A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Concussion in Rugby Union
- 3.7k Downloads
Rugby Union, a popular full-contact sport played throughout the world, has one of the highest rates of concussion of all full-contact sports.
The aim of the current review was to systematically evaluate the available evidence on concussion in Rugby Union and to conduct a meta-analysis of findings regarding the incidence of concussion.
Articles were retrieved via a number of online databases. The current review examined all articles published in English up to May 2014 pertaining to concussion in Rugby Union players. The key search terms included ‘Rugby Union’, ‘rugby’, ‘union’, and ‘football’, in combination with the injury terms ‘athletic injuries’, ‘concussion’, ‘sports concussion’, ‘sports-related concussion’, ‘brain concussion’, ‘brain injury’, ‘brain injuries’, ‘mild traumatic brain injury’, ‘mTBI’, ‘traumatic brain injury’, ‘TBI’, ‘craniocerebral trauma’, ‘head injury’, and ‘brain damage’.
The final search outcome following the eligibility screening process resulted in the inclusion of 96 articles for this review. The meta-analysis included a total of 37 studies. The results of the meta-analysis revealed an overall incidence of match-play concussion in men’s rugby-15s of 4.73 per 1,000 player match hours. The incidence of concussion during training was 0.07 per 1,000 practice hours. The incidence of concussion in women’s rugby-15s was 0.55 per 1,000 player match hours. In men’s rugby-7s match-play, concussion incidence was 3.01 per 1,000 player match hours. The incidence of concussion varied considerably between levels of play, with elite level play recording a rate of 0.40 concussions per 1,000 player match hours, schoolboy level 0.62 concussions per 1,000 player match hours, and the community or sub-elite level recording a rate of 2.08 concussions per 1,000 player match hours. The incidence of concussion in men’s rugby-15s as a function of playing position (forwards vs. backs) was 4.02 and 4.85 concussions per 1,000 player match hours, respectively.
Concussion is a common injury sustained and reported in match play and to a lesser extent during practice by Rugby Union players. Based on the available published data, there appears to be a variation in risk of concussion across level of play, with the sub-elite level having the greatest incidence of injury. Future research focused on studying the acute consequences and best management strategies in current players, and the potential longer term outcomes of concussion in retired players, is needed. A focus on the areas of prevention, injury identification, and medical management, and risk for long-term outcomes will be of benefit to current athletes.
KeywordsChronic Traumatic Encephalopathy Rugby Player Rugby League Elite Level Player Match
The authors thank Debbie Booth from the University of Newcastle for her assistance with the initial database search and Sarah Hiles from the University of Newcastle for her assistance with methodology regarding meta-analysis. Funding was provided by the Brain Foundation, Australia; NSW Sporting Injuries Committee; and Hunter Medical Research Institute (HMRI) funded by Jennie Thomas.
Conflict of interest
The authors do not have any conflicts of interest to declare.
Andrew Gardner has a clinical practice in neuropsychology involving individuals who have sustained sports-related concussion (including current and former athletes). He has received travel funding from the Australian Football League (AFL) to present at the Concussion in Football Conference in 2013. Previous grant funding includes the New South Wales (NSW) Sporting Injuries Committee, the Brain Foundation, and the Hunter Medical Research Institute, supported by Jennie Thomas. Grant Iverson, Ph.D., has been reimbursed by the Government, professional scientific bodies, and commercial organizations for discussing or presenting research relating to mild traumatic brain injury (TBI) and sport-related concussion at meetings, scientific conferences, and symposiums. He has a clinical and consulting practice in forensic neuropsychology involving individuals who have sustained mild TBIs. He has received research funding from several test publishing companies, including ImPACT Applications, Inc., CNS Vital Signs, and Psychological Assessment Resources (PAR, Inc.). He is a co-investigator, collaborator, or consultant on grants relating to mild TBI funded by several organisations, including, but not limited to, the Canadian Institute of Health Research, Alcohol Beverage Medical Research Council, Rehabilitation Research and Development (RR&D) Service of the US Department of Veterans Affairs, Vancouver Coastal Health Research Institute, and Roche Diagnostics Canada.
- 1.International Rugby Board (IRB). IRB strategic plan. http://www.irb.com/aboutirb/organisation/strategic/index.html. Accessed April 29, 2014.
- 2.International Rugby Board (IRB). IRB playing charter. http://www.irb.com/mm/Document/AboutIRB/0/PLAYINGCHARTER_6259.pdf. Accessed 29 April 2014.
- 6.Sedaud A, Marc A, Schipman J, et al. How they won the Rugby World Cup through height, mass and collective experience. Br J Sports Med. 2012;46(8):580–4.Google Scholar
- 8.Eaves S, Hughes M. Patterns of international rugby union teams before and after the introduction of professional status. Int J Perform Anal Sport. 2003;3(2):103–11.Google Scholar
- 10.Hendricks S, Karpul D, Nicolls F, et al. Velocity and acceleration before contact in the tackle during rugby union matches. J Sports Sci. 2012;20(12):1215–24.Google Scholar
- 17.Dixon G. Morbidity of rugby union injuries in New Zealand. NZ J Sports Med. 1993;21(2):18–20.Google Scholar
- 18.Yard EE, Comstock RD. Injuries sustained by rugby players presenting to United States emergency departments, 1978 through 2004. J Athlet Train. 2006;41(3):325–31.Google Scholar
- 26.IRB. International Rugby Board Concussion Guidance for General Public Document. Available from: http://irbplayerwelfare.com/pdfs/Concussion_Guidance_for_the_General_Public_EN.pdf. Accessed on April 25, 2014.
- 31.Toth C. Injuries to the nervous system occurring in sport and recreation: a systematic review. Crit Rev Phys Rehabil Med. 2006;18(3):205–56.Google Scholar
- 33.Chachad S, Khan A. Concussion in the athlete: a review. Clin Pediatr (Phila). 2006;45(3):285–8.Google Scholar
- 36.Rugby Football Union. Rugby Football Union (RFU) Concussion Resource Document. http://www.rfu.com/takingpart/playerhealth/concussion/~/media/files/2013/taking%20part/concussion/2%20concussion%20in%20rugby.ashx. Accessed 20 May 2014.
- 39.Rosenthal R. The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results. Psychol Bull. 1979;86(3):638–41.Google Scholar
- 49.Watson AWS. Injuries in schoolboy players of basketball, field-hockey, hurling, Gaelic football, rugby and soccer. NZ J Sports Med. 1997;25(2):22–4.Google Scholar
- 54.McKenna S, Borman B, Findlay J, et al. Sports injuries in New Zealand. NZ Med J. 1986;99(814):899–901.Google Scholar
- 59.Lingard DA, Sharrock NE, Salmond CE. Risk factors of sports injuries in winter. NZ Med J. 1976;83(557):69–73.Google Scholar
- 63.England Professional Rugby Injury Surveillance Project: 2010–2011 Season Report. http://www.irbplayerwelfare.com/pdfs/RFU_Community_Rugby_Injury_Surveillance_Report_10_11_EN.pdf. Accessed May 20, 2014.
- 64.England Professional Rugby Injury Surveillance Project: 2011–2012 Season Report. http://www.rfu.com/~/media/files/2013/thegame/rfu_injury%20audit%202013_web.ashx?utm_source=mdm&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=England+Professional+Rugby+Injury+Surveillance+Project. Accessed May 20, 2014.
- 65.England Professional Rugby Injury Surveillance Project: 2012–2013 Season Report. http://www.rfu.com/takingpart/~/media/files/2014/takingpart/injury_audit_report_2014_.ashx. Accessed May 20, 2014.
- 66.RFU Community Rugby Injury Surveillance Project CRISP: 2011–2012 Season Report Summary Information. http://www.rfu.com/~/media/files/2013/taking%20part/playerhealth/130402_crisp_season_report_1112_rev_2.pdf. Accessed May 20, 2014.
- 67.Roberts SP, Trewartha G, England M, et al. Epidemiology of time-loss injuries in English community-level rugby union. Br Med J. 2013;3(11):e003998.Google Scholar
- 70.Fuller CW, Taylor A, Raftery M. Epidemiology of concussion in men’s elite Rugby-7s (Sevens World Series) and Rugby-15s (Rugby World Cup, Junior World Championship and Rugby Trophy, Pacific Nations Cup and English Premiership). Br J Sports Med. doi: 10.1136/bjsports-2013-093381.
- 73.Marshall SW, Spencer RJ. Concussion in rugby: the hidden epidemic. J Athlet Train. 2001;36(3):334–8.Google Scholar
- 91.Durie RM, Munroe AD. A prospective survey of injuries in a New Zealand schoolboy rugby population. NZ J Sports Med. 2000;28(4):84–90.Google Scholar
- 114.Knouse CL, Gould TE, Caswell SV, et al. Efficacy of rugby headgear in attenuating repetitive linear impact forces. J Athlet Train. 2003;38(4):330–5.Google Scholar
- 124.Gardner A, Shores EA, Batchelor J, et al. Diagnostic efficiency of ImPACT and CogSport in concussed rugby union players who have not undergone baseline neurocognitive testing. Appl Neuropsychol. 2012;19(2):98–107.Google Scholar
- 127.Shuttleworth-Edwards AB, Radloff SE. Compromised visuomotor processing speed in players of rugby union from school through to the national adult level. Arch Clin Neuropsychol. 2008;23(5):511–20.Google Scholar