Radiation recuperator is a class of indirect contact heat exchanger widely used for waste heat recovery in high temperature industrial applications. At higher temperatures heat loss is higher and as the cost of energy continues to rise, it becomes imperative to save energy and improve overall energy efficiency. In this light, a radiation recuperator becomes a key component in an energy recovery system with great potential for energy saving. Improving recuperator performance, durability, and its design and material considerations has been an ongoing concern. Recent progress in furnace design and micro turbine applications together with use of recuperators has resulted in reduced fuel consumption, increased cost effectiveness and short pay-back time periods. Due to its high commercial value and confidential nature of the industry, little information is available in the open literature as compared to convection recuperators where results are well documented. This review paper intends to bridge the gap in literature and provides valuable information on experimental and theoretical investigations in radiation recuperator development along with identification of some unresolved issues.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Buy single article
Instant access to the full article PDF.
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.
W. Turner and S. Doty, Energy management handbook, The Fairmount Press, Inc. (2009).
D. A. Reay, Heat recovery systems, Chapman and Hall, London (1979).
R. K. Shah, B. Thonon and D. M. Benforado, Opportunities for heat exchanger applications in environmental systems, Applied Thermal Engineering, 20 (2000) 631–650.
US DOE EIA, Annual energy review, Energy Information Administration, Washington, D.C. (2006).
W. Trinks, M. H. Mawhinney and R. A. Shannon, Industrial furnaces, John Wiley and Sons, Inc. (2004).
R. Goldstick, Principles of waste heat recovery, Atlanta, GA: The Fairmont Press, Inc. (1986).
A. Schack, Metallic recuperators, In Waste heat recovery. London; Chapman and Hall Ltd. (1961), 107–116.
J. B. Jensen, Non-uniform heat transfer in thermal regenerators, Ph.D. Thesis, Denmark Technical Uni. (2011).
M. T. Zarrinehkafsh and S. M. Sadrameli, Simulation of fixed bed regenerative heat exchangers for flue gas heat recovery, Applied Thermal Engineering, 24 (2004) 373–382.
A. E. Sheindlin, High temperature equipment, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation, New York (1986).
R. K. Shah and P. S. Dušan, Fundamentals of heat exchanger design, John Wiley and Sons (2003).
E. U. Schlünder, Heat exchanger design handbook, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation (1997).
T. Kuppan, Heat exchanger design handbook, Marcel Dekker Inc. (2000).
N. Fricker, Effective use of gas on high temperature furnaces, Metallurgia, 53(12) (1986) 544–553.
J. W. Seehausen, The development and operation of high temperature metallic recuperators in the fiber glass industry, AIChE, 83(257) (1987) 272–277.
A. Ashfield, High temperature high efficiency recuperators, Glass International (1988) 30–31.
C. J. Dobos and D. R. Heintz, Documentation of compact ceramic recuperation benefits. In IGRC: proceedings (1987) 945–948.
S. M. Cho, A. H. Seltzer, T. V. Narayanan, A. C. Shah and J. K. Weddell, Design of a continuous ceramic composite heat exchanger for high temperature, high pressure applications, In proceedings of IJPGC, ASME, 30(2) (1996) 1–9.
C. Luzzato, A. Morgana, S. Chaudourne, T. O. O’Doherty and G. Sorbies, A new concept composite heat exchanger to be applied in high temperature industrial processes, Applied Thermal Engineering, 17 (1997) 789–797.
C. K. Gupta, Chemical metallurgy: Principles and practice, Wiley-VCH (2003).
S. N. Singh, S. Yokosh and R. L. Bennett, Gas combustion studies in a recuperative radiant tube, Petroleum Division: proceedings, New York, ASME (1988) 25–29.
S. S. Singh, Design of a high temperature gas fired heating system, Industrial Heating, 55 (1988) 18–20.
V. I. Yarygin, V. V. Klepikov and A. V. Vizgalov, Development of recuperative burner for a thermionic converter, In 28th IECEC, Atlanta, SAE, 1 (1993) 1033–1037.
J. L. Pellegrino, Energy and environmental profile of the U.S. glass industry, Energetics, Inc. (2002).
M. G. Howard and G. J. Wingfield, Recent trends in metallic recuperators for use in the glass industry, Glass Technology International, 28(4) (1987) 165–168.
K. Teisen, Changing criteria of furnace designs for the container industry and role of side fired recuperative glass melting tank, Glass Technology, 32(3) (1991) 75–81.
M. E. Ward, D. Knowles, S. R. Davis and J. Bohn, Effect of combustion air preheat on forge furnace productivity, IGRC, Rockville, MD (1985) 763–776.
N. Margolis and R. Brindle, Energy and environmental profile of the U.S. iron and steel industry, Energetics Inc., Columbia, Maryland (2000).
C. J. Sismey, Recuperators in glass industry, Glass (London), 64(4) (1987) 149–150.
J. E. Snyder and D. R. Petrak, Design and material selection for a high-temperature burner duct recuperator, American Ceramics Society, 14 (1985) 59–70.
S. J. Dapkunas, Ceramic heat exchangers. American Society Bulletin, 67(2) (1988) 388–391.
S. E. Dvoryashin, N. A. Mikov and I. G. Toporishchev, Increase in air heating temperature in a ceramic soaking pit, Metallurgist (1–2) (1990) 34.
L. G. Clawson and W. W. Teich, Development of a corrosion suppression approach using continuous condensing for recuperating furnaces, In ASHRAE (1986) 92: 507–516.
I. Stambler, See breakthrough for high temperature metallic recuperator, IJ GTW, 17(4) (1987) 42–47.
T. S. Sidhu, S. Prakash and R. D. Agrawal, Studies on the properties of HVOF coatings for higher temperature applications, Materials Science, 41(6) (2005) 805–823.
P. J. Maziasz, B. A. Pint, Y. Yamamoto and E. Lara-Curzio, Advanced alloys for compact, high-efficiency, high-temperature heat-exchangers, IJHE, 32 (2007) 3622–3630.
H. Jacobs, US Patent No. 2806677 (1957).
A. Schack, US Patent No. 2917285 (1959).
J. W. Seehausen, US Patent No. 3346042 (1967).
A. J. White, US Patent No. 3446279 (1969).
G. P. Kuchin, The use of gas-suspension heat exchangers utilizing waste heat gases from glass furnaces, Translated from Steldo I Keramika, 5 (1969) 8–11.
H. Jacobs, US Patent No. 3797558 (1974).
L. P. Kharitonova and A. V. Pozhorskii, Development of steam recuperators, Soviet Forging and Sheet Metal stamping Technology, 2 (1989) 78–81.
E. Azad and H. Aliahmad, Thermal performance of waste heat recuperator with heat pipes for thermal power station, Heat Recovery Systems and CHP, 9(3) (1989) 275–280.
H. Barklage, Batch preheating on glass melting furnaces, Glass Technology, 62(4) (1989) 113–121.
Y. S. Sukharchak and A. K. Yudkin, Ways of using coke more efficiently in cupolas, Soviet Castings Technology, 4 (1989) 49–51.
S. H. Chan and K. Kumar, Analytical investigation of SER recuperator performance, In ASME, Petroleum Division, v 30: proceedings. New York, ASME (1990) 161–168.
J. Tomik, New furnace utilizes glass fiber waste, Glass Industry, 71(4) (1990) 23–24.
Anon, High performance recuperation for 700–1100°C furnaces, Steel Times International, 219(6) (1991) 325.
K. Teisen, Metallic recuperator and regenerator designs compared, Glass International, 68(10) (1991) 415–418.
G. Anderson, Benefits of recuperation in intermittent kilns, In AUSTCERAM 90: proceedings, 53–55 (1990) 402–405.
W. B. Veltkamp, E. P. Van Kemenade and W. F. J. Sampers, Combustion Heated thermionic systems, In proceedings of IECEC, SAE, (1992) 3.443–3.449.
W. B. Veltkamp and E. P. Kemenade, Performance of combustion heated thermionic systems, In 28th IECEC v1: proceedings, SAE, (1993) 1019–1024.
J. Tang and A. R. Cooper, Application of pure oxygen with batch preheating to glass-melting, American Ceramic Society Bulletin, 69 (1990) 1827–1830.
K. Aydin and A. Akinci, Application of oxy-fuel firing to an E-glass furnace, Glass Tech., 34(6) (1993) 256–258.
G. M. Matveev, V. V. Mironov, E. M. Raskina and K. E. Tarasevich, Power saving in glass melting, Glass and Ceramics, 55 (1998) 11–12.
B. J. P. Buhre, L. K. Elliott, C. D. Sheng, R. P. Gupta and T. F. Wall, Oxy-fuel combustion technology for coal-fired power generation, Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 31 (2005) 283–307.
S. P. Bhat, Thermal fatigue analysis: a case study of recuperators, In Symposium on Case studies for Fatigue Education: proceedings, Philadelphia (1994) 101–108.
M. A. El-Masri, Modified high efficiency, recuperated gas turbine cycle, Journal of Engineering for Gas Turbines and Power, Transactions of ASME, 110(2) (1987) 233–242.
Z. P. Tilliette, E. Proust and F. Carre, Four-year investigation of Brayton cycle systems for future French space power applications, IJGTP, ASME, 110(4) (1988) 641–646.
C. F. McDonald, Increasing role of heat exchangers in gas turbine plants, In ASME (paper) GT 103 (1989) 10.
R. Mackay, Gas turbine generator set for hybrid vehicles, SAE technical paper series: proceedings (1992) 19–24.
R. A. Uhlig, R. L. Kiang and J. L. Buyer, Flow distribution in a model recuperator of an intercooled recuperative marine gas engine, ASME GT (1990) 394–398.
R. L. Kiang and T. L. Bowen, Application of advanced heat exchanger in a 22 Megawatt naval propulsion gas turbine, In ASME/JSME TEJC: proceedings (1995) 347–358.
K. W. Karstensen and J. C. Wiggins, Variable geometry power turbine for marine gas turbines, International Journal of Turbomachinery, 112(2) (1990) 165–174.
R. Mackay and J. C. Noe, High efficiency low cost small gas turbines, In IGTI, ASME, 6 (1991) 163–167.
J. Jen, Primary surface recuperator for vehicular gas turbine, In FTTCE: proceedings, SAE (1987) 9.
M. E. Ward and L. Holman, PSR for high performance prime-movers, In IECEC: proceedings, SAE (1992) 1–10.
D. Merchant, Economies in heat-treatment furnace technology, Metallurgia, 55(2) (1988) 80–82.
H. Kroeger and W. Schnabel, Increasing productivity by using ladle heating, Steel International, 216(10) (1988) 2.
J. G. Brissen and G. W. Swift, Measurements and modelling of recuperation for stirling refrigerator, International Journal of Cryogenics, 34(12) (1994) 971–982.
R. Smith, The use of high temperature heat exchangers to increase power plant thermal efficiency, In Proceedings, IEEE, 3 (1997) 1690–1695.
R. Budin and A. Mihelic-Bogdani, Heat recovery in polyester production: a case study, Applied Thermal Engineering, 11(1) (1997) 661–665.
J. M. Chawla, Waste heat recovery from flue gases with substantial dust load, Chemical Engineering and Processing, 38 (1999) 365–371.
G. F. Weber, J. P. Hurley and D. J. Seery, Testing of a very high temperature heat exchanger in a pilot-scale slagging furnace system, In Proceedings IJPGC, July (2000) 23–26.
V. V. Chernov and A. V. Aksenov, Intensification of heat exchange in recuperators using ceramic coatings, Refractories and Industrial Ceramics, 42 (2001) 9–10.
L. Junhong, L. Zhizhang and L. Zhiwei, Truck waste heat recovery for heating bitumen used in road maintenance, Applied Thermal Engineering, 23 (2003) 409–416.
D. A. Krivopuskov, A heat exchanger for cooling high temperature gases, Chemical and Petroleum Engineering, 39 (2003) 9–10.
M. Namba, K. Miura, Y. Tomoyasu, H. Kiuchi, Y. Harada and N. Tezuka, US Patent No. 6675880 (2004).
B. S. Chaikin, G. E. Mar’yanchik, E. M. Panov, P. T. Shaposhnikov and B. A. Makarevich, State-of-the-art plants for drying and high-temperature heating of ladles, Refractories and Industrial Ceramics, 47(5) (2006) 283–287.
K. Khoshmanesh, A. Z. Kouzani, S. Nahavandi and A. Abbassi, Reduction of fuel consumption in an industrial glass melting furnace, In TENCON, IEEE (2007) 1–4.
K. Morimoto, Y. Suzuki and N. Kasagi, High performance recuperator with oblique wavy walls, ASME Journal of Heat Transfer, 130101801 (2008) 10.
B. Tsai and Y. L. Wang, A novel swiss-roll recuperator for the micro-turbine engine, Applied Thermal Engineering, 29 (2009) 216–223.
H. Shih and Y. Huang, Thermal design and model analysis of the Swiss-roll recuperator for an innovative micro gas turbine, Applied Thermal Engineering, 29 (2009) 1493–99.
E. Aschenbruck, M. Beukenberg and G. Fruechtel, US Patent No. 7766731 (2010).
A. Bejan and A. D. Kraus, Heat transfer handbook, John Wiley and Sons, Inc. (2003).
W. M. Kays and M. E. Crawford, Convective heat and mass transfer, McGraw-Hill Book Company (1993).
H. C. Hottel and A. F. Sarofim, Radiative transfer, McGraw-Hill, New York (1967).
F. P. Incropera, P. J. Prescott and D. D. Voelkel, Hybrid systems for furnace waste heat recovery: Use of a radiation recuperator with a Rankine cycle, Heat Recovery Systems and CHP, 5(4) (1985) 321–333.
E. F. C. Somerscales and J. G. Knudsen, Fouling of heat transfer equipment, Hemisphere (1981).
V. E. Loginov, Power expended for pumping heat-transfer agents and efficiency of the heat exchange in conical radiative slot Recuperators, Engineering Physics and Thermophysics, 79(2) (2006) 390–394.
A. E. Bergles, M. K. Jensen and B. Shome, Bibliography on enhancement of convective heat and mass transfer, Journal of Enhanced Heat Transfer, 4 (1995) 1–6.
S. Kakaç, A. E. Bergles, F. Mayinger and H. Yuncu, Heat transfer enhancement of heat exchangers, Kluwer (1999).
L. D. Tijing, B. C. Pak, B. J. Baek and D. H. Lee, A study on heat transfer enhancement using straight and twisted internal fins, Int.Comm.in H.M.T., 33 (2006) 719–726.
S. Eimsa-ard, C. Thianpong and P. Promvonge, Experimental investigation of heat transfer and flow friction in a circular tube fitted with regularly spaced twisted tape elements, Int.Comm.in H.M.T., 33 (2006) 1225–1233.
H. Sharma, A. Kumar and Varun, Performance model of metallic concentric tube recuperator with counter flow arrangement, Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, Springer, 46 (2010) 295–304.
J. G. Marakis, C. Papapavlou and E. Kakaras, A parametric study of radiative heat transfer in pulverized coal furnaces, IJ HMT, 43 (2000) 2961–2971.
J. Yamada, Y. Kurosaki and T. Nagai, Radiation heat transfer between fluidizing particles and heat transfer surface in a fluidized bed, Transactions of ASME, 123 (2001) 458.
M. Eriksson and R. G. Mohammad, Radiation heat transfer in circulating fluidized bed combustors, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 44, (2005), 399–409.
F. Farhadi, B. M. Bahrami, M. M. Y. Hashemi, Radiative models for the furnace side of a bottom-fired reformer, Applied Thermal Engineering, 25 (2005) 2398–2411.
S. L. Chang and C. Q. Zhou, Impacts of radiation heat transfer on NOx calculation in industrial furnaces, 37 th IECEC (2002).
G. Scribano, G. Solero and A. Coghe, Pollutant emissions reduction and performance optimization of an industrial radiant tube burner, Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science, 30 (2006) 605–612.
M. F. Modest, Radiative heat transfer, McGraw-Hill, New York (1993).
M. Mengiic and R. Viskanta, Radiative heat transfer in three dimensional rectangular enclosures containing inhomogeneous, anisotropically scattering media, Quant. Spect. and Radiative Tfr., 33(6) (1985) 533–549.
W. A. Fiveland, A discrete-ordinates method for predicting radiative heat transfer in axisymmetric enclosures, ASME Journal of Heat transfer, 82-HT-20 (1986).
J. Truelove, Three dimensional radiation in absorbing-emitting-scattering media using DOM approximation, Quant. Spect. and Radiative Tfr., 39(1) (1988) 27–31.
F. C. Lockwood and N. G. Shah, A new radiation solution method for incorporation in general combustion prediction procedures, The Combustion Institute, (1981) 1405–1414.
J. C. Chai, H. S. Lee and S. V. Patankar, Finite volume method for radiation heat transfer, Thermophysics and Heat Transfer, 8(3) (1994) 419–425.
H. C. Hottel and E. S. Cohen, Radiant heat exchange in a gas filled enclosure: allowance for non-uniformity in temperature, AIChE Journal, 4(1) (1958) 3.
J. R. Howell and M. Perlmutter, Monte Carlo solution of thermal transfer through radiant media between gray walls, Journal of Heat Transfer, 86(1) (1964) 116–122.
J. M. Hartmann, D. Levi, R. Leon and J. Taine, Line by line and narrow band statistical model calculation for H2O, Quant. Spect. and Radiative Tfr., 32(2) (1984) 119–127.
A. Soufiani, J. M. Hartmann and J. Taine, Validity of band model calculations for CO2 and H2O applied to properties and conductive radiative transfer, Quant. Spect. and Radiative Tfr., 32 (1984) 119–27.
M. K. Denison and B. W. Webb, A spectral line based weighted sum of gray gases model for arbitrary RTE solvers, Journal of Heat Transfer, 115 (1993) 1004–1011.
D. K. Edwards, Molecular gas band radiation, In Advances in Heat Transfer, 12 (1976) 115–123.
N. Lallemant and R. Weber, A computationally efficient procedure for calculating gas radiative properties using exponential wide band model, IJHMT, 39 (1996) 3273–3286.
L. Zhang, A. Soufiani and J. Taine, Spectral correlated and non correlated radiative transfer in a finite axisymmetric system containing an absorbing and emitting real gas particle mixture, IJHMT, 31 (1985) 2261–2272.
T. K. Kim, J. A. Menart and H. S. Lee, Non-gray radiative gas analysis using the S-N discrete ordinates method, ASME Journal of Heat Transfer, 113 (1991) 946–952.
O. J. Kim and T. H. Song, Data base of WSGGM-based spectral model for radiation properties of combustion products, Quant. Spect. and Rad. Tfr., 64(4) (2000) 379–394.
Mohamed Naceur Borjinia, Kamel Guedrib and Rachid Saïdb, Modeling of radiative heat transfer in 3D complex boiler with non-gray sooting media, Journal of Quant. Spect. and Radiative Tfr., 105(2) (2007) 167–179.
N. Lallemant, A. Sayre and R. Weber, Evaluation of emissivity correlations for H2O-CO2-N2/air mixtures and coupling with solution methods of RTE, Progress in Energy and Combustion Science, 22 (1996) 543–574.
C. L. Tien, M. F. Modest and C. R. McCreight, Infrared radiation properties of nitrous oxide, Quant. Spect. and Radiative Tfr., 12 (1972) 267–277.
M. A. Brosmer and C. L. Tien, Infrared radiation properties of methane at elevated temperatures, Quant. Spect. and Radiative Tfr., 33(5) (1985) 521–532.
M. A. Brosmer and C. L. Tien, Thermal radiation properties of C2H2, ASME Heat Transfer, 107 (1985) 943–948.
I. H. Farag, Non-luminous gas radiation: approximate emissivity models, 7th IHTC, Munich, 2 (1982) 487–492.
B. Leckner, Spectral and total emissivity of H2O and CO2, Combustion and Flame, 19 (1972) 33–48.
C. B. Ludwig, W. Malkmus, J. E. Reardon and J. A. L. Thomson, Handbook of infrared radiation from combustion gases, NASA, Technical Report SP-3080 (1973).
R. Siegel and J. R. Howell, Thermal radiation heat transfer, Taylor and Francis, Washington, D.C. (2001).
T. F. Smith, Z. F. Shen and J. N. Friedman, Evaluation of coefficients for WSGGM, ASME Journal of Heat Transfer, 104 (1982) 602–608.
Sung Ho Jeong, Joon Jeong Yi, Jong Keun Kim and Man Yeong Ha, Computer modeling of the continuous annealing furnace, KSME, 5(l) (1991) 16–21.
P. J. Coelho, J. M. Goncalves and M. G. Carvalho, Modelling of radiative heat transfer in enclosures with obstacles, IJHMT, 41(4–5) (1998) 745–756.
J. G. Marakis, C. Papapavlou and E. Kakaras, A parametric study of radiative heat transfer in pulverized coal furnaces, IJHMT, 43 (2000) 2961–2971.
F. Farhadi, M. Bahrami and M. M. Y. Motamed Hashemi, Radiative models for furnace side of a bottom-fired reformer, Applied Thermal Engineering, 25 (2005) 2398–2411.
Man Young Kim, A heat transfer model for the analysis of transient heating of the slab in a direct-fired walking beam type reheating furnace, IJ HMT, 50 (2007) 3740–3748.
N. Selcük, R. G. Siddal and J. M. Beer, A comparison of mathematical models of the radiative behavior of a largescale experimental furnace, 16 th International Symposium on Combustion, 53 (1976).
A. S. Jamaluddin and P. J. Smith, Predicting radiative transfer in axisymmetric cylindrical enclosures using DOM, Combustion Science and Technology, 62 (1988) 173.
Y. Mori, Y. Yamada and K. Hijikata, Radiation effects on performances of radiative gas heat exchanger, IJHMT, 23 (1980) 1079–1089.
E. L. Mediokritskii, V. L. Gaponov and V. E. Loginov, Study of heat transfer in computer models, Engineering Physics and Thermophysics, 70(1) (1997) 117–122.
A. J. Jolly, T. O’ Doherty and C. J. Bates, COHEX: a computer model for solving the thermal energy exchange in an ultra high temperature heat exchanger, Applied Thermal Engineering, 18 (1998) 1263–1276.
W. Kim, Analysis on prediction of temperature distribution in an annular radiative recuperator, International Journal of Energy Research, 23 (1999) 637–647.
G. Sethi and A. M. Ghosh, Towards Cleaner Technologies: a process story in Firozabad glass industry, TERI (2008).
Recommended by Associate Editor Tong Seop Kim
Harshdeep Sharma is an Associate Professor in SCME, Galgotias University, Greater Noida, India. His field of specialization is radiation heat transfer. His interests include modeling, simulation of heat transfer problems in high temperature applications.
About this article
Cite this article
Sharma, H., Kumar, A., Varun et al. A review of metallic radiation recuperators for thermal exhaust heat recovery. J Mech Sci Technol 28, 1099–1111 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12206-013-1186-4
- Double shell
- Heat recovery
- Heat transfer
- Thermal radiation