Assessing Fidelity of Implementation (FOI) for School-Based Mindfulness and Yoga Interventions: A Systematic Review
- 1.8k Downloads
As school-based mindfulness and yoga programs gain popularity, the systematic study of fidelity of program implementation (FOI) is critical to provide a more robust understanding of the core components of mindfulness and yoga interventions, their potential to improve specified teacher and student outcomes, and our ability to implement these programs consistently and effectively. This paper reviews the current state of the science with respect to inclusion and reporting of FOI in peer-reviewed studies examining the effects of school-based mindfulness and/or yoga programs targeting students and/or teachers implemented in grades kindergarten through twelve (K-12) in North America. Electronic searches in PsychInfo and Web of Science from their inception through May 2014, in addition to hand searches of relevant review articles, identified 312 publications, 48 of which met inclusion criteria. Findings indicated a relative paucity of rigorous FOI. Fewer than 10 % of studies outlined potential core program components or referenced a formal theory of action, and fewer than 20 % assessed any aspect of FOI beyond participant dosage. The emerging nature of the evidence base provides a critical window of opportunity to grapple with key issues relevant to FOI of mindfulness-based and yoga programs, including identifying essential elements of these programs that should be faithfully implemented and how we might develop rigorous measures to accurately capture them. Consideration of these questions and suggested next steps are intended to help advance the emerging field of school-based mindfulness and yoga interventions.
KeywordsMindfulness Yoga Fidelity Implementation Review School-based intervention
This project was supported by and made possible through a grant from the National Institute on Drug Abuse (R34DA029237). We would like to thank Tony Garofano for his gracious help with graphics and layout.
Conflict of Interest
- Barnes, V. A., Taylor, F. A., & Davis, H. (2001). Impact of Transcendental Meditation on cardiovascular function at rest and during acute stress in adolescents with high normal blood pressure. Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 51, 597–605.Google Scholar
- Barnes, V. A., Pendergrast, R. A., Harshfield, G. A., & Treiber, F. A. (2008). Impact of breathing awareness meditation on ambulatory blood pressure and sodium handling in prehypertensive African American adolescents. Ethnicity & Disease, 18(1), 1–5.Google Scholar
- Beauchemin, J., Hutchins, T. L., & Patterson, F. (2008). Mindfulness meditation may lessen anxiety, promote social skills, and improve academic performance among adolescents with learning disabilities. Complementary Health Practice Review, 13(1), 34–45.Google Scholar
- Berger, D. L., Silver, E. J., & Stein, R. E. (2009). Effects of yoga on inner-city children’s well-being: a pilot study. Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine, 15(5), 36–42.Google Scholar
- Black, D. S., & Fernando, R. (2013). Mindfulness training and classroom behavior among lower-income and ethnic minority elementary school children. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 23(7), 1242–1246.Google Scholar
- Crane, R.S., Soulsby, J.G., Kuyken, W., Williams, J.M.G., Eames, C, Bartley, T., et al. (2012b). The Bangor, Exeter & Oxford mindfulness-based interventions teaching assessment criteria (MBI:TAC). http://www.mindfulnessteachersuk.org.uk/pdf/MBI-TACJune2012.pdf.
- Deming, W. E. (1986). Out of crisis. Cambridge: MIT Press.Google Scholar
- Dobkin, P. L., Hickman, S., & Monshat, K. (2013). Holding the heart of mindfulness-based stress-reduction: balancing fidelity and imagination when adapting MBSR. Mindfulness, 5(6), 710–718.Google Scholar
- Durlak, J. A. (1985). School-based prevention programs for children and adolescents. New York: Plenum.Google Scholar
- Elder, C., Nidich, S., Colbert, R., Hagelin, J., Grayshield, L., Oviedo-Lim, D., et al. (2011). Reduced psychological distress in racial and ethnic minority students practicing the transcendental meditation program. Journal of Instructional Psychology, 38(2), 109–116.Google Scholar
- Feagans Gould, L., Mendelson, T., Dariotis, J. K., Ancona, M., Smith, A. S. R., Gonzalez, A. A., Smith, A. A., & Greenberg, M. T. (2014). Assessing fidelity of core components in a mindfulness and yoga intervention for urban youth: applying the CORE process. New Directions for Youth Development, 142, 59–81.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Fixsen, D. L., Naoom, S. F., Blase, K. A., Friedman, R. M. & Wallace, F. (2005). Implementation research: a synthesis of the literature. Tampa, FL: University of South Florida, Louis de la Parte Florida Mental Health Institute, The National Implementation Research Network (FMHI Publication #231). http://ctndisseminationlibrary.org/PDF/nirnmonograph.pdf.
- Frank, J. L., Reibel, D., Broderick, P., Cantrell, T., & Metz, S. (2013). The effectiveness of mindfulness-based stress reduction on educator stress and well-being: results from a pilot study. Mindfulness, Advance online publication. doi: 10.1007/s12671-013-0246-2.
- Gregoski, M. J., Barnes, V. A., Tingen, M. S., Harshfield, G. A., & Treiber, F. A. (2011). Breathing awareness mediation and LifeSkills training programs influence upon ambulatory blood pressure and socium excretion among African American adolescents. Journal of Adolescent Health 48, 59–64.Google Scholar
- Hagins, M., Haden, S. C., & Daly, L. A. (2013). A randomized controlled trial on the effects of yoga on stress reactivity in 6th grade students. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. doi: 10.1155/2013/607134.
- Institute of Education Sciences. (2013) Common guidelines for education research and development: a report from the Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education and the National Science Foundation. Retrieved from: http://ies.ed.gov/pdf/CommonGuidelines.pdf.
- Jennings, P. A., Snowberg, K. E., Coccia, M. A., & Greenberg, M. T. (2011). Improving classroom learning environments by cultivating awareness and resilience in education (CARE): results of two pilot studies. Journal of Classroom Interaction, 46(1), 37–48.Google Scholar
- Jennings, P. A., Frank, J. L., Snowberg, K. E., Coccia, M. A., & Greenberg, M. T. (2013). Improving classroom learning environments by Cultivating Awareness and Resilience in Education (CARE): results of a randomized controlled trial. School Psychology Quarterly, 28(4), 374–390.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jones, S.M & Bouffard, S.M. (2012). Social and emotional learning in schools: from programs to strategies. Social Policy Report (vol. 26, no. 4). Society for Research in Child Development. http://www.srcd.org/sites/default/files/documents/spr_264_final_2.pdf.
- Kabat-Zinn, J. (1990). Full catastrophe living: using the wisdom of your body and mind to face stress, pain, and illness. New York: Bantam Dell.Google Scholar
- Kuyken, W., Weare, K., Ukoumunne, O. C., Vicary, R., Motton, N., Burnett, R., Cullen, C., Hennelly, S., & Huppert, F. (2013). Effectiveness of the mindfulness in schools programme: non-randomized controlled feasibility study. The British Journal of Psychiatry, 203(2), 126–131.CrossRefPubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lantieri, L., Nagler Kyse, E., Harnett, S., & Malkmus, C. (2011). Building inner resilience in teachers and students. In G.M. Reevy & E. Frydenberg (Eds.), Personality, Stress, and Coping: Implications for Education (pp. 267-292). Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.Google Scholar
- Le, T. N., & Gobert, J. M (2013). Translating and implementing a mindfulness-based youth suicide prevention intervention in a native American community. Journal of Child and Family Studies. doi: 10.1007/s10826-013-9809-z.
- Nidich, S. I., Nidich, R. J., & Rainforth, M. (1986). School effectiveness: achievement gains at the Maharishi School of the Age of Enlightenment. Education, 107(1), 49–54.Google Scholar
- Peck, H. L., Kehle, T. J., Bray, M. A., & Theodore, L. A. (2005). Yoga as an intervention for children with attention problems. School Psychology Review, 34(3), 415–424.Google Scholar
- Reid, E., & Miller, L. (2009). An exploration in mindfulness: classroom of detectives. The Teachers College Record, 111(12), 2775–2785.Google Scholar
- Roeser, R. W., Schonert-Reichl, K. A., Jha, A., Cullen, M., Wallace, L., Wilensky, R., et al. (2013). Mindfulness training and reductions in teacher stress and burnout: results from two randomized, waitlist-control field trials. Journal of Educational Psychology, 105(3), 787–804.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
- Ross, A., Friedman, E., Bevans, M., & Thomas, S. (2012). Frequency of yoga practice predicts health: results from a national survey of yoga practice. Evidence-based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2012/983258.
- Ruiz-Primo, M.A. (2005). A multi-method and multi-score approach for studying fidelity of implementation. Unpublished manuscript.Google Scholar
- Winzelberg, A. J., & Luskin, F. M. (1999). The effect of a meditation training in stress levels in secondary school teachers. Stress and Health, 15(2), 69–77.Google Scholar
- Wisner, B. L. (2013). An exploratory study of mindfulness meditation for alternative school students: perceived benefits for improving school climate and student functioning. Mindfulness. doi: 10.1007/s12671-013-0215-9.