Contemporary Jewry

, Volume 37, Issue 1, pp 125–170 | Cite as

The Holocaust in Israeli Political Culture: Four Constructions and Their Consequences

Editor’s Note: This Article is Followed by Four Comments and a Response by Ian Lustick
Article

Abstract

The collective memory of the Holocaust among Israeli Jews has featured competition among four related but distinct constructions: Zionist Proof-text; Wasting Asset; Object Lesson for safeguarding human rights; and Template for Jewish life. This paper will analyze this competition and the implications of the apparent victory of the Template. While there is a sequence to the changing prominence of these different versions of the Holocaust, each version has enjoyed periods of relative success since World War II. In recent decades, however, the Holocaust as a Template for Jewish Life has emerged as ascendant. Throughout, competition among the four constructions was driven by parochial and temporary political interests and by the unintended consequences of dissatisfactions associated with any one of them. My analysis will trace this competition and those consequences, using them to explain the extreme and highly particular features of current Israeli Jewish collective memory of the Holocaust. The paper concludes with an assessment of the implications of the hegemonic status of this version of the Holocaust for appreciating Israel’s contemporary political predicament.

Keywords

Israel Holocaust Political culture Collective memory Hegemony Constructivism 

References

  1. Achcar, Gilbert. 2010. The Arabs and the Holocaust: The Arab–Israeli war of narratives (London: Saqi, 2010). London: Saqi.Google Scholar
  2. Alter, Robert. 1971. The Israelis: Founders and sons, by Amos Elon. Commentary Magazine, September 1, 1971. https://www.commentarymagazine.com/articles/the-israelis-founders-and-sons-by-amos-elon/.
  3. Arendt, Hannah. 1963. Eichmann in Jerusalem: A report on the banality of evil. New York: Penguin.Google Scholar
  4. Arian, Asher, and Ayala Keissar-Sugarman. 2009. A portrait of Israeli Jews: Beliefs, observance, and values of Israeli Jews. Jerusalem: Guttman Center for Surveys of the Israel Democracy Institute, 2012. https://en.idi.org.il/media/5439/guttmanavichaireport2012_engfinal.pdf.
  5. Auerbach, Yehudit. 1991. Ben-Gurion and reparations from Germany. In David Ben-Gurion: Politics and leadership in Israel, ed. Ronald Zweig, 274–292. London: Frank Cass.Google Scholar
  6. Auron, Yair. 1997. Jewish-Israeli Identity among Israel’s future teachers. Jewish Political Studies Review 9 (1–2): 105–122.Google Scholar
  7. Aviner, Shlomo. 1982. Our attachment to the land of Israel. Artzi 1: 8–19.Google Scholar
  8. Avnery, Uri. 2009. Trivializing the Holocaust. Antiwar.com, May 11, 2009. http://original.antiwar.com/avnery/2009/05/10/trivializing-the-holocaust/.
  9. Bar, Doron. 2005. Holocaust Commemoration in Israel during the 1950s: The Holocaust Cellar on Mount Zion. Jewish Social Studies 12 (1): 16–38.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  10. Bashir, Bashir, and Amos Goldberg (eds.). 2015. The Holocaust and the Nakba: Memory, National identity and Jewish–Arab Partnership. Jerusalem: Hakibbutz Hameuchad Publishing House.Google Scholar
  11. Bauer, Yehuda. 2001. Rethinking the Holocaust. New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  12. Ben-Amos, Avner, Ilana Bet-El, and Moshe Tlamin. 1999. Holocaust Day and memorial day in Israeli schools: Ceremonies, education and history Israel studies. Israel Studies 4 (1): 258–284.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  13. Brecher, Michael. 1973. Images, process and feedback in foreign policy: Israel’s decisions on German reparations. American Political Science Review 67 (1): 73–102.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  14. Brecher, Michael. 1980. Decisions in Crisis: Israel, 1967 and 1973. Berkeley: University of California Press.Google Scholar
  15. Brenner, Michael, and Pamela S. Nadell, eds. forthcoming. Reinventing Israel in the twenty-first century. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.Google Scholar
  16. Burg, Avraham. 2007. Victory over Hitler. Tel Aviv: Yedioth Ahronoth Books.Google Scholar
  17. Carmon, Aryeh. 1979. Teaching the Holocaust as a means of fostering values. Curriculum Inquiry 9 (3): 209–228.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  18. Cohen, Boaz. 2008. Setting the Agenda of Holocaust research: Discord at Yad Vashem in the 1950s. In Holocaust historiography in CONTEXT, ed. David Bankier, and Dan Mikhman, 255–292. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem.Google Scholar
  19. Cromer, Gerald. 2004. A war of words: Political violence and public debate in Israel. Milton Park: Frank Cass.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  20. Dahan-Kalev, Henriette. 2014. A second order decision: Holocaust and Mizrahim. Israel: Sde Boker.Google Scholar
  21. Dinur, Ben-Zion. 1953. Presented at the Divrei HaKnesset, May 12, 1953, vol. 14.Google Scholar
  22. Divrei HaKnesset. 1952. Proceedings of the Knesset (trans.), vol. 10.Google Scholar
  23. Don-Yehiya, Eliezer. 1993. Memory and political culture: Israeli society and the Holocaust. In Studies in Contemporary Jewry ed. Ezra Mendelsohn, 139–162, vol. 9.Google Scholar
  24. Elon, Amos. 1972. The Israelis: Founders and sons. New York: Bantam Books.Google Scholar
  25. Feldman, Lily Gardner. 1984. The special relationship between West Germany and Israel. Boston: George Allen & Unwin.Google Scholar
  26. Feldman, Jackie. 2008. Above the death pits, beneath the flag: Youth voyages to Poland and the performance of Israeli national identity. New York: Berghahn Books.Google Scholar
  27. Finkel, Evgeny. 2015. The phoenix effect of state repression: Jewish resistance during the Holocaust. American Political Science Review 109 (2): 339–353.Google Scholar
  28. Finkelstein, Norman. 2000. The Holocaust industry. London: Verso.Google Scholar
  29. Firer, Ruth. 1987. The treatment of the Holocaust in textbooks. In The Treatment of the Holocaust in textbooks: The Federal Republic of Germany, Israel, The United States of America, ed. Randolph L. Braham, 153–229. Boulder: Social Science Mongraphs.Google Scholar
  30. Fisch, Harold. 1978. The Zionist revolution: A new perspective. New York: St. Martin’s Press.Google Scholar
  31. Fisch, Harold. 1982. The Zionism of Zion. Tel Aviv: Zmora-Bitan.Google Scholar
  32. Folman, Ari. 2008. Waltz with Bashir. Bridgit Folman Film Gang.Google Scholar
  33. Friedlander, Saul. 1990. The Shoah between memory and history. Jewish Quarterly 37 (1): 5–11.Google Scholar
  34. Geertz, Nurith. 1981. The few against the many: Rhetorics and structures in the election speeches of Menachem Begin. Sifrei Siman Kriah 16–17: 106–114.Google Scholar
  35. Gil, Idit. 2012. The Shoah in Israeli collective memory: Changes in meanings and protagonists. Modern Judaism 32 (12): 76–101.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  36. Glanz, James. 2016. Israeli Defense Minister compares beloved Palestinian poet to Hitler. New York Times, July 21, 2016.Google Scholar
  37. Goldberg, J.J. 2016. Avigdor Lieberman is sorry-not-sorry for comparing Iran deal to Hitler deal. The Forward, August 9, 2016. http://forward.com/opinion/347134/avigdor-lieberman-is-sorry-not-sorry-for-comparing-iran-deal-to-hitler-deal/.
  38. Gringauz, Samuel. 1947. Jewish Destiny as the DP’s see it: The ideology of the surviving remnant. Commentary Magazine 4: 501–509.Google Scholar
  39. Grossman, Kurt R. 1954. Germany’s moral debt: The German–Israel agreement. Washington, D.C.: Public Affairs Press.Google Scholar
  40. Gur-Zev, Ilan. 2000. Defeating the enemy within: Exploring the link between Holocaust education and the Arab/Israeli conflict. Religious Education 95 (4): 373–401.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  41. Gutman, Yisrael. 1988a. Jewish resistance—Questions and assessments. In The historiography of the Holocaust period: Proceedings of the fifth Yad Vashem international historical conference, Jerusalem, March 1983, ed. Yisrael Gutman, and Gideon Greif, 641–678. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem.Google Scholar
  42. Gutman, Yisrael, and Greif, Gideon, eds. 1988. The historiography of the Holocaust period: Proceedings of the Fifth Yad Vashem international historical conference, Jerusalem, March 1983. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem.Google Scholar
  43. Heruti-Sover, Tali. 2014. Teaching the Holocaust: A job best done by business? Haaretz, April 28, 2014.Google Scholar
  44. Israel Air Force Ceremony—F-15 Jets over Auschwitz. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h1FHvsuMzAc. Accessed 16 July 2015.
  45. Jockusch, Laura. 2013. Historiography in transit: Survivor historians and the writing of Holocaust history in the late 1940s. Leo Baeck Institute Year Book 58: 75–94.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  46. Kasher, Menachem. 1968. The great era. Jerusalem: Torah Shlema.Google Scholar
  47. Kashti, Or. 2010 Education ministry bumps professor from post for criticizing ‘superficial’ teaching of Holocaust. Haaretz, July 21, 2010.Google Scholar
  48. Kenan, Orna. 2003. Between memory and history: The evolution of Israeli historiography of the Holocaust, 1945–1961. New York: Peter Lang.Google Scholar
  49. Keren, Nili. 2004. Teaching the Holocaust: A mission. In Teaching about the Holocaust essays by college and university lecturers, ed. S. Totten, B.R. Bartrop, and S.L. Jacobs, 123–138. Westport, CT: Praeger.Google Scholar
  50. Klar, Yechiel, Noa Schori-Eyal, and Yonat Klar. 2013. The ‘never again’ state of Israel: The emergence of the Holocaust as a core feature of Israeli identity and its four incongruent voices. Journal of Social Issues 69 (1): 125–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  51. Lazar, D., and R. Wittmann, eds. forthcoming. The Eichmann trial.Google Scholar
  52. Lustick, Ian S. 2006. Negotiating truth: The Holocaust, Lehavdil, and Al-Nakba. Journal of International Affairs 60 (1): 51–80.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  53. Lustick, Ian S. 1969. Author notes, September 29, 1969.Google Scholar
  54. Lustick, Ian S. forthcoming. The changing Holocaust in Israeli political culture: Constructing the Holocaust as a ‘Template for Jewish Life’ and its implications for Israeli foreign policy. In Reinventing Israel in the twenty-first century. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.Google Scholar
  55. Magid, Shaul. 2015. American jews must stop obsessing about the Holocaust. Tablet Magazine, January 26, 2015.Google Scholar
  56. Ministry of Education. 1959. Deepening Jewish consciousness in public schools: Instructions and curriculum. Jerusalem: Government Printer.Google Scholar
  57. Morris, Benny. 1999. Righteous victims: A history of the Zionist-Arab Conflict, 1881–1998. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.Google Scholar
  58. Naor, Aryeh. 2003. Lessons of the Holocaust versus territories for peace, 1967–2001. Israel Studies 8 (1): 130–152.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  59. Netanyahu, Benjamin. 2013. PM addresses the Jewish Agency Board of Governors. Newsletter of the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, February 18, 2013. http://mfa.gov.il/MFA/PressRoom/2013/Pages/PM-Netanyahu-addresses-Jewish-Agency-Board-Feb-2013.aspx.
  60. Newman, Marissa. 2015. IDF Chief cites Holocaust to justify Haredi service. Times of Israel, April 15, 2015.Google Scholar
  61. Novick, Peter. 2000. The Holocaust in American life. Boston: Mariner, Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
  62. Ophir, Adi. 1987. On sanctifying the Holocaust: An anti-theological treatise. Tikkun 2 (1): 61–66.Google Scholar
  63. Ophir, Adi. 2005. The order of evils: Toward an ontology of morals. New York: Zone Books.Google Scholar
  64. Patt, Avinoam. 2015. ‘It will not be said that our youth marched like sheep to the slaughter’—Writing about resistance in the immediate aftermath of the Holocaust. Montreal.Google Scholar
  65. Perlmutter, Amos. 1987. The life and times of Menachem Begin. Garden City, NJ: Doubleday.Google Scholar
  66. “PLO Leaders ‘like Hitler and His Henchmen,’ Begin.” Citizen. August 5, 1982. https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=2194&dat=19820805&id=DOVfAAAAIBAJ&sjid=7O4FAAAAIBAJ&pg=3807,1410960&hl=en.
  67. Porat, Dina. 1991. Ben-Gurion and the Holocaust. In David Ben-Gurion: Politics and leadership in Israel, ed. Ronald Zweig, 145–172. New York: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi.Google Scholar
  68. Ram, Uri. 1995. Zionist historiography and the invention of modern Jewish nationhood: The case of Ben Zion Dinur. History and Memory 7 (1): 91–124.Google Scholar
  69. Rashty, Sandy. 2014. Israelis’ tough stance at Auschwitz. Jewish Chronicle OnLine, January 30, 2014. http://www.thejc.com/news/uk-news/115241/israelis%E2%80%99-tough-stance-auschwitz.
  70. Reich, Tova. 2008. My Holocaust: A novel. New York: HarperCollins.Google Scholar
  71. Resnik, Julia. 2003. ‘Sites of memory’ of the Holocaust: shaping national memory in the education system in Israel. Nations and Nationalism 9 (2): 297–317.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  72. Rivlin, Reuven. 2015. President Rivlin addresses official ceremony marking the commencement of Israel’s Holocaust Memorial Day, April 15, 2015. http://www.president.gov.il/English/ThePresident/Speeches/Pages/news_150415_01.aspx.
  73. Rosenfled, Alvin H. 2011. The end of the Holocaust. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar
  74. Ross, Gaylen. 2014. Killing Kasztner: The Jew who dealt with Nazis. GR Films.Google Scholar
  75. Rowland, Robert C. 1985. The rhetoric of Menachem Begin: The myth of redemption through return. Lanham, MA: University Press of America.Google Scholar
  76. Rubinstein, Ariel. 2015. A dozen reasons why Israel should do away with Holocaust Memorial Day. Haaretz, April 16, 2015. http://arielrubinstein.tau.ac.il/articles/haaretz_041515_eng.pdf.
  77. Rudoren, Jodi. 2012. Proudly Bearing elders’ scars, their skin says ‘never forget.’ New York Times, September 30, 2012.Google Scholar
  78. Rudoren, Jodi. 2014. Holocaust told in one word, 6 million times. New York Times, January 25, 2014.Google Scholar
  79. Sagi, Avi. 2010. The Holocaust and the foundation of Jewish identity. Azure Online, no. 42. http://azure.org.il/include/print.php?id=552.
  80. Sarid, Yossi. 2013. Raised on the Holocaust. Haaretz, October 25, 2013.Google Scholar
  81. Schatzker, Chaim. 1988. The Holocaust in textbooks: A comparative analysis. In The historiography of the Holocaust period, ed. Yisrael Gutman, and Gideon Greif, 467–479. London: Vallentine Mitchell.Google Scholar
  82. Segev, Tom. 1993. The seventh million. New York: Hill and Wang.Google Scholar
  83. Segev, Tom. 1999. One Palestine complete: Jews and Arabs under the British Mandate. New York: Henry Holt.Google Scholar
  84. Segev, Tom. 2010. The makings of history. Haaretz, April 10, 2010.Google Scholar
  85. Shapira, Anita (ed.). 2004a. Israeli identity in transition. Westport, CT: Praeger.Google Scholar
  86. Shapira, Anita, (ed). 2004b. Whatever became of ‘negating exile’?. In, ed. Anita Shapira, 69–108. Westport, CT: Praeger.Google Scholar
  87. Shapira, Anita, ed. 1998. The Holocaust: Private memories, public memory. Jewish Social Studies 4 (2): 40–58.Google Scholar
  88. Sharett, Yaakov (ed.). 2007. Moshe Sharett and the German reparations controversy. Tel Aviv: Society to Commemorate Moshe Sharett.Google Scholar
  89. Shipler, David. 1981. Begin defends raid, pledges to Thwart a new ‘Holocaust’. New York Times, June 10, 1981.Google Scholar
  90. Stauber, Roni. 2007. The Holocaust in Israeli public debate in the 1950s. London: Vallentine Mitchell.Google Scholar
  91. Stauber, Roni. 2008. Philip Friedman and the beginning of Holocaust studies. In Holocaust historiography in context: Emergence, challenges, polemics and achievements, ed. David Bankier, and Dan Michman, 83–102. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem.Google Scholar
  92. Stauber, Roni. forthcoming. The impact of the Eichmann trial on relations between Israel and the Federal Republic of Germany. In The Eichmann trial, ed. D. Lazar and R. Wittmann.Google Scholar
  93. Teveth, Shabtai. 1987. Ben-Gurion: The burning ground 1886–1948 (Boston: Houghton Mifflin:1987). Boston: Houghton Mifflin.Google Scholar
  94. Teveth, Shabtai. 1996. Ben-Gurion and the Holocaust. New York: Harcourt Brace & Co.Google Scholar
  95. The Nizkor Project, Remembering the Holocaust, The trial of Adolf Eichmann. http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/e/eichmann-adolf/transcripts/ (1991–2012).
  96. Vashem, Yad. 2015. Annual report: Achievements and challenges. https://view.publitas.com/yad-vashem/yad-vashem-annual-report-2015/page/1.
  97. Weitz, Yehiam. 1996. The holocaust on trial: The impact of the Kasztner and Eichmann trials on Israeli society. Israel Studies 1 (2): 1–26.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  98. Weitz, Yechiam. 2007. Introduction. In Moshe Sharett and the German reparations controversy, ed. Yaakov Sharett, 11–54. Tel Aviv: Society to Commemorate Moshe Sharett.Google Scholar
  99. Weitz, Yechiam. 2008. The founding father and the war criminal’s trial: Ben Gurion and the Eichmann trial. Yad Vashem Studies 36 (1): 211–252.Google Scholar
  100. Weitz, Yechiam. 2009. In the name of six million accusers: Gideon Hausner as Attorney-general and his place in the Eichmann trial. Israel Studies 14 (2): 26–49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  101. Weitz, Yechiam. 2013. Even Ben-Gurion exploited the Holocaust when it suited him. Haaretz, October 31, 2013. http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.555402.
  102. Wiesel, Elie. 1974. Ominous signs and unspeakable thoughts. New York Times, December 28, 1974.Google Scholar
  103. Wiesel, Elie. 1999. The Perils of indifference. The history place, April 12, 1999. http://www.historyplace.com/speeches/wiesel.htm.
  104. Yablonka, Hannah. 2003. The development of Holocaust consciousness in Israel: The Nuremberg, Kapos, Kastner, and Eichmann trials. Israel Studies 8 (3): 1–24.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  105. Yablonka, Hannah. 2008. As heard by the witnesses, the public, and the judges: Three variations on the testimony in the Eichmann Trial. In Holocaust historiography in context: Emergency, challenges, polemics and achievements, ed. David Bankier, and Dan Michman, 567–587. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem.Google Scholar
  106. Yablonka, Hannah. 2009. Oriental Jewry and the Holocaust: A tri-generational perspective. Israel Studies 14 (1): 94–122.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  107. Young, James E. 1993. The texture of memory: Holocaust memorials and meaning (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993). New Haven: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
  108. Zerrtal, Idith. 2005. Israel’s Holocaust and the politics of nationhood., Second New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
  109. Zuckerman, Moshe. 1993. Shoah in a sealed room: The “Holocaust” in the Israeli Press during the Gulf War. Tel Aviv: Hotzat HaMachber.Google Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2017

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Department of Political ScienceUniversity of PennsylvaniaPhiladelphiaUSA

Personalised recommendations