# Beyond mere knowledge of mathematics: The importance of knowing-to act in the moment

## Abstract

*Knowing-to* is active knowledge which is present in the moment when it is required. To try to produce knowing-to, formal education focuses on forms of knowing which are easier to teach and to test: knowing-that (factual), knowing-how (technique and skills), and knowing-why (having a story in order to structure actions and from which to reconstruct actions). Together these constitute knowing-about the subject. Expertise is demonstrated by being able to respond to assessments: to write essays and to solve routine problems. The central problem of education is that knowing-about does not in itself guarantee knowing-to, as teachers have attested throughout the ages. For example, Edward Fitzgerald (Harrison, 1937) captures it beautifully in one stanza of his purported translation of the Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam:

Myself when young did eagerly frequent,

Doctor and Saint and heard great argument,

About it and about: but ever more Came out by the same door as in I went (p. 341).

Instead of trying to reach definitions, we illustrate distinctions amongst kinds of *knowing* as used by various authors in the past. Then we turn to our own experience, for it is in one's own experience that one can locate and enliven sources of metaphoric resonances and metonymic triggers which constitute understanding. Drawing on our experience we distinguish knowing-to from other forms of knowing, and explore implications of that distinction for teaching and learning mathematics. We propose that *knowing-to* act in the moment depends on the structure of attention in the moment, depends on what one is aware of. Educating this awareness is most effectively done by labelling experiences in which powers have been exhibited, and developing a rich network of connections and triggers so that actions ‘come to mind’. No-one can act if they are unaware of a possibility to act; no-one can act unless they have an act to perform.

## Keywords

Formal Education Central Problem Learning Mathematic Labelling Experience Active Knowledge## Preview

Unable to display preview. Download preview PDF.

## References

- Bauersfeld, H.: 1993, 'Theoretical perspectives on interaction in the mathematics classroom', in R. Biehler, R. Scholz, R. Sträßer and B. Winkelmann (eds.),
*The Didactics of Mathematics as a Scientific Discipline*, Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.Google Scholar - Bereiter, C. and Scardammalia, M.: 1989,
*Knowing Learning and Instruction: Essays in Honor of Robert Glaser*, Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale.Google Scholar - Biggs, J.: 1994, 'Modes of learning, forms of knowing, and ways of schooling', in A. Demetriou, M. Shayer and A. Efklides (eds.),
*Neo-Piagetian Theories of Cognitive Development*, Routledge, London, pp. 31–51.Google Scholar - Brousseau, G.: 1984, 'The crucial role of the didactical contract in the analysis and construction of situations in teaching and learning mathematics', in H. Steiner (ed.),
*Theory of Mathematics Education*, Paper 54, Institut fur Didaktik der Mathematik der Universität Bielefeld, pp. 110–119.Google Scholar - Brousseau, G.: 1997,
*Theory of Didactical Situations in Mathematics: Didactiques des Mathématiques, 1970–1990*, (translated by N. Balacheff, M. Cooper, R. Sutherland, V. Warfield), Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.Google Scholar - Brown, J., Collins, A. and Duguid, P.: 1989, 'Situated cognition and the culture of learning',
*Educational Researcher*18(1), 32–41.Google Scholar - Brown, M.: 1981, 'Is it an add, or a multiply, Miss?' (part 3),
*Mathematics in Schools*10(1), 26–28.Google Scholar - Bruner, J.: 1966,
*Towards a Theory of Instruction*, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar - Burton, L.: 1995, 'Moving towards a feminist epistemology of mathematics',
*Educational Studies in Mathematics*28(3), 275–291.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Burton, L. (ed.): (in press),
*Learning Mathematics: From Hierarchies to Networks*, Falmer Press, London.Google Scholar - Chevellard, Y.: 1985,
*La Transposition Didactique,*La Pensée Sauvage, Grenoble.Google Scholar - Clancey, W.: 1993, 'Situated Action: a neuropsychological interpretation response to Vera & Simon',
*Cognitive Science*17, 87–116.Google Scholar - Collins, A., Brown, J. and Newman, S.: 1989, 'Cognitive apprenticeship: teaching the crafts of reading, writing, and mathematics', in L. Resnick (ed.),
*Knowing, Learning, and Instruction: essays in honor of Robert Glaser,*Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, pp. 453–494.Google Scholar - Davidov, D.: 1990, 'Types of Generalisation in Instruction',
*Soviet Studies in Mathematics Education*Vol. 2, NCTM, Reston.Google Scholar - Detterman D. and Sternberg, R. (eds.): 1993,
*Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition, and Instruction*, Ablex, Norwood N.J.Google Scholar - De Jong, T. and Ferguson-Hessler, M.: 1996, 'Types and qualities of knowledge',
*Educational Psychologist*31(2), 105–113.Google Scholar - Dewey, J.: 1902,
*The Child and the Curriculum*, U of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar - Dubinsky E. and Levin P.: 1986, 'Reflective abstraction and mathematics education: the genetic decomposition of induction and compactness',
*Journal of Mathematical Behaviour*5, 55–92.Google Scholar - Fennema, E. and Franke, M.: 1992, 'Teachers' knowledge and its impact', in D. Grouws (ed.),
*Handbook of Research on Mathematics Teaching,*MacMillan, New York, pp. 147–164.Google Scholar - Frayn, M.: 1998,
*Copenhagen*, Methuen Drama, Methuen, London.Google Scholar - Gates, P.: 1993, '“I just didn't think of it”: learning to teach mathematics',
*Proceedings of the British Society for Research in Learning Mathematics Meeting May 22*, pp. 29–34.Google Scholar - Gattegno, C.: 1987,
*The Science of Education Part I: Theoretical Considerations*, Educational Solutions, New York.Google Scholar - Greeno, J. Smith, D. and Moore, J.: 1993, 'Transfer of situated learning', in D. Detterman and R. Sternberg (eds.),
*Transfer on Trial: Intelligence, Cognition, and Instruction*, Abbex, Norwood, NJ, pp. 99–167.Google Scholar - Harrison, G. (ed.): 1937,
*A Book of English Poetry*, Penguin, Harmondsworth.Google Scholar - Hewitt, D.: 1994,
*The Principle of Economy in the Learning and Teaching of Mathematics*, unpublished PhD dissertation, Open University, Milton Keynes.Google Scholar - Hiebert, J. and Carpenter, T.: 1992, 'Learning and teaching with understanding', in D. Grouws (ed.),
*Handbook of Research on Mathematics Teaching and Learning*, MacMillan, New York, pp. 65–93.Google Scholar - Hofer, B. and Pintrich, P.: 1997, 'The development of epistemological theories: beliefs about knowledge and knowing and their relation to learning',
*Review Of Educational research*67(1), 88–140.Google Scholar - Honderich, T.: 1995,
*The Oxford Companion to Philosophy*, Oxford University Press, Oxford.Google Scholar - Hoyles, C.: 1998, 'A culture of proving in school maths?', in D. Tinsley and D. Johnson (eds.),
*Information and Communications Technologies in School Mathematics*, Chapman & Hall, London, pp. 169–182.Google Scholar - Kang, W. and Kilpatrick, J.: 1992, 'Didactic transposition in mathematics textbooks',
*For The Learning of Mathematics*12(1), 2–7.Google Scholar - Kieren, T.: 1994, 'Bonuses of understanding mathematical understanding', in D. Robitaille, D. Wheeler and C. Kieran (eds.),
*Selected Lectures from the 7th International Congress on Mathematical Education*, Les Presses de l'Université Laval, Quebec, pp. 211–228.Google Scholar - Krutetskii, V.: 1976,
*The Psychology of Mathematical Abilities in Schoolchildren*, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.Google Scholar - Lacan, J.: 1985, 'Sign, symbol and imagery', in Blonsky (ed.),
*On Signs*, Blackwell, Oxford.Google Scholar - Lave, J.: 1988,
*Cognition in Practice: Mind, Mathematics and Culture in Everyday Life*, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar - Locke, J.: 1894, (Dover reprint 1959):
*An Essay Concerning Human Understanding*, 2 Vols, Dover, London.Google Scholar - Marton, F. and Fazey, J.: (preprint),
*Understanding as Space of Experienced Variation*.Google Scholar - Mason, J., Burton, L. and Stacey, K.: 1982,
*Thinking Mathematically*, Addison Wesley, London.Google Scholar - Mason, J. and Davis, J.: 1988, 'Cognitive and metacognitive shifts',
*PME XII*, (ed. Borbás) Vol. 2, pp. 487–494.Google Scholar - Mason, J. and Davis, J.: 1989, 'The inner teacher, the didactic tension, and shifts of attention', in G. Vergnaud, M. Rogalski and M. Artigue (eds.),
*Proceedings of PME XIII*, Paris, Vol. 2, pp. 274–281.Google Scholar - Mason, J. and Spence, M.: 1998, 'Towards a psychology of knowing-to', in C. Kane, M. Goos and E. Warren (eds.),
*Proceedings of MERGA*21, Coolangatta, New South Wales, Australia.Google Scholar - Mason, J.: 1989, 'Mathematical abstraction seen as a delicate shift of attention',
*For the Learning of Mathematics*9(2). 2–8.Google Scholar - Mason, J.: 1993, 'Working on awareness', in J. Searl (ed.),
*Proceedings of the Edinburgh Mathematics Teaching Conference*, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.Google Scholar - Mason, J.: 1996,
*Personal Enquiry: Moving from Concern towards Research*, Open University, Milton Keynes.Google Scholar - Mason, J.: 1998, 'Structure of attention in teaching mathematics, Plenary address to Canadian Mathematics Education Study Group 15th meeting, May', in Y. Pothier (ed.),
*Proceedings of cmESG 15*, in preparation.Google Scholar - Maturana, H. and Varela, F.: 1972, 'Autopoesis and cognition: the realization of the living', D. Reidel, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.Google Scholar
- Maturana, H. and Varela, F.: 1988,
*The Tree of Knowledge: the Biological Roots of Human Understanding*, Shambala, Boston.Google Scholar - Maturana, H.: 1988, 'Reality: the search for objectivity or the quest for a compelling argument',
*Irish Journal of Psychology*9(1), 25–82.Google Scholar - McGowen, M.: 1998, 'Cognitive units, concept images, and cognitive collages', Unpublished PhD thesis, Warwick University, Coventry.Google Scholar
- Michener, E.: 1978, 'Understanding understanding mathematics',
*Cognitive Science*2, 361–383.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Miller, L., Malone, J. and Kandl, T.: 1992, 'A study of secondary teachers' perceptions of the meaning of understanding',
*AERA paper*, San Francisco.Google Scholar - Northfield, J. and Baird, J.: 1992,
*Learning from the PEEL Experience*, Monash University Printing Service, Melbourne.Google Scholar - Noss, R. and Hoyles, C.: 1996,
*Windows on Mathematical Meanings,*Mathematics Education Library, Kluwer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands.Google Scholar - Perry, W.: 1968,
*Forms of Intellectual and Ethical Development in the College Years: a scheme*, Holt, Rhinehart & Winston, New York.Google Scholar - Piaget, J.: 1950, 'Introduction á l'epistemologie genetique', presses Univ. de France, Paris.Google Scholar
- Piaget, J.: 1977,
*The Development of Thought: Equilibration of Cognitive Structures*, (translated by A. Rosin), Harvard University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar - Pimm, D.: 1987,
*Speaking Mathematically*, Hodder & Stoughton, London.Google Scholar - Pirie, S. and Kieren, T.: 1994, 1Growth in mathematical understanding: how can we characterise it and how can we represent it?',
*Educational Studies in Mathematics*26(2–3), 165–190.CrossRefGoogle Scholar - Polya, G.: 1945,
*How To Solve It*, Princeton University Press, Cambridge.Google Scholar - Polya, G.: 1962,
*Mathematical Discovery: On Understanding, Learning, and Teaching Problem Solving*, Combined edition, Wiley, New York.Google Scholar - Reid, B.: 1980,
*The Haida Legend of The Raven and The First Humans*, Museum Note No. 8, U. B. C. Museum of Anthropology, Vancouver.Google Scholar - Renkl, A., Mandl, H. and Gruber, H.: 1996, 'Inert knowledge: analyses and remedies',
*Educational Psychologist*31(2), 115–121.Google Scholar - Russell, B.: 1914,
*Our Knowledge of the External World as a Field for Scientific Mathod in Philosophy*, George Allen & Unwin, London.Google Scholar - Ryle, G.: 1949,
*The Concept of Mind*, Hutchinson, London.Google Scholar - Schoenfeld, A.: 1988, 'When good teaching leads to bad results: The disasters of 'well taught' mathematics classes',
*Educational Psychologist*23, 145–166.Google Scholar - Schön, D.: 1983,
*The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action*, Temple Smith, London.Google Scholar - Schön, D.: 1987,
*Educating the Reflective Practitioner*, Jossey-Bass, London.Google Scholar - Shah, I.: 1968,
*The Way of the Sufi*, Jonathon Cape, London.Google Scholar - Shulman, L.: 1987, 'Knowledge and teaching: Foundations of the new reform',
*Harvard Educational Review*57(1), 1–22.Google Scholar - Sierpinska, A.: 1994,
*Understanding in Mathematics*, Falmer Press, London.Google Scholar - Skemp, R.: 1979,
*Intelligence, Learning and Action*, Wiley, Chichester.Google Scholar - Spence, M.: 1996, 'Psychologising algebra: case studies of knowing in the moment', unpublished PhD thesis, Madison Wisconsin.Google Scholar
- Tahta, D.: 1972,
*A Boolean Anthology: Selected Writings of Mary Boole on Mathematics Education*, Association of Teachers of Mathematics, Derby.Google Scholar - van Hiele, P.: 1986,
*Structure and Insight: A Theory of Mathematics Education*, Academic Press, Orlando.Google Scholar - Vergnaud, G.: 1981, 'Quelques orientations théoriques et méthodologiques des recherches Françaises en didactique des mathématiques',
*Actes duVième Colloque de PME,*Vol. 2, pp. 7–17, Edition IMAG, Grenoble.Google Scholar - Whitehead, A.: 1932,
*The Aims of Education and Other Essays*, Williams & Norgate, London.Google Scholar