Although detailed descriptions of how to create and build independence using activity schedules are available elsewhere (e.g., Higbee & Brodhead, 2016; Higbee & Sellers, 2017; McClannahan & Krantz, 1999), a brief summary of how to select activities for inclusion in a digital activity schedule and standard prompting/teaching techniques is included here. We refer the reader to the cited papers for more detailed descriptions and instructions.
Selecting Activities and Arranging the Environment
Specific activities to be included in a beginning activity schedule, including a digital one, should be moderately preferred, close-ended (i.e., have a clear beginning and end), relatively brief, and already independently performed by the learner, as the focus during initial activity schedule training is on how to follow the schedule rather than on the activities themselves (Higbee & Sellers, 2017). Beginning activity schedules are usually composed of at least two to three activity pages plus a terminal reinforcer page (typically a small amount of a preferred edible) at the end. Additional activities can be added as the learner demonstrates mastery of the schedule to form progressively longer response chains. The sequence of activities should be changed frequently to ensure that the learner’s behavior comes under the control of the pictures displayed as opposed to becoming a sequence of rote behaviors under proprioceptor control of sensations repeated in a performance chain.
Activity schedules can be used in multiple environments. However, beginning play/leisure activity schedules often are used at a table or desk that is large enough to both hold the schedule and provide enough room to complete the activities (the floor could also be used in the absence of a desk or table). Activity materials are typically placed on a shelf near the desk/table. They could also be placed directly on the table if it is large enough to hold all materials and still have a clear work space to complete activities. Alternatively, materials could be placed on the floor near the table. When learners are first beginning to use activity schedules, the idea is to have the materials close at hand to reduce travel time and the potential for distraction. Once learners have mastered the basic components of activity schedule following, materials can be placed in their natural locations.
Sequence of Activity Schedule Following
Learners are taught, through a procedure called “graduated guidance,” described in the next section on prompting procedures, to follow the activity schedule. The following sequence of behaviors constitutes “following the schedule”:
-
1.
Retrieve the schedule (obtain the tablet or other digital device) and place it on the table/floor where activities will be completed.
-
2.
Open the schedule file/program (Steps 1 and 2 may be completed by a parent or teacher for a digital schedule, depending on the learner’s level of familiarity with the technology).
-
3.
Touch the picture of the activity (an observing response).
-
4.
Obtain the materials necessary for completing the activity (e.g., retrieve the pictured puzzle from a shelf).
-
5.
Complete the activity.
-
6.
Return the materials back to their original location.
-
7.
“Turn the page” on the digital schedule to display the next activity by touching or clicking on the arrow in the bottom-right corner of the screen.
-
8.
Repeat Steps 3–7 until reaching the terminal reinforcer page and consuming the reinforcer.
-
9.
Return the digital device to its original location or close the program.
Prompting Procedures and Error Correction
In an effort to reduce dependence on adult-provided verbal prompts and instructions, learners are taught to follow activity schedules exclusively via physical prompts delivered from behind the learner, so as not to block the learner’s view of the relevant visual stimuli that should control their behavior (McClannahan & Krantz, 1999). The only verbal instruction given to the learner should be the initial instruction to begin completing the schedule (e.g., “It’s time to do your activity schedule. Here you go!”). After that, the person assisting the learner to follow the schedule should not provide any additional verbal instructions, verbal prompts, or conversation until the schedule is completed (unless one of the included activities is a social activity during which verbal interaction would be appropriate). The amount of physical prompting provided will depend on each individual learner’s abilities but will often begin with hand-over-hand guidance that should be provided in a way that allows the learner to complete the schedule with as few errors as possible. This physical guidance should be faded as quickly as possible to avoid prompt dependence. A typical fading sequence would begin with hand-over-hand guidance that is progressively faded to physical prompts at the wrist, forearm, elbow, and shoulder, followed by gradually increased physical distance between the prompter and the learner. We have found that light physical prompts from behind at the shoulders are particularly effective for guiding learners back and forth between the schedule and the activity materials. Fading can take place dynamically within sessions or can be scripted across sessions. One practical method for prompt fading that has been particularly useful when parents are the primary implementers is that used by Gerencser et al. (2017), where test sessions are periodically run using a 5-s prompt delay procedure to determine the steps a learner can complete independently. Prompts that the learner needed to complete the task are recorded on a data sheet, which then serves as a teaching guide for sessions until the next test session is conducted (see the Appendix, Fig. 28, for a sample data sheet). Behavior analysts who have the capacity to view sessions live through videoconference technology could also provide parents with fading suggestions in real time.
When learners make errors, the type of error will determine how the implementer/prompter should respond. If the learner begins to drift off task or begins to engage in stereotypy with schedule materials, the implementer/prompter should simply interrupt this behavior and physically redirect the learner to complete the activity correctly. However, if the learner obtains the incorrect materials after touching the picture representing those materials, he or she should be redirected back to the schedule, physically prompted to touch the picture of the materials again, and physically guided to obtain the correct materials. This helps ensure that learner behavior comes under the control of the schedule.
Advanced Activity Schedule Components
Once learners have mastered following basic activity schedules with brief, close-ended activities, more complex activities can be introduced. For example, implementers can add choice pages in which the learner can select from two or more available activities. On a close-ended activity schedule that a learner previously mastered, choice pages could be added to the schedule to replace one or more of the close-ended activities. Learners can also be taught to set and respond to digital timers using visual cues in order to include open-ended activities in the digital schedule. Red circles representing the number of minutes for the activity and a green circle representing the start button are placed below the picture of the open-ended activity. The minute button on the digital timer is also colored red and the start/stop button colored green. The learner is physically prompted to touch each circle below the picture and the corresponding colored button on the timer to set and start the timer. Responding to these more complex activity schedule pages can often be taught via graduated guidance within activity schedule sessions. If a learner requires more practice, modeling and teaching sessions with timers and choice pages could occur outside of activity schedule sessions (Higbee & Sellers, 2017; McClannahan & Krantz, 1999).
Data Collection
Learner performance can be measured by scoring steps from the schedule-following sequence that were performed independently by the learner. A sample data sheet is included in the Appendix, Fig. 28. Whereas collecting data during each teaching session would be ideal during the initial stages of learning, Gerencser et al. (2017) suggest using test sessions that may provide sufficient data to make decisions about prompt levels. An example of the data sheet that is similar to the one used by Gerencser et al. is provided in the Appendix, Fig. 29. Also, when parents are implementing activity schedules, behavior analysts could score performance viewed live through videoconferencing technology or via recorded sessions sent electronically by parents.