Abstract
Organic and synthetic flocculants are conventional flocculants used in wastewater treatment and tap water purification. The challenges of toxic residue and the resultant secondary pollutants generated from organic and synthetic flocculants have attracted research efforts towards microbial extracellular polymers as nontoxic and biodegradable substitutes. However, the bioflocculants themselves have been associated with high production costs and low efficiency. To address these challenges, tremendous efforts have been made to hybridise cations with the bioflocculants. The contradictory reports on the role of cations in bioflocculation have necessitated this review. This paper reviews the relevant and recent literature on EPS-cation structuring, cationization of bioflocculants, the efficiency of the cationization of bioflocculants, the factors affecting cation induced bioflocculation, and the mechanisms of cation induced bioflocculation. Variations in experimental procedures microbial species and growth medium composition yield bioflocculants with positive or negative functional sites and may be responsible for the contradictory effect of the cations. Establishment of a standard fermentation system that could elucidate the mechanism of cation induced bioflocculation and of the standard techniques for evaluation of the cationic content of wastewater treated with cationized bioflocculants is needded for better understanding of the cation stimulated bioflocculation.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abu-Elreesh G, Zaki S, Farag S, Elkady MF, Abd-El-Haleem D (2011) Exobiopolymer from polyhydroxyalkanoate-producing transgenic yeast. Afr J Biotechnol 10:6558–6563
Aljuboori AHR, Idris A, Abdullah N, Mohamad R (2013) Production and characterization of a bioflocculant produced by aspergillus flavus. Bioresour Technol 127:489–493
Aljuboori AHR, Idris A, Al-joubory HHR, Uemura Y, Abubakar BI (2015) Flocculation behavior and mechanism of bioflocculant produced by aspergillus flavus. J Environ Manag 150:466–471
Brown MJ, Lester JN (1980) Comparison of bacterial extracellular polymer extraction methods. Appl Environ Microbiol 40:179–185
Bruus JH, Nielsen PH, Keiding K (1992) On the stability of activated sludge flocs with implications to dewatering. Water Res 26:1597–1604
Cao G, Zhang Y, Chen L, Liu J, Mao K, Li K, Zhou J (2015) Production of a bioflocculant from methanol wastewater and its application in arsenite removal. Chemosphere 141:274–281
Chen Z, Meng T, Li Z, Liu P, Wang Y, He N, Liang D (2017) Characterization of a beta-glucosidase from bacillus licheniformis and its effect on bioflocculant degradation. AMB Express 7:197
Comte S, Guibaud G, Baudu M (2006) Relations between extraction protocols for activated sludge extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) and EPS complexation properties: part I. comparison of the efficiency of eight EPS extraction methods. Enzym Microb Technol 38:237–245
Cosa S, Okoh A (2014) Bioflocculant production by a consortium of two bacterial species and its potential application in industrial wastewater and river water treatment. Pol J Environ Stud 23(3):689–696
Cosa S, Ugbenyen AM, Mabinya LV, Rumbold K, Okoh AI (2013) Characterization and flocculation efficiency of a bioflocculant produced by a marine Halobacillus. Environ Technol 34:2671–2679
Cruz I, Bashan Y, Hernàndez-Carmona G, De-Bashan LE (2013) Biological deterioration of alginate beads containing immobilized microalgae and bacteria during tertiary wastewater treatment. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 97:9847–9858
Deng S, Yu G, Ting YP (2005) Production of a bioflocculant by aspergillus parasiticus and its application in dye removal. Colloids Surf B: Biointerfaces 44:179–186
Derjaguin BV, Landau L (1993) Theory of the stability of strongly charged lyophobic sols and of the adhesion of strongly charged particles in solutions of electrolytes. Prog Surf Sci 43:30–59
Dlangamandla C, Dyantyi S, Mpentshu Y, Ntwampe S, Basitere M (2016) Optimisation of bioflocculant production by a biofilm forming microorganism from poultry slaughterhouse wastewater for use in poultry wastewater treatment. Water Sci Technol 73:1963–1968
Elkady M, Farag S, Zaki S, Abu-Elreesh G, Abd-El-Haleem D (2011) Bacillus mojavensis strain 32A, a bioflocculant-producing bacterium isolated from an Egyptian salt production pond. Bioresour Technol 102:8143–8151
Faust L (2014) Bioflocculation of wastewater organic matter at short retention times. Wageningen University, Dissertation
Freitas F, Alves VD, Reis MA (2011) Advances in bacterial exopolysaccharides: from production to biotechnological applications. Trends Biotechnol 29:388–398
Frølund B, Palmgren R, Keiding K, Nielsen PH (1996) Extraction of extracellular polymers from activated sludge using a cation exchange resin. Water Res 30:1749–1758
Gao Q, Zhu XH, Mu J, Zhang Y, Dong XW (2009) Using Ruditapes philippinarum conglutination mud to produce bioflocculant and its applications in wastewater treatment. Bioresour Technol 100:4996–5001
Giri SS, Harshiny M, Sen SS, Sukumaran V, Park SC (2015) Production and characterization of a thermostable bioflocculant from Bacillus subtilis F9, isolated from wastewater sludge. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 121:45–50
Gkotsis P, Peleka E, Zamboulis D, Mitrakas M, Tolkou A, Zouboulis A (2017) Wastewater treatment in membrane bioreactors: the use of polyelectrolytes to control membrane fouling. Environ Process 4(1):9–21
Gomaa EZ (2012) Production and characteristics of a heavy metals removing bioflocculant produced by Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Pol J Microbiol 61:281–289
Gong W-X, Wang S-G, Sun X-F, Liu X-W, Yue Q-Y, Gao B-Y (2008) Bioflocculant production by culture of Serratia ficaria and its application in wastewater treatment. Bioresour Technol 99:4668–4674
González A, Pokrovsky O, Jiménez-Villacorta F, Shirokova L, Santana-Casiano J, González-Dávila M, Emnova E (2014) Iron adsorption onto soil and aquatic bacteria: XAS structural study. Chem Geol 372:32–45
Guo J, Lau AK, Zhang Y, Zhao J (2015a) Characterization and flocculation mechanism of a bioflocculant from potato starch wastewater. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 99:5855–5861
Guo J, Yu J, Xin X, Zou C, Cheng Q, Yang H, Nengzi L (2015b) Characterization and flocculation mechanism of a bioflocculant from hydrolyzate of rice Stover. Bioresour Technol 177:393–397
Ha J, Gélabert A, Spormann AM, Brown GE Jr (2010) Role of extracellular polymeric substances in metal ion complexation on Shewanella oneidensis: batch uptake, thermodynamic modeling, ATR-FTIR, and EXAFS study. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 74:1–15
Hay ID, Wang Y, Moradali MF, Rehman ZU, Rehm BH (2014) Genetics and regulation of bacterial alginate production. Environ Microbiol 16:2997–3011
Horan N, Eccles C (1986) Purification and characterization of extracellular polysaccharide from activated sludges. Water Res 20:1427–1432
Huang L, Li M, Si G, Wei J, Ngo HH, Guo W, Xu W, du B, Wei Q, Wei D (2018) Assessment of microbial products in the biosorption process of Cu (II) onto aerobic granular sludge: extracellular polymeric substances contribution and soluble microbial products release. J Colloid Interface Sci 527:87–94
Ji B, Zhang X, Li Z, Xie H, Xiao X, Fan G (2010) Flocculation properties of a bioflocculant produced by bacillus licheniformis. Water Sci Technol 62:1907–1913
Kanmani P, Yuvapriya S (2017) Exopolysaccharide from bacillus sp. YP03: its properties and application as a flocculating agent in wastewater treatment. Int J Environ Sci Technol (Tehran):1–10
Khiew SK, Teng TT, Wong YS, Ong SA, Ismail N, Alkarkhi A (2016) Effects of cationization hybridized biopolymer from Bacillus subtilis on flocculating properties. Desalin Water Treat 57:16086–16095
Lei X, Chen Y, Shao Z, Chen Z, Li Y, Zhu H, Zhang J, Zheng W, Zheng T (2015) Effective harvesting of the microalgae Chlorella vulgaris via flocculation–flotation with bioflocculant. Bioresour Technol 198:922–925
Li WW, Yu HQ (2014) Insight into the roles of microbial extracellular polymer substances in metal biosorption. Bioresour Technol 160:15–23
Li L, Ma F, Zuo H (2016) Production of a novel bioflocculant and its flocculation performance in aluminum removal. Bioengineered 7(2):98–105
Lin Y, de Kreuk M, Van Loosdrecht M, Adin A (2010) Characterization of alginate-like exopolysaccharides isolated from aerobic granular sludge in pilot-plant. Water Res 44:3355–3364
Lin Y, Sharma P, van Loosdrecht M (2013) The chemical and mechanical differences between alginate-like exopolysaccharides isolated from aerobic flocculent sludge and aerobic granular sludge. Water Res 47:57–65
Liu H, Fang HH (2002) Extraction of extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of sludges. J Biotechnol 95:249–256
Liu W, Yuan H, Yang J, Li B (2009) Characterization of bioflocculants from biologically aerated filter backwashed sludge and its application in dying wastewater treatment. Bioresour Technol 100:2629–2632
Liu W, Wang K, Li B, Yuan H, Yang J (2010) Production and characterization of an intracellular bioflocculant by Chryseobacterium daeguense W6 cultured in low nutrition medium. Bioresour Technol 101:1044–1048
Liu C, Wang K, Jiang JH, Liu WJ, Wang JY (2015a) A novel bioflocculant produced by a salt-tolerant, alkaliphilic and biofilm-forming strain bacillus agaradhaerens C9 and its application in harvesting Chlorella minutissima UTEX2341. Biochem Eng J 93:166–172
Liu W, Liu C, Yuan H, Yang J (2015b) The mechanism of kaolin clay flocculation by a cation-independent bioflocculant produced by Chryseobacterium daeguense W6. AIMS Environ Sci 2:169–179
Liu W, Zhao C, Jiang J, Lu Q, Hao Y, Wang L, Liu C (2015c) Bioflocculant production from untreated corn Stover using Cellulosimicrobium cellulans L804 isolate and its application to harvesting microalgae. Biotechnol Biofuels 8:170
Liu W, Hao Y, Jiang J, Zhu A, Zhu J, Dong Z (2016a) Production of a bioflocculant from pseudomonas veronii L918 using the hydrolyzate of peanut hull and its application in the treatment of ash-flushing wastewater generated from coal fired power plant. Bioresour Technol 218:318–325
Liu W, He R, Liu C (2016b) An alkali-tolerant strain microbacterium esteraromaticum C26 produces a high yield of cation-independent bioflocculant. AIMS Environ Sci 3:408–419
Lu W-Y, Zhang T, Zhang D-Y, Li C-H, Wen J-P, Du L-X (2005) A novel bioflocculant produced by Enterobacter aerogenes and its use in defecating the trona suspension. Biochem Eng J 27:1–7
Luo Z, Chen L, Chen C, Zhang W, Liu M, Han Y, Zhou J (2014) Production and characteristics of a bioflocculant by Klebsiella pneumoniae YZ-6 isolated from human saliva. Appl Biochem Biotechnol 172:1282–1292
Luo L et al (2016) Isolation, identification, and optimization of culture conditions of a bioflocculant producing bacterium bacillus megaterium SP1 and its application in aquaculture wastewater treatment. Biomed Res Int 2016:2758168–2758168
Makapela B (2015) Evaluation of bioflocculant-producing potential of bacillus pumilus strain isolated from Tyume River in the eastern Cape Province of South Africa. University of Fort Hare, Dissertation
Makapela B, Okaiyeto K, Ntozonke N, Nwodo UU, Green E, Mabinya LV, Okoh AI (2016) Assessment of Bacillus pumilus isolated from fresh water milieu for bioflocculant production. Appl Sci 6:211
McKinney RE, Edwards GP (1952) A fundamental approach to the activated sludge process: II. A proposed theory of floc formation [with discussion]. Sewage and Industrial Wastes 280–287
Merrylin J, Kaliappan S, Kumar SA, Yeom I, Rajesh BJ (2013) Effect of extracellular polymeric substances on sludge reduction potential of Bacillus licheniformis. Int J Environ Sci Technol (Tehran) 10:85–92
Miki B, Poon NH, James AP, Seligy VL (1982) Possible mechanism for flocculation interactions governed by gene FLO1 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. J Bacteriol 150:878–889
Miranda-Trevino JC, Coles CA (2003) Kaolinite properties, structure and influence of metal retention on pH. Appl Clay Sci 23:133–139
Moghannem SA, Farag MM, Shehab AM, Azab MS (2018) Exopolysaccharide production from bacillus velezensis KY471306 using statistical experimental design. Braz J Microbiol 49(3):452–462
Moral ÇK, Ertesvåg H, Sanin FD (2016) Guluronic acid content as a factor affecting turbidity removal potential of alginate. Environ Sci Pollut R 23:22568–22576
Ndejiko MJ (2014) Effect of surface roughness on Escherichia coli biofilm formation and their susceptibility to benzalkonium chloride. Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, Dissertation
Ntsangani N (2016) Assessment of the flocculating efficiency of bioflocculant produced by Bacillus sp. AEMREG4 isolated from Tyhume river, eastern cape, South Africa. Dissertation, University of Fort Hare
Ogunsade OO, Bakare MK, Adewale IO (2015) Purification and characterization of bioflocculant produced by bacillus amyloliquefaciens ABL 19 isolated from Adeti stream, Ilesa, Osun state, Nigeria. Nat Sci 13:54–64
Okaiyeto K (2016) Evaluation of flocculating performance of a thermostable bioflocculant produced by marine bacillus sp. Environ Technol 37(14):1829–1842
Okaiyeto K, Nwodo UU, Mabinya LV, Okoh AI (2013) Characterization of a bioflocculant produced by a consortium of Halomonas sp. Okoh and micrococcus sp. Leo. Int J Environ Res Public Health 10:5097–5110
Okaiyeto K, Nwodo UU, Mabinya LV, Okoli AS, Okoh AI (2015) Characterization of a bioflocculant (MBF-UFH) produced by bacillus sp. AEMREG7. Int J Mol Sci 16:12986–13003
Okaiyeto K, Nwodo UU, Mabinya LV, Okoli AS, Okoh AI (2016a) Evaluation of flocculating performance of a thermostable bioflocculant produced by marine bacillus sp. Environ Technol 37:1829–1842
Okaiyeto K, Nwodo UU, Okoli AS, Mabinya LV, Okoh AI (2016b) Studies on bioflocculant production by bacillus sp. AEMREG7. Pol J environ stud 25 (1)
Okaiyeto K, Nwodo UU, Okoli SA, Mabinya LV, Okoh AI (2016c) Implications for public health demands alternatives to inorganic and synthetic flocculants: bioflocculants as important candidates. MicrobiologyOpen 5(2):177–211
Pathak M, Devi A, Bhattacharyya K, Sarma H, Subudhi S, Lal B (2015) Production of a non-cytotoxic bioflocculant by a bacterium utilizing a petroleum hydrocarbon source and its application in heavy metal removal. RSC Adv 5:66037–66046
Patil SV, Salunkhe RB, Patil CD, Patil DM, Salunke BK (2010) Bioflocculant exopolysaccharide production by Azotobacter indicus using flower extract of Madhuca latifolia L. Appl Biochem Biotechnol 162:1095–1108
Patil SV, Patil CD, Salunke BK, Salunkhe RB, Bathe G, Patil DM (2011) Studies on characterization of bioflocculant exopolysaccharide of Azotobacter indicus and its potential for wastewater treatment. Appl Biochem Biotechnol 163:463–472
Peng L, Yang C, Zeng G, Wang L, Dai C, Long Z, Liu H, Zhong Y (2014) Characterization and application of bioflocculant prepared by Rhodococcus erythropolis using sludge and livestock wastewater as cheap culture media. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 98:6847–6858
Prasertsan P, Dermlim W, Doelle H, Kennedy J (2006) Screening, characterization and flocculating property of carbohydrate polymer from newly isolated Enterobacter cloacae WD7. Carbohydr Polym 66:289–297
Pronk M, Neu TR, Van Loosdrecht M, Lin Y (2017) The acid soluble extracellular polymeric substance of aerobic granular sludge dominated by Defluviicoccus sp. Water Res 122:148–158
Pu S-y, L-l Q, J-p C, Zhang B-r XM (2014) Preparation and application of a novel bioflocculant by two strains of Rhizopus sp. using potato starch wastewater as nutrilite. Bioresour Technol 162:184–191
Rao B, Sudharsan K, Sekaran R, Mandal A (2013) Characterization of exopolysaccharide from bacillus amyloliquefaciens BPRGS for its bioflocculant activity. Int J Sci Eng Res 4:1696–1704
Seviour T, Lambert LK, Pijuan M, Yuan Z (2010) Structural determination of a key exopolysaccharide in mixed culture aerobic sludge granules using NMR spectroscopy. Environ Sci Technol 44:8964–8970
Shahadat M, Teng TT, Rafatullah M, Shaikh Z, Sreekrishnan T, Ali SW (2017) Bacterial bioflocculants: a review of recent advances and perspectives. Chem Eng Sci 328:1139–1152
Sheng G-P, Yu H-Q, Li X-Y (2010) Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) of microbial aggregates in biological wastewater treatment systems: a review. Biotechnol Adv 28:882–894
Sobeck DC, Higgins MJ (2002) Examination of three theories for mechanisms of cation-induced bioflocculation. Water Res 36:527–538
Suazo FJC (2006) Efect of reactor feeding pattern on performance of an activated sludge sbr. Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Dissertation
Subramanian SB, Yan S, Tyagi R, Surampalli R (2010) Extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) producing bacterial strains of municipal wastewater sludge: isolation, molecular identification, EPS characterization and performance for sludge settling and dewatering. Water Res 44:2253–2266
Subudhi S, Bisht V, Batta N, Pathak M, Devi A, Lal B (2016) Purification and characterization of exopolysaccharide bioflocculant produced by heavy metal resistant Achromobacter xylosoxidans. Carbohydr Polym 137:441–451
Sun PF, Lin H, Wang G, Lu LL, Zhao YH (2015a) Preparation of a new-style composite containing a key bioflocculant produced by Pseudomonas aeruginosa ZJU1 and its flocculating effect on harmful algal blooms. J Hazard Mater 284:215–221
Sun P, Hui C, Bai N, Yang S, Wan L, Zhang Q, Zhao Y (2015b) Revealing the characteristics of a novel bioflocculant and its flocculation performance in Microcystis aeruginosa removal. Sci Rep 5:17465
Tezuka Y (1969) Cation-dependent flocculation in a Flavobacterium species predominant in activated sludge. Appl Microbiol 17:222–226
Ugbenyen A, Okoh A (2014) Characteristics of a bioflocculant produced by a consortium of Cobetia and bacillus species and its application in the treatment of wastewaters. Water SA 40:139–144
Ugbenyen A, Cosa S, Mabinya L, Babalola OO, Aghdasi F, Okoh A (2012) Thermostable bacterial bioflocculant produced by Cobetia spp. isolated from Algoa Bay (South Africa). Int J Environ Res Public Health 9:2108–2120
Ugbenyen A, Cosa S, Mabinya L, Okoh A (2014) Bioflocculant production by bacillus sp. Gilbert isolated from a marine environment in South Africa. Biotechnol Appl Biochem 50:49–54
Verwey EJW (1947) Theory of the stability of lyophobic colloids. J Phys Chem 51(3):631–636
Wan C, Zhao XQ, Guo SL, Alam MA, Bai FW (2013) Bioflocculant production from Solibacillus silvestris W01 and its application in cost-effective harvest of marine microalga Nannochloropsis oceanica by flocculation. Bioresour Technol 135:207–212
Wang SG, Gong WX, Liu XW, Tian L, Yue QY, Gao BY (2007) Production of a novel bioflocculant by culture of Klebsiella mobilis using dairy wastewater. Biochem Eng J 36:81–86
Wang L, Ma F, Lee DJ, Wang A, Ren N (2013) Bioflocculants from hydrolysates of corn Stover using isolated strain Ochrobactium ciceri W2. Bioresour Technol 145:259–263
Wang K, Li W, Rui X, Chen X, Jiang M, Dong M (2014) Characterization of a novel exopolysaccharide with antitumor activity from lactobacillus plantarum. 70810. Int J Biol Macromol 63:133–139
Wang Z, Shen L, Zhuang X, Shi J, Wang Y, He N, Chang Y-I (2015) Flocculation characterization of a bioflocculant from bacillus licheniformis. Ind Eng Chem Res 54:2894–2901
Wei L, Li Y, Noguera DR, Zhao N, Song Y, Ding J, Zhao Q, Cui F (2017) Adsorption of Cu2+ and Zn2+ by extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) in different sludges: effect of EPS fractional polarity on binding mechanism. J Hazard Mater 321:473–483
Wu JY, Ye HF (2007) Characterization and flocculating properties of an extracellular biopolymer produced from a Bacillus subtilis DYU1 isolate. Process Biochem 42:1114–1123
Xia S et al (2008) Production and characterization of a bioflocculant by Proteus mirabilis TJ-1. Bioresour Technol 99:6520–6527
Xia X, Lan S, Li X, Xie Y, Liang Y, Yan P, Chen Z, Xing Y (2018) Characterization and coagulation-flocculation performance of a composite flocculant in high turbidity drinking water treatment. Chemosphere 206:701–708
Xiong Y, Wang Y, Yu Y, Li Q, Wang H, Chen R, He N (2010) Production and characterization of a novel bioflocculant from bacillus licheniformis. Appl Environ Microbiol 76:2778–2782
Yim JH, Kim SJ, Ahn SH, Lee HK (2007) Characterization of a novel bioflocculant, p-KG03, from a marine dinoflagellate, Gyrodinium impudicum KG03. Bioresour Technol 98:361–367
Yue L, Ma C, Chi Z (2006) Bioflocculant produced by Klebsiella sp. MYC and its application in the treatment of oil-field produced water. J Ocean Univ China 5:333
Zaki S, Farag S, Elreesh GA, Elkady M, Nosier M, El Abd D (2011) Characterization of bioflocculants produced by bacteria isolated from crude petroleum oil. Int J Environ Sci Technol (Tehran) 8:831–840
Zaki SA, Elkady MF, Farag S, Abd-El-Haleem D (2013) Characterization and flocculation properties of a carbohydrate bioflocculant from a newly isolated bacillus velezensis 40B. J Environ Biol 34:51
Zhang ZQ, Bo L, Si-qing X, Wang XJ, Yang AM (2007) Production and application of a novel bioflocculant by multiple-microorganism consortia using brewery wastewater as carbon source. J Environ Sci 19:667–673
Zhang C, Wang X, Wang Y, Li Y, Zhou D, Jia Y (2016) Synergistic effect and mechanisms of compound bioflocculant and AlCl3 salts on enhancing Chlorella regularis harvesting. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 100:5653–5660
Zhao H, Zhong C, Chen H, Yao J, Tan L, Zhang Y, Zhou J (2016) Production of bioflocculants prepared from formaldehyde wastewater for the potential removal of arsenic. J Environ Manag 172:71–76
Zulkeflee Z, Aris AZ, Shamsuddin ZH, Yusoff MK (2012) Cation dependence, pH tolerance, and dosage requirement of a bioflocculant produced by bacillus spp. UPMB13: flocculation performance optimization through kaolin assays. Sci World J 2012:495659–495659
Zulkeflee Z, Shamsuddin ZH, Aris AZ, Yusoff MK, Komilis D, Sánchez A (2016) Glutamic acid independent production of bioflocculants by Bacillus subtilis UPMB13. Environ Process 3(2):353–367
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge Universiti Teknologi Malaysia and GUP Tier1 (Q. J130000.2545.13H22) and Demand-Driven Innovation grant (R. J130000.7845.4 L190) for their financial support and Pakar Go Green Sdn. Bhd for supplying the fungus strain used in this study.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare no financial or commercial conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mohammed, J.N., Dagang, W.R.Z.W. Role of Cationization in Bioflocculant Efficiency: a Review. Environ. Process. 6, 355–376 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40710-019-00372-z
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40710-019-00372-z