, Volume 42, Issue 6, pp 715–723 | Cite as

Invisible Face of Boron Pollution in Fluvial Ecosystem: The Level in the Tissues of Sentinel and Nectonic Organisms

  • Naime Arslan


Turkey is the largest producer of borate products in the world. Among four largest boron mines in Turkey two of them are located in basins of Orhaneli and Emet Streams. In this study, boron levels in abiotic (water–sediment) and some biotic elements (sentinel organisms; Asellus aquaticus, Gammarus pulex, Chironomus tentans, Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri and nektonic organism; Squalius cii) of Orhaneli and Emet Streams were investigated and their ranks among the food chain were demonstrated. Since Orhaneli and Emet Streams confluence to form Mustafakemalpaşa Brook which feeds Uluabat Lake which is one of the most important Ramsar fields of the world, Boron levels in those two streams have importance in terms of both continuances of aquatic systems. Present study results have shown that boron levels in water of both streams are much higher (vary between 8.64 and 16.73 mg L−1) than not only Turkish Standard but also limits determined by WHO, US EPA, and NAS. Boron levels determined in sediments of two streams vary between 18.05 and 36.7 mg kg−1. The highest boron level in the biotic elements was determined in liver of Squalius cii (34.64 mg kg−1), it is followed by Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri (2.84 mg kg−1), Chironomus tentans (2.11 mg kg−1), and Gammarus pulex (1.98 mg kg−1).


Boron pollution Orhaneli and Emet streams 



The author is grateful to Dr. Özgür Emiroğlu and Dr. Arzu Çiçek, who kindly provided a collection of samples and analyses for the study, respectively.


  1. Anonymous. 2005. Soil Science Society of Turkey. International Soil Meeting (ISM) on soil sustaining life on earth, managing soil and technology, 2006. Retrieved 2 November, 2011, from
  2. APHA. 1992. Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater. Washington, DC: American Public Health Association.Google Scholar
  3. Arslan, N., A. Çiçek, C. Akkan, D. Kılınç, and E. Acı. 2010. Accumulation of heavy metals by earthworms in boron contaminated area (Kırka-Eskişehir). Zoology in the Middle East, Advances of Earthworm Taxonomy IV: 111–117.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  4. ASTM. 1985. Preparation of biological samples for inorganic chemical analysis. 1. Annual Book of ASTM Standards, D-19, 740–747.Google Scholar
  5. Budavari, S., M.J. O’Neal, A. Smith, P.E. Heckelman, and J.F. Kinneary. 1996. The Merck Index: An encyclopedia of chemicals, drugs, and biologicals. Whitehouse Station: Merck and Co.Google Scholar
  6. Çöl, M., and C. Çöl. 2003. Environmental boron contamination in waters of Hisarcik area in the Kütahya Province of Turkey. Food and Chemical Toxicology 41: 1417–1420.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  7. Çöl, M., Y. Genc, and B.S. Şaylı. 2000. Osteoporosis prevalence in women living in a boron mineral region of Turkey, and combined factors. Archives of Complex Environmental Studies 3–4: 30–41.Google Scholar
  8. Coughlin, J.R. 1998. Sources of human exposure: Overview of water supplies as sources of boron. Biological Trace Element Research 66: 87–100.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. ECETOC (European Centre for Ecotoxicology and Toxicology of Chemicals). 1997. Ecotoxicology of some inorganic borates—Interim report, Brussels, special report No. 11.Google Scholar
  10. EGVM. 2003. Expert group on vitamins and minerals safe, upper levels for vitamins and minerals. Food Standards Agency. Retrieved 4 December, 2011, from
  11. Eimers, R.D., R.D. Evans, and P.M. Welbourn. 2001. Cadmium accumulation in the freshwater isopod Asellus racovitzai: The relative importance of solute and particulate sources at trace concentrations. Environmental Pollution 111: 247–253.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Emiroğlu, Ö., A. Çiçek, N. Arslan, S. Aksan, and M. Rüzgar. 2010. Boron concentration in water, sediment and different organisms around large borate deposits of Turkey. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology. doi: 10.1007/s00128-010-9961-8.Google Scholar
  13. EPA Method 200.8. 2001. Determination of trace elements in waters and wastes by inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry. Revision 5.4, Methods for the determination of metals in environmental samples. Environmental Protection Agency, Supplement I, Washington, DC.Google Scholar
  14. FAO. 1976. Water quality for agriculture. Irag. and Drainage Paper 29, Rome.Google Scholar
  15. Fernandez, M., S. Cuesta, O. Jimene, M.A. Garcia, L.M. Hernandez, M.L. Marina, and M.J. Gonzalez. 2000. Organochlorine and heavy metal residues in the water/sediment system of the Southeast Regional Park in Madrid, Spain. Chemosphere 41: 801–812.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Hirst, H., I. Jüttner, and S.J. Ormerod. 2002. Comparing the responses of diatoms and macroinvertebrates to metals in upland streams of Wales and Cornwall. Freshwater Biology 47: 1752–1765.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  17. Howe, P.D. 1998. A review of boron effects in the environment. Biological Trace Element Research 66: 153–166.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Kılıç, A.M. 2004. Importance of boron mine for Turkey and place in the future. In Proceedings of the 2nd International Boron Symposium, 34.Google Scholar
  19. Korkmaz, M., M. Yenigün, S. Bakırdere, O.Y. Ataman, S. Keskin, T. Müezzinoğlu, and M. Lekili. 2011. Effects of chronic boron exposure on semen profile. Biological Trace Element Research 143: 738–750.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. NAS. 1980. Boron in mineral tolerance of domestic animals. Washington, DC: NAS.Google Scholar
  21. Natural Health Products Directorate Health Canada. 2007. Boron as a medicinal ingredient in oral. Retrieved 4 December, 2011, from
  22. Nordberg, M., D.M. Templeton, O. Andersen, and J.H. Duffus. 2009. Glossary of terms used in ecotoxicology. Pure and Applied Chemistry 81: 829–970.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  23. Önal, G., and F. Burat. 2008. Boron mining and processing in Turkey. Gospodarka Surowcami Mineralnymi 24: 49–60.Google Scholar
  24. Özen A, M. Canbek, M. Uyanoğlu, N. Arslan, and A. Çiçek. 2009. Investigation of heavy metal and boron compound toxicological effect to Limnodrilus hoffmeisteri, a indicator organism. In IV International Boron Symposium, 421–428 (in Turkish).Google Scholar
  25. Özulug, M., and J. Freyhof. 2011. Revision of the genus Squalius in Western and Central Anatolia, with description of four new species (Teleostei: Cyprinidae). Ichthyological Exploration of Freshwaters 22: 107–148.Google Scholar
  26. Provin, T.L., and J.L. Pitt. 2002. Description of water analysis parameters. Soil and Crop Science Department. Retrieved 16 November, 2011, from
  27. Rinderhagen, M., J. Ritterhoff, and G.P. Zauke. 2000. Biomonitoring of polluted water—Reviews on actual topics. Scitech Publications, Environmental Research Forum.Google Scholar
  28. Şaylı, B.S., E. Tuccar, and A.H. Elhan. 1998. An assessment of fertility in boron-exposed Turkish subpopulations. Reproductive Toxicology 12: 297–304.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  29. Sharma, S. 1996. Applied multivariate techniques. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
  30. Smolders, A.J.P., R.A.C. Lock, G. van der Velde, R.I. Medina Hoyos, and J.G.M. Roelofs. 2003. Effects of mining activities on heavy metal concentrations in water, sediment, and macroinvertebrates in different reaches of the Pilcomayo River, South America. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 44: 314–323.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  31. Stoumboudi, M.T., M. Kottelat, and R. Barbierri. 2006. The fishes of the inland waters of Lesbos Island, Greece. Ichthyological Exploration of Freshwaters 17: 129–146.Google Scholar
  32. Tabanchnick, B.G., and L.S. Fidell. 1996. Using multivariate statistics. New York: Harper Collins College Publishers.Google Scholar
  33. Tokatlı, C., E. Köse, K. Uysal, A. Çiçek, and N. Arslan. 2011. Determination of macro and micro elements concentrations in epipelic diatom frustules in Porsuk Dam Lake. Tarım Bilimleri Araştırma Dergisi 4: 1–6 (in Turkish, English summary).Google Scholar
  34. Turkish Environmental Guidelines. 2004. National Recommendent Water Quality Criteria. Retrieved 9 October, 2011, from
  35. Türkez, H., F. Geyikoglu, A. Tatar, M.S. Keles, and I. Kaplan. 2012. The effects of some boron compounds against heavy metal toxicity in human blood. Experimental and Toxicologic Pathology 64: 93–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. US EPA. 2004. United States Environmental Protection Agency Integrated Risk Information System. Toxicological review of boron and compounds. Retrieved 3 October, 2011, from
  37. Watanabe, N.C., S. Harada, and Y. Komai. 2000. Long-term recovery from mine drainage disturbance of a macroinvertebrate community in the Ichi-Kawa River, Japan. Hydrobiologia 429: 171–180.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  38. WHO. 1998a. Environmental health criteria, 204. Retrieved 9 October, 2011, from
  39. WHO. 1998b. Environmental health criteria Boron. Retrieved 11 October, 2011, from
  40. Xu, Y., and J.Q. Jiang. 2008. Technologies for boron removal. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research 47: 16–24. doi: 10.1021/ie0708982.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Yüce, G., and D. Ugurluoglu Yasin. 2012. Assessment of an increase in boron and arsenic concentrations at the discharge area of Na-Borate mine (Kırka-Eskisehir, Turkey). Journal of Terrestrial Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences 23. doi: 10.3319/TAO.2012.05.10.01.

Copyright information

© Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences 2013

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Biology Department, Science and Art FacultyEskişehir Osmangazi UniversityEskisehirTurkey

Personalised recommendations