If Addiction is not Best Conceptualized a Brain Disease, then What Kind of Disease is it?
A modest opposition to the brain disease concept of addiction has been mounting for at least the last decade. Despite the good intentions behind the brain disease rhetoric – to secure more biomedical funding for addiction, to combat “stigma,” and to soften criminal approaches – the very concept of addiction as a brain disease is deeply conceptually confused. We question whether Lewis goes far enough in his challenge, robust as it is, of the brain disease concept. For one thing, the notion that addiction is a disease (especially within the behavioral realm) is challenging to refute or confirm because the disease concept itself is poorly defined in medical and psychological nosology. More important, quibbling over what kind of disease addiction is unlikely to be productive. The rational response to adjudicating whether addiction is a brain disease is not to engage in potentially fruitless debates over the question of disease classification but rather to view addiction as an enormously complex set of behaviors that operate on several dimensions, ranging from molecular function and structure and brain physiology to psychology, the psychosocial environment, and social and cultural relations.
KeywordsAddiction Brain disease Reductionism Levels of analysis National Institute on Drug Abuse Neurocentrism Philosophy of medicine Over-medicalization
- 3.Klein, Donald F. 1978. A proposed definition of mental illness. In Critical issues in psychiatric diagnosis, ed. Donald F. Klein and Robert L. Spitzer, 41–71. New York: Raven Press.Google Scholar
- 4.Henriques, Gregg R. 2002. The harmful dysfunction analysis and the differentiation between mental disorder and disease. The Scientific Review of Mental Health Practice 1(2): 157–173.Google Scholar
- 8.Zachar, Peter, and Kenneth S. Kendler. 2012. The removal of Pluto from the class of planets and homosexuality from the class of psychiatric disorders: a comparison. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine 7(4).Google Scholar
- 10.Satel, Sally and Lilienfeld, Scott O. 2013. Brainwashed. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
- 11.Gold, Ian. 2009. Reduction in psychiatry. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 54(8): 506–520.Google Scholar
- 14.Kagan, Jerome. 2006. An argument for mind. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Google Scholar
- 15.Dennett, Daniel. 1995. Darwin’s dangerous idea. New York: Simon & Schuster.Google Scholar
- 17.Pinker, Steven. 2003. The blank slate: the modern denial of human nature. New York: Penguin.Google Scholar
- 18.Lewis, Marc. 2011. Memoirs of an addicted brain: a neuroscientist examines his former life on drugs. New York: Public Affairs.Google Scholar
- 21.Satel, Sally, and Lilienfeld, Scott O. 2013. Addiction and the brain-disease fallacy. In Brainwashed, 49–71. New York: Basic Books.Google Scholar
- 22.Whitten, Lori. 2001. NIH develops high school curriculum supplement on addiction. NIDA Notes 16(1): http://archives.drugabuse.gov/NIDA_Notes/NNVol16N1/NIH.html. Accessed 2 August 2016.
- 23.Public Policy Statement: Definition of Addiction. 2011. American Society of Addiction Medicine. http://www.asam.org/advocacy/find-a-policy-statement/view-policy-statement/public-policy-statements/2011/12/15/the-definition-of-addiction. Accessed 2 August 2016.
- 24.Massing, Michael. 2000. Seeing drugs as a choice or as a brain anomaly. New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2000/06/24/arts/seeing-drugs-as-a-choice-or-as-a-brain-anomaly.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm. June 24, Accessed 2 August 2016.
- 25.Tran, Quynh-Giang. 2002. Drug policy chief looks to the root of addiction: U.S. eyes 10 % reduction in abuse in two years. Boston Globe, July 10, A3.Google Scholar
- 26.Biden, Joseph. 2009. Remarks of the vice president and chief kerlikowske on his nomination as the new director of the office of national drug control policy. Office of the Vice President: https://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/remarks-vice-president-and-chief-kerlikowske-his-nomination-new-director-office-nat. Accessed 2 August 2016.
- 27.Rose, C., and Volkow, N. 2011. The Charlie Rose Brain Series, Year 2. The Charlie Rose Show, PBS. New York.Google Scholar
- 28.Lemonick, Michael D. 2007. How We get addicted. Time. http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1640436,00.html. July 5, Accessed 2 August 2016.
- 29.Interlandi, Jeneen. 2008. What addicts need. Newsweek. http://www.newsweek.com/what-addicts-need-93767. February 23, Accessed 2 August 2016.
- 31.Higgins, Stephen T., Silverman, Kenneth, and Heil, Sarah H., eds. 2008. Contingency management in substance abuse treatment. New York: The Guilford Press.Google Scholar
- 33.Leshner, Alan I. 1997. Treatment: effect on the brain and body. National Methamphetamine Drug Conference. https://www.ncjrs.gov/ondcppubs/publications/drugfact/methconf/plenary2.html. Accessed 2 August 2016.