Coastal resource foraging, the culture of coastal livelihoods, and human well-being in Southeastern Puerto Rico: consensus, consonance, and some implications for coastal policy
Based on 3 years of fieldwork in Southeastern Puerto Rico (SE PR), we report on data showing that Puerto Rican coastal resource foragers (CR foragers) have a distinct cultural model of well-being, when compared with their non-foraging neighbors. The CR foragers’ cultural model of well-being is directly related to the foraging lifestyle. It emphasizes independence, investment in social relationships, and enjoyment of the natural environment over the more stable access to higher income available in the formal economy. As such, we view this cultural model as an alternative to the individualistic/capitalistic model of continual growth and wealth accumulation. Building on previous analysis in which we found higher subjective well-being for coastal resource foragers compared with non-foraging neighbors as reported by García-Quijano et al. (J Anthropol Res 71 (2):145–167 2015), we find that the higher well-being of CR foragers compared with their non-foraging neighbors is consistent with Dressler’s (2018) framework of cultural consonance, in this case between what they value in life and what they are able to obtain through their occupation and lifestyle as CR foragers. We discuss the implication of our findings for coastal policy in CR foraging dependent locales such as SE PR.
KeywordsCoastal resource foraging Well-being Cultural consonance Consensus Culture of coastal resource use Puerto Rico
We are thankful for the collaboration of the many individuals and their families on the southeastern coast who generously gave us their time and shared their knowledge and experiences with us. We thank our co-investigators in this grant, Dr. Ana Pitchon and Dr. Miguel Del Pozo, and our dedicated student researchers, Natalia Rodríguez, Víctor Pagán, and Yasmín Pérez, for their fieldwork amid sometimes challenging circumstances, as well as Manuel Valdés-Pizzini, Kurt Grove, Ruperto Chaparro, Lillian Ramírez Durand, Angel Dieppa, Ruth Santiago, Nelson Santos Torres, Catherine Robinson, and Jon Blaney for the support and guidance in various stages of our project. We thank our families for supporting us and sharing time in the field. Dr. Hilda Lloréns and Dr. José Alvarado provided valuable help in our analysis. We thank three anonymous reviewers for comments and suggestions that helped us strengthen this manuscript.
This research was funded by a National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration- University of Puerto Rico Sea Grant.
Compliance with Ethical Standards
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
- Aronoff, Joel. 1967. Psychological needs and cultural systems: A case study. Princeton: Van Nostrand-Reinhold.Google Scholar
- Borgatti, S. 1996. ANTHROPAC 4.0 methods guide. Natick: Analytic Technologies.Google Scholar
- Breslow, Sara Jo, Brit Sojka, Raz Barnea, Xavier Basurto, Courtney Carothers, Susan Charnley, Sarah Coulthard, Nives Dolsak, Jamie Donatuto, Carlos García-Quijano, Christina C. Hicks, Arielle Levine, Michael B. Mascia, Karma Norman, Melissa Poe, Terre Satterfield, Kevin St. Martin, and Phillip S. Levin. 2016. Conceptualizing and operationalizing human wellbeing for ecosystem assessment and management. Environmental Science & Policy 66: 250–259.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Cadilla, J. 1988. Elementos de la geografía de Puerto Rico. San Juan: Editorial Librotex.Google Scholar
- Susan Charnley, Courtney Carothers, Terre Satterfield, Arielle Levine, Melissa R. Poe, Karma Norman, Jamie Donatuto, Sara Jo Breslow, Michael B. Mascia, Phillip S. Levin, Xavier Basurto, Christina C. Hicks, Carlos García-Quijano, Kevin St. Martin. 2017. Evaluating the best available social science for natural resource management decision-making. Environmental Science & Policy 73: 80–88.Google Scholar
- Comitas, Lambros. (1974). Occupational Multiplicity in Rural Jamaica. in Work and Family Life. L. Comitas, and D. Lowenthal (eds.) Garden City, NY: Anchor Books.Google Scholar
- Daly, Herman, and John Cobb. 1994. For the common good: Redirecting the economy toward community, the environment, and a sustainable future. Boston: Beacon Press.Google Scholar
- Dominguez-Cristobal, Carlos. 2008. La politica forestal del manglar en Puerot Rico durante el siglo XIX: el caso del manglar de Jobos, Las Mareas, Caño Grande y Punta Caribe de Guayama. Acta Cientifica 22 (1–3): 67–77.Google Scholar
- Dressler, William. 2018. Culture and the individual theory and method of cultural consonance. New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
- Dressler, W. W., & Bindon, J. R. (2000). The health consequences of cultural consonance: Cultural dimensions of lifestyle, social support, and arterial blood pressure in an African American community. American Anthropologist 102 (2): 244–260. https://doi.org/10.1525/aa.2000.102.2.244.
- Dressler, William W., Camila D. Borges, Mauro C. Balierio, and José Ernesto dos Santos (2005). Measuring Cultural Consonance: Examples with Special Reference to Measurement Theory in Anthropology. Field Methods 17 (4): 331–355. https://doi.org/10.1177/1525822X05279899.
- Dressler, William, Mauro Balieiro, and José Ernesto dos Santos. 2015. Finding culture change in the second factor: Stability and change in cultural consensus and residual agreement. Field Methods 27 (1): 22–38.Google Scholar
- Ed Diener, Robert A. Emmons, Randy J. Larsen and Sharon Griffin. (1985). The Satisfaction With Life Scale. Journal of Personality Assessment 49 (1): 71–75. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327752jpa4901_13.
- Field, Ralph, Eddy Laboy, Jorge Capella, Pedro Robles, and Carmen González. 2003. Jobos Bay estuarine profile: A national estuarine research reserve. Salinas: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. https://coast.noaa.gov/data/docs/nerrs/Reserves_JOB_SiteProfile.pdf.Google Scholar
- García-Quijano, Carlos G. 2006. Resisting extinction: The value of local ecological knowledge for small-scale fishers in southeastern Puerto Rico. Ph.D., University of Georgia, Athens, GA.Google Scholar
- García-Quijano, Carlos and Hilda Lloréns. 2017. What rural, coastal Puerto Ricans can teach us about thriving in times of crisis. The Conversation.Google Scholar
- García-Quijano, Carlos and Hilda Lloréns. (2018). Many Puerto Ricans fear recovery plan could be greedy land grab. New York Daily News. September 18, 2018.Google Scholar
- García-Quijano, Carlos, John Poggie, Ana Pitchon, Miguel del Pozo and José Alvarado. 2013. The coast’s bailout: coastal resource use, quality of life, and resilience in Southeastern Puerto Rico: technical report submitted to University of Puerto Rico Sea Grant (NOAA).Google Scholar
- García-Quijano, Carlos G, John J. Poggie, and Miguel del Pozo (2016). En el Monte También Se Pesca: ‘Pesca de Monte’, ambiente, subsistencia y comunidad en los bosques costeros del sureste de Puerto Rico. Caribbean Studies 43 (2): 115–144.Google Scholar
- Giusti-Cordero, Juan. 1994. Labor, ecology, and history in a Caribbean sugar plantation region: Loíza, Puerto Rico 1770–1950. Binghamton: State University of New York.Google Scholar
- Griffith, David, and Manuel Valdés-Pizzini. 2002. Fishers at work, workers at sea: A Puerto Rican journey through labor and refuge. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.Google Scholar
- Griffith, David, Manuel Valdés-Pizzini, and Carlos García-Quijano. 2007. Socioeconomic profiles of fishers, their communities, and their reponses to marine protective measures in Puerto Rico. NOAA Series on U.S. Caribbean Fishing Communitties. Miami: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, southeast fisheries science center.Google Scholar
- Gutiérrez Sanchez, Jaime. 1982. Características personales y de trabajo de los Pescadores de Puerto Rico. Mayaguez: UPR Sea Grant Press.Google Scholar
- Hicks, Christina, Arielle Levine, Arun Agrawal, Xavier Basurto, Sara Breslow, Courtney Carothers, Susan Charnley, Sarah Coulthard, Nives Dolsak, Jamie Carlos, Donatuto García-Quijano, Michael Mascia, Karma Norman, Melissa Poe, Terre Satterfield, Kevin St. Martin, and Phillip Levine. 2016. Engage key social concepts for sustainability: Social indicators, both mature and emerging, are underused. Science 352 (6281): 38–40.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Jobos NERR. (2009). 2010–2015 Management Plan for the Jobos Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve. Aguirre, PR: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. http://drna.pr.gov/historico/oficinas/arn/recursosvivientes/costasreservasrefugios/JobosBayManagementPlanFINALdecember.pdf.
- Johnson, Jeffrey C. 1990. Selecting Ethnographic Informants. Qualitative research methods. Newbury Park: Sage Publications.Google Scholar
- Johnson, D., T. Acott, N. Stacey, and J. Urquhart. 2018. Social wellbeing and the values of small-scale fisheries. In MARE Publication Series. Basel: Springer International Publishing.Google Scholar
- Kubiszewski, Ida, Nabeeh Zakariyya, and Diane Jarvis. 2019. Subjective wellbeing at different spatial scales for individuals satisfied and dissatisfied with life. PeerJ 7: e6502. https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.6502.
- Louv, Richard. 2005. Last child in the woods: Saving our children from nature-deficit disorder. Chapel Hill: Algonquin Books.Google Scholar
- Lugo, Ariel. 1988. The mangroves of Puerto Rico are in trouble. Acta Cientifica 2: 124.Google Scholar
- McGoodwin, James. 1990. Crisis in the world’s fisheries: People, problems, and policies. Stanford: Stanford University Press.Google Scholar
- Mintz, Sidney. 1960. Worker in the cane: A Puerto Rican life history. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- New York Daily News. 2018. Many Puerto Ricans fear recovery plan could be greedy land grab. September 18, 2018.Google Scholar
- Pérez, Ricardo. 2005. The state and small-scale fisheries in Puerto Rico. In New directions in Puerto Rican studies. Gainesville: University of Florida Press.Google Scholar
- Poggie, John J. 1978. Deferred gratification as an adaptive characteristic for small-scale fishermen. Ethos 6 (2): 115–123.Google Scholar
- Pollnac, R., and J. Poggie. 2006. Job Satisfaction in the Fishery in Two Southeast Alaskan Towns. Human Organization 65: 332–342.Google Scholar
- Poggie, John, and Carl Gersuny. 1974. Fishermen of Galilee: The human ecology of a New England coastal community. Marine Bulletin Series. Kingston: Univerity of Rhode Island.Google Scholar
- Pollnac, Richard, and John Poggie. 2008. Happiness, well-being and psychocultural adaptation to the stresses associated with marine fishing. Human Ecology Review 15 (2): 194–200.Google Scholar
- Pollnac, Richard, Susan Abbot-Jamieson, Courtland Smith, Marc Miller, Patricia Clay, and Bryan Oles. 2006. Toward a model for fisheries social impact assessment. Marine Fisheries Review 68: 1–18.Google Scholar
- Puerto Rico DTRHPR. (2014). Departamento del Trabajo y Recursos Humanos de Puerto Rico: Empleo y Desempleo en Puerto Rico en 2013. http://cce.estadisticas.gobierno.pr/Documentos/1BCD3176-843C-4A38-997764681B2AE5CA/DTRH_EmpleoDesempleoPR_201312.pdf.
- Scott, James. 2009. The art of not being governed: Aa anarchist history of upland Southeast Asia. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- Stiglitz, J., A. Sen, and J. Fitoussi. 2010. Mismeasuring our lives: Why GDP doesn’t add up: Report by the commission on the measurement of economic performance and social progress. New York: The New Press.Google Scholar
- Smith, M. Estellie. 1977. Comments on the heuristic utility of maritime anthropology. The Maritime Anthropologist 1: 2–5.Google Scholar
- Strauss, Claudia. 1992. Models and motives. In Human Motives and Cultural Models, ed. Roy D’Andrade and Claudia Strauss, 1–20. New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
- Suarez-Caabro, José. 1979. El Mar de Puerto Rico: Una Introduccion a las Pesquerias de la Isla. Rio Piedras: Editorial de La Universidad de Puerto Rico.Google Scholar
- Valdés-Pizzini, Manuel. 1987. Apuntes Sobre el Desarrollo Histórico de la Pesca en Puerto Rico. Mayaguez: UPR Sea Grant Press.Google Scholar
- Valdés-Pizzini, Manuel. 1990. Etnología Crítica del Trabajo en las Pesquerías de Puerto Rico y el Caribe Insular. Caribbean Studies 23 (1/2): 61–82.Google Scholar
- Weller, Susan. 2014. Structured interviewing and questionnaire construction. In Handbook of Methods in Cultural Anthropology, ed. H.R. Bernard and C. Gravlee, 343–390. London: Rowman and Litlefield.Google Scholar