Abstract
Tools for assessing and communicating salt marsh condition are essential to guide decisions aimed at maintaining or restoring ecosystem integrity and services. Multimetric indices (MMIs) are increasingly used to provide integrated assessments of ecosystem condition. We employed a theory-based approach that considers the multivariate relationship of metrics with human disturbance to construct a salt marsh MMI for five National Parks in the northeastern USA. We quantified the degree of human disturbance for each marsh using the first principal component score from a principal components analysis of physical, chemical, and land use stressors. We then applied a metric selection algorithm to different combinations of about 45 vegetation and nekton metrics (e.g., species abundance, species richness, and ecological and functional classifications) derived from multi-year monitoring data. While MMIs derived from nekton or vegetation metrics alone were strongly correlated with human disturbance (r values from −0.80 to −0.93), an MMI derived from both vegetation and nekton metrics yielded an exceptionally strong correlation with disturbance (r = −0.96). Individual MMIs included from one to five metrics. The metric-assembly algorithm yielded parsimonious MMIs that exhibit the greatest possible correlations with disturbance in a way that is objective, efficient, and reproducible.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adamowicz, S.C., and C.T. Roman. 2005. New England salt marsh pools: A quantitative analysis of geomorphic and geographic features. Wetlands 25: 279–288.
Barbier, E.B., S.D. Hacker, C. Kennedy, E.W. Koch, A.C. Stier, and B.R. Silliman. 2011. The value of estuarine and coastal ecosystem services. Ecological Monographs 81: 169–193.
Bertness, M.D., P.J. Ewanchuk, and B.R. Silliman. 2002. Anthropogenic modification of New England salt marsh landscapes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 99: 1395–1398.
Blocksom, K.A. 2003. A performance comparison of metric scoring methods for a multimetric index for mid-Atlantic highlands streams. Environmental Management 31: 670–682.
Boix, D., S. Gascón, J. Sala, M. Martinoy, J. Gifre, and X.D. Quintana. 2005. A new index of water quality assessment in Mediterranean wetlands based on crustacean and insect assemblages: The case of Catalunya (NE Iberian Peninsula). Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 15: 635–651.
Brazner, J.C., N.P. Danz, G.J. Niemi, R.R. Regal, A.S. Trebitz, R.W. Howe, J.M. Hanowski, L.B. Johnson, J.H. Ciborowski, C.A. Johnston, E.D. Reavie, V.J. Brady, and G.V. Sgro. 2007. Evaluation of geographic, geomorphic and human influences on Great Lakes wetland indicators: A multi-assemblage approach. Ecological Indicators 7: 610–635.
Burdick, D.M., M. Dionne, R.M. Boumans, and F.T. Short. 1997. Ecological response to tidal restorations of two northern New England salt marshes. Wetlands Ecology and Management 4: 129–144.
Carullo, M., B.K. Carlisle, and J.P. Smith. 2007. A New England rapid assessment method for assessing condition of estuarine marshes: A Boston Harbor, Cape Cod and islands pilot study. Boston: Massachusetts Office of Coastal Zone Management.
Chesapeake Bay Program. 2014. Bay Field Guide 2014. Online taxonomic database. http://www.chesapeakebay.net/fieldguide. Accessed 15 Jan 2014.
Daiber, F.C. 1986. Conservation of tidal marshes. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold.
Danz, N.P., G.J. Niemi, R.R. Regal, T. Hollenhorst, L.B. Johnson, J.M. Hanowski, R. Axler, J.J.H. Ciborowski, T. Hrabik, V.J. Brady, J.R. Kelly, J.A. Morrice, J.C. Brazner, R.W. Howe, C.A. Johnston, and G.E. Host. 2007. Integrated gradients of anthropogenic stress in the U.S. Great Lakes basin. Environmental Management 39: 631–647.
Deegan, L.A. 2002. Lessons learned: The effects of nutrient enrichment on the support of nekton by seagrass and salt marsh ecosystems. Estuaries 25: 727–742.
Dionne, M., F.T. Short, and D.M. Burdick. 1999. Fish utilization of restored, created, and reference salt-marsh habitat in the Gulf of Maine. American Fisheries Society Symposium 22: 384–404.
Duncan, W.H. 1974. Vascular halophytes of the Atlantic and Gulf Coasts of North Carolina north of Mexico. In Ecology of halophytes, ed. R.J. Reimold and W.H. Queen, 23–50. New York: Academic.
Edinger, G.J., D.J. Evans, S. Gebauer, T.G. Howard, D.M. Hunt, and A.M. Olivero, eds. 2002. Ecological communities of New York state, second edition. A revised and expanded edition of Carol Reschke's ecological communities of New York state. Albany: New York Natural Heritage Program, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation.
Eleuterius, L. 1990. Tidal marsh plants. Gretna: Pelican Publishing.
Falcone, J.A., D.M. Carlisle, and L.C. Weber. 2010. Quantifying human disturbance in watersheds: Variable selection and performance of a GIS-based disturbance index for predicting the biological condition of perennial streams. Ecological Indicators 10: 264–273.
Fennessy, M.S., A.D. Jacobs, and M.E. Kentula. 2007. An evaluation of rapid methods for assessing the ecological condition of wetlands. Wetlands 27: 543–560.
FishBase. 2014. A Global Information System on Fishes. Online taxonomic database. http://www.fishbase.org/home.htm. Accessed Jan 2014.
Fleming, G.P., and K.D. Patterson. 2013. Natural communities of Virginia: Ecological groups and community types, 13–16. Richmond: Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation Natural Heritage Technical Report.
Fry, J.A., G. Xian, S. Jin, J.A. Dewitz, C.G. Homer, L. Yang, C.A. Barnes, N.D. Herold, and J.D. Wickham. 2011. Completion of the 2006 National Land Cover Database for the conterminous United States. Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing 77: 858–864.
Greenberg, R., J.E. Maldonado, S. Droege, and M.V. McDonald. 2006. Tidal marshes: A global perspective on the evolution and conservation of their terrestrial vertebrates. Bioscience 56: 675–685.
Haines, A., and T.F. Vining. 1998. Flora of Maine: A manual for identification of native and naturalized vascular plants. Bar Harbor: Thomas.
Harrison, J.W. 2004. Classification of vegetation communities of Maryland: First iteration. Annapolis: NatureServe and Maryland Natural Heritage Program Maryland Department of Natural Resources.
Hering, D., C.K. Feld, O. Moog, and T. Ofenböck. 2006. Cook book for the development of a multimetric index for biological condition of aquatic ecosystems: Experiences from the European AQEM and STAR projects and related initiatives. Hydrobiologia 566: 311–324.
Hopkinson, C.S., W. Cai, and X. Hu. 2012. Carbon sequestration in wetland dominated coastal systems—A global sink of rapidly diminishing magnitude. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 4: 186–194.
Howard, R.J., and I.A. Mendelssohn. 1999. Salinity as a constraint on growth of oligohaline marsh macrophytes. I. Species variation in stress tolerance. American Journal of Botany 86: 785–794.
Hughes, J.E., L.A. Deegan, J.C. Wyda, M.J. Weaver, and A. Wright. 2002. The effects of eelgrass habitat loss on estuarine fish communities of southern New England. Estuaries 25: 235–249.
IRL (Indian River Lagoon) Species Inventory. 2014. Smithsonian Indian River Lagoon Species Inventory. Online taxonomic database. http://www.sms.si.edu/irlspec/index.htm. Accessed 15 Jan 2014.
James-Pirri, M.J., C.T. Roman, and E.L. Nicosia. 2012. Monitoring nekton in salt marshes: A protocol for the National Park Service’s long-term monitoring program, Northeast Coastal and Barrier Network. Fort Collins: National Park Service Natural Resource Report NPS/NCBN/NRR—2012/579.
James-Pirri, M.J., J.L. Swanson, C.T. Roman, H.S. Ginsberg, and J.F. Heltshe. 2014. Ecological thresholds for salt marsh nekton and vegetation communities. In Application of threshold concepts in natural resource decision making, ed. G.R. Guntenspergen, 291–319. New York: Springer.
Kachigan, S.K. 1982. Multivariate statistical analysis: A conceptual introduction. New York: Radius Press.
Karr, J.R. 1999. Defining and measuring river health. Freshwater Biology 41: 221–234.
Karr, J.R., and E.W. Chu. 2000. Sustaining living rivers. Hydrobiologia 422 (423): 1–14.
Kennish, M.J. 2001. Coastal salt marsh systems in the US: A review of anthropogenic impacts. Journal of Coastal Research 17: 731–748.
Kent, M., and P. Coker. 1994. Vegetation description and analysis—A practical approach. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons.
Kirwan, M.L., and J.P. Megonigal. 2013. Tidal wetland stability in the face of human impacts and sea-level rise. Nature 504: 53–60.
Konisky, R.A., D.M. Burdick, M. Dionne, and H.A. Neckles. 2006. A regional assessment of salt marsh restoration and monitoring in the Gulf of Maine. Restoration Ecology 14: 516–525.
Langman, O.C., J.A. Hale, C.D. Cormack, M.J. Risk, and S.P. Madon. 2012. Developing multimetric indices for monitoring ecological restoration progress in salt marshes. Marine Pollution Bulletin 64: 820–835.
Lee, K.-S., F.T. Short, and D.M. Burdick. 2004. Development of a nutrient pollution indicator using the seagrass, Zostera marina, along nutrient gradients in three New England estuaries. Aquatic Botany 78: 197–216.
Lopez, R.D., and M.S. Fennessy. 2002. Testing the floristic quality assessment index as an indicator of wetland condition. Ecological Applications 12: 487–497.
Lougheed, V.L., and P. Chow-Fraser. 2002. Development and use of a zooplankton index of wetland quality in the Laurentian Great Lakes basin. Ecological Applications 12: 474–486.
Mack, J.J. 2004. Integrated wetland assessment program, part 4: Vegetation index of biotic integrity (VIBI) and tiered aquatic life uses (TALUs) for Ohio wetlands. Columbus: Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, Wetland Ecology Group Technical Report WET/2004-4.
Magee, D.W., and H.E. Ahles. 1999. Flora of the northeast: A manual of the vascular flora of New England and adjacent New York. Amherst: Univ. of Massachusetts Press.
MEA (Millennium Ecosystem Assessment). 2005. Ecosystems and human well-being: Current state and trends—Coastal systems. Washington: Island Press.
Mereta, S.T., P. Boets, L. De Meester, and P.L.M. Goethals. 2013. Development of a multimetric index based on benthic macroinvertebrates for the assessment of natural wetlands in southwest Ethiopia. Ecological Indicators 29: 510–521.
Miller, S.J., D.H. Wardrop, W.M. Mahaney, and R.P. Brooks. 2006. A plant-based index of biological integrity (IBI) for headwater wetlands in central Pennsylvania. Ecological Indicators 6: 290–312.
Miller, K.M., B.R. Mitchell, and B.J. McGill. 2016. Constructing multimetric indices and testing ability of landscape metrics to assess condition of freshwater wetlands in the northeastern US. Ecological Indicators 66: 143–152.
Möller, I., M. Kudella, F. Rupprecht, T. Spencer, M. Paul, B.K. van Wesenbeeck, G. Wolters, K. Jensen, T.J. Bouma, M. Miranda-Lange, and S. Schimmels. 2014. Wave attenuation over coastal salt marshes under storm surge conditions. Nature Geoscience 7: 727–731.
Moore, G.E., D.M. Burdick, C.R. Peter, and M. Dionne. 2010. Regional assessment of tidal marsh restoration in New England using the Restoration Performance Index (RPI): Final report. Gloucester: NOAA Restoration Center.
Neckles, H.A., M. Dionne, D.M. Burdick, C.T. Roman, R. Buchsbaum, and E. Hutchins. 2002. A monitoring protocol to assess tidal restoration of salt marshes on local and regional scales. Restoration Ecology 10: 556–563.
Neckles, H.A., G.R. Guntenspergen, W.G. Shriver, N.P. Danz, W.A. Wiest, J.L. Nagel, and J.H. Olker. 2013. Identification of metrics to monitor salt marsh integrity on National Wildlife Refuges in relation to conservation and management objectives. Laurel: USGS Patuxent Wildlife Research Center.
Neckles, H.A., J.E. Lyons, G.R. Guntenspergen, W.G. Shriver, and S.C. Adamowicz. 2015. Use of structured decision making to identify monitoring variables and management priorities for salt marsh ecosystems. Estuaries and Coasts 38: 1215–1232.
Nestlerode, J.A., V.D. Hansen, A. Teague, and M.C. Harwell. 2014. Application of a three-tier framework to assess ecological condition of Gulf of Mexico coastal wetlands. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 186: 3477–3493.
NYNHP (New York Natural Heritage Program). 2013. Online conservation guide. Available from: http://acris.nynhp.org/. Accessed 8 Feb 2014.
Ortega, M., J. Velasco, A. Millán, and C. Guerrero. 2004. An ecological integrity index for littoral wetlands in agricultural catchments of semiarid Mediterranean regions. Environmental Management 33: 412–430.
Pendleton, L., D.C. Donato, B.C. Murray, S. Crooks, W.A. Jenkins, S. Sifleet, C. Craft, J.W. Fourqurean, J.B. Kauffman, N. Marbà, and P. Megonigal. 2012. Estimating global “blue carbon” emissions from conversion and degradation of vegetated coastal ecosystems. PloS One 7 (9): e43542.
R Core Team. 2016. R: A language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna: R Foundation for Statistical Computing http://www.r-project.org/.
Raposa, K.B., C.T. Roman, and J.F. Heltshe. 2003. Monitoring nekton as a bioindicator in shallow estuarine habitats. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 81: 239–255.
Roman, C.T., N. Jaworski, F.T. Short, S. Findlay, and R.S. Warren. 2000. Estuaries of the northeastern United States: Habitat and land use signatures. Estuaries 23: 743–764.
Roman, C.T., M.J. James-Pirri, and J.F. Heltshe. 2001. Monitoring salt marsh vegetation. Wellfleet: National Park Service Technical Report, Long-term Coastal Ecosystem Monitoring Program at Cape Cod National Seashore.
Roman, C.T., K.B. Raposa, S.C. Adamowicz, M.J. James-Pirri, and J.G. Catena. 2002. Quantifying vegetation and nekton response to tidal restoration of a New England salt marsh. Restoration Ecology 10: 450–460.
Schafale, M.P., and A.S. Weakley. 1990. Classification of the natural communities of North Carolina, third approximation. Raleigh: North Carolina Department of Environment, Health, and Natural Resources, Natural Heritage Program.
Schoolmaster, D.G., Jr., J.B. Grace, and E.W. Schweiger. 2012. A general theory of multimetric indices and their properties. Methods in Ecology and Evolution 3: 773–781.
Schoolmaster, D.R., Jr., J.B. Grace, E.W. Schweiger, G.R. Guntenspergen, B.R. Mitchell, K.M. Miller, and A.M. Little. 2013. An algorithmic and information-theoretic approach to multimetric index construction. Ecological Indicators 23: 14–23.
Short, F.T., D.M. Burdick, C.A. Short, R.C. Davis, and P.A. Morgan. 2000. Developing success criteria for restored eelgrass, salt marsh and mud flat habitats. Ecological Engineering 15: 239–252.
Shumway, S.W., and C.R. Banks. 2001. Species distributions in interdunal swale communities: The effects of soil waterlogging. American Midland Naturalist 145: 137–146.
Silberhorn, G.M. 1999. Common plants of the mid-Atlantic coast: A field guide. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Simenstad, C.A., and R.M. Thom. 1996. Functional equivalency trajectories of the restored Gog-Le-Hi-Te estuarine wetland. Ecological Applications 6: 38–56.
Simon, T.P. 1998. Modification of an index of biotic integrity and development of reference condition expectation for dunal, palustrine wetland fish communities along the southern shore of Lake Michigan. Aquatic Ecosystem Health and Management 1: 49–62.
Smith, S.M., K.C. Medeiros, K. Lee, S.E. Fox, and H. Bayley. 2010. Annual Report on Estuarine Restoration at East Harbor (Truro, MA), Cape Cod National Seashore, 2009. Philadelphia: National Park Service Natural Resources Report NPS/NER/NRR—2010.
Sperduto, D.D. 2011. Natural community systems of New Hampshire. 2nd ed. Concord: New Hampshire National Heritage Bureau.
Staszak, L.A., and A.R. Armitage. 2013. Evaluating salt marsh restoration success with an index of ecosystem integrity. Journal of Coastal Research 29: 410–418.
Stevens, S., B. Milstead, M. Albert, and G. Entsminger. 2005. Northeast coastal and barrier network vital signs monitoring plan. Boston: National Park Service Technical Report NPS/NER/NRTR—2005/025.
Stoddard, J.L., A.T. Herlihy, D.V. Peck, R.M. Hughes, T.R. Whittier, and E. Tarquinio. 2008. A process for creating multimetric indices for large-scale aquatic surveys. Journal of the North American Benthological Society. 27: 878–891.
Swain, P.C., and J.B. Kearsley. 2001. Classification of the natural communities of Massachusetts, version 1.3. Westborough: Natural Heritage and Endangered Species Program, Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife.
Tiner, R.W. 2009. Field guide to tidal wetland plants of the northeastern United States and neighboring Canada: Vegetation of beaches, tidal flats, rocky shores, marshes, swamps, and coastal ponds. Amherst: Univ. of Massachusetts Press.
USDA (U.S. Department of Agriculture). 2014. Natural Resources Conservation Service plants database. http://plants.usda.gov/index.html. Accessed Jan 2014.
USEPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency). 2011. National wetland condition assessment: Field operations manual. Washington: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EPA-843-R-10-001.
USEPA (U.S. Environmental Protection Agency). 2016. National wetland condition assessment: 2011 technical report. Washington: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency EPA-843-R-15-006.
Wardrop, D.H., M.E. Kentula, S.F. Jensen, D.L. Stevens Jr., K.C. Hychka, and R.P. Brooks. 2007. Assessment of wetlands in the upper Juniata watershed in Pennsylvania, USA using the hydrogeomorphic approach. Wetlands 27: 432–445.
Wigand, C., R. Comeleo, R. McKinney, G. Thursby, M. Chintala, and M. Charpentier. 2001. Outline of a new approach to evaluate ecological integrity of salt marshes. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 5: 1541–1554.
Wigand, C., B. Carlisle, J. Smith, M. Carullo, D. Fillis, M. Charpentier, R. McKinney, R. Johnson, and J. Heltshe. 2011. Development and validation of rapid assessment indices of condition for coastal tidal wetlands in southern New England, USA. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 182: 31–46.
Wilcox, D.A., J.E. Meeker, P.L. Hudson, B.J. Armitage, M.G. Black, and D.G. Uzarski. 2002. Hydrologic variability and the application of index of biotic integrity metrics to wetlands: A Great Lakes evaluation. Wetlands 22: 588–615.
Wolfe, R.J. 1996. Effects of open marsh water management on selected tidal marsh resources: A review. Journal of the American Mosquito Control Association 12: 701–712.
Zedler, J.B., and S. Kercher. 2004. Causes and consequences of invasive plants in wetlands: Opportunities, opportunists, and outcomes. Critical Reviews in Plant Sciences 23: 431–452.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported, in part, by funding from USGS National Park Monitoring Program. In addition, GRG and JGB acknowledge support from the USGS Climate and Land-Use Research and Development Program. We are grateful to Holly Plaisted for assistance with data preparation, to Jennifer Olker for analytical guidance, and to the many NPS professional staff and summer research assistants who helped with vegetation and nekton sampling. We extend sincere appreciation to Nick Danz and two anonymous reviewers for helpful comments that improved the manuscript. All data used in this paper are publicly available through USGS at https://dx.doi.org/10.5066/F7ZP449D. The use of trade, product, or firm names in this publication is for descriptive purposes only and does not imply endorsement by the US Government.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Communicated by Cathleen Wigand
Electronic Supplementary Material
Supplemental Table 1
(DOCX 59 kb)
Supplemental Table 2
(DOCX 24 kb)
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nagel, J.L., Neckles, H.A., Guntenspergen, G.R. et al. Development of a Multimetric Index for Integrated Assessment of Salt Marsh Ecosystem Condition. Estuaries and Coasts 41, 334–348 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12237-017-0293-3
Received:
Revised:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12237-017-0293-3