Skip to main content

MaCRA: a model-based framework for maritime cyber-risk assessment

Abstract

In the current economy, roughly 90% of all world trade is transported by the shipping industry, which is now accelerating its technological growth. While the demand on mariners, ship owners, and the encompassing maritime community for digital advances (particularly towards digitization and automation) has led to efficient shipping operations, maritime cyber-security is a pertinent issue of equal importance. As hackers are becoming increasingly aware of cyber-vulnerabilities within the maritime sector, and as existing risk assessment tools do not adequately represent the unique nature of maritime cyber-threats, this article introduces a model-based risk assessment framework which considers a combination of cyber and maritime factors. Confronted with a range of ship functionalities, configurations, users, and environmental factors, this framework aims to comprehensively present maritime cyber-risks and better inform those in the maritime community when making cyber-security decisions. By providing the needed maritime cyber-risk profiles, it becomes possible to support a range of parties, such as operators, regulators, insurers, and mariners, in increasing overall global maritime cyber-security.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Fig. 5
Fig. 6
Fig. 7
Fig. 8
Fig. 9
Fig. 10
Fig. 11
Fig. 12
Fig. 13
Fig. 14

Notes

  1. All tables and figures were created by the authors to illustrate framework abilities.

References

  • Allianz Global Corporate and Specialty SE (2016) Safety and shipping review 2016. Allianz Global Corporate and Specialty

  • Archives UN Administration R (2016) CFR Title 47 (parts 80-end) code of federal regulation title 47 telecommunications revised as of October 1, 2016. Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)

  • Balduzzi M (2014) AIS exposed understanding vulnerabilities & attacks 2.0. BlackHat

  • Bateman S (2010) Regional maritime security: threats and risk assessments. University of Wollongong

  • BBC News (2009) Nuclear subs collide in atlantic. BBC

  • BigOceanData (2016) AIS and anti-piracy maritime security. BigOceanData

  • BIMCO, CLIA, ICS, INTERCARGO, INTERTANKO (2016) The guidelines on cyber security onboard ships v2.0. International Chamber of Shipping

  • Bordonali C, Ferraresi s, Richter W (2017) Shifting gears in cyber security for connected cars. McKinseyĊompany Advanced Industries

  • Borgovini R, Pemberton s, Rossi M (1993), Failure mode, effects, and criticality analysis (FMECA). Reliability Analysis Center

  • den Braber F, Hogganvik I, Lund M S, Stølen K, Vraalsen F (2007) Model-based security analysis in seven steps — a guided tour to the coras method. BT Technology Journal

  • Cappelli D, Moore A, Trzeciak R (2012) The CERT guide to insider threats: How to prevent, detect and respond to information technology crimes (theft, Sabotage, Fraud), Addison-Wesley, Reading

  • Cassidy W (2017) China-based cyberattack hits logistics operators, shippers. Outsource 5(6):1–8

    Google Scholar 

  • Cavotec (2014) Moormaster frequently asked questions. Cavotec

  • CERT Insider Threat Center (2014) Unintentional insider threats: Social engineering. Tech. Rep. CMU/SEI-2013-TN-024, Software Engineering Institute Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh

  • Cherdantseva Y, Burnap P, Blyth A, Eden P, Jones K, Soulsby H, Stoddart K (2016) A review of cyber security risk assessment methods for scada systems. Computers & Security 56

  • Coffed J (2014) The threat of gps jamming. Exelis

  • Collier E (2017) eLoran: More accurate & less vulnerable but not a done deal yet. Marine electronics

  • Collins R (2017) The state of cybersecurity in the rail industry. White paper

  • Committee JH, Harwood S (2015) Cyber risk. Joint Hull Committee (JHC)

  • Control CAT (2015) Cyber security project. https://www.csfi.us

  • Costa NA, Jakobsen JJ, Weber R, Lundh M, MacKinnon SN (2018) Assessing a maritime service website prototype in a ship bridge simulator: navigators’ experiences and perceptions of novel e-navigation solutions. WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13437-018-0155-2

  • Costin A (2016) Security of cctv and video surveillance systems: Threats, vulnerabilities, attacks, and mitigations. In: Proceedings of the 6th international workshop on trustworthy embedded devices

  • CyberKeel (2014a) Maritime cyber-risks. NCC Group Publication

  • CyberKeel (2014b) Security risks and weaknesses in ecdis systems. NCC Group Publication

  • Danish Defence Intelligence Sevice’s Center for Cyber Security (2014) Threat assessment: The cyber threat against the maritime sector. Marine Cyberwatch

  • Daszuta W, Ghosh S (2018) Seafarers’ perceptions of competency in risk assessment and management: an empirical study. WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13437-018-0156-1

  • Degani A (2004) Taming HAL: Designing Interfaces Beyond 2001. Springer, Berlin

    Google Scholar 

  • Dyryavyy Y (2014) Preparing for cyber battleships: electronic chart display and information system security. NCC Group Publication

  • ECDIS Info (2014) ECDIS Regulations. http://www.ecdis-info.com/ecdis_regulations.html

  • European Cybercrime center (2014) The internet organised crime threat assessment (iOCTA). European Police Office, The Hague

    Google Scholar 

  • Fitch C (2004) Crime and punishment: The psychology of hacking in the new millennium. SANS Institute

  • Francillon A, Danev B, Capkun S (2011) Relay attacks on passive keyless entry and start systems in modern cars. Network and Distributed System Security Symposium

  • Franckx E (2001) Fisheries enforcement related legal and institutional issues: national, subregional or regional perspectives. FAO legislative study 71. Development Law Service: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations

  • Goerlandt F, Montewka J (2015) Maritime transportation risk analysis: review and analysis in light of some foundational issues. Reliability Engineering & System Safety

  • GPS World staff (2016) US coast guard issues gps jamming alert. GPS World

  • Grant A, Williams P, Basker S (2014) GPS jamming and the impact on maritime navigation. The General Lighthouse Authorities

  • Heffner C (2013) Exploiting surveillance cameras like a hollywood hacker. Tactical Network Solutions, Columbia

    Google Scholar 

  • Igure VM, Laughter SA, Williams RD (2006) Security issues in scada networks. Computers & Security

  • IMO Navigation (2017) http://www.imo.org/en/OurWork/Safety/Navigation/, accessed: 2017-05-17

  • International Chamber of Shipping (2016) Review of maritime transport. United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD)

  • International Maritime Organization (1974) International convention for the safety of life at sea. IMO

  • International Maritime Organization (2004) Solas chapter V annex 17: Automatic identification systems (AIS). IMO

  • International Maritime Organization (2009a) Solas ch V regulation 19: Carriage requirements for shipborne navigational systems and equipment. IMO

  • International Maritime Organization (2009b) Solas chapter V regulation 19-1: Long range identification and tracking of ships. IMO

  • Jones K, Tam K, Papadaki M (2016) Threats and impacts in maritime cyber security. IET Engineering & Technology Reference

  • Kröner U, Greidanus H, Gallagher R, Sironi M, Azzalin G, Littmann F, Tebaldi P, Timossi p, Shaw D (2009) Report on authentication in fisheries monitoring. Joint Research Centre (JRC)

  • Labunets K, Paci F, Massacci F, Ruprai R (2014) An experiment on comparing textual vs. visual industrial methods for security risk assessment. In: 2014 IEEE 4th International Workshop on Empirical Requirements Engineering (EmpiRE)

  • Lane RO, Nevell DA, Hayward SD, Beaney TW (2010) Maritime anomaly detection and threat assessment. 13th International Conference on Information Fusion

  • Latin America & Caribbean (2014) Seized n korean ship: Cuban weapons on board. BBC

  • Leyden J (2016) Water treatment plant hacked, chemical mix changed for tap supplies. The Register

  • Lund MS, Solhaug B, Stlen K (2010) Model-Driven Risk analysis: The CORAS approach. Springer Publishing Company, Incorporated

  • Maersk (2017) A. P. Moller Maersk improves underlying profit and grows revenue in first half of the year. Maersk https://edit.maersk.com/en/the-maersk-group/press-room/press-release-archive/2017/8/a-p-moller-maersk-interim-report-q2-2017

  • Man Y, Lundh M, MacKinnon SN (2018) Managing unruly technologies in the engine control room: from problem patching to an architectural thinking and standardization. WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13437-018-0159-y

  • MarEx (2016) Nigerian navy: Crewmembers involved in pirate attacks. The Maritime Executive

  • Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) (1997) Safety digest 02/1997. gov.uk

  • Marine accident investigation branch (2012) Grounding of CSL THAMES in the Sound of Mull 9 august 2011. Marine accident investigation branch (MAIB)

  • Marine accident investigation branch (2014) Report on the investigation of the grounding of Ovit in the Dover Strait on 18 september 2013. Marine accident investigation branch (MAIB)

  • Montewka J, Ehlers S, Goerlandt F, Hinz T, Tabri K, Kujala P (2014) A framework for risk assessment for maritime transportation systems—a case study for open sea collisions involving ropax vessels. Reliability Engineering & System Safety

  • Moorex M (2014) Mooring and auto-mooring solutions. ShipServ

  • Mordechai G, Kedma G, Kachlon A, Elovici Y (2014) Airhopper: Bridging the air-gap between isolated networks and mobile phones using radio frequencies. Malicious & Unwanted Software Conference

  • Nankivell KL, Reeves J, Pardo RP (2017) The indo-asia-pacific’s maritime future: A practical assessment of the state of asian seas. Daniel K. Inouye Asia Pacific Center for Security Studies (DKI APCSS) and King’s College London (KCL)

  • National PNT Advisory Board (2010) Jamming the global positioning system: A national security threat recent events and potential cures. General Lighthouse Authorities

  • NIST (2012) Guide for conducting risk assessments - information security. NIST Special publication 800–30

  • Nordström J, Goerlandt F, Sarsama J, Leppänen P, Nissilä M, Ruponen P, Lübcke T, Sonninen S (2016) Vessel triage: A method for assessing and communicating the safety status of vessels in maritime distress situations. Safety Science

  • Norway MP (2017) Inert gas system (IGG). Maritime Protection AS

  • Offshore Blue (2013) Tales of the unexpected. The Navigator: Inspiring professionalism in marine navigators

  • Offshore Blue (2016) A re-cap of the navtex system. Navigator’s Newsletter

  • Peltier TR (2005) Information security risk analysis. Auerbach Publishing, New York

    Book  Google Scholar 

  • Rios Insua D, Banks D, Rios J (2016) Modeling opponents in adversarial risk analysis. Risk Analysis

  • Rolls Royce (2017) Autonomous ships: The next step. Marine Ship Intelligence

  • Rothblum A (2000) Human error and marine safety. International Workshop on Human Factors in Offshore Operations (HFW2002)

  • Safa HH, Souran DM, Ghasempour M, Khazaee A (2016) Cyber security of smart grid and scada systems, threats and risks. In: CIRED Workshop 2016

  • Santamarta R (2014a) Satcom terminals: Hacking by air, sea, and land

  • Santamarta R (2014b) A wake-up call for satcom security. IOActive

  • Santamarta R (2015) Maritime security: Hacking into a voyage data recorder (VDR). IOActive

  • Schmidt D, Radke K, Camtepe S, Foo E, Ren M (2016) A survey and analysis of the gnss spoofing threat and countermeasures. ACM Comput Surv

  • SeaCert (2016) Global maritime distress and safety system (GMDSS) radio operator. Maritime NZ

  • ESC Global Security (2015) Maritime cyber security white paper: Safeguarding data through increased awareness. ESCGS Cyber Security White Papers

  • Simon H, Ray H (2005) A taxonomy of network and computer attacks. Computers and Security

  • Snyder D, Powers J, Bodine-Baron E, Fox B, Kendrick L, Powell M (2015) Improving the cybersecurity of u.s air force military systems throughout their life cycles. RAND corporation Research Report

  • Sommestad T, Ekstedt M, Holm H (2013) The cyber security modeling language: A tool for assessing the vulnerability of enterprise system architectures. IEEE Systems Journal

  • Stålhane T, Sindre G (2014) An experimental comparison of system diagrams and textual use cases for the identification of safety hazards. Int J Inf Syst Model Des

  • Suh J (2014) The failure of the south korean national security state

  • Tam K, Jones K (2018a) Cyber-risk assessment for autonomous ships. IEEE TCS Cyber Security

  • Tam K, Jones KD (2018b) Maritime cybersecurity policy: the scope and impact of evolving technology on international shipping. https://doi.org/10.1080/23738871.2018.1513053

  • Traub P, Hudson R (2007) Alarm management strategies on ships bridges and railway control rooms, a comparison of approaches and solutions. Paper read at RINA Event, at London

  • Trend news agency (2012) Iran oil tankers said by zanzibar to signal wrong flag. Bloomberg

  • United States General Accounting Office (1999) Information security risk assessment practices of leading organizations. GAO/AIMD-98-68

  • US Army Criminal Investigation Command (2017a) Cyber sextortion. CPF 0002-17-CID361-9H

  • US Army Criminal Investigation Command (2017b) Cybersecurity: Sextortion exploitation of u.s. service members. U.S. Army Criminal Investigation Command

  • US Department of Homeland Security (2015) Gps and critical infrastructure. Civil GPS Service Interface Committee

  • USMRC Maritime Cyber Assurance Research (2016) The reality of shipboard cyber vulnerabilities. USMRC Maritime Cyber Assurance Team (MCAT)

  • Vandenborn Y, Bell R (2015) Standard safety special edition - ECDIS assisted grounding. Marine accident investigation branch (MAIB)

  • Wagstaff J (2014) All at sea: Global shipping fleet exposed to hacking threat. Reuters, Canary Wharf

    Google Scholar 

  • Weintrit A (2015) Activities in Navigation: Marine Navigation and Safety of Sea Transportation. Taylor & Francis Group

  • Wingrove M (2016) Lack of training causes ship accidents and detentions. Marine Electronics & Communications

  • Yeomans G (2014) Autonomous vehicles handing over control: Opportunities and risks for insurance. Lloyd’s, London

    Google Scholar 

  • Zhang J, Ioannou P (2006) Automated container transport system between inland port and terminals. ACM Transactions on Modeling and Computer Simulation

Download references

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to express their great appreciation to Tom Crichton, Captain Robert Hone, and Steven Furnell from the University of Plymouth for their assistance and guidance throughout this paper.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Kimberly Tam.

Additional information

Publisher’s note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Tam, K., Jones, K. MaCRA: a model-based framework for maritime cyber-risk assessment. WMU J Marit Affairs 18, 129–163 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13437-019-00162-2

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13437-019-00162-2

Keywords

  • Maritime
  • Cyber-security
  • Risk assessment
  • Cyber-threats