Res. 101, 13067.Google Scholar
  40. Lui, A. T. Y.: 1998, ‘Multiscale and Intermittent Nature of Current Disruption in the Magnetotail’ Physics Space Plasmas 15, 233.Google Scholar
  41. Lui, A. T. Y.: 1999, ‘Particle Acceleration in Disruption of the Tail Current Sheet’ Physics Chem. Earth 24, 259.Google Scholar
  42. Lui, A. T. Y. and Meng, C.-I.: 1979, ‘Relevance of Southward Magnetic Fields in the Neutral Sheet to Anisotropic Distribution of Energetic Electrons and Substorm Activity’ AJ. Geophys. Res. 84, 5817.Google Scholar
  43. Lui, A. T. Y. and Murphree, J. S.: 1998, ‘A Substorm Model with Onset Location Tied to an Auroral Arc’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 25, 1269.Google Scholar
  44. Lui, A. T. Y., Meng, C.-I. and Akasofu, S.-I.: 1976, ‘Search for the Magnetic Neutral Line in the Near-Earth Plasma Sheet, l. Critical Re-Examination of Earlier Studies of Magnetic Field Observations’ J. Geophys. Res. 81, 5934.Google Scholar
  45. Lui, A. T. Y., Frank, L. A., Ackerson, K. L., Meng, C.-I. and Akasofu, S.-I.: 1977, ‘Systematic Study of Plasma Flow During Plasma Sheet Thinnings’ J. Geophys. Res. 82, 4815.Google Scholar
  46. Lui, A. T. Y., Lopez, R. E., Krimigis, S. M., McEntire, R.W., Zanetti, L. J. and Potemra, T. A.: 1988, ‘A Case Study of Magnetotail Current Sheet Disruption and Diversion’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 15, 721.Google Scholar
  47. Lui, A. T. Y., Chang, C.-L., Mankofsky, A., Wong, H.-K. and Winske, D.: 1991, ‘A Cross-Field Current Instability for Substorm Expansions’ J. Geophys. Res. 96, 11389.Google Scholar
  48. Lui, A. T. Y., Yoon, P. H. and Chang, C.-L.: 1993, ‘Quasi-Linear Analysis of Ion Weibel Instability in the Earth's Neutral Sheet’ J. Geophys. Res. 98, 153.Google Scholar
  49. Lui, A. T. Y., Liou, K., Newell, P. T., Meng, C.-I., Ohtani, S.-I., Kokubun, S., Ogino, T., Brittnacher, M. and Parks, G.: 1998, ‘Plasma and Magnetic Flux Transport Associated with Auroral Breakups’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 25, 4059.Google Scholar
  50. Lui, A. T. Y., Chapman, S. C., Liou, K., Newell, P. T., Meng, C.-I., Brittnacher, M. and Parks, G. K.: 2000, ‘Is the Dynamic Magnetosphere an Avalanching System?’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 27, 911.Google Scholar
  51. Lundin, R.: 1997, ‘Discussion 1: On Merging and Reconnection’ Phys. Chem. Earth 22, 605.Google Scholar
  52. Lyons, L. R. and Pridmore-Brown, D. C.: 1990, ‘Force Balance Near an X Line in a Collisionless Plasma’ J. Geophys. Res. 95, 20903.Google Scholar
  53. Maynard, N. C., Burke, W. J., Basinska, E. M., Erickson, G. M., Hughes, W. J., Singer, H. J., Yahnin, A. G., Hardy, D. A. and Mozer, F. S.: 1996, ‘Dynamics of the Inner Magnetosphere Nnear Times of Substorm Onsets’ J. Geophys. Res. 101, 7705.Google Scholar
  54. Mauk, B. H.: 1986, ‘Quantitative Modeling of the Convection Surge Mechanism of Ion Acceleration’ J. Geophys. Res. 91, 13423.Google Scholar
  55. Nagai, T., Fujimoto, M., Saito, Y., Machida, S., Terasawa, T., Nakamura, R., Yamamoto, T., Mukai, T., Nishida, A. and Kokubun, S.: 1998, ‘Structure and Dynamics of Magnetic Reconnection for Substorm Onsets with Geotail Observations’ J. Geophys. Res. 103, 4419.Google Scholar
  56. Nishida, A. and Nagayama, N.: 1973, ‘Synoptic Survey for the Neutral Line in the Magnetotail During the Substorm Expansion Phase’ J. Geophys. Res. 78, 3782.Google Scholar
  57. Nishida, A. and Hones, E. W., Jr.: 1974, ‘Association of Plasma Sheet Thinning With Neutral Line Formation in the Magnetotail’ J. Geophys. Res. 79, 535.Google Scholar
  58. Ohtani, S., Takahashi, S. K., Zanetti, L. J., Potemra, T. A., McEntire, R.W. and Iijima, T: 1992a, ‘Initial Signatures ofMagnetic Field and Energetic Particle Fluxes at Tail Reconfiguration: Explosive Growth Phase’ J. Geophys. Res. 97, 19311.Google Scholar
  59. Ohtani, S., Takahashi, K. and Russell, C. T.: 1992b, ‘Radial Expansion of the Tail Current Disruption During Substorms: A New Approach to Substorm Onset Region’ J. Geophys. Res. 97, 3129.Google Scholar
  60. Ohtani, S., Anderson, B. J., Sibeck, D. G., Newell, P. T., Zanetti, L. J., Potemra, T. A., Takahashi, K., Lopez, R. E., Angelopoulos, V., Nakamura, R., Klumpar, D. M. and Russell, C. T.: 1993, ‘A Multisatellite Study of a Pseudo-Substorm Onset in the Near-Earth Magnetotail’ J. Geophys. Res. 98, 19355.Google Scholar
  61. Parker, E. N.: 1996, ‘The Alternative Paradigm for Magnetospheric Physics’ J. Geophys. Res. 101, 10587.Google Scholar
  62. Pellat, R., Coroniti, F. V. and Pritchett, P. L.: 1991, ‘Does Ion Tearing Exist?’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 18, 143.Google Scholar
  63. Petrukovich, A. A., Sergeev, V. A., Zelenyi, L. M., Mukai, T., Yamamoto, T., Kokubun, S., Shiokawa, K., Deehr, C. S., Budnick, E. Y., Büchner, J., Federov, A. O., Grigorieva, V. P., Hughes, T. J., Pissarenko, N. F., Romanov, A. A. and Sandahl, I.: 1998, ‘Two Spacecraft Observations of a Reconnection Pulse During an Auroral Breakup’ J. Geophys. Res. 103, 47.Google Scholar
  64. Petschek, H. E.: 1964, ‘Magnetic Field Annihilation’ AAS-NASA Symposium on the Physics of Solar Flares, NASA Spec. Publ. SP-50, p. 425.Google Scholar
  65. Roux, A., Perraut, S., Robert, P., Morane, A., Pedersen, A., Korth, A., Kremser, G., Aparicio, B., Rodgers, D. and Pellinen, R.: 1991, ‘Plasma Sheet Instability Related to the Westward Traveling Surge’ J. Geophys. Res. 96, 17697.Google Scholar
  66. Samson, J. C., Wallis, D. D., Hughes, T. J., Creutzberg, F., Ruohoniemi, J. M. and Greenwald, R. A.: 1992, ‘Substorm Intensifications and Field Line Resonances in the Nightside Magnetosphere’ J. Geophys. Res. 97, 8495.Google Scholar
  67. Sergeev, V., Bosinger, T. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1986, ‘Impulsive Processes in the Magnetotail During Substorm Expansion’ J. Geophys. 60, 175.Google Scholar
  68. Sergeev, V. A., Angelopoulos, V., Mitchell, E. G. and Russell, C. T.: 1998, ‘In situ Observations of Magnetotail Reconnection Prior to the Onset of a Small Substorm’ J. Geophys. Res. 103, 19121.Google Scholar
  69. Shay, M. A., Drake, J. F., Denton, R. E. and Biskamp, D.: 1998, ‘Structure of the Dissipation Region During Collisionless Magnetic Reconnection’ J. Geophys. Res. 103, 9165.Google Scholar
  70. Sitnov, M. I. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1999, ‘Cross-Field Current Instability as a Catalyst of the Explosive Reconnection in the Geomagnetotail’ J. Geophys. Res. 104, 6941.Google Scholar
  71. Sitnov, M. I., Malova, H. V. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1997, ‘Quasineutral Sheet Filamentation Instability Induced by Electron Preferential Acceleration from Stochasticity’ J. Geophys. Res. 102, 163.Google Scholar
  72. Takahashi, K., Zanetti, L. J., Lopez, R. E., McEntire, R. E., Potemra, T. A. and Yumoto, K.: 1987, ‘Disruption of the Magnetotail Current Sheet Observed by AMPTE/CCE’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 14, 1019.Google Scholar
  73. Ugai, M.: 1994, ‘Computer Studies on the Fast ReconnectionMechanism Under an Externally Driven Boundary Condition’ Phys. Plasmas 1, 1070.Google Scholar
  74. Ugai, M.: 1998, in S. Kokubun and Y. Kamide (eds), ‘What is the Basic Physical Mechanism of Fast Reconnection Development Responsible for Substorms?’ Substorms-4, Terra Scientific Publishing Co., Tokyo, Japan, P. 449.Google Scholar
  75. Vassiliadis, D. V., Sharma, A. S., Eastman, T. E. and Papadopoulos, K.: 1990, ‘Low-Dimensional Chaos in Magnetospheric Activity from AE Time Series’ Geophys. Res. Lett. 17, 1841.Google Scholar
  76. Vasyliunas, V. M.: 1996, in T. Chang and J. R. Jasperse (eds), ‘Time Scale for Magnetic Field Changes After Substorm Onset: Constraints From Dimensional Analysis’ Physics of Space Plasmas, MIT Center for Geo/Cosmo Plasma Physics, Cambridge, MA, P. 553.Google Scholar
  77. Vasyliunas, V. M.: 1998, in S. Kokubun and Y. Kamide (eds), ‘Fundamentals of Current Description’ Substorms-4, Terra Scientific Publishing Co., Tokyo, Japan, p. 9.Google Scholar
  78. Wiechen, H., Büchner, J. and Otto, A.: 1996, ‘Reconnection in the Near-Earth Plasma Sheet: A Three-Dimensional Model’ J. Geophys. Res. 101, 24911.Google Scholar
  79. Wiens, R. G. and Rostoker, G.: 1975, ‘Characteristics of the Development of theWestward Electrojet During the Expansive Phase of Magnetospheric Substorms’ J. Geophys. Res. 80, 2109.Google Scholar
  80. Winglee, R. M., Lui, A. T. Y., Lin, R. P., Lepping, R. P., Kokubun, S., Rostoker, G. and Samson, J. C.: 1998, in J. L. Horwitz, D. L. Gallagher, and W. K. Peterson (eds), ‘Magnetospheric-Ionospheric Activity During an Isolated Substorm: A Comparison Between WIND/Geotail/CANOPUS Observations andModeling’ Geospace Mass and Energy Flow, AGU Geophys.Monogr. Ser.,AGU, Washington, D. C., p. 181.Google Scholar
  81. Yamada, M., Ji, H., Hsu, S., Carter, T., Kulsrud, R., Bretz, N., Jobes, F., Ono, Y. and Perkins, F.: 1997, ‘Study of Driven Magnetic Reconnection in a Laboratory Plasma’ Phys. Plasmas 4 (5), 1936.Google Scholar
  82. Yamauchi, M. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1997, ‘Modified MHD Waves in a Current Sheet in Space’ Physics of Plasmas 4, 4382.Google Scholar
  83. Yoon, P. H. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1993, ‘Nonlinear Analysis of Generalized Cross-Field Current Instability’ Phys. Fluids B5 (3), 836.Google Scholar
  84. Yoon, P. H. and Lui, A. T. Y.: 1998, in S. Kokubun and Y. Kamide (eds), ‘Cross-Field Current Instability and Substorm Expansion Onset’ Substorms-4, Terra Scientific Publishing Co., Tokyo, Japan, p. 387.Google Scholar
  85. Zelenyi, L. M., Petrukovich, A. A., Budnick, E. Y., Romanov, S. A. Sergeev, V. A., Mukai, T., Yamamoto, T., Kokubun, S., Shiokawa, K., Deehr, C. S., Büchner, J. and Sandahl, I.: 1998, in S. Kokubun and Y. Kamide (eds), ‘Substorm Onset Models and Observations’ Substorms-4, Terra Scientific Publishing Co., Tokyo, Japan, p. 327.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Kluwer Academic Publishers 2001

Authors and Affiliations

  • A.T.Y. Lui
    • 1
  1. 1.U.S.A

Personalised recommendations