Advertisement

Water History

, Volume 6, Issue 3, pp 247–263 | Cite as

Water law in British-ruled Palestine

  • David SchorrEmail author
Article
  • 312 Downloads

Abstract

This article surveys the water law of Palestine under British rule, identifying the legal norms governing the use of water and explaining some of the factors shaping the development of this area of the law. It argues that despite their lack of official lawmaking power, Arabs and Jews succeeded in decisively shaping the course taken by water law in this period. After surveying the Ottoman water law in force when the British took power in 1917, the article examines influential court decisions in a case brought by the Arab residents of the village Artas against government expropriation of water, and explains the significance of this litigation for the subsequent development of Palestine’s water law. It then discusses British initiatives meant to reform water law and subject the country’s water to state control, plans frustrated by the opposition of Zionist groups fearful of increased government regulation. It closes by noting that water law was made in this colonial context neither by imposition from above nor by resistance from below, but by intervention of subject peoples at the highest levels of official lawmaking.

Keywords

Palestine Water law Property rights League of Nations Mandate Zionists Arabs 

Notes

Acknowledgments

Landon Derentz, Bill Gutterman, Shira Hantzis, Rachel Jacobson, Adi Levitski, MJ Muwassi, Yael Nomkin, Waseem Omar, Ariel Pariente, and Ben Soloway all provided critical research assistance. Dan Bitan, Nandini Chatterjee, Assaf Likhovski, Amer Marei, Assaf Selzer, Bob Varady, an anonymous reviewer, and participants in the faculty seminar at Tel Aviv University Faculty of Law supplied helpful comments at various stages. Research funding was provided by the Israel-Palestine Scientific Organization; the Israel Science Foundation (grant no. 1108/11); the University of Plymouth’s Judging Empire travel fellowship; the David Berg Foundation Institute for Law and History and the Cegla Center Interdisciplinary Research of the Law, both at Tel Aviv University; and the US National Endowment for the Humanities. Any views, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this article do not necessarily reflect those of the National Endowment for the Humanities or any other funder.

References

Books, articles, and official publications

  1. Bunton M (1999) Inventing the status quo: Ottoman land-law during the Palestine mandate, 1917–1936. Int Hist Rev 21:28–56CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  2. Caponera DA (1954) Water Law in Moslem Countries. FAO, RomeGoogle Scholar
  3. D’Ohsson IM (1820) Tableau Général de L’empire Othoman, vol 3. Firmin Didot, ParisGoogle Scholar
  4. French L (1931) First report on agricultural development and land settlement in Palestine. Garden City Press, JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  5. Government of Palestine (1947) Memorandum on the water resources of Palestine. Government Printer, JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  6. Great Britain (1936) Report by his Majesty’s Government in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland to the Council of the League of Nations on the Administration of Palestine and Trans-Jordan for the year 1936. HMSO, LondonGoogle Scholar
  7. Grove RH (1995) Green imperialism: colonial expansion, tropical island Edens and the origins of environmentalism, 1600–1860. Cambridge University Press, CambridgeGoogle Scholar
  8. Guha R, Gadgil M (1989) State forestry and social conflict in British India. Past Present 123:141–177CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  9. Halperin H (1956) LeHatza’at Hok Hamayim. Gov Print Off, Tel AvivGoogle Scholar
  10. Hirsch AM (1959) Water legislation in the Middle East. Am J Comp Law 8:168–186CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  11. Hofri-Winogradow AS (2012) Zionist Settlers and the English Private Trust in Mandate Palestine. Law Hist Rev 30:813–864CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  12. Hooper CA (1936) The civil law of Palestine and Trans-Jordan. Azriel, JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  13. Hope-Simpson J (1930) Palestine: report on immigration, land settlement and development. Cmd 3686. HMSO, LondonGoogle Scholar
  14. Jardine RF (1944) The regional control of water resources in the Middle East with special reference to the legal aspect. In: The proceedings of the conference on Middle East agricultural development, Cairo, February 7th–10th 1944. Middle East Supply Centre, Agricultural report no. 6, Cairo, pp 181–189Google Scholar
  15. Knoll B (2006) Beyond the Mission Civilisatrice: the properties of a normative order within an internationalized territory. Leiden J Int Law 19:275–304CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  16. Lemire V (2011) The awakening of Palestinian hydropolitical consciousness: the Artas-Jerusalem water conflict of 1925. Jerus Q 48:31–53Google Scholar
  17. Likhovski A (1998) Between “Mandate” and “State”: re-thinking the periodization of Israeli legal history. J Isr Hist 19(2):39–68CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Likhovski A (2006) Law and identity in Mandate Palestine. University of North Carolina Press, Chapel HillGoogle Scholar
  19. Malchi E (1953) The history of the law of Palestine, 2nd edn. Dinnim, Tel AvivGoogle Scholar
  20. Mogannam ME (1932) Palestine legislation under the British. Ann Am Acad Polit Soc Sci 164:47–54CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  21. Pedersen S (2010) The impact of league oversight on British policy in Palestine. In: Miller R (ed) Britain, Palestine and Empire: The mandate years. Ashgate, Farnham, pp 39–65Google Scholar
  22. Rook RE (2000) An American in Palestine: Elwood Mead and Zionist Water Resource Planning, 1923–1936. Arab Stud Q 22:71–89Google Scholar
  23. Sachar HM (1996) A history of Israel: from the rise of Zionism to our time, 2nd edn. Knopf, New YorkGoogle Scholar
  24. Trottier J (1999) Hydropolitics in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. PASSIA, JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  25. Tute RC (1927) The Ottoman land laws, with a commentary on the Ottoman land code of 7th Ramadan 1274. Greek Convent Press, JerusalemGoogle Scholar
  26. Worthington EB (1946) Middle East science: a survey of subjects other than agriculture, a report to the Director General Middle East Supply Centre, August 1945. HMSO, LondonGoogle Scholar

Legislation

  1. Declaration Giving Force to Palestine (Amendment) Order in Council, 1940 (1950). Yalkut Pirsumim no 83, 26 Apr 1950, 892Google Scholar
  2. Defence (Water Distribution) Regulations, 1944. Off Gaz no 1375 (suppl 2), 16 Nov 1944, 1157–1161Google Scholar
  3. Drainage (Surface Water) Ordinance, 1942. Off Gaz no 1201 (suppl 1), 25 June 1942, 58–61Google Scholar
  4. Electricity Concessions Ordinance, 1934. Drayt 2:633–657Google Scholar
  5. Emergency Powers (Colonial Defence) Order in Council, 1939. Off Gaz no 914 (suppl 2), 26 Aug 1939, 656–658Google Scholar
  6. Foreign Jurisdiction Act, 1890. 53 & 54 Vict Ch 37Google Scholar
  7. Land Law (1858). In: Ongley F (transl) (1892) The Ottoman Land Code. William Clowes, London, 1–70Google Scholar
  8. Mandate for Palestine (1922). The Avalon Project. http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/palmanda.asp
  9. Mejelle (1867–77). In: Hooper (1936) vol 1Google Scholar
  10. Municipal Corporations (Sewerage, Drainage and Water) Ordinance, 1936, Off Gaz 560 (suppl 1), 2 Jan 1936, 1–11Google Scholar
  11. Palestine (Amendment) Order in Council, 1940. Off Gaz no 1093 (suppl 2), 1 May 1941, 666–667Google Scholar
  12. Palestine Order in Council, 1922, as amended by Palestine (Amendment) Order in Council, 1923. Legislation of Palestine 1918–1925 1:1–22Google Scholar
  13. Safeguarding of Public Water Supplies Ordinance, 1937. Off Gaz no 711 (suppl 1), 19 Aug 1937, 185–188Google Scholar
  14. Urtas Springs Ordinance, 1925. Legislation of Palestine 1918–1925 1:513–514Google Scholar
  15. Water Law, 5719–1959. Laws of the State of Israel 13:173Google Scholar
  16. Water Survey Ordinance, 1938. Off Gaz no 757 (suppl 1), 10 Feb 1938, 4–5Google Scholar

Court cases

  1. Court of Cassation (1912) C.C.D. No. 180. Noted in: Hooper (1936) 2:157Google Scholar
  2. Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (1926) Jerusalem-Jaffa District Governor v Murra. Appeals Cases 1926:321–330Google Scholar
  3. Supreme Court of Cyprus (1890) Loizo v Vehim. Cyprus Law Reps 2:91–104Google Scholar
  4. Supreme Court of Palestine (1925) Murra v District Governor, Jerusalem-Jaffa District. Collection of Judgments of the Courts of Palestine 1919–1933 5:1818–1834Google Scholar
  5. Supreme Court of Palestine (1935) Michaelis v Local Council of Rehovoth. Palestine Law Reps 2:284Google Scholar

Archival files

  1. District Governor v Murra Printed Papers. Shelfmark P.P. 1316, judgment 8/1926, British LibraryGoogle Scholar
  2. File CO 733/155. United Kingdom National Archives, Colonial Office seriesGoogle Scholar
  3. File CO 733/248. United Kingdom National Archives, Colonial Office seriesGoogle Scholar
  4. File CO 733/440. United Kingdom National Archives, Colonial Office seriesGoogle Scholar
  5. File ISA/RG 2/M/210/13. Israel State Archives, Mandate seriesGoogle Scholar
  6. File ISA/RG 2/M/210/14. Israel State Archives, Mandate seriesGoogle Scholar
  7. File ISA/RG 2/M/478/14. Israel State Archives, Mandate seriesGoogle Scholar
  8. File ISA/RG 2/M/478/15. Israel State Archives, Mandate seriesGoogle Scholar
  9. File ISA/RG 3/M/711/3. Israel State Archives, Mandate seriesGoogle Scholar
  10. File ISA/RG 3/M/721/24. Israel State Archives, Mandate seriesGoogle Scholar
  11. File ISA/RG 3/M/729/23. Israel State Archives, Mandate seriesGoogle Scholar
  12. File KKL8\131. Central Zionist Archives, Jewish National Fund collectionGoogle Scholar
  13. File S53\960. Central Zionist Archives, Jewish Agency collectionGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Faculty of LawTel Aviv UniversityTel AvivIsrael

Personalised recommendations