Skip to main content
SpringerLink
Log in

Virtual reconstruction and kinematic simulation of a marble sawmill through the integration of historical and archeological data

  • Original Paper
  • Published:
Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

One of the greatest difficulties researchers encounter when attempting to comprehensively recover the technological heritage of the past lies in the fact that many components (machines, tools, etc.) were fully or partially made with ephemeral materials (such as wood). For this reason, in this work, we use virtual reality tools based on 3D models and the kinematic simulation of mechanisms and machines in order to integrate information from archeological remains and information obtained from written records during research on the recovery of the technological heritage of the past. In order to demonstrate the adequacy and suitability of the proposed method, the buildings and machinery of the Fallen Mill at El Escorial (Spain) have been virtually reconstructed as a case study. This one consisted of two mills, one flour mill and one marble sawmill, and was built at the end of the sixteenth century but, following a long period of abandonment, only scarce physical remains exist today. The Fallen Mill was highly important to the construction of the Monastery of El Escorial as, on the one hand, it was the first flour mill at the Monastery and, on the other hand, the marble sawmill which made it possible to reduce the time expected for the construction of the high altarpiece in the Monastery’s Basilica by half. The virtual reconstruction enabled an integrated compression of the architecture and technique used for both mills, providing users and researchers with an interactive environment for analysis, the discussion of alternatives, and detailed knowledge of this valuable technological heritage. With this and following centuries of abandonment, the Fallen Mill can be recovered for European technological heritage and makes clear the archeological importance of the existing physical remains of both mills.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Fig. 1
Fig. 2
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Fig. 5
Fig. 6
Fig. 7
Fig. 8
Fig. 9
Fig. 10
Fig. 11
Fig. 12
Fig. 13
Fig. 14
Fig. 15
Fig. 16
Fig. 17
Fig. 18
Fig. 19
Fig. 20
Fig. 21

Similar content being viewed by others

Abbreviations

AGS:

Archivo General de Simancas

BNE:

Biblioteca Nacional de España

CSR:

Casas y Sitios Reales

LEG:

Legajo

AGP:

Archivo General de Palacio

PSLE:

Patronato San Lorenzo del Escorial

RBME:

Real Biblioteca del Monasterio de El Escorial

CMC:

Contaduría Mayor de Cuentas

1EP:

1ª época

2EP:

2ª época

f:

Folio

ff:

Folios

AMEE:

Archivo municipal de la Villa de El Escorial

SIG:

Signatura

References

  • AGP PSLE LEG.154 (1652) Hieronymus tax administration manual. Manuscript

  • AGS CMC 1EP LEG 1761 (May 10, 1581) Dattas de hierro, acero y otros metales. Obra de hierro labrado para el molino. Manuscript. Order of payment for the iron work done for the marble sawmill when it was being finished. It only mentions the money paid for the iron work done, but there is no information with respect to the elements made

  • AGS CMC 1EP LEG.1760 (1584) Dattas de compras y acarretos y otros gastos de hierro, plomo y otros metales. Pagos a Alonso de Llanos por sierras para el molino y taller del jaspe. Pagos a Fernando Cabeza porque aderezó un yunque del molino del ingenio. Manuscript. Dattas for purchases, transport and other expenses for iron, steel, lead and other metals. Payments to Alonso de Llanos for saws for the mill and marble workshop, Payments to Fernando Cabezas to fix an anvil at the marble sawmill used to grind the emery

  • AGS CMC 1EP LEG.1761 (July 30, 1579a) Dattas de albañilería. Libranzas a Francisco Rodríguez por obras de mamposteria y froga en la presa del molino. Manuscript. Order of payment made to Francisco Rodríguez on 30 July 1579, which expressly states that the masonry and brickwork was done at the mill dam to release the water from the dam

  • AGS CMC 1EP LEG.1761 (October 16, 1579b) Dattas de canteros laborantes. Libranzas a cuenta a Francisco Campero y Alonso Estevan por la obra de cantería para el artificio de bruñir y aderezar el mármol y jaspe. Manuscript. It can be deduced from the documents corresponding to the payment for the work found in the accounts kept by the Chief Bookkeeper in the Archive in Simancas and at the Monastery of El Escorial that nine payments were made from the start of the work, from 16 October 1579 to 21 May 1580, and that all of the stonework was paid for by 2 July upon the appraisal dated 1 July

  • AGS CMC 1EP LEG.1761 (August 9, 1581a) Dattas de carpinteros. Libranzas a Andrés de Herrera y Pedro de la Mola por el ingenio y obra de carpintería en el molino para aserrar, labrar y aderezar la piedra de mármol y jaspe. Manuscript. Orders of payment to Andrés de Herrera and Master Pedro de Mola for the marble sawmill

  • AGS CMC 1EP LEG.1761 (August 26, 1581b) Dattas de carpinteros. Libranzas a Andrés de Herrera y Pedro de la Mola por cosas que faltaban del ingenio. Manuscript. Orders of payment to Andrés de Herrera and Master Pedro de Mola for the marble sawmill

  • AGS CMC 2EP LEG.1040 (1578) Dattas de canteros laborantes, pagos a Nicolás de Ribero por la cantería del molino harinero y Dattas de albañilería, pagos a Gaspar Ruiz y Juan Romero por la froga del molino. Manuscript. Payments for the mill building work

  • AGS CMC 2EP LEG.383 (1585) Dattas de compras de hierro, acero y clavazón y otras cosas de hierro y adornos. Pagos a Alonso de Llanos por sierras para el molino y a Hernado Cabezas por zaticas. Manuscript. Dattas for the purchase of iron, steel, nails and other iron fittings and adornments. Payments to Alonso de Llanos for saws for the mill and marble workshop and Payments to Hernando Cabezas for marble sawmill parts

  • AGS CMC 2EP LEG.384 (1577) Dattas de canteros laborantes, pagos a Nicolás de Rivero por la presa y el molino de harina que se hace bajo la dehesa de la Herrería. Manuscript. Payments made to master Nicolás de Rivero

  • AGS CMC 2EP LEG.391 (1583) Dattas de hierro y clavazón, cobre y hechura dello. Pagos a Hernando Cabeza por abrazaderas y otras piezas para el molino, pagos a Alonso de Llanos por sierras y aderezos para el molino y pagos a Alonso Luzón por sierras y piezas para el molino. Manuscript. Dattas for iron, nails and copper. Payments to Alonso Luçon for saws and parts for the mill, payments to Hernando Cabeza for braces and other parts like plugs, screws, keys, etc. for the mill; payments to Alonso de Llanos, blacksmith, for saws for the mill

  • AGS CMC 2EP LEG.399 (1582) Dattas de hierro, acero y otros metals de 1582. Pago a Alonso de Llanos por una sierra para el molino. Manuscript. Dattas for the iron, steel and other metals. Payments to Alonso de Llanos for a saw for the mill

  • AGS CSR LEG.251 f.407 (1565) Memorial sobre algunas cosas que se podrían hacer en la dehesa de la Herrería, para que estuviese mucho más agradable y con mucho más lustre. Manuscript. The need for a flour mill had been considered since the first years of the construction of the Monastery, as established here

  • AMEE SIG.3447-26 (1588) El fuego del taller del Molino del Rey. Manuscript. Information on the fire that devoured the jasper mill, found in the judicial minutes, in the Municipal Archive of the town of the El Escorial, from the investigation carried out because of the fire

  • Babelon J (1922) Jacopo da Trezzo et la construction de l’Escurial. School of Higher Hispanic Studies Library, vol. III. Feret et Fils (eds) Bordeaux. Available online: https://archive.org/details/jacopodatrezzoet00babeuoft

  • Barceló JA (2009) The birth and historical development of computational intelligence applications in archaeology. In Archeologia e Calcolatori, 20, pp 95–109. ISSN: 1120-6861

  • Barceló JA, Vicente O (2011) Qué hacer con un modelo arqueológico virtual. Aplicaciones de la inteligencia artificial en visualización científica. In Virtual Archaeology Review 2(4):53–57 ISSN: 1989-9947

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Boato A (1998) Fonti Indirette e archaeologia dell’Architettura: una proposta di método, In: Archeologia dell’Architettura, III, pp 61–74. ISSN 0390-0592, ISBN 88-7814-137-2

  • Castro-Real A, del Rey L (1998) El Escorial, San Lorenzo del Escorial in Arquitectura y desarrollo urbano, Comunidad de Madrid. Dirección General de Arquitectura y vivienda, CAM (ed) Madrid. Available online: http://www.madrid.org/bvirtual/BVCM004469.pdf

  • CATIA V5 (2002–2018) Parametric design program based on modules, from Dassault Systémes. In this work, the modules of solid design, surfaces, assemblies and kinematics have been used preferentially

  • de Andrés G (1972) Inventario de documentos sobre la construcción y ornato del Monasterio del Escorial existentes en el archivo de su Real Biblioteca. Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas, Instituto Diego Velázquez. Madrid

  • Eiroa JA (2004) La relación entre documentos escritos y Arqueología en el estudio de la Edad Media en Europa: reflexiones para un debate teórico y metodológico, In ÁGORA, v. 10, n. 1/2, pp. 113–127. Available online: http://www.arqueologiamedieval.com/articulos/articulos.asp?id=77. ISSN: 1414–0454

  • Fabre-Dupont S (1997-1998) Le vaissellier domestique bordelais. Confrontation de données archéologiques et de données d’archives. In Archéologie du Midi Médieval 15:245–263. https://doi.org/10.3406/amime.1997.1327

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Forte M, Dell'Unto N, Issavi J, Onsurez L, Lercari N (2012) 3D Archaeology at Çatalhöyük. International Journal of Heritage in the Digital Era 1(3):351–378 ISSN: 2047-4970

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Gabellonea F, Lanorteb A, Masinic N, Lasaponara R (2017) From remote sensing to a serious game: digital reconstruction of an abandoned medieval village in Southern Italy. J Cult Herit 23:63–70 ISSN: 1296-2074

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • García N (1990) Ingeniería y arquitectura en el Renacimiento. Valladolid: Universidad de Valladolid

  • González I (1992) Fábricas hidráulicas españolas. Ministerio de Obras Públicas y Transportes de España, Madrid

    Google Scholar 

  • González I (1998) Felipe II, los ingenios y las máquinas. Sociedad Estatal para la Acción Cultural Exterior, S.A, Madrid

    Google Scholar 

  • González-Tennant E (2010) Virtual archaeology and digital storytelling: a report from Rosewood, Florida. African Diaspora Archaeology Newsletter 13(3):1–27 ISSN: 1933-8651

    Google Scholar 

  • González-Tennant E, González-Tennant D (2016) The practice and theory of new heritage for historical archaeology. Hist Archaeol 50(1):187–204 ISSN: 0440-9213

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Lastanosa PJ de (1996) Los veintún libros de los ingenios y de las máquinas de Juanelo Turriano (transcript of the manuscript). Madrid: Fundación Juanelo Turriano y Ediciones Doce calles

  • Manrique L (2004) (Transcription, introduction, notes and indices) Libro primero [tercero] de los actos capitulares del Monasterio de San Lorenzo El Real. In: Documentos para la historia del Monasterio de San Lorenzo El Real de El Escorial, 12. Escurialenses (ed) San Lorenzo de El Escorial, Madrid 1636–1715, RBME 136-I-36, 158–160

  • Moreland J (2001) Archaeology and text: subservience or enlightenment. Annu Rev Anthropol 35:135–151. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.anthro.35.081705.123132

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Murray GS, Izaga JM and Soler JM (2006) El Real Ingenio de la moneda de Segovia, maravilla tecnológica del siglo XVI. Fundación Juanelo Turriano (ed) Madrid

  • Ortiz-Corderoa R, León E, Hidalgo R (2018) Proposal for the improvement and modification in the scale of evidence for virtual reconstruction of the cultural heritage: a first approach in the mosque-cathedral and the fluvial landscape of Córdoba. J Cult Herit 30:10–15 ISSN: 1296-2074

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Quattrini R, Baleani E (2015) Theoretical background and historical analysis for 3D reconstruction model. Villa Thiene at Cicogna. J Cult Herit 16:119–125 ISSN: 1296-2074

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Ramelli A (1588) Le diverse et artificiose machine del capitano Agostino Ramelli dal Ponte della Tresia ingegniero del Christianissimo Re di Francia et de pollonia. Paris, Ramelli. Available online: http://bdh.bne.es/bnesearch/Search.do?

  • RBME 187- II-14 f.210r (1605) Manuscript. The first of the Monastery’s tax manuals written in 1605

  • RBME 187-II-14 (1652) Manual de rentas y granjerías. Manuscript. Tax administration manual and rents

  • RBME II-36 ff.1–4 (1579) Concierto entre la Congregación y los canteros Francisco Campero y Alonso Estevan para realizar la obra de cantería para el Ingenio de labrar mármol que se construye junto al molino nuevo a la salida de la dehesa de la Herrería. Manuscript. The first of the three obligation documents regarding the stonework was dated 2 September 1579, was signed before the notary Francisco Escudero, and is in the Monastery of San Lorenzo de El Escorial. It outlines the conditions under which said stonemasons had to complete the work. The conditions specify matters relating to the characteristics of the supply and receipt of the stone for the work, the conditions for contracting workers, the conditions regarding the foundation and mortar supply as well as the auxiliary elements such as scaffolding, falsework, etc. Also indicated was that it would be subject to appraisal upon completion of the work in order to adjust the price. However, nothing is specified regarding what the building was to be like

  • RBME IX-22 (1585) Manuscript. Dattas for the purchase of iron, steel, other metals and nails. Payments to Alonso de Llanos, blacksmith, for saws for the marble sawmill

  • RBME IX-4 (1584) Manuscript. Dattas for purchases, transport and other expenses for iron, steel, lead and other metals. Payments to Alonso de Llanos for saws for the mill and marble workshop, Payments to Fernando Cabezas to fix an anvil at the marble sawmill used to grind the emery

  • RBME V-18 ff.1–3 (1576) Manuscript. First obligations signed by Gaspar Ruiz and Francisco Herrero in 1576. Although the work was not performed that year and the obligations were again signed in 1578 by the same mason, Gaspar Ruiz, and Juan Romero, the year during which the mill was built

  • RBME VI-22 ff.1–2 (undated) Manuscript. First obligations of the marble mill. The documentation available on the marble mill built, firstly consists of the notarised obligations found in duplicate at El Escorial. The first obligations was signed before the notary Juan de Ybarra and specifies that the carpenters, Pedro de la Mola and Andrés de Herrera, were required to do the marble sawmill pursuant to the drawing and model provided by Jacome de Trenzo (Jacome da Trezzo) in six or seven months and to the satisfaction of Trezzo himself and Juan de Herrera

  • RBME VI-23 ff. 93-95 (1578) Manuscript. Second obligations signed by Gaspar Ruiz and Juan Romero in 1578

  • RBME VI-40 ff.3-8r (1579) Manuscript. Obligations signed by Jacome da Trezzo, Pompeo Leoni and Juan Bautista Comane for the construction of the main altarpiece in the Monastery church in January 1579

  • RBME VI-42 ff.162–164 (1579) Francisco Campero, maestro de cantería y Alonso Esteban se obligan a realizar la obra de cantería para el ingenio de labrar, bruñir y aderezar el mármol junto al molino que se hace a la salida de la dehesa de la Herrería. Manuscript. This last document, dated 2 october 1579, further specifies that money would be paid to the stonemasons for the work in instalments until completed, and once concluded, the price to be received would be adjusted in accordance with the appraisal

  • RBME VI-9 ff.7–8 (1577) Manuscript. Obligations for Master Nicolás de Rivero when building the dam and other hydraulic elements of the flour mill, signed on 20 June 1577

  • RBME VII-25 f.5 (1580) Manuscript. The appraisal of the work. The only document from which any significant data can be extracted which describes the elements installed in the building although not in the desired detail. For example, it indicates the number of stone blocks and voussoirs installed

  • RBME VII-25 f.7 (1580) Manuscript. As concerns the masonry work done for the mill, the arrangement was signed on 8 August 1580, with Miguel de Montoya once the stonework was finished. There isn’t much data that can be extracted as to what the building was like from the masonry obligations except that a stone and brick structure was built which was measured at two hundred square foot walls (a measurement from the period) and that it had to be delivered roughcast on the inside and outside and very well-polished

  • RBME VII-36 (1581) Manuscript. The order of payment to Juan Ramos, carpenter, dated 23 February 1581, indicates the construction of a door, window, floor and stairway for the Mill

  • RBME VII-5 f.1–4 (1579) Manuscript. Second obligations of the marble mill signed on 23 November 1579, before Gaspar Testa. The second document is similar to the first and outlines the contractual obligations for both masters. Neither of them offer any construction data

  • RBME VII-5 f.6 (1579) Concierto de la obra de cantería para el yngenio de labrar piedra de mármol con Francisco Campero y Alonso Esteban. Manuscript. The second of the three obligation documents regarding the stonework was dated 3 September 1579 and holds the same content that first

  • RBME VIII-16 f.16 (1582) Manuscript. The orders of payment for the altarpiece workers’ pay dated 19 May 1582, clearly states that there were two work areas at the mill, once occupied by the machines and another used as a workshop

  • RBME XII-7 ff.15–17 (1591) Manuscript. The payment document for the hydraulic system upon reforming the marble sawmill into a paper mill is dated 18 January 1591. The carpentry Datta from the reconstruction for the paper mill, specifies that said large channel meant to take the water from the pond to the reservoir was 13 metres long, 1.11 m wide and 0.83 m high. It also indicates that the reservoir measures 4.8 m long, 3.9 m wide and 1.5 m high and that the base is made up of five beams 0.27 m wide and 0.57 long. The ends of the beams are assembled in the form of a peg on two lateral beams. Moreover, it was covered with planks overlapped by a fourth of a foot (6.8 cm) to prevent water from getting through. Finally, some significant construction data on the building were also extracted from the order of payment for the carpentry work done for the reconstruction into the paper mill

  • Rua H, Alvito P (2011) Living the past: 3D models, virtual reality and game engines as tools for supporting archaeology and the reconstruction of cultural heritage—the case-study of the Roman villa of Casal de Freiria. J Archaeol Sci 38:3296–3308 ISSN: 0305-4403

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Sánchez FV (2016) Estudio histórico-tecnológico de las serrerías de corte de piedras duras en el s. XVI: aplicación al análisis y reconstrucción gráfica del molino de corte de mármol utilizado en la construcción del retablo mayor del Monasterio de El Escorial. Tesis Doctoral, Escuela Técnica superior de Ingeniería y Diseño Industrial, Universidad politécnica de Madrid . Madrid. Available online: http://oa.upm.es/42870/

  • Sanders D (2008) Why do virtual heritage? In: Clark, Jeffrey T., hagemeister, Emily M (Eds.) Digital Discovery: exploring new frontiers in human heritage (Proceedings from the 34th Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology conference, Fargo, ND, USA, April 2006), Budapest: Archaeolingua, pp. 427–436

  • Small DB (1995) Introduction. In: Small DB (ed) Methods in the Mediterranean. Historical and Archaeological View son texts and Archaeology. E.J.Brill, Leiden-New York-Köln ISBN: 9004095810

    Google Scholar 

  • Volpaia B della (s.XVI) manuscript Mss. It. IV, 41 (=5363). Venice Martian Library

  • Wilson PN (1960) Watermills with horizontal wheel. Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings, London, Titus Wilson & Son ltd, Kendal. Available online: http://www.fastonline.org/CD3WD_40/JF/430/22-526.pdf

Download references

Acknowledgements

Authors thank National Heritage for authorizing the investigation and clearing of the physical remains of the mill. Also, thanks to the city council of the El Escorial; especially to Ana Luzón (responsible of the Archive) and Gregorio Sánchez Meco (chronicler of the Villa). Thanks to Almudena Pérez de Tudela (conservator of El Escorial’s monastery) and the staff of the Monastery’s Royal Library. Also, to the General Archive of Simancas and the rest of archives consulted.

The authors would also like to thank the Technical University of Madrid for the funding received to do this project (GI 1556190036).

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Escuela Técnica Superior de Ingeniería y Diseño Industrial, Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, C/Ronda de Valencia 3, 28012, Madrid, Spain

    Francisca Victoria Sánchez, José Manuel Arenas, María del Mar Recio & Rufino Horcajo

Authors
  1. Francisca Victoria Sánchez
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. José Manuel Arenas
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  3. María del Mar Recio
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  4. Rufino Horcajo
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to José Manuel Arenas.

Electronic supplementary material

ᅟ

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Sánchez, F.V., Arenas, J.M., del Mar Recio, M. et al. Virtual reconstruction and kinematic simulation of a marble sawmill through the integration of historical and archeological data. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 11, 2435–2452 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-018-0692-9

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12520-018-0692-9

Keywords

Search

Navigation