Abstract
The paper explores the impact of civil society on India’s capitalist development. While the concept of civil society is controversial, the interpretations of the phenomenon can be reduced to two major views. The first view builds on the optimistic analysis by Alexis de Tocqueville, who introduces the idea of civil society as a partnership of equal individuals that promote the common good, and the second view builds on the analysis by Antonio Gramsci, who sees civil society as the organization that supports the hegemony of the dominant classes pursuing particularistic interests. The paper focuses on India’s civil society having in mind these alternative views in order to explore which one of the two fits better to the case. The paper builds on the hypothesis that, due to the widespread informality of India’s economy, the associations of civil society are a major character in India’s society, playing a crucial regulative role in substitution of the state, and that the analysis of civil society enhances the understanding of capitalist organization and of the power relations governing it. The argument is that it is hardly appropriate to interpret India’s organized society as ‘good’ civil society, while the Gramscian interpretation appears to be more appropriate to the Indian case in which the organizations of civil society are the tools to regulate the economy, managing interest conflicts and building social consensus over the hegemony of the elites. The argument is supported with evidence coming from Arni, a market town in Provincial India in which the economy is vastly informalized and the market is not the prevailing organizing principle, while institutions and structures produced in civil society regulate economic transactions.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Banejee S (2011) Anna Hazare, Civil society and the state. Econ Polit Wkly 46(36)
Basile E (2013) Capitalist development in India’s informal economy. Routledge, London
Basile E (2015) Local–global integration, diversification and informality: long-term change in Arni during the late twentieth century. In: Harriss-White B (ed) Middle India and urban–rural development. Four decades of change. Springer, New Delhi
Behar A, Prakash A (2004) India: expanding and contracting democratic space. In: Alagappa M (ed) Civil society and political change in Asia. Expanding and contracting democratic space. Stanford University Press, Stanford
Chandhoke N (2009) Civil Society in conflict cities: the case of Ahmedabad, WP No 64, Crisis States Research Centre
Chandhoke N (2012) Civil society in India. In: Edwards M (ed) The Oxford handbook of civil society, Chapter 13. Oxford Handbooks, Oxford
Chatterjee P (2001) On civil and political society in post-colonial democracies. In: Kaviraj S, Khilnani S (eds) Civil Society, history and possibilities. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Chatterjee P (2008) Democracy and economic transformation in India. Econ Polit Wkly 43(16):53–62
Chhibber PK (1999) Democracy without associations. Transformation of the party system and social cleavages in India. The University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor
Deshpande R (2010) Caste associations in the post-Mandal era notes from Maharashtra. CAS occasional paper series: no. 2, Department of Politics and Public Administration, University of Pune, Pune
Diamond L (1994) Rethinking civil society. Toward democratic consolidation. J Democr 5(3):4–17
Edwards M (2014) Civil society, 3rd edn. Polity Press, Cambridge (UK) and Malden (USA)
Gramsci A (1975) Quaderni del carcere. In: Gerratana V (ed.), 4 volumes. Einaudi, Torino
Harriss J (2005) Political participation, representation and the urban poor. Findings from research in Delhi. Econ Polit Wkly 40(11):1041–1054
Harriss J (2007) Antinomies of empowerment. observations on civil society, politics and urban governance in India. Econ Polit Wkly 42(26):2716–2724
Harriss-White B (2003) India working. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Hoeber Rudolph S (2004) Is civil society the answer? In: Bhattacharyya D, Jayal NG, Mohapatra BN, Pi S (eds) Interrogating social capital. Sage, New Delhi
Hoeber Rudolph S (2000) Civil society and the realm of freedom. Econ Polit Wkly 35(20):1762–1769
Jayal GN (2007) The role of civil society. In: Ganguly S, Diamond L, Plattner MF (eds) The state of India’s democracy. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore
Jenkins R (2005) Civil society: active or passive? The case of India. In: Burnell P, Randal V (eds) Politics in the developing world. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Kamath L, Vijayabaskar M (2009) Limits and possibilities of middle class associations as urban collective actors. Econ Polit Wkly 44:368–376
Kaviraj S (2001) In search of civil society. In: Kaviraj S, Khilnani S (eds) Civil society. history and possibility. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Kothari R (1984) The non-party political process. Econ Polit Wkly 19(5):216–224
Kumar N (2006) Provincialism in modern india: the multiple narratives of education and their pain. Mod Asian Stud 40(2):397–423
Laine J (2014) Debating civil society: contested conceptualizations and development trajectories. Int J Not-for-Profit Law 16(1):59
Mahajan G (2013) What is civil and uncivil in civil society? In: Jodhka SS (ed) Interrogating India’s modernity: democracy, identity and citizenship. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Mohanty R (2002) Civil society and NGOs. Indian J Polit Sci 63(2/3):213–232
Rudolph LI, Hoeber Rudolph S (1960) The Political role of India’s caste associations. Pac Affairs 33(1):5–22
Schmitter PC (1974) Still the century of corporatism? Rev Polit 36(1):85–131
Shah M (2014) Civil society and Indian democracy. Possibilities of social transformation. Econ Polit Wkly 49(8)
Srinivas MN (1957) A note on sanskritization and westernization. Far Eastern Q 15(4):529–548
Tandon R, Mohanty R (2000) Civil Society and governance. A research study in India, part of a global comparative research study on civil society and governance co-ordinated by IDS, Sussex, UK, Synthesis report
Tocqueville de A (1840) Democracy in America, Book 2, translated by Henry Reeve, revised and corrected. www.marxists.org
White G (2004) Civil society, democratization and development: clearing the analytical ground. In: Burnell P, Calvert P, Cass F (eds) Civil society in democratization. Portland, London
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Basile, E. Civil society and small town capitalism: the case of Arni. Decision 44, 133–145 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40622-017-0156-6
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40622-017-0156-6