Spatial Integration of Natural Gas Markets: a Literature Review
- 80 Downloads
Purpose of Review
The purpose of this paper is to clarify the definition of an integrated market and to provide a commented overview of the different empirical methodologies that have been proposed to assess the degree of spatial integration of natural gas markets.
In recent years, the methodologies assessing gas market integration have evolved from simple empirical works based solely on price data analyses to more complex ones based on the theoretical notion of spatial equilibrium capturing the effects of both price and non-price data.
A number of liberalization reforms have stimulated the emergence of spatially diverse markets for wholesale natural gas interconnected through spatial arbitrage, which plays a crucial role in the determination of local prices. In recent years, a vast and rapidly growing empirical literature has emerged to examine the degree of integration of these markets. A close examination of this literature has shown that only a handful of studies pay attention to the theoretical notion of market integration and account for the role played by trade flows, capacity constraints, and unit transaction costs.
KeywordsSpatial integration Law of one price Integration of gas markets Natural gas markets Market integration Price convergence
We are grateful to Ramteen Sioshansi and to two anonymous referees for a series of useful suggestions that helped us to improve the article.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
Ekaterina Dukhanina and Olivier Massol declare no conflicts of interest.
Human and Animal Rights and Informed Consent
This article does not contain any studies with human or animal subjects performed by any of the authors.
Papers of particular interest, published recently, have been highlighted as: • Of importance •• Of major importance
- 1.ACER. European Gas Target model review and update. January 2015.Google Scholar
- 2.European Commission. Energy union package. February 2015.Google Scholar
- 3.European Parliament. Energy union: key decisions for the realisation of a fully integrated energy market. April, 2016.Google Scholar
- 4.Cournot A-A Recherches sur les Principes Mathématiques de la Théorie des Richesses. 1838. Paris.Google Scholar
- 5.Marshall A. Principles of economics. Book five: general relations of demand, supply and value. Chapter 1. 1890.Google Scholar
- 6.IGU World LNG report – 2015 Edition I.Google Scholar
- 10.Samuelson PA. Spatial price equilibrium and linear programming. Am Econ Rev. 1952;42(3):283–303.Google Scholar
- 11.Takayama T, Judge GC. Spatial and temporal price and allocation models. Amsterdam: North- Holland; 1971.Google Scholar
- 17.De Vany A, Walls WD. Pipeline Access and Market integration in the natural gas industry: evidence from cointegration tests. Energy J. 1993;14(4):1–19.Google Scholar
- 19.Walls D. Price Convergence across Natural Gas Fields and City Markets. The Energy Journal. 1994;15(4):37–48.Google Scholar
- 28.Brown SPA, Yücel MK. Market arbitrage: European and North American natural gas prices. Energy J Special Issue. 2009:167–85. https://doi.org/10.5547/issn0195-6574-ej-vol30-nosi-11.
- 34.• Olsen KK, Mjelde JW, Bessler DA. Price formulation and the law of one price in internationally linked markets: an examination of the natural gas markets in the USA and Canada. Ann Reg Sci. 2015;54(1):117–42. In addition to VECM estimation the paper performs directed acyclic graph and variance decomposition analyses. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 35.• Growitsch C, Stronzik M, Nepal R. Price convergence and information efficiency in German natural gas markets. German Econ Rev. 2015;16(1):87–103. The paper covers different methodologies of assessment of the market integration and attempts to account for transportation costs. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 38.Neumann A, Cullmann A. What’s the story with natural gas markets in Europe? Empirical evidence from spot trade data. 9th international conference on the European energy market. 2012.Google Scholar
- 40.Neumann A. Linking natural gas markets—is LNG doing its job? Energy J Special Issue. 2009;30:187–99.Google Scholar
- 41.Mu X, Ye H. Towards an integrated spot LNG market: an interim assessment. Energy J. 2018;39(1)Google Scholar
- 42.• Li R, Joyeux R, Ripple RD. International natural gas market integration. The Energy Journal. 2014;35(4):159–79. The paper employs recent methodologies based on price convergence and assesses the degree of market integration between different regions using pipeline and LNG prices. CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- 45.Taylor AM. Potential pitfalls for the purchasing-power-parity puzzle? Sampling and specification biases in mean-reversion tests of the law of one price. Econometrica, 2001:9(2): 473–498.Google Scholar
- 50.•• Massol O, Banal-Estañol A. Market power and spatial arbitrage between interconnected gas hubs. USAEE Working Paper No. 16–281. 2016. The paper applies a new approach based on spatial equilibrium theory and accounts for transportation costs, trade flows, and capacity constraints. Google Scholar
- 54.Platts LNG Daily, 2016. https://www.platts.com/IM.Platts.Content/ProductsServices/Products/lngdaily.pdf