Human Rights Review

, Volume 16, Issue 2, pp 83–98 | Cite as

Is There a Human Right to Freedom of Religion?

Article

Abstract

A human right to freedom of religion is not equivalent to a right to tolerance. Human rights and tolerance-rules serve for different purposes and are based on different justifications. Tolerance-rules serve to protect a peaceful living together with strangers who share no common values. Human rights serve to protect every individual’s personhood. Religion can only be a matter of human rights, if and so far as it is a condition of development and maintenance of personhood. Discussion about a human right to freedom of religion makes sense only if we can identify a particular scope of protection which concerns only religion and if the freedom of religion is not embraced by wider-framed freedoms. The freedom of religious thoughts and the freedom of religious speech are embraced by the general human rights to freedom of thoughts and freedom of speech. Here, there is no need for a special human right to freedom of religion. The right not to be forced to act contrary to religiously founded moral rules is embraced by the general human right to freedom of conscience. And again, there is no need for a special human right. The target of religious practices in a narrower sense (rites) is to become flexible and porous and not to resist the threats of the sacral in order to avoid the destruction of personhood. Therefore, we have to recognize a human right to freedom of religious rites. It protects only the actions of accommodation to the overwhelming power of the sacral. It does not protect, however, any action with which it is intended to rule the world or to rule over others, to organize certain practical challenges, or to discover or to maintain scientific theories or technical means.

Keywords

Human rights Tolerance Religion Sacral Personhood 

References

  1. Agamben G (2002) Homo Sacer. Die souveräne Macht und das nackte Leben. Frankfurt, SuhrkampGoogle Scholar
  2. Durkheim É (2001) The Elementary Forms of Religious Life, Oxford, Oxford University Press [1912]Google Scholar
  3. Eliade M (1987) The Sacred and the Profane. The Nature of Religion. OrlandoGoogle Scholar
  4. Fichte JG (1796) Grundlage des Naturrechts nach Principien der Wissenschaftslehre. Jena, GablerGoogle Scholar
  5. Fischer G, Riedesser P (2009) Lehrbuch der Psychotraumatologie, München/Basel: Reinhardt (4th ed)Google Scholar
  6. Forst R (2003) Toleranz im Konflikt. Geschichte, Gehalt und Gegenwart eines umstrittenen Begriffs. Frankfurt, SuhrkampGoogle Scholar
  7. Geertz C (1987) Religion as a Cultural System. In: Seth D. Kunin (ed): Theories of Religion. A Reader. New Brunswick, Rutgers University Press 1987Google Scholar
  8. Heidegger M (1986) Sein und Zeit. Tübingen, Niemeyer (16th ed)Google Scholar
  9. Hock K (2008) Einführung in die Religionswissenschaft. Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft (3rd ed)Google Scholar
  10. James W (2008) Varieties of Religious Experience, a Study in Human Nature. Rockville, ManorGoogle Scholar
  11. Kaesler D (2009): Religiös unmusikalisch. Bemerkungen zum Verhältnis von Jürgen Habermas zu Max Weber. http://www.literaturkritik.de/, (Nr. 6 July 2009)
  12. Kant I (1786) Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten. Riga, Hartknoch (2nd ed)Google Scholar
  13. Kermani N (2005) Der Schrecken Gottes. Attar, Hiob und die metaphysische Revolte, München, Deutscher TaschenbuchverlagGoogle Scholar
  14. Lübbe H (2004) Religion nach der Aufklärung. München, Finke (3rd ed),Google Scholar
  15. Luhmann N (1982) Funktion der Religion. Frankfurt, SuhrkampGoogle Scholar
  16. Nishitani K (2001) Was ist Religion. Frankfurt, InselGoogle Scholar
  17. Otto R (2004) Das Heilige. Über das Irrationale in der Idee des Göttlichen und sein Verhältnis zum Rationalen. München, C.H. BeckGoogle Scholar
  18. Perren-Klingler G (1995) Trauma. Vom Schrecken des Einzelnen zu den Ressourcen der Gruppe. Bern, HauptGoogle Scholar
  19. Quante M (2007) Person. Berlin/New York, de GruyterGoogle Scholar
  20. Riesebrodt M (2007) Cultus und Heilsversprechen. Eine Theorie der Religionen, München, C.H.BeckGoogle Scholar
  21. Schleiermacher F (2007) Über die Religion. Reden an die Gebildeten unter ihren Verächtern. Stuttgart, Reclam [1799]Google Scholar
  22. Spaemann R (2006) Persons. The Difference between ‘Someone‘ and ‘Something‘. Oxford, Oxford University PressGoogle Scholar
  23. Spencer H (2001) The Proper Sphere of Government – Letter VII [1843]. In: Herbert Spencer, Political Writings (ed. by John Offer), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (2nd ed)Google Scholar
  24. Taylor Ch (2012) Interculturalism or Multiculturalism. In: Philosophy and Social Criticism, 38, No.4–5 (May/June, 2012)Google Scholar
  25. Tiedemann P (2012) Religionsfreiheit – Menschenrecht oder Toleranzgebot? Was Religion ist und warum sie rechtlichen Schutz verdient. Berlin/Heidelberg, SpringerCrossRefGoogle Scholar
  26. Tiedemann P (2013a) Human Dignity as an Absolute Value. In: Brugger, Kirste (ed.): Human Dignity as a Foundation of Law. .ARSP-B 137, Baden-Baden, Nomos 2013, pp. 25Google Scholar
  27. Tiedemann P (2013b) The Relation between Human Dignity and Human Rights In: Brugger, Kirste (ed.): Human Dignity as a Foundation of Law. ARSP-B 137, Baden-Baden, Nomos 2013, pp 193Google Scholar
  28. Tiedemann P (2013c): Menschenwürde als Rechtsbegriff. Eine philosophische Klärung. Berlin, Berliner Wissenschaftsverlag (3rd ed)Google Scholar
  29. Tugendhat E (2003) Egozentrizität und Mystik. Eine anthropologische Studie. München, C.H. BeckGoogle Scholar
  30. von Manz HG (2014) Ist der Begriff der Menschenwürde für die gegenwärtige bioethische Diskussion noch tauglich? Ein Plädoyer aus transzendentalphilosophischer Sicht. In: Götz, Schwenzer, Seelmann, Taupitz (ed): Familie – Recht – Ethik. Festschrift für Gerd Brudermüller zum 65. Geburtstag. Munich, BeckGoogle Scholar

Copyright information

© Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2014

Authors and Affiliations

  1. 1.Frankfurt am MainGermany
  2. 2.Department of LawJustus-Liebig-UniversityGiessenGermany

Personalised recommendations