# Geomechanical analysis of the stability conditions of shallow cavities for Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES) applications

## Abstract

Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES) systems compress air into underground cavities when there is an excess of energy production (e.g., in the electrical grid or in an electrical plant) and generate electrical energy using a turbine when the electricity demand exceeds the production. Underground air storage requires construction of new underground cavities or reconditioning of existing underground openings. This paper presents a study of geomechanical stability of shallow circular cavities carried out as part of a multidisciplinary project that investigated the feasibility of using existing underground mining works (drifts and shafts) from iron mining works dating back from the first half of the twentieth century in northern Minnesota (USA). The paper addresses the fundamental problem of establishing the stability conditions of shallow cylindrical or spherical openings excavated in cohesive ground, and subjected to either decreasing or increasing internal pressure, associated with the process of contraction or expansion of the cavities during operation of a CAES system. A statically admissible analytical model for a shallow circular opening in cohesive ground derived from the limit analysis lower bound theorem is presented, and key dimensionless groups of variables controlling the stability of the cavity, defined in terms of a scalar factor of safety, are identified. The analytical model allows several observations of practical interest to be made with regard to the stability of shallow cavities. Numerical finite-difference models are used to validate the various observations and to quantify the underestimation of factors of safety obtained with the proposed lower bound solution. The paper also presents a critical evaluation of limit equilibrium (Terzaghi’s type) models that are traditionally used to design cavities for gas and air storage. Comparisons of results obtained with existing limit equilibrium models, with the proposed analytical model and with numerical models, show that limit equilibrium models can lead to both over conservative (i.e., too safe or uneconomical) and to nonconservative (i.e., unsafe) cavity designs depending on the ranges of values considered for the dimensionless groups of variables governing the problem. Finally, the effect of various parameters such as water in the ground, frictional strength and others, on the stability of the cavity are discussed.

## Keywords

CAES Shallow cavities Stability Factor of safety Limit analysis Limit equilibrium## References

- Abramson LW, Thomas SL, Sharma S, Boyce GM (2002) Slope stability and stabilization methods, 2nd edn. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Addison WD, Brumpton GR, Vallini DA, McNaughton NJ, Davis DW, Kissin SA, F PW, Hammond AL (2005) Discovery of distal ejecta from the 1850 Ma Sudbury impact event. Geology 33–3:193–196CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Atkinson JH, Potts D (1977) Stability of a shallow circular tunnel in cohesionless soil. Geotechnique 27:203–215CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Bauer SJ, Gaither KN, Webb SW, Nelson C (2012) Compressed air energy storage in hard rock. Feasibility study. Technical report SAND2012-0540. Sandia National LaboratoriesGoogle Scholar
- Bell J (1966) Dimensionless parameters for homogeneous earth slopes. ASCE SM J Soil Mech Found Div 5:51–65Google Scholar
- Blindheim OT, Broch E, Grøv E (2004) Gas storage in unlined caverns. Norwegian experience over 25 years. In: Tunnelling and underground space technology. Underground space for sustainable urban development. Proceedings of the 30th ITA-AITES World Tunnel Congress, Singapore, 22–27 May 2004Google Scholar
- Brady BHG, Brown ET (2004) Rock mechanics for underground mining. Kluwer Academic Publishers, DordrechtGoogle Scholar
- Caquot A (1934) Équilibre des massifs a frottement interne. Gaunthier-Villars, ParisGoogle Scholar
- Carranza-Torres C (2004) Report to Geodata S.p.A., Turin, Italy: computation of factor of safety for shallow tunnels using Caquot’s lower bound solution. Technical report. Itasca Consulting Group. MinneapolisGoogle Scholar
- Carranza-Torres C, Fairhurst C (1999) The elasto-plastic response of underground excavations in rock masses that satisfy the Hoek–Brown failure criterion. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 36:777–809Google Scholar
- Carranza-Torres C, Reich T, Saftner D (2013) Stability of shallow circular tunnels in soils using analytical and numerical models. In: Labuz J, Bentler J (eds) Proceedings of the 61st anunual geotechnical engineering conference. MinnesotaGoogle Scholar
- Carranza-Torres C, Fosnacht D, Hudak GJ (2016) Analytical and numerical study of the stability of shallow underground openings for mining and compressed air energy storage applications. In: Ranjith PG, Zhao J (eds) Keynote Lecture. Proceedings of the IC3G international conference on geomechanics, geoenergy and georesources. September 28–29, 2016, Monash University. Melbourne. Australia. www.d.umn.edu/~carranza/IC3G
- Cavallo A (2007) Controllable and affordable utility-scale electricity from intermittent wind resources and compressed air energy storage (CAES). Energy 32:120–127CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Coduto DP, Yeung MC, Kitch WA (2011) Geotechnical engineering. Principles and practices, 2nd edn. Pearson, Upper Saddle RiverGoogle Scholar
- Damjanac B, Carranza-Torres C, Dexter R (2002) Technical review of the Lined Rock Cavern (LRC) concept and design methodology: steel liner response. Technical report. Prepared for U.S. Department of Energy National Energy Technology Laboratory Morgantown,West Virginia Under: Prime Contract No. DE-AM26-99FT40463. Subcontract No. 735937-30001-02. Itasca Consulting Group, Inc., Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.SGoogle Scholar
- Davis EH, Gunn MJ, Mair RJ, Seneviratne HN (1980) The stability of shallow tunnels and underground openings in cohesive material. Geotechnique 30:397–416CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Davis RO, Selvadurai APS (2002) Plasticity and geomechanics. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeCrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Dawnson E, Roth W, Drescher A (1999) Slope stability analysis by strength reduction. Geotechnique 49:835–840CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Denholm P, Sioshansi R (2009) The value of compressed air energy storage with wind in transmission-constrained electric power systems. Energy Policy 37–8:3149–3158CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- d’Escatha Y, Mandel J (1971) Profondeur critique d’eboulement d’un souterrain. CR Acad Sci 273:470–473Google Scholar
- d’Escatha Y, Mandel J (1974) Stabilité d’une galerie peu profunde en trerrain meuble. Inustrie Minérale 6:1–9Google Scholar
- Fairhurst C, Carranza-Torres C (2002) Closing the circle. In: Labuz J, Bentler J (eds) Proceedings of the 50th annual geotechnical engineering conference. February 22, 2002, University of Minnesota. http://www.itascacg.com
- Fosnacht DR, PHES Study Team (2011) Pumped hydro energy storage (PHES) using abandoned mine pits on the Mesabi Iron Range of Minnesota. Technical Report NRRI/TR-2011/50. Natural Resources Research Institute, University of Minnesota Duluth. http://www.nrri.umn.edu, see Publications
- Fosnacht DR, Wilson EJ, Marr JD, Carranza-Torres C, Hauck SA, Teasley RL (2015) Compressed air energy storage (CAES) in northern Minnesota using underground mine workings and above ground features. Technical report NRRI/TR-2015/54. Natural Resources Research Institute, University of Minnesota Duluth. http://www.nrri.umn.edu, see Publications
- Goodall DC, Åberg B, Brekke TL (1988) Fundamentals of gas containment in unlined rock caverns. Rock Mech Rock Eng 21:235–258CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Guglielmetti V, Grasso P, Mahtab A, Xu S (2008) Mechanized tunnelling in urban areas. Design methodology and construction control. CRC Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Hammah RE, Yacoub TE, Corkum B, Wibowo F (2007a) Analysis of blocky rock slopes with finite element shear strength reduction analysis. In: Proceedings of the 1st Canada-US rock mechanics symposium. Vancouver Rocks 2007, Vancouver, British ColumbiaGoogle Scholar
- Hammah RE, Yacoub TE, Curran JH (2007b) Serviceability-based slope factor of safety using the shear strength reduction (SSR) method. In: Ribeiro e Sousa L, Olalla C, Grossmann N (eds) Proceedings of the 11th Congress of the International Society for Rock Mechanics, LisbonGoogle Scholar
- Hoek E, Bray J (1981) Rock slope engineering. CRC Press, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Hoek E, Brown ET (1980) Empirical strength criterion for rock masses. J Geotech Eng Div ASCE 106:1013–1035Google Scholar
- Hoek E, Brown ET (1997) Practical estimates of rock mass strength. Int J Rock Mech Min Sci 34:1165–1186CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Hoek E, Carranza-Torres C, Corkum B (2002) Hoek–Brown failure criterion—2002 edition. In: Proceedings of NARMS-TAC 2002. University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada, Mining Innovation and Technology, pp 267–273Google Scholar
- Itasca (2008) FLAC (Fast Lagrangian Analysis of Continua) Version 8.0. Itasca Consulting Group, Inc., Minneapolis, MinnesotaGoogle Scholar
- Jaeger JC, Cook NGW, Zimmerman R (2007) Fundamentals of rock mechanics, 4th edn. Blackwell Publishing, OxfordGoogle Scholar
- Kim HM, Park D, Ryu DW, Song WK (2012) Parametric sensitivity analysis of ground uplift above pressurized underground rock caverns. Eng Geol 135–136:60–65CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Kolymbas D (2005) Tunnelling and tunnel mechanics: a rational approach to tunnelling. Springer, BerlinGoogle Scholar
- Kovári K (1993) Basic consideration on storage of compressed natural gas in rock chambers. Rock Mech Rock Eng 26:1–27CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lamppa M (2004) Iron country: rich ore, rich lives. Lake Superior Port Cities Press, DuluthGoogle Scholar
- Leoni L (1985) Water-filled abandoned mines as heat source for district heating. Undergr Space 9:23–27Google Scholar
- Liang J, Lindblom U (1994) Analyses of gas storage capacity in unlined rock caverns. Rock Mech Rock Eng 27:115–134CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Lodge RWD, Gibson HL, Stott GM, Hudak GJ, Jirsa MA, Hamilton MA (2013) New U-Pb geochronology from Timiskaming-type assemblages in the Shebandowan and Vermilion greenstone belts, Wawa subprovince, Superior Craton: Implications for the Neoarchean development of the southwestern Superior Province. Precambrian Res 235:264–277CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Londe P (1988) Discussion on the paper ‘Determination of the shear stress failure in rock masses’, by Ucar R (Paper 20431), March 1986, Vol 112, No. 3. J Geotech Eng Div ASCE 114-3, 374–376Google Scholar
- Lyamin AV, Sloan SW (2002a) Lower bound limit analysis using non-linear programming. Int J Numer Methods Eng 55:573–611CrossRefzbMATHGoogle Scholar
- Lyamin AV, Sloan SW (2002b) Upper bound limit analysis using linear finite elements and non-linear programming. Int J Numer Anal Methods Geomech 26:181–216CrossRefzbMATHGoogle Scholar
- Mandel J, Habib P, D’Escatha Y, Halpen B, Luong MP, Zarka J (1974) Etude theorique et experimentale de la stabilité des cavités souterraines. In: Symposium franco-polonais de problémes de rhéologie et de mécanique des sols, Nice. pp 255–270Google Scholar
- Marsden R (1968) Geology of the iron ores of the lake superior region in the United States. In: Ridge JD (ed) vol 1. The American Institute of Mining, Metallurgical, and Petroleum Engineers, Inc. pp 490–492Google Scholar
- Michalowski RL (2002) Stability charts for uniform slopes. J Geotech Geoenviron Eng ASCE 128–4:351–355CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- MNDNR-LAM (2011) Underground mine mapping project: a geographic information system of the documented underground mine features on the Mesabi Iron Range. Technical report. Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (MNDNR). Division of Lands and Minerals (LAM). http://www.dnr.state.mn.us/lands_minerals/underground/index.html
- Mühlhaus HB (1985) Lower bound solutions for circular tunnels in two and three dimensions. Rock Mech Rock Eng 18:37–52CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Peele R (1945) Mining engineers handbook, vol 1, 3rd edn. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Peterson D, Gallup C, Jirsa M, Davis DW (2001) Correlation of the Archean assemblages across the US-Canadian border: phase I geochronology. In: 47th Annual meeting. Institute on Lake Superior Geology, Proceedings, pp 77–78Google Scholar
- Pietruszczak S (2010) Fundamentals of plasticity in geomechanics. CRC Press, Boca RatonzbMATHGoogle Scholar
- Plaxis bv (2012) PLAXIS Version 2012. DelftGoogle Scholar
- Potts DM, Zdravkovic L (1999) Finite element analysis in geotechnical engineering: Theory. Thomas Telford, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Proctor RV, White TL (1977) Earth tunnelling with steel supports. Commerical Shearing Inc, YoungstownGoogle Scholar
- Reich T (2016) Application of Caquot’s solution to the analysis of stability of shallow circular cavities in Tresca material. Master’s thesis. University of Minnesota, Duluth Campus, MN, USAGoogle Scholar
- Rocscience (2014) RS2 Version 9. Canada, TorontoGoogle Scholar
- Shidahara T, Oyama T, Nakagawa K (1993) The hydrogeology of granitic rocks in deep boreholes used for compressed air storage. Eng Geol 35:207–213CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Sofregaz US Inc. (1999) Commercial potential of natural gas storage in Lined Rock Caverns (LRC). Technical report. Prepared for the U.S. Department of Energy, Morgantown, WV 101 pGoogle Scholar
- Succar S, Williams RH (2008) Compressed air energy storage: theory, resources and application for wind power. Princeton Environmental Institute, Princeton University, technical report. Prepared by the Energy Systems Analysis GroupGoogle Scholar
- Terzaghi K (1943) Throretical soil mechanics. Wiley, New YorkGoogle Scholar
- Wyllie DC, Mah CW (2004) Rock slope engineering: Civil and mining. Taylor & Francis, LondonGoogle Scholar
- Zaugg P (1975) Air-storage power generating plants. Brown Boveri Rev 62:338–347Google Scholar