Youth Group Cliques: How Religious Goals Can Disguise Discriminatory Group Dynamics
- 313 Downloads
This paper provides an in-depth, qualitative analysis of two Christian youth groups. Researchers conducted personal interviews with participating youth and their youth ministers and collected extensive field notes on participant observations of youth group events. Findings indicate the presence of youth group cliques with clear delineations about which participants are youth group insiders and which are outsiders. Results show that insider participants are typically socioeconomically-advantaged youth, while outsiders are typically youth from disadvantaged backgrounds. Despite the existence of these exclusionary practices within both groups, leaders in the two cases demonstrate differing levels of awareness of and response to these dynamics. This paper explores the specifics of both cases, illuminating who is targeted for exclusion within these groups and how this targeting varies across the two congregational contexts. Implications of these findings are that religious youth groups may perpetuate broader socioeconomic divisions. Specifically, the analysis reveals that rather than forming benign cliques, youth group members may be discriminating against others based on their relative socioeconomic advantage.
KeywordsYouth groups Socioeconomic status Religious stratification Church cultures
This research was funded through the generosity of a Lilly Endowment Inc. grant and institutional support from the University of Notre Dame. The authors wish to thank Christian Smith, Hilary Davidson, Katie Spencer, Brad Vermurlen, Brandon Vaidyanathan, Peter Mundey, and Kaitlyn Conway for their valuable feedback and contributions to the project.
- Charles, G. 2001. The bold alternative: Staying in Church in the 21st Century. Louisville: Geneva Press.Google Scholar
- Cohen, E.G., and R.A. Lotan. 1995. Producing equal-status interaction in the heterogeneous classroom. American Education Research Journal 32(1): 99–120.Google Scholar
- Emerson, M., and C. Smith. 2000. Divided by faith: Evangelical religion and the problem of race in America. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
- Hestenes, R. 1985. An expanded syllabus for building Christian Community through small groups. Philadelphia: Westminster Press.Google Scholar
- Hoge, D.R., B. Johnson, and D.A. Luidens. 1994. Vanishing boundaries: The religion of mainline Protestant baby boomers. Westminster: John Knox Press.Google Scholar
- Hunter, J.D. 1983. American evangelicalism: Conservative religion and the quandary of modernity. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
- Kelley, D.M. 1986. Why conservative churches are growing: A study in sociology of religion. Macon: Mercer University Press.Google Scholar
- Larson, Reed and David Hansen. 2006. Faith-based youth groups stand out in fostering teens’ growth experiences. College of ACES Illinois. 19 Oct. 2009. http://research.aces.illinois.edu/report/hcd/faith.
- Shlomo, S., and Y. Sharan. 1976. Small-group teaching. Englewood Cliffs: Education Technology Publication, Inc.Google Scholar
- Smith, C. 1998. American evangelicalism: Embattled and thriving. London: The University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar
- Smith, J.P. 2007. The impact of socioeconomic status on health over the life-course. Journal of Human Resources XLII: 739–764.Google Scholar
- Snell Herzog, P., C. Smith, C. Tavares, and K. Christoffersen. 2009. Denominational differences in congregational youth ministry programming and empirical evidence of systematic non-response biases in surveys. Review of Religious Research 51(1): 21–38.Google Scholar
- Sparkes, Jo. 1999. Schools, education and social exclusion. Centre for analysis of social exclusion London School of Sociology. 30 Nov. 2011. http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/6482/1/Schools,_Education_and_Social_Exclusion.pdf.
- Steensland, B., J.Z. Park, M.D. Regnerus, L.D. Robinson, B. Wilcox, and R.D. Woodberry. 2000. The measure of American religion: Toward improving the state of the art. Social Forces 79: 291–318.Google Scholar