Skip to main content

Power Discourses of Fish Death: Case of Linnunsuo Peat Production

Abstract

This article explores the peat production impacts on Jukajoki river in Finland by implementing discourse analysis. Four discourses are explored: state truth statements; company statements that are in close proximity of state power; discourses provided by the local community Selkie, who provided counter-narratives to the official views; and finally media and related discourses. In conclusion, the discourses by the state and closely related actors (A–B) comprised implementation of their power and justifying it at the expense of those who are excluded from such power, in this case the village. The village narrative (C) contains elements that strongly contradict the statements provided by those with power. The results indicate local communities should be taken more seriously. The systematic denial of local peoples’ rights should be reviewed, and local participation in environmental permit assessments implemented.

This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.

Fig. 1

Notes

  1. 1.

    pH 2.77–3.4 and amount of iron 300 000 µg l−1. Such amounts are lethal to all life in a waterbody.

  2. 2.

    The choice of autoethnography as a method contains limitations and benefits compared for example with participant observation. Insider view embedded in it can be criticized from the viewpoint of a biased interpretation. I am aware of these risks and have tried to balance this with the use of discourses reflected in official documents.

  3. 3.

    Such as local ecological knowledge (Berkes 1999).

  4. 4.

    State power here signifies actors which are in close proximity of formal, established structures of governance.

  5. 5.

    Space does not allow here to discuss the rural–urban divide or residence of Finns in the context of local knowledge. Focus here is on people living in close proximity of natural habitats.

  6. 6.

    Linnunsuo = mire of the bird.

  7. 7.

    An administrational concept referring to a process where authorities have to do all in their power to stop the threats or problems.

References

Official Documents

  1. Agency for Environmental Permits for Eastern Finland. Environmental Permit for the “Linnunsuo” Peat Production Area, 2003. Dnro ISY-2002-Y-192 (In Finnish).

  2. Center of Economic Development, Transport and the Environment—CEDTE. Decision. POKELY/469/07.00/2010. 23rd November 2010 (In Finnish).

  3. Center of Economic Development, Transport and the Environment—CEDTE. Decision. POKELY/469/07.00/2010. 3rd November 2011 (In Finnish).

  4. Complaint Submitted by the Village Association of Selkie to the Center of Economic Development, Transport and the Environment—CEDTE, North Karelia, 26.07.2010 (In Finnish).

  5. (a) Complaint Submitted by the Village Association of Selkie to the Regional State Administrative Agency for Eastern Finland, 28.1.2011 (In Finnish).

  6. (b) Clarifying Explanation of the Village Association of Selkie in Response to the Response Provided by the Company “VAPO”, submitted 23.5.2011 at the Regional State Administrative Agency—Eastern Finland (In Finnish).

  7. Police. The Report for the Criminal Investigation. 16.02.2012. 8480/R/10360/11 (In Finnish).

  8. Regional State Administrative Agency-RAA. Decision. ISAVI/13/04.08/2011 (In Finnish).

  9. Regional State Administrative Agency-RAA. Decision. ISAVI/9/04.08/2012 (In Finnish).

  10. VAPO. Suggestion for a Course of Action. 17.11.2010. Submitted at the Center of Economic Development, Transport and the Environment in Joensuu (In Finnish).

  11. VAPO. Response to the Complaint Submitted by the Village Association of Selkie. 20.4.2011 (In Finnish).

  12. (a) VAPO. A Letter to the Village of Selkie. February 2012 (In Finnish).

Published Sources

  1. Beck, U. 1999. World at risk. Malden: Polity Press.

    Google Scholar 

  2. Berkes, F. 1999. Sacred ecology—Traditional ecological knowledge and resource management. Philadelphia: Taylor & Francis.

    Google Scholar 

  3. Ettlinger, N. 2011. Governmentality as epistemology. Annals of Association of American Geographers 101: 537–560.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  4. Foucault, M. 1990. Intellectuals and power. In Discourses: Conversations in postmodern art and culture, ed. Ferguson, R, W. Olander, M. Tucker, K. Fiss, 471 pp. New York: Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

  5. Foucault, M. 2005. Archaeology of knowledge. Tampere: Vastapaino (In Finnish).

  6. Foucault, M. 2010. The order of things: An archaeology of human sciences. Helsinki: Gaudeamus (In Finnish).

  7. Husserl, E. 2011. The crisis of European sciences and transcendental phenomenology. Helsinki: Gaudeamus (In Finnish).

  8. Lehtinen, M. 2011. Afterword by the translator. In The crisis of European sciences and transcendental phenomenology, ed. Husserl, E. Helsinki: Gaudeamus (In Finnish).

  9. Luotonen, E. 2006. Oura of the fisherman. In The unknown archipelagoThe lived landscape of Selkämeri Sea, ed. Häyrynen, M, E. Luotonen, E. Mustalampi, E. Bruk. Helsinki: Otava (In Finnish).

  10. Miettinen, T. 2012. Europe as a philosophical idea. Tieteessä tapahtuu 6: 3–12. (In Finnish).

    Google Scholar 

  11. Mustonen, T. 2009. Never-ending life-world of peoples of the bear. Joensuu: Joensuun yliopisto (In Finnish, English summary).

  12. Mustonen, T. 2012a. Re-reading critical infrastructure—A view from the indigenous communities of the Russian Arctic. In Russian critical infrastructuresVulnerabilities and policies, ed. Pynnöniemi, K, 124 pp. Helsinki: Finnish Institute of International Affairs.

  13. Mustonen, T. 2012b. Rebirth of indigenous Arctic Nations and polar resource management: Critical perspectives from Siberia and Sámi areas of Finland. Biodiversity 1–9. doi:10.1080/14888386.2012.725652.

  14. Mustonen, T. 2013. Ice fishing cultures of North Karelia, Finland—The case of Puruvesi winter seining. In EcoculturesBlueprints for sustainable communities, ed. Böhm, S, Z. Bharucha, J. Pretty. Essex: University of Essex Press (in press).

  15. Mustonen, T., K. Mustonen, A. Aikio, and P. Aikio. 2010. Drowning reindeer, drowning homes—Indigenous Sámi and hydroelectricity development in Sompio, Finland. Kontiolahti: Snowchange Cooperative.

    Google Scholar 

  16. Nevalainen, J. 2004. Knowledge politics of game of spaceA struggle for the change of city center. Joensuu: Joensuun yliopisto (In Finnish, English Summary).

  17. Orru, M., and H. Orru. 2008. Sustainable use of Estonian peat reserves and environmental challenges. Estonian Journal of Earth Sciences 2008: 87–93. doi:10.3176/earth.2008.2.04.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  18. Pynnöniemi, K. (ed.). 2012. Russian critical infrastructures—Vulnerabilities and policies. Helsinki: Finnish Institute of International Affairs.

    Google Scholar 

  19. Rannikko, P, and N. Schuurman (eds.). 1997. The magic of living in the Taiga. Human and nature in the biosphere of North Karelia. Joensuu: Publications of Karelian Institute (In Finnish).

  20. Selkien kyläyhdistys. 2004. SelkieCultural village. Jyväskylä: Village Association of Selkie (In Finnish).

  21. Tanskanen, M. 2000. Behind the seenAn inquiry into cultural aspects of a landscape of a marsh-mire ditched for forestry. Joensuu: Joensuun yliopisto (In Finnish, English summary).

  22. (b) VAPO. 2012. Peat production on sulfide soil. Case Linnunsuo in Eastern Finland. In Geological survey of Finland. 7th International acid sulfate soil conference: Towards harmony between land use and the environment. Proceedings Volume. Vaasa: Geological Survey of Finland.

  23. Vesajoki, H, and M. Pihlatie. 2011. PielisjokiStream of life. Hyvinkää: Authors (In Finnish, English Summary).

  24. Wahlström, E, E. Hallanaro, and S. Manninen. 1996. Future of the Finnish environment. Helsinki: Edita (In Finnish).

Media Sources

  1. Engineering and Mining Journal. www.e-mj.com. Accessed March 2010.

  2. Hassi, S. 2010. Holy peat cow and fish deaths. Blog, www.satuhassi.fi. 17th November 2010. http://www.satuhassi.fi. Accessed 12 June 2013 (In Finnish).

  3. Karjalainen. Jukajoki is dead. Karjalainen 17.11.2010 (In Finnish).

  4. Karjalainen. The dead fish returned. Karjalainen 23.6.2011 (In Finnish).

Download references

Acknowledgments

This article has been made possible by the Turvetuotanto ja vesistövaikutusten hallinta: Relevanteista faktoista tehokkaisiin normeihin/WATER MANAGEMENT AND PEAT PRODUCTION: From the Relevant Facts to Effective Norms (WAPEAT) (Suomen Akatemian hanke 263465) Project. The author is thankful to Jarmo Rinne, Hilkka Heinonen and Kaisu Mustonen and two anonymous reviewers for comments regarding the article.

Author information

Affiliations

Authors

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Tero Mustonen.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Mustonen, T. Power Discourses of Fish Death: Case of Linnunsuo Peat Production. AMBIO 43, 234–243 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-013-0425-3

Download citation

Keywords

  • Peat production
  • Fish death
  • Discourse analysis
  • Jukajoki
  • North Karelia
  • Finland
  • Local knowledge