Abstract
Plato decided that the poets, that is, all creative writers, should be banned from his ideal state. He objected to the claim that they imparted knowledge to their audiences. The poets gave no explanation of the basis for the stories that they told or the conclusions to which those stories led. Plato denied the validity of any claim to knowledge that was not accompanied by an account that justified the claim. Management scholars make comparable objections to management consultants. They argue that consultants use rhetoric and story-telling to persuade clients of their knowledge, when their services often have no foundation in real knowledge. Consultancy knowledge is to a large extent socially constructed, dependent for its status as knowledge on clients’ acceptance of it as such. Consultants often sell their services and persuade clients of their value by appealing to their relevance to passing management fashions and fads. The poets necessarily are susceptible to Plato’s objections, because they are creative artists whose proper business is primarily to entertain rather than to impart knowledge. By contrast, consultants have a clear role in imparting and applying management knowledge. They should respond to management scholars’ objections by shifting their focus ever more sharply towards the technoeconomic contributions that consultants can make to their clients, and away from the use of rhetoric and story-telling to promote their services.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrahamson, E. 1996. Management fashion. Academy of Management Review 21 (1): 254–285.
Alvesson, M. 1993. Organisations as rhetoric: Knowledge-intensive firms and the struggle with ambiguity. Journal of Management Studies 30 (6): 997–1015.
Ashton, J. 2020. Divide audit and consulting? Not on my watch (at least, not voluntarily). The Times, 1 February 2020, p.53.
Brownson, C.L. 1897. Reasons for Plato’s hostility to the poets. Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association 28: 5–41.
Clark, T., and G. Salaman. 1998. Creating the ‘right’ impression: Towards a dramaturgy of management consultancy. The Services Industries Journal 18 (1): 18–38.
Duncan, T.S. 1945. Plato and Poetry. The Classical Journal 40 (8): 481–494.
Edman, E. 1936. Poetry and truth in Plato. The Journal of Philosophy 33 (22): 605–609.
Fincham, R. 2002. Charisma versus technique: Differentiating the expertise of management gurus and management consultants. In Critical consulting: New perspectives on the management advice industry, ed. T. Clark and R. Fincham, 191–205. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers Ltd.
Fincham, R. 2005. Business process reengineering and the commodification of managerial knowledge. Journal of Marketing Management 11 (7): 707–719.
Fincham, R., and T. Clark. 2002. The emergence of critical perspectives on consulting. In Critical consulting: New perspectives on the management advice industry, ed. T. Clark and R. Fincham, 1–18. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers Ltd.
Fine, G. 1990. Knowledge and belief in republic V-VII. In Epistemology, ed. S. Everson, 85–115. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gilbert, A.H. 1939. Did Plato banish the poets or the critics? Studies in Philology 36 (1): 1–19.
Greiner, L., and I. Ennsfellner. 2010. Management consultants as professionals, or are they? Organisational Dynamics 39 (1): 72–83.
Griswold, C.L. 1981. The ideas and the criticism of poetry in Plato's republic, book 10. Journal of the History of Philosophy 19 (2): 135–150.
Gulley, N. 1977. Plato on poetry. Greece & Rome 24 (2): 154–169.
Halliwell, S. 2000. The subjection of muthos to logos: Plato's citations of the poets. The Classical Quarterly 50 (1): 94–112.
Harvey, W., T. Morris, and M. Müller Santos. 2017. Reputation and identity conflict in management consulting. Human Relations 70 (1): 92–118.
Heusinkveld, S., and K. Visscher. 2012. Practise what you preach: How consultants frame management concepts as enacted practice. Scandinavian Journal of Management 28 (4): 285–297.
Kieser, A., and L. Leiner. 2009. Why the rigour–relevance gap in management research is unbridgeable. Journal of Management Studies 4 (3): 516–533.
Lee, D.C. 2010. Interpreting Plato’s Republic: Knowledge and belief. Philosophy Compass 5 (10): 854–864.
Legge, K. 2002. On knowledge, business consultants and the selling of Total quality management. In Critical consulting: New perspectives on the management advice industry, ed. T. Clark and R. Fincham, 74–90. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers Ltd.
Leybourne, S. 2006. Improvisation within the Project Management of change: Some Observations from UK financial services. Journal of Change Management 6 (4): 365–381.
Mitchell, V.W. 1994. Problems and risk in the purchasing of consultancy services. The Services Industries Journal 14 (3): 315–339.
Molloy, E., and R. Whittington. 2005. Practices of Organising: Inside and outside the processes of change. In Strategy process (advances in strategic management), Volume, ed. G. Szulanski, J. Porac, and Y. Doz, vol. 22, 491–515.
Morris, T., and L. Empson. 1998. Organisation and expertise: An exploration of knowledge bases and the management of accounting and consulting firms. Accounting Organisations and Society 23 (5–6): 609–624.
Nees, D.B., and L.E. Greiner. 1985. Seeing behind the look-alike management consultants. Organisational Dynamics 13 (3): 68–79.
Nikolova, N., M. Reihlen, and J. Schlapfner. 2009. Client-consultant interaction: Capturing social practices of professional service production. Scandinavian Journal of Management 25 (3): 289–298.
Partee, M.H. 1973. Plato on the criticism of poetry. Philological Quarterly 52 (4): 629–642.
Pettigrew, A.M. 2003. Co-producing knowledge and the challenges of international collaborative research. In Innovative forms of Organising, ed. A.M. Pettigrew, R. Whittington, L. Melin, C. Sánchez-Runde, F.A.J. Van den Bosch, W. Ruigrok, and T. Numagami. London: Sage Publications Ltd.
Pettigrew, A.M. 2012. Context and action in the transformation of the firm: A reprise. Journal of Management Studies 49 (7): 1304–1328.
Pettigrew, A.M., R.W. Woodman, and K.S. Cameron. 2001. Studying Organisational change and development: Challenges for future research. Academy of Management Journal 44 (4): 697–713.
Plato 2013a. Republic: Books 1–5, Trans. Emlyn-Jones, C. and Preddy, W., Cambridge Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Plato 2013b. Republic: Books 6–10, Trans. Emlyn-Jones, C. and Preddy, W., Cambridge Mass.: Harvard University Press.
Sturdy, A. 1997. The Consultancy Process – An Insecure Business. Journal of Management Studies 34(3): 389–413.
Van Nistelrooij, A., L. De Caluwe, and N. Schouten. 2007. Management consultants’ Colourful ways of looking at change: An explorative study under Dutch management consultants. Journal of Change Management 17 (3-4): 243–254.
Werr, A., and T. Stjernberg. 2003. “Exploring management consulting firms as knowledge systems”, −. Organisation Studies 24 (6): 881–908.
Whittle, A. 2006. The paradoxical repertoires of management consultancy. Journal of Organisational Change Management 19 (4): 424–436.
Wright, C., and J. Kitay. 2002. ‘But does it work?’ Perceptions of the impact of management consulting. Strategic Change 11 (5): 271–278.
Wright, C., A. Sturdy, and N. Wylie. 2012. Management innovation through standardisation: Consultants as standardisers of organisational practice. Research Policy 41 (3): 652–662.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
The author states that there is no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Shaw, D. Would Plato Have Banned the Management Consultants?. Philosophy of Management 20, 101–111 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40926-020-00147-9
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40926-020-00147-9