Advertisement

DECISION

, Volume 44, Issue 3, pp 227–238 | Cite as

Impact assessment of group-based credit–lending projects with controlled project placement bias and self-selection bias

  • Debadutta Kumar PandaEmail author
Research Article

Abstract

A large number of microfinance impact assessment studies were conducted in different parts of the world in last two decades, but most of the impact assessment methods were put to questions. There were methodological concerns associated with both external validation and internal validation. Many microfinance impact assessment studies have suffered from issues related to counterfactual selection, project/programme placement bias and self-selection bias. To address those problems, this paper studied some of the important impact assessment frameworks. This study involved extensive literature scanning. Important impact assessment models were analysed and discussed focusing on unit of analysis, selection of impact variables, selection of comparison group and control of self-selection bias and project placement bias. The study concluded that a methodical analysis of counterfactual would help in avoiding self-selection bias and project placement bias.

Keywords

Impact assessment Group-lending Microfinance project Control group Self-selection bias 

References

  1. Abbas F, Sarwar MN, Hussain S (2005) Group-based credit–lending project route to income generation and poverty reduction: evidence from district Faisalabad, Pakistan. J Agric Soc Sci 1(2):144–147Google Scholar
  2. Amin S, Rai AS, Topa G (2003) Does microcredit reach the poor and vulnerable? evidence from Northern Bangladesh. J Dev Econ 70:59–82CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  3. Ardener S (1964) The comparative study of rotating credit associations. J Roy Anthropol Inst 94(1):201–229Google Scholar
  4. Armendariz B, Morduch J (2007) The economics of group-based credit–lending project. Prentice-Hall of India, New DelhiGoogle Scholar
  5. Asim S (2008). Evaluating the impact of microcredit on women’s empowerment in Pakistan. http://oxford.academia.edu/SalmanAsim/Papers/74584/Evaluating-the-Impact-of-Microcredit-on-Women-s-Empowerment-in-Pakistan
  6. Barker JL (1999) Evaluating the poverty impact of projects. In: A handbook for practitioners LCSPR/PRMPO, The World Bank, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  7. Bennett L, Cuevas CE (1996) Sustainable banking with the poor. J Int Dev 8(2):145–153CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  8. Bennett L, Goldberg M, Hunte P (1996) Ownership and sustainability lessons on group based financial services from South Asia. J Int Dev 8(2):271–289CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Brook RM, Hillyer KJ, Bhuvaneshwari G (2008a) Group-based credit–lending project for community development, poverty alleviation and natural resources management in Peri-urban Hubli-Dharwad, India. Environ Urban 20(1):149–163CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Brook RM, Hillyer KJ, Bhuvaneshwari G (2008b) Microfinance for community development, poverty alleviation and natural resources management in Peri-urban Hubli-Dharwad, India. Environ Urban 20(1):149–163CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Buckley G (1997) Micro finance in Africa: is it either a problem or solution? World Dev 25(7):1081–1094CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Carroll T (1973) Group credit for small farmers. USAID spring review of small credit for farmers 19:264–282Google Scholar
  13. Chowdhury MJA (2009). Microcredit, micro-enterprises and self-employment of women: experience from the Grameen Bank in Bangladesh. Paper presented in FAO-IFAD-ILO workshop on gap, trends and current research in gender dimensions of agriculture and rural employment: differentiated path way out of poverty, Rome, 31st March–2nd April 2009Google Scholar
  14. Chowdhury MJA, Ghose D, Wright RE (2009) The impact of micro-credit on poverty: evidence from Bangladesh. Prog Dev Stud 9:115–125CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  15. Cohen M, Burjorjee DL (2003) The impact of microfinance, Donor brief no. 13. CGAP, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  16. Coleman BE (1999) The impact of group lending in NorthEast Thailand. J Dev Econ 60:105–141CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Conlin M (1999) Peer group microlending projects in Canada and the United States. J Dev Econ 60:249–269CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cuong NV, Pham MT, Minh NP (2007) Poverty targeting and impact of a governmental microcredit project in Vietnam, PMMA. In: Working paper 2007–29, poverty and economic policy, VietnamGoogle Scholar
  19. Dash A. (2003) Poverty and sustainability: achieving double bottom line in microfinance. In: Paper presented in 2nd impact global meeting, South Africa, 5–9 May 2003Google Scholar
  20. Desilva D, Denby N (1992) Banking the unbankble: bring credit to the poor. Horizon India Books, New DelhiGoogle Scholar
  21. Donaghue K (2004) Microfinance in the Asian Pacific. Asian Pac Econ Lit 18(1):41–61CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  22. Dunn E (2001) Microcredit and microenterprise performance: impact evidence from Peru. Small Enterp Dev J 12:22–33CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Dunn E, Arbuckle JG (2001) The impact of microcredit: a case study from Peru. Assessing the impact of micro-enterprise services (AIMS). Management Systems International, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  24. Evans TG, Adams AM (1999) Demystifying nonparticipation in microcredit: a population-based analysis. World Dev 27(2):419–430CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  25. Eversole R (2000) Beyond microcredit—The trickle up programme. Small Enterp Dev 11(1):45–48CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Ghalib AK (2007). Measuring the impact of microfinance intervention: a conceptual framework of social impact assessment. Paper presented at the Singapore economic review conference, SingaporeGoogle Scholar
  27. Gomez R, Santor E (2008) Does the microfinance lending models actually work. Whitehead J Dipl Int Relat Summer/Fall 2008:37–56Google Scholar
  28. Guha-Khasnobis B, Hazarika G (2007) Household access to microcredit and children’s food security in rural Malwi. Research paper no. 2007/87, United Nations University and World Institute for Development Economic Research, UNU-WIDER Project on Gender and Food SecurityGoogle Scholar
  29. Handa S, Kirton C (1999) The economics of rotating savings and credit associations: evidence from the Jamaican Partner. J Dev Econ 60(1):173–194CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  30. Haque MS, Yamao M (2008) Can microcredit alleviate rural poverty: a case study of Bangladesh. World Acad Sci Eng Technol 46:648–656Google Scholar
  31. Harper M (1998) The new middle women: profitable banking through on lending groups. Oxford and IBH Publishing Co. Pvt. Ltd., New DelhiCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  32. Harper M (ed) (2007) What is wrong with microfinance?, What is wrong with microfinance. Intermediate technology publications Ltd., United KingdomGoogle Scholar
  33. Hasan ME, Iglebaek M (2004). Microfinance with unreached people in the rural area: experience and learning. Paper presented in Asia Pacific region microcredit summit meeting councils, Dhaka, 18th FebGoogle Scholar
  34. Hiatt SR, Woodworth WP (2006) Alleviating poverty through microfinance: village banking outcomes in Central America. Soc Sci J 43:471–477CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  35. Hickson R (2001) Financial services for the very poor—thinking outside the box. Small Enterp Dev 12(2):55–67CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Hong Son N (2007) “The efficiency and effectiveness of group-based credit–lending project: evidences of projects from Non-Governmental Organizations in Vietnam”, Ph. D thesis, School of Economics, University of Queensland, UKGoogle Scholar
  37. Hossain M, Diaz CP (1999) Reaching the poor with effective microcredit: evaluation of a Grameen Bank replication in the Philippines. Paper presented in the international workshop on assessing the impact of agricultural research on poverty alleviation, international centre for tropical agriculture, CIAT, Cali, Colombia, 14–16 Sept 1999Google Scholar
  38. Javed A, Luqman M, Khan AS, Farah AA (2006) Impact of microcredit scheme of nrsp on socio-economic condition of female community in district Rawalakot, Azad Jammu and Kashmir, Pakistan. J Agric Soc Sci 2(3):142–144Google Scholar
  39. Johnson S (2000) Gender impact assessment in group-based credit–lending project and microenterprise: why and how. Dev Pract 10(1):89–93CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  40. Jung H (2004) Does microfinance makes a difference: measuring the social impact of microfinance. Microfinance Matters 3Google Scholar
  41. Kabeer N (2001) Conflicts over credit: re-evaluating the empowerment potential of loans to women in rural Bangladesh. World Dev 29(1):63–84CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  42. Kabeer N (2005) Is microfinance a magic bullet for women’s empowerment? analysis of findings from South Asia. Econ Polit Wkly XL(44–45):4709–4718Google Scholar
  43. Kando T (2007) Impact of group-based credit–lending project on rural households in the Philippines. Operations Evaluation Department, Asian Development Bank, ManilaGoogle Scholar
  44. Karlon D (2001) Group-based credit–lending project impact assessments: The peril of using new member as a control group. Department of Economics, MIT, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  45. Karlon, D and Goldberg, N (2007) “Impact Evaluation for Group-based credit–lending project: Review of Methodological Issues”, Doing Impact Evaluation, No. 7, The WorldBank, Washington D.CGoogle Scholar
  46. Khandker SR (2005) Microfinance and poverty: evidence using panel data from Bangladesh. World Bank Econ Rev 19(2):263–286CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  47. Khandker SR, Samad HA, Khan ZH (1998) Income and employment effect of microcredit programmes: village level evidence from Bangladesh. J Dev Stud 35(2):96–124CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  48. Kurtz DV (1973) The rotating credit association: an adaption to poverty. Hum Organ 32:49–58CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  49. Machogu CG (2008) Impact of microfinance on poverty eradication in Kenya. In: Lazar D, Palanichamy P (eds) Microfinance and poverty eradication: Indian and global experiences. New Century Publications, New Delhi, pp 513–523Google Scholar
  50. Makina D, Malobola LM (2004) Impact assessment of microfinance programmes, including lessons from Khula Enterprise Finance. Dev South Afr 21(5):799–814CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Matin I, Sulaiman M, Saleque MA (eds) (2007) “Imagining microfinance more boldly: unleashing the true potential of microfinance”, what is wrong with microfinance. Intermediate Technology Publication Ltd., United KingdomGoogle Scholar
  52. Montgomery H, Weiss J (2005) Great expectations: group-based credit–lending project and poverty reduction in Asia and Latin America. ADB Institute Research Paper Series No. 63, Asian Development Bank Institute Publishing, TokioGoogle Scholar
  53. Morduch J (1995) Income smoothening and consumption smoothening. J Econ Perspect 9(1):103–114CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  54. Morduch J, Haley B (2001) Analysis of the effects of microfinance on poverty reduction. NUY working paper, NYU, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  55. Mosley P (1997). The use of control groups in the impact assessment of microfinance. Working paper no. 19, ILO, GenevaGoogle Scholar
  56. Mosley P (2001) Microfinance and poverty in Bolivia. J Dev Stud 37:101–132CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  57. Mourji F (2000) Impact Study of Zakoura microcredit programme. Micro-Start programme, Local Technical service Provider, United Nations Capital development Fund, New York, USAGoogle Scholar
  58. Muhammad AL (2001) Micro credit and saving of rural households in Bangladesh. Bangladesh Dev Stud 27(1):51–68Google Scholar
  59. Nguyen CH (2007) Determinants of credit participation and its impact on household consumption: evidence from rural Vietnam. Discussion paper 2007/03, Centre for Economic Reform and Transformation, School of Management and Languages, Heriot-Watt University, EdinburghGoogle Scholar
  60. Panda DK (2008) Performance of self help groups under group-based credit–lending project projects: evidence from a tribal district of Orissa. Vikas Vani J 2(3):51–60Google Scholar
  61. Panda DK (2009a) Assessing the impact of participation in women self-help group based group-based credit–lending project: non-experimental evidence from rural households in India. Int J Rural Manag 5(2):197–215CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  62. Panda DK (2009b) Impact of microfinance on rural households: an empirical evidence from a coastal district of Orissa. Metamorphosis 8(2):48–60CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  63. Panda DK (2009c) Participation in group based microfinance and its impact on rural households: a quasi-experimental evidence from an India State. Glob J Financ Manag 1(2):171–183Google Scholar
  64. Panda DK and Atibudhi HN (2009) Impact of group based microfinance on rural household savings: empirical findings from india. The Microfinance Review 1(1):54–68Google Scholar
  65. Panda DK, Atibudhi HN (2010) Impact of group based group-based credit–lending project on the income of rural households: a non-experimental evidence from an Indian State. J Rural Coop 38(2):173–186Google Scholar
  66. Panda DK, Atibudhi HN (2011) A study on self-help group based microfinance impacting poor rural households. IIMS J Manag Sci 2(1):35–45Google Scholar
  67. Park A (2001) Group-based credit–lending project with Chinese characteristics. World Dev 29(1):39–62CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  68. Paxton J (2003) A poverty outreach index and its application to microfinance. Econ Bull 9(2):1–10Google Scholar
  69. Pitt MM, Khandekar SR (2002) Credit programmes for the poor and seasonality in rural Bangladesh. J Dev Stud 36(2):1–24CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  70. Pitt MM, Khandkar SR (1996) Household and intrahousehold impact of the Grameen Bank and similar targeted credit programs in Bangladesh. World Bank discussion paper no. 320, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  71. Pitt MM, Khandkar SR (1998) The impact of group based credit programmes on poor households in Bangladesh: does gender of participants matter. J Polit Econ 106(5):958–996CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Rahman S, Rafiq RB, Momen MA (2009) Impact of microcredit programmes on higher income borrowers: evidence from Bangladesh. Int Bus Econ Res J 8(2):119–124Google Scholar
  73. Robinson M (2001) The microfinance revolution: sustainable finance for the poor. World Bank, Washington, DCCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  74. Rutherford S (1998) The savings of the poor: improving financial services in Bangladesh. J Int Dev 10(1):1–15CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  75. Rutherford S (2002) Raising the curtain on the microfinancial services era. In: CGAP focus note number CGAP, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  76. Sarangi N (2007) Group-based credit–lending project and rural poor in India: impact assessment based on fieldworks in Madhya Pradesh. Paper presented in the conference on sustainable development and livelihood, Delhi School of Economics, India, 6–8 Feb 2007Google Scholar
  77. Shamsuddoha M, Azad ASMS (2004). Assessing impact of microfinance on poverty alleviation: Bangladesh perspective. Paper presented in the conference on enhancing performance: agenda for growth, organized by Prestige Institute of Management and Research (PIMR), Indore, IndiaGoogle Scholar
  78. Shaw J (2004) Microenterprise occupation and poverty reduction in microfinance programme: evidence from Sri Lanka. World Dev 32:1247–1264CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  79. Smith DH and Pillheimer K (1983) Self-help groups as social movement organizations: social structure and social change. Research in social movements: conflicts and change 5(2):203–233Google Scholar
  80. Tripathy KK, Jain SK (2008) Microfinance and self-employment activities towards income generation and poverty alleviation in rural areas under SGSY: an empirical investigation in Haryana and Orissa. Paper presented in international conference on issues in public policy and sustainable development, IGNOU, New Delhi, 26–28 March 2008Google Scholar
  81. Xavier MJ, Raja J, Nandhini SU (2007) Entrepreneurship development through corporate intervention among self help groups in India—The case of HLL’s project Shakti, Social Banking: perspectives and experiences. The ICFAI University Press, Hyderabad, pp 148–168Google Scholar
  82. Yunus M (1999) Banker to the poor: micro lending and battle against world poverty. Pacific Affairs, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  83. Yunus M (2007) Creating a world without poverty: social business and the future of capitalism. Public Affairs Books, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  84. Zaman H (2000) Assessing the poverty and vulnerability impact of micro-credit in Bangladesh. In: A case study of BRAC, World Bank, Washington, DCGoogle Scholar
  85. Zaman H (2004) Scaling up microfinance in Bangladesh: determinants, impacts and lessons. World bank policy research working paper no. 3398, World Bank, Washington DCGoogle Scholar
  86. Zeller M (2001) Solidarity groups: reaching the poor clients with high repayment rates. Focal Point Microfinance 2(1):4–6Google Scholar
  87. Zewde ZN, Tollens E (2008) Group-based credit–lending project impact evaluation at household level. In: Lazar D, Palanichamy P (eds) Group-based credit–lending project and poverty eradication: Indian and global experiences. New Century Publications, New DelhiGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Indian Institute of Management Calcutta 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Economics and StrategyInstitute of Management TechnologyHyderabadIndia

Personalised recommendations