A method to estimate the impact of clear-cutting on nutrient concentrations in boreal headwater streams
- 329 Downloads
Large-scale forestry operations, like clear-cutting, may impair surface water quality if not done with environmental considerations in mind. Catchment and country level estimates of nutrient loads from forestry are generally based on specific export values, i.e., changes in annual exports due to the implemented forestry operations expressed in kg ha−1. We introduce here a specific concentration approach as a method to estimate the impact of clear-cutting on nutrient concentrations and export in headwater streams. This new method is potentially a more dynamic and flexible tool to estimate nutrient loads caused by forestry, because variation in annual runoff can be taken into account in load assessments. We combined water quality data from eight boreal headwater catchment pairs located in Finland and Sweden, where the effect of clear-cutting on stream water quality has been studied experimentally. Statistically significant specific concentration values could be produced for total nitrogen, nitrate, ammonium, and phosphate. The significant increases in the concentrations of these nutrients occurred between 2 and 6 years after clear-cutting. Significant specific concentration values could not be produced for total phosphorus and total organic carbon with the whole dataset, although in some single studies significant increases in their concentrations after clear-cutting were observed. The presented method enables taking into account variation in runoff, temporal dynamics of effects, and the proportional size of the treated area in load calculations. The number of existing studies considering large site-specific variation in responses to clear-cutting is small, and therefore further empirical studies are needed to improve predictive capabilities of the specific concentration values.
KeywordsFinal cutting Nitrogen Phosphorus Site preparation Specific concentration Total organic carbon
We thank Swedish Environmental protection Agency and Nordic Forest Research Co-operation Committee for financial support (project: Leaching of carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus from forest land in the Nordic and Baltic countries, SNS project no 110) and Mr. Jaakko Heinonen for statistical advice.
- Abdelnour, A., M. Stieglitz, F. Pan, and R. McKane. 2011. Catchment hydrological responses to forest harvest amount and spatial pattern. Water Resources Research W09521 47: 1–18.Google Scholar
- Ahtiainen, M., and P. Huttunen. 1999. Long-term effects of forestry managements on water quality and loading in brooks. Boreal Environment Research 4: 101–114.Google Scholar
- Andersson, L., and A. Lepistö. 2000. Annual variability of nitrogen concentrations and export from forested catchments: A consequence of climatic variability, sampling strategies or human interference? Boreal Environment Research 5: 221–233.Google Scholar
- Finér, L., M. Ahtiainen, H. Mannerkoski, V. Möttönen, S. Piirainen, P. Seuna, and M. Starr. 1997. Effects of harvesting and scarification on water and nutrient fluxes. A description of catchment and methods, and results from the pretreatment calibration period. The Finnish Forest Research Institute, Research Papers 648, 38 pp.Google Scholar
- Finér, L., T. Mattsson, S. Joensuu, H. Koivusalo, A. Laurén, T. Makkonen, M. Nieminen, S.E. Tattari, et al. 2010. Metsäisten valuma-alueiden vesistökuormituksen laskenta (A method for calculating nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment load from forest catchment). The Finnish Environment 10: 1–33.Google Scholar
- Grip, H. 1982. Water chemistry and runoff in forest streams at Kloten. UNGI Report 58. Division of Hydrology, Department of Physical Geography, Uppsala University, 144 pp.Google Scholar
- Haapanen, M., K. Kenttämies, P. Porvari, and T. Sallantaus. 2006. Kivennäismaan uudistushakkuun vaikutus kasvinravinteiden ja orgaanisen aineen huuhtoutumiseen; raportti Kurussa ja Janakkalassa sijaitsevien tutkimusalueiden tuloksista. (The effect of clear-cutting on the export of nutrients and organic matter; a report from Kuru and Janakkala study catchments). The Finnish Environment 816: 43–59.Google Scholar
- Kenttämies, K. 2006. A method for calculating nutrient loads from forestry: Principles and national applications in Finland. Verhandlungen des Internationalen Verein Limnologie 29: 1591–1594.Google Scholar
- Laurén, A., J. Heinonen, H. Koivusalo, S. Sarkkola, S. Tattari, T. Mattsson, M. Ahtiainen, S. Joensuu, et al. 2009. Implications of uncertainty in a pre-treatment dataset when estimating treatment effects in paired catchment studies: Phosphorus loads from forest clear-cuts. Water, Air, and Soil pollution 196: 251–261.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Palviainen, M., L. Finér, A. Laurén, S. Launiainen, S. Piirainen, T. Mattsson, and M. Starr. 2014. Nitrogen, phosphorus, carbon, and suspended solids loads from forest clear-cutting and site preparation: Long-term paired catchment studies from Eastern Finland. AMBIO 43: 218–233.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ring, E. 2007. Estimation of leaching of nitrogen and phosphorus from forestry in northern Sweden. In How to estimate N and P losses from forestry in northern Sweden, vol. 146, ed. S. Löfgren, 6–13. Stockholm: KSLA Tidskrift.Google Scholar
- Statistical Yearbook of Finland. 2013. Statistics Finland, vol. 108, 699 pp.Google Scholar
- Swedish Forest Agency. 2013. Swedish Statistical Yearbook of Forestry 2013, 374 pp. http://www.skogsstyrelsen.se/en/.
- Ylitalo, E. 2013. Statistical Yearbook of Forestry 2013. Sastamala: Finnish Forest Research Institute, 448 pp.Google Scholar