Abstract
Several challenges are encountered in the development of maraging steels with desired combinations of mechanical properties. These include the need to explore a large process design space, the time- and effort-consuming standardized testing protocols for property evaluations, and the lack of a formal design of experiments strategy that guides the selection of the process conditions for the next set of experiments based on a thorough analyses of the previously accumulated data. In this work, we explored the effect of the different combinations of the aging temperature and the aging time on the yield strength of 350-grade maraging steels using high-throughput protocols. For this purpose, a total of 21 small volumes of differently aged samples were produced and studied using spherical nanoindentation stress–strain protocols. Furthermore, the results of these tests were modeled using Gaussian process regression (GPR) to establish data-driven linkages between the yield strengths and the aging parameters. The predicted yield strengths were found to be in reasonable agreement with the experimentally measured ones. It is also demonstrated that the GPR model can provide objective guidance in the selection of the next set of experiments.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Viswanathan UK, Dey GK, Asundi MK (1993) Precipitation hardening in 350 grade maraging steel. Metall Trans A 24:2429–2442
Floreen S (1968) The physical metallurgy of maraging steels. Metall Rev 13(1):115–128
Weiss BZ (1983) Maraging steels—structure, properties and applications. In: Comins NR, Clark JB (eds) Specialty steels and hard materials. Pergamon, New York, pp 35–54
Singh GK, Ghosh MM (2017) Study on precipitation hardening of C 250 grade maraging steel. Trans Indian Inst Met 70(8):2111–2122
Tewari R, Mazumder S, Batra IS, Dey GK, Banerjee S (2000) Precipitation in 18 wt% Ni maraging steel of grade 350. Acta Mater 48:1187–1200
Fielding LCD (2014) Understanding toughness and ductility in novel steels with mixed microstructures. University of Cambridge, Cambridge
Rack HJ, Kalish D (1971) The strength and fracture toughness of 18Ni(350) maraging steel. Metall Mater Trans B 2(11):3011–3020
Marcisz J, Adamczyk M, Garbarz B (2017) Optimisation of mechanical properties of 18% Ni 350 grade maraging steel using novel heat treatment. Arch Metall Mater 62(1):73–84
Abramov OV, Il’in AI, Kardonskii VM (1983) Effect of heat treatment on the mechanical properties of maraging steel. Metal Sci Heat Treat 25(4):298–301
Kladaric I, Kozak D, Krumes D (2009) The effect of aging parameters on properties of maraging steel. Mater Manuf Process 24(7–8):747–749
Lima Filho VX, Barros IF, Abreu HFGD (2017) Influence of solution annealing on microstructure and mechanical properties of maraging 300 steel. Mater Res 20:10–14
Tavares SSM, Pardal JM, Martins TRDB, Schmitt VM, Szlejf JFV (2017) Influence of austenitizing on the mechanical properties of maraging 300 and Sae 4340 steels—comparative study. Mater Res 20:39–46
Viswanathan UK, Kishore R, Asundi MK (1996) Effect of thermal cycling on the mechanical properties of 350-grade maraging steel. Metall Mater Trans A 27(3):757–761
Ooi SW, Hill P, Rawson M, Bhadeshia HKDH (2013) Effect of retained austenite and high temperature laves phase on the work hardening of an experimental maraging steel. Mater Sci Eng A 564:485–492
Morito S, Igarashi R, Kamiya K, Ohba T, Maki T (2010) Effect of cooling rate on morphology and crystallography of lath martensite in Fe–Ni alloys. Mater Sci Forum 638–642:1459–1463
Ali M, Porter D, Kömi J, Eissa M, El Faramawy H, Mattar T (2019) Effect of cooling rate and composition on microstructure and mechanical properties of ultrahigh-strength steels. J Iron Steel Res Int 26(12):1350–1365
Simm TH, Sun L, Galvin DR, Hill P, Rawson M, Birosca S, Gilbert EP, Bhadeshia H, Perkins K (2017) The effect of a two-stage heat-treatment on the microstructural and mechanical properties of a maraging steel. Materials (Basel, Switzerland) 10(12):1346
Polanski M, Kwiatkowska M, Kunce I, Bystrzycki J (2013) Combinatorial synthesis of alloy libraries with a progressive composition gradient using laser engineered net shaping (LENS): hydrogen storage alloys. Int J Hydrog Energy 38(12159):12171
Baron C, Springer H, Raabe D (2016) Combinatorial screening of the microstructure–property relationships for Fe–B–X stiff, light, strong and ductile steels. Mater Des 112:131–139
Ding S, Liu Y, Li Y, Liu Z, Sohn S, Walker FJ, Schroers J (2014) Combinatorial development of bulk metallic glasses. Nat Mater 13:494–500
Potyrailo R, Rajan K, Stoewe K, Takeuchi I, Chisholm B, Lam H (2011) Combinatorial and high-throughput screening of materials libraries: review of state of the art. ACS Comb Sci 13:579–633
Springer H, Belde M, Raabe D (2013) Bulk combinatorial design of ductile martensitic stainless steels through confined martensite-to-austenite reversion. Mater Sci Eng A 582:235–244
Li Z, Ludwig A, Savan A, Springer H, Raabe D (2018) Combinatorial metallurgical synthesis and processing of high-entropy alloys. J Mater Res 33:3156–3169
Weaver JS, Khosravani A, Castillo A, Kalidindi SR (2016) High throughput exploration of process–property linkages in Al-6061 using instrumented spherical microindentation and microstructurally graded samples. Integr Mater Manuf Innov 5:192–211
ASTM A255-10 (2018) Standard test methods for determining hardenability of steel. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA. www.astm.org
Salzbrenner BC, Rodelas JM, Madison JD, Jared BH, Swiler LP, Shen Y-L, Boyce BL (2017) High-throughput stochastic tensile performance of additively manufactured stainless steel. J Mater Process Technol 241:1–12
Boyce B, Salzbrenner B, Rodelas J, Swiler L, Madison J, Jared B, Shen Y-L (2017) Extreme-value statistics reveal rare failure-critical defects in additive manufacturing. Adv Eng Mater 19:1700102
Heckman NM, Ivanoff TA, Roach AM, Jared BH, Tung DJ, Brown-Shaklee HJ, Huber T, Saiz DJ, Koepke JR, Rodelas JM, Madison JD, Salzbrenner BC, Swiler LP, Jones RE, Boyce BL (2019) Automated high-throughput tensile testing reveals stochastic process parameter sensitivity. Mater Sci Eng A 772:138632
Springer H, Raabe D (2012) Rapid alloy prototyping: compositional and thermo-mechanical high throughput bulk combinatorial design of structural materials based on the example of 30Mn–1.2C–xAl triplex steels. Acta Mater 60(12):4950–4959
Wu CP, Tsay LW, Chen C (2003) Notched tensile testing of T-200 maraging steel and its laser welds in hydrogen. Mater Sci Eng A 346(1):302–309
He Y, Yang K, Qu W, Kong F, Su G (2002) Strengthening and toughening of a 2800-MPa grade maraging steel. Mater Lett 56(5):763–769
MacLeod R, Barnett P, Clark J, Cresswell W (2006) Mass-dependent predation risk as a mechanism for house sparrow declines? Biol Lett 2(1):43–46
Hutchinson B, Hagström J, Karlsson O, Lindell D, Tornberg M, Lindberg F, Thuvander M (2011) Microstructures and hardness of as-quenched martensites (0.1–0.5%C). Acta Mater 59(14):5845–5858
Balos S, Rajnovic D, Sidjanin L, Eric Cekic O, Moraca S, Trivkovic M, Dedic M (2019) Vickers hardness indentation size effect in selective laser melted MS1 maraging steel. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part C J Mech Eng Sci. https://doi.org/10.1177/0954406219892301
Ohmura T, Tsuzaki K, Matsuoka S (2001) Nanohardness measurement of high-purity Fe–C martensite. Scr Mater 45(8):889–894
Sakai PR, Lima MSF, Fanton L, Gomes CV, Lombardo S, Silva DF, Abdalla AJ (2015) Comparison of mechanical and microstructural characteristics in maraging 300 steel welded by three different processes: LASER, PLASMA and TIG. Procedia Eng 114:291–297
Qian F, Sharp J, Rainforth WM (2016) Microstructural evolution of Mn-based maraging steels and their influences on mechanical properties. Mater Sci Eng A 674:286–298
Pathak S, Kalidindi SR, Weaver JS, Wang Y, Doerner RP, Mara NA (2017) Probing nanoscale damage gradients in ion-irradiated metals using spherical nanoindentation. Sci Rep 7:1–12
Weaver JS, Priddy MW, McDowell DL, Kalidindi SR (2016) On capturing the grain-scale elastic and plastic anisotropy of alpha-Ti with spherical nanoindentation and electron back-scattered diffraction. Acta Mater 117:23–34
Khosravani A, Morsdorf L, Tasan CC, Kalidindi SR (2018) Multiresolution mechanical characterization of hierarchical materials: spherical nanoindentation on martensitic Fe–Ni–C steels. Acta Mater 153:257–269
Weaver JS, Kalidindi SR (2016) Mechanical characterization of Ti–6Al–4 V titanium alloy at multiple length scales using spherical indentation stress–strain measurements. Mater Des 111:463–472
Gong X, Mohan S, Mendoza M, Gray A, Collins P, Kalidindi SR (2017) High throughput assays for additively manufactured Ti–Ni alloys based on compositional gradients and spherical indentation. Integr Mater Manuf Innov 6:218–228
Pathak S, Kalidindi SR (2015) Spherical nanoindentation stress–strain curves. Mater Sci Eng R Rep 91:1–36
Kalidindi SR, Pathak S (2008) Determination of the effective zero-point and the extraction of spherical nanoindentation stress–strain curves. Acta Mater 56:3523–3532
Guo Z, Sha W (2004) Modelling the correlation between processing parameters and properties of maraging steels using artificial neural network. Comput Mater Sci 29(1):12–28
Fernandez-Zelaia P, Yabansu YC, Kalidindi SR (2019) A comparative study of the efficacy of local/global and parametric/nonparametric machine learning methods for establishing structure–property linkages in high-contrast 3D elastic composites. Integr Mater Manuf Innov 8(2):67–81
Tapia G, Elwany AH, Sang H (2016) Prediction of porosity in metal-based additive manufacturing using spatial Gaussian process models. Addit Manuf 12:282–290
Sabin TJ, Bailer-Jones CAL, Withers PJ (2000) Accelerated learning using Gaussian process models to predict static recrystallization in an Al–Mg alloy. Model Simul Mater Sci Eng 8:687–706
Jung J, Yoon JI, Park H, Kim J, Kim H (2019) An efficient machine learning approach to establish structure–property linkages. Comput Mater Sci 156:17–25
Yabansu YC, Iskakov A, Kapustina A, Rajagopalan S, Kalidindi SR (2019) Application of Gaussian process regression models for capturing the evolution of microstructure statistics in aging of nickel-based superalloys. Acta Mater 178:45–58
Yabansu YC, Rehn V, Hötzer J, Nestler B, Kalidindi SR (2019) Application of Gaussian process autoregressive models for capturing the time evolution of microstructure statistics from phase-field simulations for sintering of polycrystalline ceramics. Model Simul Mater Sci Eng 27(8):084006
ASTM E975–03 (2003) Standard practice for X-ray determination of retained austenite in steel with near random crystallographic orientation. ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA. www.astm.org
Fischer-Cripps AC (1999) The Hertzian contact surface. J Mater Sci 34(1):129–137
Kim HN, Mandal S, Basu B, Kalidindi SR (2019) Probing local mechanical properties in polymer–ceramic hybrid acetabular sockets using spherical indentation stress–strain protocols. Integr Mater Manuf Innov 8(3):257–272
Iskakov A, Yabansu YC, Rajagopalan S, Kapustina A, Kalidindi SR (2018) Application of spherical indentation and the materials knowledge system framework to establishing microstructure-yield strength linkages from carbon steel scoops excised from high-temperature exposed components. Acta Mater 144:758–767
Donohue B, Ambrus A, Kalidindi S (2012) Critical evaluation of the indentation data analyses methods for the extraction of isotropic uniaxial mechanical properties using finite element models. Acta Mater 60:3943–3952
Patel DK, Kalidindi SR (2016) Correlation of spherical nanoindentation stress–strain curves to simple compression stress–strain curves for elastic–plastic isotropic materials using finite element models. Acta Mater 112:295–302
Bishop CM (2006) Pattern recognition and machine learning (information science and statistics). Springer, Berlin
Williams CK, Rasmussen CE (2006) Gaussian processes for machine learning. MIT Press, Cambridge
Chen T, Morris J, Martin E (2007) Gaussian process regression for multivariate spectroscopic calibration. Chemom Intell Labor Syst 87(1):59–71
Yang M, Long S-L, Liang Y-L (2018) Study on the key role of hierarchical microstructure for strength and plasticity in a lath martensitic steel. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 324:012043
Kitahara H, Ueji R, Tsuji N, Minamino Y (2006) Crystallographic features of lath martensite in low-carbon steel. Acta Mater 54:1279
Morsdorf L, Jeannin O, Barbier D, Mitsuhara M, Raabe D, Tasan CC (2016) Multiple mechanisms of lath martensite plasticity. Acta Mater 121:202–214
Lv Z, Zhang X, Huang X, Hansen N (2017) EBSD characterization of deformed lath martensite in IF steel. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 219:012033
Kitahara H, Ueji R, Tsuji N, Minamino Y (2006) Crystallographic features of lath martensite in low-carbon steel. Acta Mater 54(5):1279–1288
Niu M, Zhou G, Wang W, Shahzad MB, Shan Y, Yang K (2019) Precipitate evolution and strengthening behavior during aging process in a 2.5 GPa grade maraging steel. Acta Mater 179:296–307
Qian F, Rainforth W (2019) The formation mechanism of reverted austenite in Mn-based maraging steels. J Mater Sci 54:1–8
Li X, Yin Z (1995) Reverted austenite during aging in 18Ni(350) maraging steel. Mater Lett 24(4):239–242
Li K, Wei L, An B, Yu B, Misra RDK (2019) Aging phenomenon in low lattice-misfit cobalt-free maraging steel: microstructural evolution and strengthening behavior. Mater Sci Eng A 739:445–454
Viswanathan UK, Dey GK, Sethumadhavan V (2005) Effects of austenite reversion during overageing on the mechanical properties of 18 Ni (350) maraging steel. Mater Sci Eng A 398(1):367–372
Reis AGD, Reis DAP, Abdalla AJ, Otubo J (2015) High-temperature creep resistance and effects on the austenite reversion and precipitation of 18 Ni (300) maraging steel. Mater Charact 107:350–357
Moshka O, Pinkas M, Brosh E, Ezersky V, Meshi L (2015) Addressing the issue of precipitates in maraging steels—unambiguous answer. Mater Sci Eng A 638:232–239
Farooque M, Ayub H, Ul Haq A, Khan AQ (1998) The formation of reverted austenite in 18% Ni 350 grade maraging steel. J Mater Sci 33(11):2927–2930
Li K, Wei L, Yu B, Misra RDK (2019) Reverted austenite with distinct characteristics in a new cobalt-free low lattice misfit precipitate-bearing 19Ni3Mo1.5Ti maraging steel. Mater Lett 257:126692
Simm T, Sun L, McAdam S, Hill P, Rawson M, Perkins K (2017) The influence of lath, block and prior austenite grain (PAG) size on the tensile, creep and fatigue properties of novel maraging steel. Materials (Basel, Switzerland) 10(7):730
Turner DM, Niezgoda SR, Kalidindi SR (2016) Efficient computation of the angularly resolved chord length distributions and lineal path functions in large microstructure datasets. Model Simul Mater Sci Eng 24(7):075002
Raheem Z (2019) Modern physical metallurgy and materials engineering (PDFDrive.com)
Hall AM, Slunder CJ (1968) The metallurgy, behavior, and application of the 18-percent nickel maraging steels. NASA SP-5051
Marcisz J, Adamczyk M, Garbarz B (2017) Optimisation of mechanical properties of 18% Ni 350 grade maraging steel using novel heat treatment. Arch Metall Mater 62:73–84
Davis JR (1995) ASM specialty handbook: carbon and alloy steels. ASM International, Materials Park
Sacks J, Schiller SB, Welch WJ (1989) Designs for computer experiments. Technometrics 31(1):41–47
Sacks J, Welch WJ, Mitchell TJ, Wynn HP (1989) Design and analysis of computer experiments. Stat Sci 4:409–423
Kleijnen JP, Beers WV (2004) Application-driven sequential designs for simulation experiments: Kriging metamodelling. J Oper Res Soc 55(8):876–883
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge support from N00014-18-1-2879. We also would like to thank the IEN/IMAT Materials Characterization Facility at Georgia Institute of Technology.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Parvinian, S., Yabansu, Y.C., Khosravani, A. et al. High-Throughput Exploration of the Process Space in 18% Ni (350) Maraging Steels via Spherical Indentation Stress–Strain Protocols and Gaussian Process Models. Integr Mater Manuf Innov 9, 199–212 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40192-020-00177-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40192-020-00177-1