The black box within a black box: Solitary confinement practices in a subset of U.S. immigrant detention facilities
In September 2013, the United States Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) issued a directive regarding the use of solitary confinement for ICE detainees. Among other provisions, the directive mandated reporting on the rationale behind decisions to place a detainee into solitary confinement, with particular emphases on placements lasting more than 14 days and for reasons related to illness and other “special vulnerabilities.” This paper analyzes administrative data from ICE, gathered via a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, on the use of solitary confinement per the 2013 ICE directive. The FOIA request covers 1193 incidents of solitary confinement from the beginning of the directive (September 2013) through the date of the FOIA request (September 2016), across six facilities under the jurisdiction of two California Field Offices (Los Angeles and San Francisco). Results reveal significant differences in the use of solitary confinement by gender, mental illness status, whether the confined individual had an attorney, Field Office jurisdiction, and individual facility. In addition, we document the extensive use of solitary confinement for “protective custody” and show that this category is potentially punitive in nature. Given the limited nature of access to information on ICE detainees, this is one of the only analyses of solitary confinement in immigrant detention facilities in the United States.
KeywordsSolitary confinement Immigration detention United States Immigration
- American Civil Liberties Union of Colorado. (2010). ACLU and experts slam findings of DOC report on solitary confinement. November 29, 2010. https://aclu-co.org/aclu-and-experts-slam-findings-of-doc-report-on-solitary-confinement/.
- Association, A. (Ed.). (2011). ABA standards for criminal justice: Treatment of prisoners (3rd ed.). Chicago, IL: American Bar Association, Criminal Justice Standards Committee.Google Scholar
- Association of State Correctional Administrators, and The Arthur Liman Public Interest Program, Yale Law School. (2016). Aiming to reduce time-in-cell: Reports from correctional systems on the numbers of prisoners in restricted housing and on the potential of policy changes to bring about reforms.Google Scholar
- Brodsky, S., & Scogin, F. (1988). Inmates in protective custody: First data on emotional effects. Forensic Reports, 1(December), 267–280.Google Scholar
- Browne, A., Hastings, A., Kall, K., & DiZerega, M. (2015). Keeping vulnerable populations safe under PREA: Alternative strategies to the use of segregation in prisons and jails. New York, NY: Vera Institute of Justice.Google Scholar
- Eagly, I., & Shafer, S. (2015). A national study of access to counsel in immigration court. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 164, 1.Google Scholar
- Eisen, L.-B. (2017). Private prisons lock up thousands of Americans with almost no oversight. New York, NY: The Brennan Center for Justice.Google Scholar
- Esquivel, P. (2017). ‘We Don’t Feel OK Here’: Detainee deaths, suicide attempts and hunger strikes plague California immigration facility. Los Angeles Times, August 8, 2017. http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-adelanto-detention-20170808-story.html.
- Fialho, C. (2018). FOIA request data on average daily detained population, March 2, 2018.Google Scholar
- Foster, D., Davis, D., & Sandler, D. (1987). Detention torture South Africa psychological, legal, and historical studies. Cape Town and Johannesburg: David Phillip.Google Scholar
- García Hernández, C. C. (2014). Immigration detention as punishment. UCLA Law Review, 61(5), 1346–1414.Google Scholar
- Gibbons, J. J., & de B. Katzenbach, N. (2006). Confronting confinement—A report of the commission on safety and abuse in America’s prisons. New York, NY: Vera Institute of Justice.Google Scholar
- Gordon, S. (2013). Solitary confinement, public safety, and recidivism. Univeristy of Michigan Journal of Law Reform, 47, 495.Google Scholar
- Grassian, S., & Kupers, T. (2011). The Colorado study vs. the reality of supermax confinement. Correctional Mental Health Report, 13(1), 1–4.Google Scholar
- Hafemeister, T., & George, J. (2012). The ninth circle of hell: An Eighth amendment analysis of imposing prolonged supermax solitary confinement on inmates with a mental illness. Denver University Law Review, 90, 1.Google Scholar
- Haney, C. (1993). Infamous punishment: The psychological effects of isolation. National Prison Project Journal, 8(2), 3–21.Google Scholar
- Haney, C., & Lynch, M. (1997). Regulating prisons of the future: A psychological analysis of supermax and solitary confinement. New York Review of Law and Social Change, 23, 477–570.Google Scholar
- Hayes, L., & Rowan, J. (1988). National study of jail suicides: Seven years later. Alexandria, VA: National Center on Institutions and Alternatives.Google Scholar
- Homeland Security Advisory Council. (2016). Report of the subcommittee on privatized immigration detention facilities. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Homeland Security.Google Scholar
- U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. (2013). Review of the use of segregation for ICE detainees. 11065.1. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Homeland Security.Google Scholar
- Kaufman, M. (2008). Detention, due process, and the right to counsel in removal proceedings. Stanford Journal of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, 4(113), 138–149.Google Scholar
- Kim, S., Pendergrass, T., & Zelon, H. (2012). Boxed In: The true cost of extreme isolation in New York’s prisons. New York, NY: New York Civil Liberties Union.Google Scholar
- Kupers, T. (1999). Prison madness: The mental health crisis behind bars and what we must do about it (1st ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.Google Scholar
- Kupers, T. (2017). Solitary: The inside story of supermax isolation and how we can abolish it. Oakland, CA: University of California Press.Google Scholar
- Lovell, D., & Toch, H. (2011). Some observations about the colorado segregation study. Correct Ment Health Rep, 13(1), 1–4.Google Scholar
- Markowitz, P. (2009). Barriers to representation for detained immigrants facing deportation: Varick street detention facility, a case study. Fordham Law Review, 78, 541.Google Scholar
- Mehta, S. (2010). Deportation by default: Mental disability, unfair hearings, and indefinite detention in the us immigration system. New York, NY: Human Rights Watch.Google Scholar
- Mendez, J. (2011). Interim report prepared by the special rapporteur of the human rights council on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. New York, NY: United Nations.Google Scholar
- Metcalf, H., Morgan, J., Oliker-Friedland, S., Resnik, J., Spiegel, J., Tae, H., Work, A., & Holbrook, B. (2013). Administrative segregation, degrees of isolation, and incarceration: A national overview of state and federal correctional policies. SSRN Scholarly Paper ID 2286861. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2286861. Accessed 5 April 2018.
- National Immigrant Justice Center (NIJC). (2012). Invisible in isolation: The use of solitary confinement in immigrant detention. Heartland Alliance’s National Immigrant Justice Center (NIJC) and Physicians for Human Rights (PHR). http://www.immigrantjustice.org/sites/immigrantjustice.org/files/Inter-AmericanCommission_Solitary_SegReport.pdf.
- Nelson, S. (2016). Private prison companies, punched in the gut, will keep most federal business. U.S. News and World Report, August 18, 2016. http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2016-08-18/private-prison-companies-punched-in-the-gut-will-keep-most-federal-business.
- Obama, B. (2016). The president’s role in advancing criminal justice reform. Harvard Law Review, 130, 811.Google Scholar
- Office of Detention Oversight. (2014). Office of detention oversight compliance inspection: Enforcement and removal operations, San Francisco, Yuba County Jail. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2997612-2012-ODO-Inspection-Sacramento-Cnty-Jail-CA.html.
- Reiter, K. (2016). 23/7: Pelican bay prison and the rise of long-term solitary confinement. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- Ridgeway, J., & Casella, J. (2010). Controversial Colorado study shows prisoners ‘improve’ in solitary confinement. Solitary Watch. November 7, 2010. http://solitarywatch.com/2010/11/07/controversial-colorado-study-shows-prisoners-improve-in-solitary-confinement/.
- Riveland, C. (1999). Supermax prisons: Overview and general considerations. Washington, DC: National Institute of Corrections.Google Scholar
- Romano, M. (2017). The prevalence and severity of mental illness among California prisoners on the rise. Stanford Justice Advocacy Project. https://law.stanford.edu/publications/the-prevalence-and-severity-of-mental-illness-among-california-prisoners-on-the-rise/.
- Schlanger, M. (2012). Prison segregation: Symposium introduction and preliminary data on racial disparities. Michigan Journal of Race and Law, 18, 241.Google Scholar
- Slater, R. (1986). Psychiatric intervention in an atmosphere of terror. American Journal of Forensic Psychiatry, 7(1), 5–12.Google Scholar
- Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC). (2014). Surprising variability in detainer trends by gender, nationality. http://trac.syr.edu/immigration/reports/340/.
- Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC). (2016). New data on 637 detention facilities used by ICE in FY 2015. http://trac.syr.edu/immigration/reports/422/.
- United Nations Committee against Torture. (2014). Concluding observations on the third to fifth periodic reports of United States of America.Google Scholar
- United States Government Accountability Office. (2013). Bureau of prisons: Improvements needed in bureau of prisons’ monitoring and evaluation of impact of segregated housing. Washington, DC.Google Scholar
- Urbina, I., & Rentz, C. (2013). Immigrants held in solitary cells, often for weeks. New York Times, March 23, 2013.Google Scholar
- Woodman, S. (2017). Exclusive: ICE put detained immigrants in solitary confinement for hunger striking. The Verge, February 27, 2017. https://www.theverge.com/2017/2/27/14728978/immigrant-deportation-hunger-strike-solitary-confinement-ice-trump.