Abstract
Climate change is an important environmental problem and one whose economic implications are many and varied. This paper starts with the presumption that mitigation of greenhouse gases is a necessary policy that has to be designed in a cost effective way. It is well known that market instruments are the best option for cost effectiveness. But the discussion regarding which of the various market instruments should be used, how they may interact and what combinations of policies should be implemented is still open and very lively. In this paper we propose a combination of instruments: the marketable emission permits already in place in Europe for major economic sectors and a CO2 tax for economic sectors not included in the emissions permit scheme. The study uses an applied general equilibrium model for the Spanish economy to compute the results obtained with the new mix of instruments proposed. As the combination of the market for emission permits and the CO2 tax admits different possibilities that depend on how the mitigation is distributed among the economic sectors, we concentrate on four possibilities: cost-effective, equalitarian, proportional to emissions, and proportional to output distributions. Other alternatives to the CO2 tax are also analysed (tax on energy, on oil and on electricity). Our findings suggest that careful, well designed policies are needed as any deviation imposes significant additional costs that increase more than proportionally to the level of emissions reduction targeted by the EU.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.
References
Aldy JE, Krupnick AJ, Newell RG, Parry, IWH, Pizer WA (2009) Designing climate mitigation policy. RFF discussion paper, 08-16-REV
Alesina AF, Passarelli F (2010) Regulation versus taxation. NBER working paper no. 16413
Ansuategi A, Galarraga I (2009) Carbon pricing as an effective instrument of climate policy: searching for an optimal policy instrument. Rivista di Politica Economica, VII-IX
Arto I, Gallastegui MC, Ansuategi A (2009) Accounting for early action in the European Union Emission Trading Scheme. Energy Policy 37: 3194–3924
Babiker MH, Mayer M, Wieng I, Hyman R (2001) The MIT emissions prediction and policy analysis EPPA model. MIT Global Change Joint Program, 71, Cambridge, MA
Baranzini A, Goldemberg J, Speck S (2000) A future for carbon taxes: survey. Ecol Econ 32: 395–412
Baumol WJ, Oates WE (1971) The use of standards and prices for protection of the environment. Swedish J Econ 73: 42–54
Baumol WJ, Oates WE (1988) The theory of environmental policy, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press
Böhringer C, Rosendahl KE (2010) Green promotes the dirtiest: on the interaction between black and green quotas in energy markets. J Regul Econ 37: 316–325
Boots M (2003) Green certificates and carbon trading in the Netherlands. Energy Policy 31(1): 43–50
COD (2008) Proposal for a decision of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Effort of Member States to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions to meet the community’s greenhouse gas emission reduction commitment up to 2020. 2008/0014 (COD)
Dellink R, Hofkes M, van Ierland E, Verbruggen H (2004) Dynamic modelling of pollution abatement in a CGE framework. Econ Model 21(6): 965–989
Del Río P (2009) Interactions between climate and energy policies: the case of Spain. Clim Policy 9: 119–138
Del Río P, Labandeira X, Linares P (2009) La interacción del sistema europeo de comercio de emisiones con otros instrumentos de política. Papeles de Economía Española 121: 211–224
Eurostat (2005) Energy, transport and environment. European Statistic Office, Luxemburg
Faehn T, Gómez-Plana A, Kverndokk S (2009) Can a carbon permit system reduce Spanish unemployment?. Energy Econ 31(4): 595–604
Gallastegui MC, Galarraga I (2010) La Unión Europea Frente al Cambio Climático: El Paquete de Medidas sobre Cambio Climático y Energía (20-20-20). In: Becker F, Cazorla LM, Martínez-Simancas J (eds) Tratado de Energías Renovables. Iberdrola-Thomson-Aranzadi
Gallastegui MC, Iñarra E, Prellezo R (2002) Bankruptcy of fishing resources: the Northern European anglerfish fishery. Mar Resour Econ 17(4):291–307
Gollier C (2010) Ecological discounting. J Econ Theory 145: 812–829
González-Eguino M (2010) Modelización de los coste de mitigación de emisiones: el caso de un mercado de permisos de emisión para España. Trimestre Económico 305(1): 185–218
Goulder LH, Parry I (2008) Instruments choice in environmental policy. Resource for the future. Discussion Paper 08-07, Washington, DC
Goulder LH, Stavins RN (2010) Interactions between state and federal climate change policies. Foundazione Eni Enrico Mattei Working Papers, 487
Goulder LH, Parry I, Williams RC III, Burtraw DT (1999) The cost-effectiveness of alternative instruments for environmental protection in a second-best setting. J Public Econ 72: 329–360
Green KP, Hayward SF, Hassett KA (2007) Climate change: cap vs. Taxes. Environmental Policy Outlook, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, AEI, no. 2, June
Hahn RW (1989) Economic prescriptions for environmental problems: how the patient followed the doctor’s orders. J Econ Perspect 3(2): 95–114
Hahn RW (2000) The impact of economics on environmental policy. J Environ Econ Manag 39: 375–399
Hauser T, Bradley R, Childs B, Werkman J, Heilmayr R (2008) Leveling the carbon playing field: international competition and US climate policy design. Peterson Institute for International Economics, World Resource Institute, Washington, DC
Hayashi F (1982) Tobin’s q, rational expectations and optimal investment rule. Econometrica 50: 213–224
Heyes A (2000) Implementing environmental regulation: enforcement and compliance. J Regul Econ 17: 107–129
Hoel M (1990) Efficient international agreements for reducing emissions of CO2. University of Oslo Working papers. Department of Economics
Hoel M, Karp LS (2002) Taxes versus quotas for a stock pollutant. Resour Energy Econ 24: 367–384
Hourcade JC, Neuhoff K, Demailly D, Sato M (2008) Differentiation and dynamics of EU ETS industrial competitiveness impacts. Climate Strategies Papers
INE (2002) Cuentas Económicas. Instituto Nacional de Estadística, Madrid
Kolstad CD, Toman M (2005) The economics of climate policy. In: Mäler KG, Vincent J (eds) Handbook of environmental economics, vol 3. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 1561–1618
Krutilla K (1999) Environmental policy and transactions cost. In: van den Bergh (eds) Handbook of environmental and resource economics. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham
Labandeira X, Rodríguez M (2007) Wide and narrow approaches to national climate policies: a case study for Spain. Clim Policy 10(1): 51–69
Linares P, Santos FJ, Ventosa M (2008) Interactions of carbon reduction and renewable support policies in electricity markets: a review of existing results and some recommendations for a coordinated regulation. Clim Policy 8(4): 377–394
Manresa A, Sancho F (2005) Implementing a double dividend: recycling ecotaxes towards lower labour taxes. Energy Policy 33(12): 1577–1585
Morthorst PE (2003) National environmental targets and international emission reduction instruments. Energy Policy 31: 73–83
Newell RG, Stavins RN (2003) Cost heterogeneity and potential savings from market-based policies. J Regul Econ 23: 43–59
Nordhaus WD (2008) The challenge of global warming: economic models and environmental policy. Yale University Press, New Haven
OECD (2009) The cost-effectiveness of climate change mitigation policy instruments. In: The economics of climate change mitigation: policies and options for global action beyond 2012. Paris
Parry I, Pizer B (2007) Combating global warming: is taxation or cap-and-trade the better strategy for reducing greenhouse emissions. Regulation 30(3):18–22
Pearce D (2006) The political economy of an energy tax: the United Kingdom’s climate change levy. Energy Econ 28: 149–158
Rutherford T, Paltsev S (2000) GTAP-EG: incorporating energy statistics into GTAP format. WP, University of Colorado
Shoven J, Whalley J (1992) Applying general equilibrium. Cambridge University Press
Sijm J (2003) Interaction of the EU emissions trading directive with climate policy instruments in the Netherlands. Policy brief INTERACT project. ECN, Amsterdam
Sijm J (2005) The interaction between the EU emissions trading scheme and national energy policies. Clim Policy 5: 79–89
Sijm J (2007) Options for post-2012 EU burden sharing and EU ETS allocation. ECN and MNP Working paper
Springer U (2003) The market for tradable GHG permits under the Kyoto protocol: a survey of model studies. Energy Econ 25: 527–551
Stern N (2008) The economics of climate change. Am Econ Rev 98(2): 1–37
Tietenberg T (1990) Economic instruments for environmental regulation. Oxf Rev Econ Policy 6(1): 17–34
Tirole J (2010) From Pigou to extended liability: on the optimal taxation of externalities under imperfect financial markets. Rev Econ Stud 77(2):697–729
Uzawa H (2003) Economic theory and global warming. Cambridge University Press. ISBN:052182386-2
Weitzman ML (1974) Prices versus quantities. Rev Econ Stud 41: 477–491
Weyant JP (ed) (1999) The costs of the Kyoto protocol: a multi-model evaluation. Energy J 20:1–398
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Gallastegui, M.C., González-Eguino, M. & Galarraga, I. Cost effectiveness of a combination of instruments for global warming: a quantitative approach for Spain. SERIEs 3, 111–132 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13209-011-0054-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13209-011-0054-7
Keywords
- Environmental policy instruments
- Applied general equilibrium models
- Cap and trade
- CO2 tax
- Climate policy