Abstract
Objectives
To compare pre-season to post-season changes on a battery of clinical neurological outcome measures between non-contact, contact, and collision sport athletes over multiple seasons of play.
Methods
244 high school and collegiate athletes participating in multiple non-contact, contact, and collision sports completed standardized annual pre-season and post-season assessments over 1–4 years. Pre/post-season changes in 10 outcome measures assessing concussion symptoms, neurocognitive performance, and balance were compared between the groups using linear mixed models.
Results
Small, but statistically significant overall pre/post-season change differences were present between the groups for Axon computerized neurocognitive test processing speed, attention, and working memory speed scores (Axon-PS, Axon-Att, Axon-WMS), as well as Balance Error Scoring System (BESS) total score. Small seasonal declines not exceeding reliable-change thresholds were observed in the collision sport group relative to the contact and non-contact groups for Axon-PS and Axon-Att scores. The collision and contact sport groups demonstrated less pre-/post-season improvement than the non-contact sport group for Axon-WMA and BESS, with less BESS improvement also observed in the collision sport group relative to the contact sport group. Overall, longitudinal performance on all 10 outcome measures remained stable in all 3 groups over 4 years.
Conclusion
Our findings do not necessarily support the notion that participation in sports associated with exposure to repetitive head impacts has clinically meaningful cumulative effects over the course of a season, nor over four consecutive seasons in high school and collegiate athletes.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
N. F. S. H. S. A. National. (2016, March 9, 2016). 2014–2015 High School Athletics Participaiton Survey. http://www.nfhs.org/ParticipationStatics/PDF/2014-15_Participation_Survey_Results.pdf.
N. National. (2016, December 12, 2017). NCAA Sports Sponsorship and Participation Rates Report: Student-Athlete Participation 1981–1981–2015–2016. http://www.ncaapublications.com/productdownloads/PR1516.pdf.
Talavage TM, Nauman EA, Breedlove EL, Yoruk U, Dye AE, Morigaki KE, et al. Functionally-detected cognitive impairment in high school football players without clinically-diagnosed concussion. J Neurotrauma. 2014;31:327–38.
Breedlove EL, Robinson M, Talavage TM, Morigaki KE, Yoruk U, O’Keefe K, et al. Biomechanical correlates of symptomatic and asymptomatic neurophysiological impairment in high school football. J Biomech. 2012;45:1265–72.
Nauman EA, Breedlove KM, Breedlove EL, Talavage TM, Robinson ME, Leverenz LJ. Post-season neurophysiological deficits assessed by ImPACT and fMRI in athletes competing in American football. Dev Neuropsychol. 2015;40:85–91.
Abbas K, Shenk TE, Poole VN, Breedlove EL, Leverenz LJ, Nauman EA, et al. Alteration of default mode network in high school football athletes due to repetitive subconcussive mild traumatic brain injury: a resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging study. Brain Connect. 2015;5:91–101.
Abbas K, Shenk TE, Poole VN, Robinson ME, Leverenz LJ, Nauman EA, et al. Effects of repetitive sub-concussive brain injury on the functional connectivity of Default Mode Network in high school football athletes. Dev Neuropsychol. 2015;40:51–6.
Johnson B, Neuberger T, Gay M, Hallett M, Slobounov S. Effects of subconcussive head trauma on the default mode network of the brain. J Neurotrauma. 2014;31:1907–13.
Slobounov SM, Walter A, Breiter HC, Zhu DC, Bai X, Bream T, et al. The effect of repetitive subconcussive collisions on brain integrity in collegiate football players over a single football season: a multi-modal neuroimaging study. Neuroimage Clin. 2017;14:708–18.
Churchill NW, Hutchison MG, Di Battista AP, Graham SJ, Schweizer TA. Structural, functional, and metabolic brain markers differentiate collision versus contact and non-contact athletes. Front Neurol. 2017;8:390.
Davenport EM, Whitlow CT, Urban JE, Espeland MA, Jung Y, Rosenbaum DA, et al. Abnormal white matter integrity related to head impact exposure in a season of high school varsity football. J Neurotrauma. 2014;31:1617–24.
Davenport EM, Apkarian K, Whitlow CT, Urban JE, Jensen JH, Szuch E, et al. Abnormalities in diffusional kurtosis metrics related to head impact exposure in a season of high school varsity football. J Neurotrauma. 2016;33:2133–46.
Bahrami N, Sharma D, Rosenthal S, Davenport EM, Urban JE, Wagner B, et al. Subconcussive head impact exposure and white matter tract changes over a single season of youth football. Radiology. 2016;281:919–26.
Bazarian JJ, Zhu T, Blyth B, Borrino A, Zhong J. Subject-specific changes in brain white matter on diffusion tensor imaging after sports-related concussion. Magn Reson Imaging. 2012;30:171–80.
Bazarian JJ, Zhu T, Zhong J, Janigro D, Rozen E, Roberts A, et al. Persistent, long-term cerebral white matter changes after sports-related repetitive head impacts. PLoS One. 2014;9:e94734.
Merchant-Borna K, Asselin P, Narayan D, Abar B, Jones CM, Bazarian JJ. Novel method of weighting cumulative helmet impacts improves correlation with brain white matter changes after one football Season of sub-concussive head blows. Ann Biomed Eng. 2016;44:3679–92.
Mayinger MC, Merchant-Borna K, Hufschmidt J, Muehlmann M, Weir IR, Rauchmann BS, et al. White matter alterations in college football players: a longitudinal diffusion tensor imaging study. Brain Imaging Behav. 2017;12:44–53.
Chun IY, Mao X, Breedlove EL, Leverenz LJ, Nauman EA, Talavage TM. DTI detection of longitudinal WM Abnormalities due to accumulated head impacts. Dev Neuropsychol. 2015;40:92–7.
McAllister TW, Ford JC, Flashman LA, Maerlender A, Greenwald RM, Beckwith JG, et al. Effect of head impacts on diffusivity measures in a cohort of collegiate contact sport athletes. Neurology. 2014;82:63–9.
Koerte IK, Ertl-Wagner B, Reiser M, Zafonte R, Shenton ME. White matter integrity in the brains of professional soccer players without a symptomatic concussion. JAMA. 2012;308:1859–61.
Poole VN, Abbas K, Shenk TE, Breedlove EL, Breedlove KM, Robinson ME, et al. MR spectroscopic evidence of brain injury in the non-diagnosed collision sport athlete. Dev Neuropsychol. 2014;39:459–73.
Poole VN, Breedlove EL, Shenk TE, Abbas K, Robinson ME, Leverenz LJ, et al. Sub-concussive hit characteristics predict deviant brain metabolism in football athletes. Dev Neuropsychol. 2015;40:12–7.
Kawata K, Rubin LH, Takahagi M, Lee JH, Sim T, Szwanki V, et al. Subconcussive impact-dependent increase in plasma S100beta levels in collegiate football players. J Neurotrauma. 2017;34:2254–60.
Wilson MJ, Harkrider AW, King KA. Effect of repetitive, subconcussive impacts on electrophysiological measures of attention. South Med J. 2015;108:559–66.
Gysland SM, Mihalik JP, Register-Mihalik JK, Trulock SC, Shields EW, Guskiewicz KM. The relationship between subconcussive impacts and concussion history on clinical measures of neurologic function in collegiate football players. Ann Biomed Eng. 2012;40:14–22.
Brett BL, Solomon GS. Comparison of neurocognitive performance in contact and noncontact nonconcussed high school athletes across a two-year interval. Dev Neuropsychol. 2017;42:70–82.
McAllister TW, Flashman LA, Maerlender A, Greenwald RM, Beckwith JG, Tosteson TD, et al. Cognitive effects of one season of head impacts in a cohort of collegiate contact sport athletes. Neurology. 2012;78:1777–84.
Koerte IK, Nichols E, Tripodis Y, Schultz V, Lehner S, Igbinoba R, et al. Impaired cognitive performance in youth athletes exposed to repetitive head impacts. J Neurotrauma. 2017;34:2389–95.
Miyashita TL, Diakogeorgiou E, Marrie K. Correlation of head impacts to change in balance error scoring system scores in division I men’s lacrosse players. Sports Health. 2017;9:318–23.
Murray NG, Grimes KE, Shiflett ED, Munkasy BA, D’Amico NR, Mormile ME, et al. Repetitive head impacts do not affect postural control following a competitive athletic season. Int J Psychophysiol. 2017;132:81–6.
Kawata K, Rubin LH, Lee JH, Sim T, Takahagi M, Szwanki V, et al. Association of football subconcussive head impacts with ocular near point of convergence. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2016;134:763–9.
Brokaw EB, Fine MS, Kindschi KE, Santago II, Lum PS, Higgins M. Cross-sectional evaluation of visuomotor tracking performance following subconcussive head impacts. Technol Health Care. 2017;26:109–18.
Belanger HG, Vanderploeg RD, McAllister T. Subconcussive blows to the head: a formative review of short-term clinical outcomes. J Head Trauma Rehabil. 2016;31:159–66.
Mac Donald CL, Dikranian K, Song SK, Bayly PV, Holtzman DM, Brody DL. Detection of traumatic axonal injury with diffusion tensor imaging in a mouse model of traumatic brain injury. Exp Neurol. 2007;205:116–31.
Budde MD, Janes L, Gold E, Turtzo LC, Frank JA. The contribution of gliosis to diffusion tensor anisotropy and tractography following traumatic brain injury: validation in the rat using Fourier analysis of stained tissue sections. Brain. 2011;134:2248–60.
Mackey AP, Whitaker KJ, Bunge SA. Experience-dependent plasticity in white matter microstructure: reasoning training alters structural connectivity. Front Neuroanat. 2012;6:32.
Scholz J, Klein MC, Behrens TE, Johansen-Berg H. Training induces changes in white-matter architecture. Nat Neurosci. 2009;12:1370–1.
Broglio SP, McCrea M, McAllister T, Harezlak J, Katz B, Hack D, et al. A National Study on the Effects of Concussion in Collegiate Athletes and US Military Service Academy Members: The NCAA-DoD Concussion Assessment, Research and Education (CARE) Consortium Structure and Methods. Sports Med. 2017;47:1437–51.
McCrory P, Meeuwisse W, Johnston K, Dvorak J, Aubry M, Molloy M, et al. Consensus statement on Concussion in Sport 3rd International Conference on Concussion in Sport held in Zurich, November 2008. Clin J Sport Med. 2009;19:185–200.
Meachen SJ, Hanks RA, Millis SR, Rapport LJ. The reliability and validity of the brief symptom inventory—18 in persons with traumatic brain injury. Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 2008;89:958–65.
Pavot W, Diener E, Colvin CR, Sandvik E. Further validation of the Satisfaction with Life Scale: evidence for the cross-method convergence of well-being measures. J Pers Assess. 1991;57:149–61.
McCrea M, Kelly JP, Randolph C, Kluge J, Bartolic E, Finn G, et al. Standardized assessment of concussion (SAC): on-site mental status evaluation of the athlete. J Head Trauma Rehabil. 1998;13:27–35.
Barr WB, McCrea M. Sensitivity and specificity of standardized neurocognitive testing immediately following sports concussion. J Int Neuropsychol Soc. 2001;7:693–702.
Eckner JT, Kutcher JS, Broglio SP, Richardson JK. Effect of sport-related concussion on clinically measured simple reaction time. Br J Sports Med. 2014;48:112–8.
Eckner JT, Whitacre RD, Kirsch NL, Richardson JK. Evaluating a clinical measure of reaction time: an observational study. Percept Mot Skills. 2009;108:717–20.
McCrory P, Makdissi M, Davis G, Collie A. Value of neuropsychological testing after head injuries in football. Br J Sports Med. 2005;39(suppl 1):i58–63.
Iverson GL, Lovell MR, Collins MW. Interpreting change on ImPACT following sport concussion. Clin Neuropsychol. 2003;17:460–7.
Gualtieri CT, Johnson LG. Reliability and validity of a computerized neurocognitive test battery, CNS Vital Signs. Arch Clin Neuropsychol. 2006;21:623–43.
Guskiewicz KM, Ross SE, Marshall SW. Postural stability and neuropsychological deficits after concussion in collegiate athletes. J Athl Train. 2001;36:263–73.
Rice SG. American Academy of Pediatrics Council on Sports, and Fitness. Medical conditions affecting sports participation. Pediatrics. 2008;121:841–8.
Derogatis LR. BSI 18. Brief Symptom Inventory 18: Administration, scoring and procedures manual: NCS Pearson, Incorporated. 2001.
Lipton RB, Dodick D, Sadovsky R, Kolodner K, Endicott J, Hettiarachchi J, et al. A self-administered screener for migraine in primary care: the ID Migraine validation study. Neurology. 2003;61:375–82.
Broglio SP, Katz BP, Zhao S, McCrea M, McAllister T, CC Investigators. Test-retest reliability and interpretation of common concussion assessment tools: findings from the NCAA-DoD CARE Consortium. Sports Med. 2018;48:1255–68.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank Ms. Courtney McDonald, Ms. Ashley Rettmann, Ms. Lea Franco, and Mr. Max Bowen for their important contributions to this project, as well as all of the additional research and medical staff at the University of Michigan, Medical College of Wisconsin, University of California Los Angeles, and University of North Carolina. Primary funding for this work was provided through a research grant from the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). This project utilized a REDCap database housed at the Medical College of Wisconsin and supported by the Clinical & Translational Science Institute of Southeast Wisconsin (UL1TR001436). Dr. Eckner received effort support during the project period through career development awards from the Rehabilitation Medicine Scientist Training Program (RMSTP) and the National Institutes of Health (K23 HD078502-03). This publication was also made possible, in part, with support from the Grand Alliance CARE Consortium, funded by the NCAA and the DoD. The USAMRAA, Fort Detrick, MD, USA, is the awarding and administering acquisition office. This work was supported by the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health Affairs through the Psychological Health and Traumatic Brain Injury Program under Award No. W81XWH-14-2-0151. Opinions, interpretations, conclusions and recommendations are those of the authors and are not necessarily endorsed by the DoD (DHP funds).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
This study was performed in accordance with the standards of ethics outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki. All participants provided informed written consent (or written assent with parental consent, for minors) prior to participation in this study. This research was approved by the Institutional Review Boards at the University of Michigan, Medical College of Wisconsin, University of California Los Angeles, and University of North Carolina. All sources of funding for this study are listed in the Acknowledgements.
Conflict of Interest:
In the previous 36 months and during the project period: Author Eckner has received unrelated research funding from the following: US Department of Health and Human Services, National Institutes of Health, NICHD; Rehabilitation Medicine Scientist Training Program; University of Michigan; Foundation for Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation; ElMindA Ltd; he is co-inventor of US patent 8,657,295 owned by employer University of Michigan; he was a paid grant reviewer for SRA International; he received speaker honoraria from the University of Utah and the American College of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons/Canadian Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons Joint Annual Conference. Author Nelson has received unrelated research funding from the NIH, Advancing a Healthier Wisconsin, Department of Defense, National Collegiate Athletic Association. Author Giza has received unrelated research funding from the following: NIH/NINDS, UCLA Brain Injury Research Center, UCLA Steve Tisch BrainSPORT Program, Easton Clinic for Brain Health; he has received consultant fees from Neural Analytics Inc.; he has been a paid advisory panel member for Highmark Interactive with stock/stock options and an unpaid advisory panel member for the MLS, NBA, US Soccer, and NCAA (travel reimbursement only for MLS and NCAA); he has been a Data Safety Monitoring Board member for LA Biomed Institute; he has received payment for providing expert medical-legal testimony; he receives book royalties from Wiley Publishing; he has received speaker honoraria for Sports Neurology lectures at multiple academic and medical institutions; he is a clinical consultant to the LA Lakers, NFL-Neurological Care Program, NHL Players Association. Author Guskiewicz has received unrelated research funding from the following: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; Department of Defense; National Collegiate Athletic Association; National Football League. Authors Wang, Bancroft, Pohorence, Broglio, He, Kutcher, and McCrea declare no conflicts.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Eckner, J.T., Wang, J., Nelson, L.D. et al. Effect of Routine Sport Participation on Short-Term Clinical Neurological Outcomes: A Comparison of Non-Contact, Contact, and Collision Sport Athletes. Sports Med 50, 1027–1038 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-019-01200-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-019-01200-y